User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > nfratami says: Endorsements - There Needs to Be More Than 1 Given Per Position
Page:
 
Drago
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Drago

ENDORSEMENTS FOR EVERYONE! EVERYONE GETS AN ENDORSEMENT! YAY!


So where exactly is the negative of EVERYONE getting an endorsement? Granted, the "number 1" lottery winner might get +5 to 3 different attributes and +3 to an SA, while the bottom of the barrel might just be getting +1 confidence, but I don't see how everyone getting something is bad. The "winners" still get an advantage, and still get the better pieces of equipment, but the bottom of the barrel still gets a little bit of love, even if it is small.


Why not just create a new equipment spot then, pants we'll say - for everyone.

Here's my problem with your suggestion DB - it is going to take time and effort to write this stuff into the game, time and effort that could be spent elsewhere increasing the other aspects of the game. Nothing was wrong with the status quo last year... but endorsements are a great idea. Writing this stuff in to help 50% of the GLB population is going to be a lot harder than just the simple... 1 per position, per league.

This was a great suggestion from Bort until a bunch of selfish people started going "Well wait, the chances are I'm going to lose out!" Yes, you are going to lose out... 99% of people are going to lose out. 1% will win. And then, the following year, you get to go through it all again...

When was the last time you saw an endorsement for an offensive lineman?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago

I think 1 per position. per league.
Say it is 2-3 per pos, per conf. Let's say your team loses out, doesn't get any.
Sonow you have 15 teams in the league, some of which have gotten multiple
winning agents... now you have 15 teams that have a distinct advantage
over your squad. How do you propose to keep this from happening?
Theway it is now, there might be 10 teams in your league which get an
advantage at one, maybe two positions - you can gameplan for that/those
positions. Rather than in the situation you've suggested where you're
just going at an uphill battle against all 15 teams.


Ok, I see your point there, the solution is to make a limit to the number of endorsements allowed per team. Now, what does everyone think that # should be? ( there's a tough question I don't have a good answer to as of yet...lol )

*edit- Didn't the whole Chicago Bears offensive line do the "superbowl shuffle" in a commercial way back when?*
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 13:55:19
 
77racing
offline
Link
 
Hutchinson OL for the Vikes has done endorsements
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago
When was the last time you saw an endorsement for an offensive lineman?


i remember getting sick of those visa ads with the entire patriots offensive line (plus brady).
 
Drago
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Drago

When was the last time you saw an endorsement for an offensive lineman?


i remember getting sick of those visa ads with the entire patriots offensive line (plus brady).


Which was really more about Brady, but point taken.
 
Drago
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 77racing
Hutchinson OL for the Vikes has done endorsements


Don't remember any of them. Vikings market only?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Drago
When was the last time you saw an endorsement for an offensive lineman?

i remember getting sick of those visa ads with the entire patriots offensive line (plus brady).

Which was really more about Brady, but point taken.


true... and as i recall, brady actually swung the deal to include them as a way of saying thanks.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago
Originally posted by dmfa41

One per position is kind of silly. I remember Strahan and Jason Taylor both had ads for different things at one point.

As for the flaming: get it out of here.


One or none imo.

Giving a bunch out just makes those players/teams who didn't get as many pieces, or any pieces, at that much more of a disadvantage to the entire league... as opposed to just a few teams in the league who might have gotten a piece or two.


no one has ever asked for a "bunch" 2 QBs in an entire league with endorsements OMG EVERYONE GETS A PIECE OF EQUIPTMENT

responding to your posts are pointless because you make it seem like I want everyone in the league to have a piece of equipment

l2reading comprehension
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago
Originally posted by VladtheImpaler1

Well, just like in real life, I would hope that the endorsements would go to the players earning more fame that season.
You don't see 3rd string "fresh out of college/ suck really bad in NFL " players getting endorsements for Nike do you?


His name was Ryan Leaf. His name is Brady Quinn.

So whoever earns the most fame should just get the equipment hands down then... no lottery system?


this was never said, more putting words in peoples mouths
 
77racing
offline
Link
 
Hutchinson NIKE..
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago
The slippery slope we're going down here is that you people asking for more than 1 per position are going to be that much more upset when you miss out on the gear... and it'll get to the point where, "oh f-it... everyone gets an endorsement." So let's just cut the shit and make a new slot for equipment...


i honestly could care less if i have an endorsement, i think it would be more fun/better practice to implement something into the game that enhances a larger collection of players game play
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago
ENDORSEMENTS FOR EVERYONE! EVERYONE GETS AN ENDORSEMENT! YAY!


wasn't the point at all whatsoever

"hey i dont want everyone in the league to have endorsements, they didnt say that but i guess ill just argue against that"
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago
Originally posted by VladtheImpaler1

ok ok, come on lets try to keep the pages of bickering to a minimum. Can we get back to debating exactly HOW many , per position, per conference / or league, we think is acceptable?

*edit- currently im in favor of around 2-3 per pos. per conf. *


I think 1 per position. per league.

Say it is 2-3 per pos, per conf. Let's say your team loses out, doesn't get any.

So now you have 15 teams in the league, some of which have gotten multiple winning agents... now you have 15 teams that have a distinct advantage over your squad. How do you propose to keep this from happening?

The way it is now, there might be 10 teams in your league which get an advantage at one, maybe two positions - you can gameplan for that/those positions. Rather than in the situation you've suggested where you're just going at an uphill battle against all 15 teams.


If there are more items it is less likely for one team to get a dominant advantage statistically than there is if there are fewer.

Why are you assuming that these items are going to be GAME CHANGING they are going to be an extra piece of equipment. If a QB has custom gear is that going to change your game planning? I would sure hope not lol.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by Drago


ENDORSEMENTS FOR EVERYONE! EVERYONE GETS AN ENDORSEMENT! YAY!


So where exactly is the negative of EVERYONE getting an endorsement? Granted, the "number 1" lottery winner might get +5 to 3 different attributes and +3 to an SA, while the bottom of the barrel might just be getting +1 confidence, but I don't see how everyone getting something is bad. The "winners" still get an advantage, and still get the better pieces of equipment, but the bottom of the barrel still gets a little bit of love, even if it is small.


Why not just create a new equipment spot then, pants we'll say - for everyone.

Here's my problem with your suggestion DB - it is going to take time and effort to write this stuff into the game, time and effort that could be spent elsewhere increasing the other aspects of the game. Nothing was wrong with the status quo last year... but endorsements are a great idea. Writing this stuff in to help 50% of the GLB population is going to be a lot harder than just the simple... 1 per position, per league.

This was a great suggestion from Bort until a bunch of selfish people started going "Well wait, the chances are I'm going to lose out!" Yes, you are going to lose out... 99% of people are going to lose out. 1% will win. And then, the following year, you get to go through it all again...

When was the last time you saw an endorsement for an offensive lineman?


again no one has ever said ANYTHING remotely close to 50% you are creating high numbers in order to make your argument look legit

the biggest discussion about how many per position led to 2 QBs out of a league, 4 WRs out of a league. Want to do the math on those for me? Anywhere close to 50%?
 
77racing
offline
Link
 
Id like to get BORTS thoughts on this topic Before a final plan is decided upon
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.