User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
billthekill
offline
Link
 
I think instead of making "breaking tackle" the end-all, you should incoperate more of the "brick wall" veteran ability.

Say a CB with 30 str / 30 taackle attempts to tackle the said powerback. Let him make the tackle more often than it current is but, only after being dragged for an extra 2 or 3 yards.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze
Probably 80+ Str...70+ Tackling...

Depends on the formula for tackling a player...which only you know


this
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Bort how about making vision more important to tackling elusive RBs? Lower vision guys get head faked, juked, whatever easier.
 
boondocksaint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knicksfan20
a player with


60 str/60agility/60speed/60tackle should be like...the ultimate build in this game.


I don't think this should be the "ultimate build" as in always effective, though a player with these base att's should be good. I'd add in 60 vision also, and this player should be a solid "lunchbucket" type player... not spectacular at any one thing, but gets the job done pretty well overall.
 
iMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by iMan

Originally posted by TuNice


Originally posted by iMan



IRL, the most important thing you need to make a good tackle is CONFIDENCE


that is actually true lol


thank you.
you ever see those guys that always go for you feet?
and then those monsters that jsut drop their pads and nail you to the ground?
the first one is scared of being hurt and the second one is about to hurt you


No one can lower their pads if the guys dives at the feet, they may just get run over because he's moving to fast to trip up or wrap up by the legs but the best place to hit a very big, strong back is in the side of the knee or shin, you'll get them almost everytime.


you know i was talking about a defensive player.
lots of CB, when faced with a heads up tackle, instead of stepping in, the kinda wait on the side and at the last moment dive for your feet.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Bort


How do you define "elusive" or "power" back for this, though? Just based on their running style?


Well, elusive broken tackles and power broken tackles are calculated differently ain't they? Maybe it should be "power moves" and "elusive moves" instead of "power/elusive back".


Elusive guys don't really break tackles except for spinning - they avoid contact entirely with fakes and such. Breaking tackles is a power back thing.

Maybe just

Power: more likely to get fooled by head fake/juke/spin
Wrap: more likely to get trucked
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Yeah tbh Bort this thread does nothing but prove that the attribute system is flawed.
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
There just needs to be a big stamina hit on players without quality tackling trying to tackle a power back in the open field. This will simulate the ability of a power back to wear down smaller defenders over the course of the game.

In a 1on1 situation head to head the power back will lay down some big punishment but in many cases the weaker player will cut him down or at the very least get him down to a stand still 95% of the time allowing other players to clean up after him.

Poor tacklers coming in from a side angle though are going to have a very difficult time dealing with the power back and he'd break a lot of those tackles, just like in real life especially if he can't get in good position to tackle.

From behind the power back can be tackled in a lot of cases by the faster player catching up and essentially tripping him up.

If the player is able to get in good position to tackle the power back then he'll bring him down 95% of the time, if he's in poor position to start his tackle though he's going to get him maybe 10% of the time.

The more tackling the easier the tackle from good positioning but to drag a guy down from a bad spot it should be all about strength. Corners should only need 40 or 50 tackling at MOST and it should be factored in better that they are usually in a great spot to make the tackle. Strength here really isn't an issue unless you want a corner lighting up the power back. However a linebacker or defensive lineman is often involved with a blocker or dealing with bodies all over forcing him to rely on his strength and ability to hang on/wrap up so a good tackler at linebacker would be 70/70 and a good tackler at defensive line could be 90/55 or 80/60 where as a good tackler at corner is at 20/40 because he's in the open field and has the advantage there because of his agility and speed.

The real question mark are safeties, because a lot of the great ones in real life can tackle like a linebacker but I'd rate them at 50/60 to really drag down a ball carrier, the main reason being that the safety plugs the hole running at full speed leading to a huge impact because the power back won't be nearly at top speed yet.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 19:20:23
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
If HBs needed acceleration, the power backs wouldn't be able to have those stats in the first place.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Bort how about making vision more important to tackling elusive RBs? Lower vision guys get head faked, juked, whatever easier.


That's already the case.

I'm mainly interested in the state of the power back here.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Power: more likely to get fooled by head fake/juke/spin
Wrap: more likely to get trucked


Yeah, that's pretty much what I meant. Just wanted to get fancy with bolding and stuff.
 
TuNice
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by iMan
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by iMan


Originally posted by TuNice



Originally posted by iMan




IRL, the most important thing you need to make a good tackle is CONFIDENCE


that is actually true lol


thank you.
you ever see those guys that always go for you feet?
and then those monsters that jsut drop their pads and nail you to the ground?
the first one is scared of being hurt and the second one is about to hurt you


No one can lower their pads if the guys dives at the feet, they may just get run over because he's moving to fast to trip up or wrap up by the legs but the best place to hit a very big, strong back is in the side of the knee or shin, you'll get them almost everytime.


you know i was talking about a defensive player.
lots of CB, when faced with a heads up tackle, instead of stepping in, the kinda wait on the side and at the last moment dive for your feet.


or a mixture of the two. They run full speed at them and tackling their shin
 
EastBayFunk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by kalkmanc

the gang tackling is the main thing.its pretty fake when there are 8 defensive dots on top of 1 offensive dots and they all miss the tackle.


Maybe that's the next thing I need to look at adding - the ability to be dragged and slow down the guy when missing a tackle instead of just always bouncing off.


I think if you look at how power backs work in the NFL, that's more realistic. They don't necessarily break a lot of huge runs, but they'll get you some extra yards here and there by falling forward or breaking arm tackles.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Firenze

Probably 80+ Str...70+ Tackling...

Depends on the formula for tackling a player...which only you know


I'm kinda asking: if you were determine how the formula worked, what would you think goes into it?

Opinions vary widely and I want to see where they are.


So we are talking the big leagues here right?

The problem is that it does not scale.

Take a 13 cap league. The RB puts every signal point int ST.

In today's sims, that translates into massive yards. Last season it did not, this season it does.

 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by kalkmanc

the gang tackling is the main thing.its pretty fake when there are 8 defensive dots on top of 1 offensive dots and they all miss the tackle.


Maybe that's the next thing I need to look at adding - the ability to be dragged and slow down the guy when missing a tackle instead of just always bouncing off.


Seems like the HBs are already slowing quite a bit when they plow through guys...does it not?

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.