I think in the overwhelming majority of cases, the solution is not to nerf anything, but to change the actual mechanics of the sim - bottom line.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Why "nerfs" and "berfs" are a bad idea (this is long, if you have ADD don't read it)
TerrellOwns
offline
offline
Originally posted by rj414
I think in the overwhelming majority of cases, the solution is not to nerf anything, but to change the actual mechanics of the sim - bottom line.
That's what they do. It just happens that those changes tend to have a significant effect on the effectiveness of certain players.
I think in the overwhelming majority of cases, the solution is not to nerf anything, but to change the actual mechanics of the sim - bottom line.
That's what they do. It just happens that those changes tend to have a significant effect on the effectiveness of certain players.
rj414
offline
offline
Originally posted by TerrellOwns
Originally posted by rj414
I think in the overwhelming majority of cases, the solution is not to nerf anything, but to change the actual mechanics of the sim - bottom line.
That's what they do. It just happens that those changes tend to have a significant effect on the effectiveness of certain players.
But this isn't what I mean - nerfs don't change the mechanics of the sim - how the passing vectors and blocking assignments are calculated, for example. What they end up changing is the effectiveness of a certain attribute - thats the difference between what I'm suggesting and a nerf.
Originally posted by rj414
I think in the overwhelming majority of cases, the solution is not to nerf anything, but to change the actual mechanics of the sim - bottom line.
That's what they do. It just happens that those changes tend to have a significant effect on the effectiveness of certain players.
But this isn't what I mean - nerfs don't change the mechanics of the sim - how the passing vectors and blocking assignments are calculated, for example. What they end up changing is the effectiveness of a certain attribute - thats the difference between what I'm suggesting and a nerf.
Last edited Mar 5, 2009 18:18:40
TerrellOwns
offline
offline
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by TerrellOwns
Originally posted by rj414
I think in the overwhelming majority of cases, the solution is not to nerf anything, but to change the actual mechanics of the sim - bottom line.
That's what they do. It just happens that those changes tend to have a significant effect on the effectiveness of certain players.
But this isn't what I mean - nerfs don't change the mechanics of the sim - how the passing vectors and blocking assignments are calculated, for example. What they end up changing is the effectiveness of a certain attribute - thats the difference between what I'm suggesting and a nerf.
It would be very difficult to change the effectiveness of one attribute and still keep a position's overall effectiveness the same. Even if you could, players who were heavily invested in that attribute would still consider it a "berf".
Originally posted by TerrellOwns
Originally posted by rj414
I think in the overwhelming majority of cases, the solution is not to nerf anything, but to change the actual mechanics of the sim - bottom line.
That's what they do. It just happens that those changes tend to have a significant effect on the effectiveness of certain players.
But this isn't what I mean - nerfs don't change the mechanics of the sim - how the passing vectors and blocking assignments are calculated, for example. What they end up changing is the effectiveness of a certain attribute - thats the difference between what I'm suggesting and a nerf.
It would be very difficult to change the effectiveness of one attribute and still keep a position's overall effectiveness the same. Even if you could, players who were heavily invested in that attribute would still consider it a "berf".
Koncorde
offline
offline
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
i agree.
and for the record i started a thread like this to defend the defensive side of the ball against whiners for the offense who whined about pass completions being down this season. surprise surprise a mod locked it and said that bort has not even tested it yet.
but we all know this is how it starts. some whining here and there by people within the clique then viola! sim has changed OVERNIGHT.
will this get locked? will bort see this and not give in to whiners?
before anyone says i'm biased let me state that i have a QB and a TE. i OC too. so no biases here. defense has caught up with the offense a little bit (except power-backs).
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
is the defense too late to react?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2220514
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2215665
bort has commented that he is looking at "lower completion rates" for season 8. nerf next?
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
cb's going to be nerfed? bort might just be starting to do it. or at least thinking about it. check this out:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2215665
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2220514
bort posted that it is worth looking into: to get passing completion up to where season 7 was.
and then we see this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2226755
coincidence?
No offence, but you have no idea what you're on about.
I appreciate you linking to the other forum, but if you could stop talking about what will be tested as if you already know or suspect the outcome it would be very much appreciated.
i agree.
and for the record i started a thread like this to defend the defensive side of the ball against whiners for the offense who whined about pass completions being down this season. surprise surprise a mod locked it and said that bort has not even tested it yet.
but we all know this is how it starts. some whining here and there by people within the clique then viola! sim has changed OVERNIGHT.
will this get locked? will bort see this and not give in to whiners?
before anyone says i'm biased let me state that i have a QB and a TE. i OC too. so no biases here. defense has caught up with the offense a little bit (except power-backs).
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
is the defense too late to react?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2220514
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2215665
bort has commented that he is looking at "lower completion rates" for season 8. nerf next?
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
cb's going to be nerfed? bort might just be starting to do it. or at least thinking about it. check this out:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2215665
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2220514
bort posted that it is worth looking into: to get passing completion up to where season 7 was.
and then we see this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2226755
coincidence?
No offence, but you have no idea what you're on about.
I appreciate you linking to the other forum, but if you could stop talking about what will be tested as if you already know or suspect the outcome it would be very much appreciated.
PP
offline
offline
RJ is right. Nerfing players never fixes anything. For proof of that, look at all the nerfs Bort has done since ssn 1. Without fail, every time he nerfs a skill/build, he undoes it within a ssn or 2. All the nerfs do is shift the power balance back and forth. Fixing the logic in the sim is the only real, long term solution
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
i agree.
and for the record i started a thread like this to defend the defensive side of the ball against whiners for the offense who whined about pass completions being down this season. surprise surprise a mod locked it and said that bort has not even tested it yet.
but we all know this is how it starts. some whining here and there by people within the clique then viola! sim has changed OVERNIGHT.
will this get locked? will bort see this and not give in to whiners?
before anyone says i'm biased let me state that i have a QB and a TE. i OC too. so no biases here. defense has caught up with the offense a little bit (except power-backs).
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
is the defense too late to react?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2220514
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2215665
bort has commented that he is looking at "lower completion rates" for season 8. nerf next?
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
cb's going to be nerfed? bort might just be starting to do it. or at least thinking about it. check this out:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2215665
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2220514
bort posted that it is worth looking into: to get passing completion up to where season 7 was.
and then we see this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2226755
coincidence?
No offence, but you have no idea what you're on about.
I appreciate you linking to the other forum, but if you could stop talking about what will be tested as if you already know or suspect the outcome it would be very much appreciated.
lol. i have no idea?
i supposed no nerfing has been done since season 1. no whiners for the offense too. and bort doesn't give in to them.
why didn't you lock this, i wonder? what is the difference between this thread my thread that you locked? it's both talking about the response of bort to the thread created to increase pass completions
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
i agree.
and for the record i started a thread like this to defend the defensive side of the ball against whiners for the offense who whined about pass completions being down this season. surprise surprise a mod locked it and said that bort has not even tested it yet.
but we all know this is how it starts. some whining here and there by people within the clique then viola! sim has changed OVERNIGHT.
will this get locked? will bort see this and not give in to whiners?
before anyone says i'm biased let me state that i have a QB and a TE. i OC too. so no biases here. defense has caught up with the offense a little bit (except power-backs).
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
is the defense too late to react?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2220514
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2215665
bort has commented that he is looking at "lower completion rates" for season 8. nerf next?
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
cb's going to be nerfed? bort might just be starting to do it. or at least thinking about it. check this out:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2215665
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2220514
bort posted that it is worth looking into: to get passing completion up to where season 7 was.
and then we see this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2226755
coincidence?
No offence, but you have no idea what you're on about.
I appreciate you linking to the other forum, but if you could stop talking about what will be tested as if you already know or suspect the outcome it would be very much appreciated.
lol. i have no idea?
i supposed no nerfing has been done since season 1. no whiners for the offense too. and bort doesn't give in to them.
why didn't you lock this, i wonder? what is the difference between this thread my thread that you locked? it's both talking about the response of bort to the thread created to increase pass completions
taurran
offline
offline
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
cb's going to be nerfed? bort might just be starting to do it. or at least thinking about it. check this out:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2215665
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2220514
bort posted that it is worth looking into: to get passing completion up to where season 7 was.
and then we see this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2226755
coincidence?
Of course they will be.
DE's get nerfed and OT's get over corrected - means QB's complete more passes because of less pressure. Means powerbacks can now run freely through DL's and break tackles on weaker secondaries.
Next, because passing is becoming powerful with zero pressure, he nerfs quarterback checkdowns and pass quality and possibly WR vision checks, which makes CB's going rampant with pass deflections.
Now, the next step is to nerf CB's.
What next? When is the powerback nerf coming that will possibly kick off another chain of nerfs?
Next thing we know our players will all look like d leaguers.
cb's going to be nerfed? bort might just be starting to do it. or at least thinking about it. check this out:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2215665
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2220514
bort posted that it is worth looking into: to get passing completion up to where season 7 was.
and then we see this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2226755
coincidence?
Of course they will be.
DE's get nerfed and OT's get over corrected - means QB's complete more passes because of less pressure. Means powerbacks can now run freely through DL's and break tackles on weaker secondaries.
Next, because passing is becoming powerful with zero pressure, he nerfs quarterback checkdowns and pass quality and possibly WR vision checks, which makes CB's going rampant with pass deflections.
Now, the next step is to nerf CB's.
What next? When is the powerback nerf coming that will possibly kick off another chain of nerfs?
Next thing we know our players will all look like d leaguers.
Last edited Mar 5, 2009 22:04:47
Bukowski
offline
offline
Originally posted by taurran
Next thing we do our players will all look like d leaguers.
That's what they want.
All the sad ass player builders that voted for realism, that's exactly what they were voting for. They couldn't keep up with the people that actually knew what they were doing, so they voted (in essence) for everyone (scoring) to get nerfed, so that they could feel like they actually had a chance again. They seemed to feel that they would have better odds, if the score was 42-0, instead of 84-14.
They also knew that their players didn't put up any decent statistics as it is, so they wouldn't miss them when they were gone. They hadn't figured out how to get their DEs to put up massive amounts of Sacks, and were tired of having DEs put up 100 more sacks than they did, so they would much rather their sacks be cut in half.
It's pretty obvious why most people voted the way they did, and it was obvious in all of the threads discussing the subject. Whenever someone would be posting in one of those threads, sticking up for 'realism', you could click onto their player page, and see dozens of mediocre players and teams, that were desperate to become relevant again. If most DEs went back down to less than 10 sacks per season, they figured that the amount separating their players, would shrink dramatically.
Of course, this didn't apply to everyone. But it was definitely the majority, because the majority in GLB cannot build elite players, so they don't want you to have any either.
So to me, that is what brought all of this on. Bort is giving in to the majority of people that pay for his bills, the one's that wanted to feel like they could keep up with the elite players.
So let's not act surprised, because we all should have seen this coming. He's not going to rest until everyone is as mediocre as the next guy - perfect harmony.
Next thing we do our players will all look like d leaguers.
That's what they want.
All the sad ass player builders that voted for realism, that's exactly what they were voting for. They couldn't keep up with the people that actually knew what they were doing, so they voted (in essence) for everyone (scoring) to get nerfed, so that they could feel like they actually had a chance again. They seemed to feel that they would have better odds, if the score was 42-0, instead of 84-14.
They also knew that their players didn't put up any decent statistics as it is, so they wouldn't miss them when they were gone. They hadn't figured out how to get their DEs to put up massive amounts of Sacks, and were tired of having DEs put up 100 more sacks than they did, so they would much rather their sacks be cut in half.
It's pretty obvious why most people voted the way they did, and it was obvious in all of the threads discussing the subject. Whenever someone would be posting in one of those threads, sticking up for 'realism', you could click onto their player page, and see dozens of mediocre players and teams, that were desperate to become relevant again. If most DEs went back down to less than 10 sacks per season, they figured that the amount separating their players, would shrink dramatically.
Of course, this didn't apply to everyone. But it was definitely the majority, because the majority in GLB cannot build elite players, so they don't want you to have any either.
So to me, that is what brought all of this on. Bort is giving in to the majority of people that pay for his bills, the one's that wanted to feel like they could keep up with the elite players.
So let's not act surprised, because we all should have seen this coming. He's not going to rest until everyone is as mediocre as the next guy - perfect harmony.
Last edited Mar 5, 2009 19:48:57
TerrellOwns
offline
offline
I don't know what's more arrogant, assuming that most people can't build "elite" players in an incredibly simplistic game, or presuming to know what most people think and why.
Bukowski
offline
offline
Originally posted by TerrellOwns
I don't know what's more arrogant, assuming that most people can't build "elite" players in an incredibly simplistic game, or presuming to know what most people think and why.
Call me arrogant all you want, I don't really give a fuck.
You shouldn't feel insulted, I wasn't directly talking about you.
I don't know what's more arrogant, assuming that most people can't build "elite" players in an incredibly simplistic game, or presuming to know what most people think and why.
Call me arrogant all you want, I don't really give a fuck.
You shouldn't feel insulted, I wasn't directly talking about you.
TerrellOwns
offline
offline
I don't feel insulted, I was just pointing out that your post makes you come off as a complete douchebag.
Koncorde
offline
offline
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
lol. i have no idea?
i supposed no nerfing has been done since season 1. no whiners for the offense too. and bort doesn't give in to them.
why didn't you lock this, i wonder? what is the difference between this thread my thread that you locked? it's both talking about the response of bort to the thread created to increase pass completions
The fact I never saw this topic, whilst the one you raised was directly next to a topic that actually had Bort in it discussing it with you..
The fact the other thread is now moved to bugs for discussion.
The fact he actually made an effort in his OP beyond "Bort wtf don't nerf pls!".
And no, you have absolutely no clue what is currently going with testing, future plans, development and I suspect you have a wonky understanding of what changes constitute a nerf.
You've also been doing this in several threads that really don't need misinformation spreading in them, with absolutely no attempt to contribute to the topic at hand.
lol. i have no idea?
i supposed no nerfing has been done since season 1. no whiners for the offense too. and bort doesn't give in to them.
why didn't you lock this, i wonder? what is the difference between this thread my thread that you locked? it's both talking about the response of bort to the thread created to increase pass completions
The fact I never saw this topic, whilst the one you raised was directly next to a topic that actually had Bort in it discussing it with you..
The fact the other thread is now moved to bugs for discussion.
The fact he actually made an effort in his OP beyond "Bort wtf don't nerf pls!".
And no, you have absolutely no clue what is currently going with testing, future plans, development and I suspect you have a wonky understanding of what changes constitute a nerf.
You've also been doing this in several threads that really don't need misinformation spreading in them, with absolutely no attempt to contribute to the topic at hand.
Bukowski
offline
offline
Originally posted by TerrellOwns
I don't feel insulted, I was just pointing out that your post makes you come off as a complete douchebag.
Yeah, it probably does. I don't really care, though, because it really is the truth - for the most part.
By and large, the people that want scores to be lower and positions to be nerfed, are normally the ones that can't keep up.
I don't think that is so hard to fathom, that they would have ulterior motives.
I don't feel insulted, I was just pointing out that your post makes you come off as a complete douchebag.
Yeah, it probably does. I don't really care, though, because it really is the truth - for the most part.
By and large, the people that want scores to be lower and positions to be nerfed, are normally the ones that can't keep up.
I don't think that is so hard to fathom, that they would have ulterior motives.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























