User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > ReProgram the Simulation - Redo The Game
Page:
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Aholewanker
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Le-Bump.

Paired with a 100% Flex Refund and a reset, Bort could actually make a full new sim with things he always wanted like an "acceleration" attribute.

I'd be up for that. So long as I got all of my Flex back I'd definitely stick around.

Also a bump so I can get the man's opinion on it. I haven't seen his opinion on any threads in this section in ages. Actually, not since he posted one himself. Lemme know you're alive and well, Bort. Just gimmie a bone and post a message here, it can be blank for all I care. Just lemme know you read it.


Good luck with that. He's currently researching what else he can implement before fixing what is broken.


LOL.

I wish this would happen though.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Reset for sure, or no more money out of this man's pocket.

My players will be rinsed and reused from here on out
Last edited Jan 14, 2009 13:55:27
 
mastawoo
offline
Link
 
I didn't read all of this. Ignorance FTW.

Make two sims. A "legacy" sim and an "improved" sim. One will be the inflated stats and blah blah blah, so kind of season 5 to today-ish, and the other a new one that is exactly what the OP states. Make that one the hardcore sim player version. Perhaps set it up at the league level, like MMORPGS do on occasion. You know, here's a mean world, and here's a noob world. People can choose what side to be on.

So if you're pissed about the sim constantly and whine all the time, go play the inflated one and there ya have it, no more worries. And if you're just casual and would rather see your DE have 47 sacks or your RB have 55 TDs, you can go inflated and not complain about being nerfed.

But if you really want a game that's as close to accurate as possible, cross on over to the realism side.

Just my 2 cents.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
bump for similar threads popping up.
 
Homsar16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Should have figured this would get no responses, its an actual suggestion that makes sense. Forget it, we'll just implement weight classes, positional soft caps, nerf-hammers and automatic slowdown/speedups to compensate for the mechanics.

Seriously people, its the mechanics that are the core of the game and I think that's really what Bort got a chance to learn about. When he sits there and says "I wish I had put in an acceleration attribute" it shows that there are things he didn't consider when he built the game (Which is totally understandable, he had no way to know until he tested it and he really did a great job considering all the things he did get.). I think with these focuses on a rewrite of the mechanics he could enrich the experience and get rid of a lot of the unbalanced portions of the game without having to nerf builds left and right.


Tooting your own horn ftl.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Homsar16
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Should have figured this would get no responses, its an actual suggestion that makes sense. Forget it, we'll just implement weight classes, positional soft caps, nerf-hammers and automatic slowdown/speedups to compensate for the mechanics.

Seriously people, its the mechanics that are the core of the game and I think that's really what Bort got a chance to learn about. When he sits there and says "I wish I had put in an acceleration attribute" it shows that there are things he didn't consider when he built the game (Which is totally understandable, he had no way to know until he tested it and he really did a great job considering all the things he did get.). I think with these focuses on a rewrite of the mechanics he could enrich the experience and get rid of a lot of the unbalanced portions of the game without having to nerf builds left and right.


Tooting your own horn ftl.


Yeah. By trying to elicit a response with a controversial first line, then systematically listing the older proposed ideas as things I don't want to do, then stating what I think should be done I totally tooted my own horn.

Or was it where I praised Bort on the job that he did in constructing this simulation and getting a lot of things right? Or the part where I said where I was adamant that if he did this he could probably improve the game a lot?

Define "tooting your own horn" if its being hopeful, stating that the developer has done awesomely so far and could fix the game by going back and using what he has learned.. I guess I'm guilty as charged.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
I'd call a "reasonable speed" for an O-lineman about 25 Speed in GLB terms.


A pop-warner OL maybe. But an NFL OT...his speed would arguably be more in the 1st-2nd-cap range if not higher in GLB terms. I think the way speed works in this game is for relevance to the level of competition you're up against - 'game speed' for the lack of a better description. You never hear rookies saying they have to adjust to the 'strength' of the pro's....it's always the 'speed'. Sure the combine has the bench press to test strength. But if you look at the entire event, the large majority of the tests are geared toward measuring speed and agility - 10-yd dash, 40-yd dash, short shuttle, long shuttle, 3-cone drill, broad jump, vertical leap, etc. It's quite clear where the NFL places it's emphasis thus why you'll always here draft analysts claim some guy just made himself a few extra million because he ran a 4.29 40-yd dash. I'm not saying strength shouldn't have more relevance in GLB but in terms of the focus on speed/agility, I don't think GLB is as unrealistic as some claim it to be.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAGA45
Originally posted by Ken1

I'd call a "reasonable speed" for an O-lineman about 25 Speed in GLB terms.


A pop-warner OL maybe. But an NFL OT...his speed would arguably be more in the 1st-2nd-cap range if not higher in GLB terms. I think the way speed works in this game is for relevance to the level of competition you're up against - 'game speed' for the lack of a better description. You never hear rookies saying they have to adjust to the 'strength' of the pro's....it's always the 'speed'. Sure the combine has the bench press to test strength. But if you look at the entire event, the large majority of the tests are geared toward measuring speed and agility - 10-yd dash, 40-yd dash, short shuttle, long shuttle, 3-cone drill, broad jump, vertical leap, etc. It's quite clear where the NFL places it's emphasis thus why you'll always here draft analysts claim some guy just made himself a few extra million because he ran a 4.29 40-yd dash. I'm not saying strength shouldn't have more relevance in GLB but in terms of the focus on speed/agility, I don't think GLB is as unrealistic as some claim it to be.


A-men. I'd say maybe 1st - almost second range. 48 or so, maybe on speed. And 60+ on agility for the truly elite.

Anyone who disagrees with you on that post, to me, simply hasn't watched a good OT block. The speed and especially the agility they display in the performance of their craft is flat out amazing. Same for any good Defensive End. Then, and only then cause for any human being they are impressive, when you consider how big they are you realize just how flat out jaw dropping some people's athleticism can really be.
Last edited Jan 17, 2009 00:24:31
 
cjx
offline
Link
 
I agree with the need for a ground up re-code. Preferably with a total wipe so that some new ideas could be implemented. Mostly though making the sim cleaner and more interesting and making different attributes count for something would be good enough for me. Personally I think a salary cap is a necessary evil, but I'll avoid that conversation for now.

My biggest disagreement with your suggestion is the timeline. Season 10 should be the last season before "the big change". Let season 1 characters have a full life. Keep the original sim around, but obviously don't allow new characters to be created and FORCE RETIREMENT after a character's 10th season.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.