User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Endorsements - What I am thinking
Page:
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MeatBomb
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by kurieg


To calculate MVP stats:

1 - Throw out interconference games.
2 - Select the 9 highest average score differential teams. Only count stats against these teams. Throw one of them out randomly, and use the remaining 8 to compare stats with the 7 that don't make this list. Explanation -
Teams 1-9 have the best score differentials. Team 1 gains fame based on games vs. 2-9. Team 2 vs. 1 and 3-9. Etc.
Roll 1-9 and throw that team out. Team 10-16 are compared to the remaining 8 to gain fame.

Oh ya, don't bother calculating fame until the end of the season so you can weed out the terrible teams/gutjobs.


Like judging figure skating?

Throw out the highs and lows, take the average?


Would be basically the same as comparing stats against teams in your division that made the playoffs.



Gutjobs have made the playoffs.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by DavidD458
Also, Bort, (it's off topic and I apologize in advance) as this thread grows and grows, I think a solid idea would be to pick 10-15 people (non-mods, just regular members) and put them in a private forum where things like these can be discussed without growing to 20 pages in a half hour. These get out of control pretty fast and good discussion is gone after the first half hour or so.

I'd love to be a part of it.


Me too...
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by Bort



Kk,

1. We'll run a full season on the test server and tweak our formula until it looks pretty good based on the full season's stats. We do a separate MVP list for Offense, Defense, and ST players, per conference.



Bort,

I am not sure that the test server is the right environment for testing this sort of thing.

real leagues have gutted teams, uber teams, teams that gut halfway through the season, and often quite uneven levels of competition in the two different conferences.

Unless you can simulate all of those elements on the test serves (seems like too much trouble) I think you need to find a way to test against sampling of real live leagues and evaluate the results.



You're probably right, actually. I could do a MVP list based on last season stats per league from the live site, output in in a text file or something, and post results until it looks good?


Bingo!

 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MeatBomb
Originally posted by DavidD458

Originally posted by RandomBeast


why not only count stats earned while not in cruise control mode?


Solid idea.


That's a money shot right there.


It's possible to enter cruise control against a non gut team, though. Statistical analysis might be a better ally.
 
onlyrockerfan
offline
Link
 
the problem with throwing out the gut job stats is a HB could put up 200 yards and 3 TD's against a legit defense and then a couple games later that team that he ran against could go CPU, so everybody after him would put up 450-550 yards and 20 TD's against a CPU defense.....and that original HB would be behind for putting up good numbers against a real defense.
 
ChuckTaylor
offline
Link
 
I can see 400 threads now " My owner won't play me because he's trying to get his player the MVP award"
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by smizzy
all this does is give teams a reason to keep their starters in to force stats to be MVP's


Which will piss off their depth players and hurt their chances of winning.

In other words, it will become more difficult to balance player and team needs.

Yes, I think that's true to a degree.
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hikariu


Just to organize thoughts, is this correct ignoring the MVP awards.

A Pro team would get:

1 National Award - Full Season Long [+4 stats, likely +1 mid-range SA or +10/15%]

and

2 Local Awards - 8 Day Rotation [+2 stats, low range SA or +3/+5%]


If this a correct summary, I do think there should be a way to swing more than 4 endorsements (MVP+Nat+2 Local). The reality of it is sometimes more than 4 great players are on one team. And I think reflecting reality in this way makes the game more fun.
 
Link
 
With regards to MVP calculations, could you set up something where only players in that league could go in and possibly vote? Maybe decide the top 10 or something and vote?
 
ImTheCrew
offline
Link
 
off-topic, sigh sorry
Last edited Feb 26, 2009 20:39:35
 
ChuckTaylor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by smizzy

all this does is give teams a reason to keep their starters in to force stats to be MVP's


Which will piss off their depth players and hurt their chances of winning.

In other words, it will become more difficult to balance player and team needs.

Yes, I think that's true to a degree.


creating more greed and more unhappy customers.
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

You're probably right, actually. I could do a MVP list based on last season stats per league from the live site, output in in a text file or something, and post results until it looks good?


Sounds great, and I'd love to see the results.
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
I think you should do an MVP calculation for each position and give the same thing you give now for each position with the top 10 "MVP candidates" getting some chance to win the endorsement then add an MVP endorsement that adds even more than the regular endorsement EQ except the MVPs of the league cannot get their position endorsements
 
Rezlov
offline
Link
 
Sounds like a disaster waiting to happen. If the BCS can't decide the top team correctly, how is GLB going to decide the top player?

Not to mention there are FAR more factors and such.
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
It seems obvious to just add more endorcments and keep the team out of it that have multiple winners already.
Lets see the bitching when the next set of people gets left out and this starts all over again because at the end of the day thats all that happened.

Cant believe that ripping these away from people was even an option let alone a good idea.Could all be solved with just giving out more shiny new equipment so the 1% winners and 99% losers start to blend.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.