User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AA Leagues > USA AA #2 > USA AA#2 Probowl voting
Page:
 
da raiders
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James42688
As a player I'm not to worried about this. Some positions are a joke.

IMO Morgan Trent and Stacy Toran are the best CBs in the West.

NO offense but Champ Pion is not close to being the best CB in the west.


there are a few that are absolutely no brainers. snowmonkey at C is another, but i can't vote for him. hammer & bp should both be the rb's.
 
skurby1
offline
Link
 
I know, Its hard to even pay attention anymore. Certain coaches are bitter for some reason or another and dont vote where they know they should.
 
James42688
offline
Link
 
A CB should not be leading the league in tackles. He should have more then interceptions. He needs few tackles, high interceptions, and pass deflections. My two suggestions represent this fully
 
octones
offline
Link
 
High interceptions doesn't always mean you are a great CB.
 
thaima1shu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by octones
High interceptions doesn't always mean you are a great CB.


That's what I based my votes off of. I looked at the teams with the best pass defenses in terms of yards allowed, then looked at the CB's with low tackles and looked into how many times they let the other receiver catch the ball.
 
octones
offline
Link
 
I mean since this is a sim game it would be nice if they displayed the number of passes that went a CB's way, how many were caught, total yards allowed, etc. That would be a much better indicator of how good a CB really is.
 
Xaviers Crown
offline
Link
 
Eastern Conference Voting Checklist

Completed:
Buffalo Bisons
Miami Vampires
Nashville Hounds
Tampa Bay Paladins
Reno Knights
Pensacola Dolphins
West Virginia Mountaineers

In Process:
New Jersey Jets

Not Yet:
Boston Stalkers
Georgia Rhinos
Milwaukee First Order Historians
Ohio Valley Vultures
New Orleans Taints
NEVADA DICE
Tampa Bay Thunder
Texas Tornados

Last edited May 31, 2008 18:18:56
 
James42688
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by octones
High interceptions doesn't always mean you are a great CB.


Yes. I know. I am very aware of that. That is why I included the main recordable stats for a CB because I know a lot of owners are only lookin at stats. Anyone voting Champ Pion in is only lookin at stats. Not an excuse for leading the league in tackles. Its like Roy Williams makin the pro bowl each year...It just doesnt make sense.
Last edited May 31, 2008 18:31:16
 
octones
offline
Link
 
I agree, just making sure Easy to vote off just stats in this game.
 
GaDawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by octones
I mean since this is a sim game it would be nice if they displayed the number of passes that went a CB's way, how many were caught, total yards allowed, etc. That would be a much better indicator of how good a CB really is.


Low tackles and low PD normally = few passes thrown at a CB. Yeah there is the occasional run tackle, and special teams...but on a whole high tackles and high PD does not a good CB make.
 
boys41
offline
Link
 
Just wanted to thank NRobert and Xavier for noticing Battlehammer. He played ROLB for all but 2 games this regular season, then got switched to LOLB. Nice to see a ROLB get some recognition
 
James42688
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GaDawg
Originally posted by octones

I mean since this is a sim game it would be nice if they displayed the number of passes that went a CB's way, how many were caught, total yards allowed, etc. That would be a much better indicator of how good a CB really is.


Low tackles and low PD normally = few passes thrown at a CB. Yeah there is the occasional run tackle, and special teams...but on a whole high tackles and high PD does not a good CB make.


Not necessarily true. your first ex. could be due to the lack of stamina. Also I get way more then the "Occasional run tackle" I rack up 3-5 a game. You cant compare GLB stats to NFL stats

I do agree however that it isnt excusable for a CB to lead the league in tackles. He leads the league in interceptions cuz they throw on him a lot. 2 guys I posted earlier had a very good number of interceptions, a good number of PD, and the main thing they had was close to half Champ Pion's tackles. How is Champ Pion your #1 CB?
Last edited May 31, 2008 19:39:52
 
GaDawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James42688
Originally posted by GaDawg

Originally posted by octones


I mean since this is a sim game it would be nice if they displayed the number of passes that went a CB's way, how many were caught, total yards allowed, etc. That would be a much better indicator of how good a CB really is.


Low tackles and low PD normally = few passes thrown at a CB. Yeah there is the occasional run tackle, and special teams...but on a whole high tackles and high PD does not a good CB make.


Not necessarily true. your first ex. could be due to the lack of stamina. Also I get way more then the "Occasional run tackle" I rack up 3-5 a game. You cant compare GLB stats to NFL stats

I do agree however that it isnt excusable for a CB to lead the league in tackles. He leads the league in interceptions cuz they throw on him a lot. 2 guys I posted earlier had a very good number of interceptions, a good number of PD, and the main thing they had was close to half Champ Pion's tackles. How is Champ Pion your #1 CB?


I didn't say a thing about Champ Pion being #1. CB's that A. don't get thrown on and B. don't give up big plays are in my opinion way more valuable than guys that get 10 tackles a game because they allowed a receiver to CATCH the ball 10 times.

 
Gorf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James42688
Originally posted by GaDawg

Originally posted by octones


I mean since this is a sim game it would be nice if they displayed the number of passes that went a CB's way, how many were caught, total yards allowed, etc. That would be a much better indicator of how good a CB really is.


Low tackles and low PD normally = few passes thrown at a CB. Yeah there is the occasional run tackle, and special teams...but on a whole high tackles and high PD does not a good CB make.


Not necessarily true. your first ex. could be due to the lack of stamina. Also I get way more then the "Occasional run tackle" I rack up 3-5 a game. You cant compare GLB stats to NFL stats

I do agree however that it isnt excusable for a CB to lead the league in tackles. He leads the league in interceptions cuz they throw on him a lot. 2 guys I posted earlier had a very good number of interceptions, a good number of PD, and the main thing they had was close to half Champ Pion's tackles. How is Champ Pion your #1 CB?


Just wanted to agree with this. I have a CB that gets a lot of tackles in run support. Well, he used to until he moved to Pro and starting facing higher level players. When he was playing against equals though, I'd say 1/2 to 3/4 of his tackles were against the run.

A CB that stuffs the run is a valuable asset to any team.
Last edited May 31, 2008 20:01:02
 
James42688
offline
Link
 
Im sorry the last question was directed as a question to everyone and not just you. I totally agree with you. I was just sayin that in GLB there isnt a feasable way of knowing why you're not getting thrown on. You could have bad stamina and that should cause you to have low tackles and PD. And there are way too many unknowns to use low tackles and PD as your guide.

IMO...I think you should use PD and INT with a low amount of tackles to guide. In all honesty people will get left out depending on which teams they play for. There is no feasable way to figure out who truely is the best CBs but cmon everyone...dont vote for interceptions.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.