User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
papman12
offline
Link
 
Look guys we could argue about Devine being All-Pro all day, but we're not gonna get anywhere, besides the Devine controversy can we agree this is a good list?
Last edited Feb 3, 2009 12:53:03
 
LiquidSnake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by papman12
Look guys we could argue about Devine being All-Pro all day, but we're not gonna get anywhere, besides the Devine controversy can we agree this is a good list?



Honestly? No, the #1 team in a conference has one player....I am not saying it needs to be Mike (although we knwo he should be ) but there should be a few other of our players representing an "all-pro team".
 
papman12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LiquidSnake
Originally posted by papman12

Look guys we could argue about Devine being All-Pro all day, but we're not gonna get anywhere, besides the Devine controversy can we agree this is a good list?



Honestly? No, the #1 team in a conference has one player....I am not saying it needs to be Mike (although we knwo he should be ) but there should be a few other of our players representing an "all-pro team".


You guys don't really have a standout star, your team is a bunch of very good not great players with no real weakness.
 
Trashy Menace
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by papman12
Originally posted by LiquidSnake

Originally posted by papman12


Look guys we could argue about Devine being All-Pro all day, but we're not gonna get anywhere, besides the Devine controversy can we agree this is a good list?



Honestly? No, the #1 team in a conference has one player....I am not saying it needs to be Mike (although we knwo he should be ) but there should be a few other of our players representing an "all-pro team".


You guys don't really have a standout star, your team is a bunch of very good not great players with no real weakness.


He still has a very valid point. Even if he has a solid team all around, there are players that are above and beyond the rest of the team that deserve recognition.

With your reasoning, a player on a crappy team would get consideration over a player on a top level team. The player on the crappy team may put up good stats, cause there are no other options.

But did he really help his team, or did he just put up stats?

More should be considered than just stats, imo.
Last edited Feb 3, 2009 14:20:01
 
Trashy Menace
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oban14
Originally posted by Psykomamba

I'm kinda wondering where Jacob Press-Hansen is?
3rd in rushing yards and was a cornerstone i El Dorados offense.. had good numbers and all the games and was a factor in all thier games.. Not to say the two (three, i kinda gave up in all the quotes of the quote stuff) others HBs aren't great, but he should still be noticed to this..


Who are you going to bump? Noel had more TDs and also was in the top 10 for receivers.


See my comment above. Selection should not be based entirely on stats.

What the players value was to the team should be considered as well.

Jacob Press was a HUGE part of El Dorado's success this year. (I'm not knocking the accomplishments of the other RBs being discussed in any way. And if they are a huge part of their teams success, than I see your point.)
 
Trashy Menace
offline
Link
 
I apologize for the multiple posts in a row, but another thing that should be considered is the quality of opponent.

IMO, stats vs gutting or poor teams should be thrown out.

33 TDs in a 255-0 blow out doesn't impress me.

Stats vs Quality teams are what should matter.
 
Koi
offline
Link
 
Just remember, Jacob had the same chance to put up numbers against weak teams.

I personally don't care if the stats are against weak are good teams. Everyone HAD the same chance to put up numbers.

Once again, Someone didn't get mention. So they bitch because there feelings are hurt.
Last edited Feb 3, 2009 16:27:25
 
buckwild
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koi
Just remember, Jacob had the same chance to put up numbers against weak teams.

I personally don't care if the stats are against weak are good teams. Everyone HAD the same chance to put up numbers.

Once again, Someone didn't get mention. So they bitch because there feelings are hurt.


+1
gotta hate that sand in the mangina whine.
 
Trashy Menace
offline
Link
 
I'm not whining, I'm just bringing some perspective to the whole conversation.

It is very possible that Jacob Press is 4th in line, and doesn't make the All South America team, and that is fine.

Press had 8 games against solid competition. The 3 other RBs in this discussion had 5 games, 7 games, and 7 games. That leaves more blowout games for them to rack up overall stats.

I propose that the stats be taken into account on a per game average vs quality opponents.

I haven't worked through the stats, but I will tomorrow. I'll post them after.

Again, I'm not whining, but it makes no sense to go by the overall stats.
 
Koi
offline
Link
 
Once again... jacob faced the same talent as some of the other RB's. He had the chance and didn't post up the numbers. I could care less the quality of the oppenents.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
How do you take into account a teams subbing philosophy? If you have your team set to sub at 28 points in the first quarter and every subsequent quarter your stars are not going to see the field as much in an attempt to create greater team unity. While another team may leave their starters in allowing a RB to rack up 33 TD's? The pure numbers argument is garbage --- half the teams in this league were blown out by the top six or seven in every game.

You fail to realize the favor backup scenarios and then punish those players on those teams that do exactly that ---
 
Trashy Menace
offline
Link
 
Koi - Seriously, you should take a step back and not get so defensive. ... I haven't even looked to see how the numbers stack up when removing the blow out games. It is just my opinion that they shouldn't be counted. I'll look at numbers tomorrow and post them.

The 1 thing I do know is that Press had fewer games against horrible teams. That does put his overall stats at a disadvantage.

If a player gets 10 games vs poor talent and another gets 8 games who is going to put up the best overall stats?

I'll provide stats for everyone to look at tomorrow. It may not change anything. But it will be more accurate than the "overall" numbers.
 
Trashy Menace
offline
Link
 
Fwiw, I'm pretty sure Keo Oda's numbers will still be tops.

And the other 3 RBs numbers should hold up fairly well.

I'm not knocking their stats or season in any way.
 
LiquidSnake
offline
Link
 
Well the point has been proven, that good teams have more ALL PRO players then the subpar teams.....its a real life situation as well.
 
Koi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Trashy Menace
Koi - Seriously, you should take a step back and not get so defensive. ... I haven't even looked to see how the numbers stack up when removing the blow out games. It is just my opinion that they shouldn't be counted. I'll look at numbers tomorrow and post them.

The 1 thing I do know is that Press had fewer games against horrible teams. That does put his overall stats at a disadvantage.

If a player gets 10 games vs poor talent and another gets 8 games who is going to put up the best overall stats?

I'll provide stats for everyone to look at tomorrow. It may not change anything. But it will be more accurate than the "overall" numbers.



Take a step back from what? I don't take anything serious about this game. It's still in beta for christ sakes. I just get really tired of these threads and the arguments that quickly develop. I mean really? Who cares if Jacob is a stud against great teams. Who cares if Miles couldn't get it going against good teams? I mean really? Do any of us care? No we don't. Like I said before, Every time this threads pop up. There more about stroking ego's and just flat out bragging about something that means little in the game

But be my guess. Post your awesome stats. Wow the rest of us with this new found data.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.