User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Suggestion to slow down gutting and killing teams
Page:
 
Link
 
Exactly. We all understand the draw backs I think of not being able to massively fix a team overnight and we all understand the complications of being an 'early career owner' but the gutting needs to be discouraged and the firesales, i'm tellin' you right now, and you can quote me on this shit if it were to happen.

If you make it so that you can ONLY trade a max of 5 players off of your team per season for At most, max cash each, then I am willing to bet, there'll be a LOT less trading.

our teams require us to have 40 players. You're telling me, that people are going to spend 8 seasons firesaling a single rosteR? Have fun with that.

It's extreme discouragement.
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jackriley
Exactly. We all understand the draw backs I think of not being able to massively fix a team overnight and we all understand the complications of being an 'early career owner' but the gutting needs to be discouraged and the firesales, i'm tellin' you right now, and you can quote me on this shit if it were to happen.

If you make it so that you can ONLY trade a max of 5 players off of your team per season for At most, max cash each, then I am willing to bet, there'll be a LOT less trading.

our teams require us to have 40 players. You're telling me, that people are going to spend 8 seasons firesaling a single rosteR? Have fun with that.

It's extreme discouragement.


You must be new at gutting, because that's like soooo 3 seasons ago. There are many ways around this - I "legally" gut a team last season without having to trade a single person.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
Originally posted by jackriley

Exactly. We all understand the draw backs I think of not being able to massively fix a team overnight and we all understand the complications of being an 'early career owner' but the gutting needs to be discouraged and the firesales, i'm tellin' you right now, and you can quote me on this shit if it were to happen.

If you make it so that you can ONLY trade a max of 5 players off of your team per season for At most, max cash each, then I am willing to bet, there'll be a LOT less trading.

our teams require us to have 40 players. You're telling me, that people are going to spend 8 seasons firesaling a single rosteR? Have fun with that.

It's extreme discouragement.


You must be new at gutting, because that's like soooo 3 seasons ago. There are many ways around this - I "legally" gut a team last season without having to trade a single person.


Thats why, if you scan back a few pages, I also suggested the idea of putting a severe limit on how many people you can cut.

Am I new to gutting? Idk, I don't gut my teams, so .. i guess that makes me a 'virgin to gutting'?
 
Viscount
offline
Link
 
I thought I'd check out for myself how many owners have actually 'gutted' teams since the start of the season. I just went through 52 pages of the Trading Block forum and found that since the start of this season 87 teams have had a Fire Sale or were trading multiple players (I defined that as 7+players).

There are currently 5696 teams in GLB excluding D-Leagues and Pee Wee. I know that I couldn't have counted every single team that was being gutted and that a lot more teams will be gutted during the rest of the season, but so far that means only 1.5% of GLB owners have publicly gutted their teams. There's also the fact that only about half of those who gutted their teams actually sold their team back to the CPU, most kept their teams and possibly went slow build.

This would mean that throughout an entire season only about 5% of GLB owners would likely 'gut' and sell their team.

The suggestion in this thread would affect 100% of GLB owners, when it's only a solution to a problem caused by 5% of those owners.
Is it really worth it?
 
Tom Condon
offline
Link
 
three seasons and there should NOT be forced promotion. If asked am sure most would agree, but owners should still be asked
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Viscount
I thought I'd check out for myself how many owners have actually 'gutted' teams since the start of the season. I just went through 52 pages of the Trading Block forum and found that since the start of this season 87 teams have had a Fire Sale or were trading multiple players (I defined that as 7+players).

There are currently 5696 teams in GLB excluding D-Leagues and Pee Wee. I know that I couldn't have counted every single team that was being gutted and that a lot more teams will be gutted during the rest of the season, but so far that means only 1.5% of GLB owners have publicly gutted their teams. There's also the fact that only about half of those who gutted their teams actually sold their team back to the CPU, most kept their teams and possibly went slow build.

This would mean that throughout an entire season only about 5% of GLB owners would likely 'gut' and sell their team.

The suggestion in this thread would affect 100% of GLB owners, when it's only a solution to a problem caused by 5% of those owners.
Is it really worth it?


First of all, that 'information' imo, is severely flawed. Because like you said, THIS season, 87 teams. Last season it was probably another 87+ teams. That's ONLY on the topic of fire sales in the trading block.

In reality, it doesn't even remotely TOUCH the real issue of gutting, which, more often than not, DOES happen behind the seasons.

Is it worth it to make GLB a even playing field and discourage things that, quite frankly are bad for business? YES, IT ABSOLUTELY IS!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.