User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Promotion/Demotion at the end of the off-season and the problems associated with it - need ideas
Page:
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
1) Stop trying to save "everybody". You miss your expiration deadline, tough titties. And, no, it won't happen to me.
2) Promotion/demotion should start at the top (Pro League), not at the bottom. The 1st thing you need to do is send all CPU teams to the bottom. 2nd, send all gutted/slow build teams to level appropriate league. 3rd, fill the empty spots with the promoted teams from below using the criteria you set up in your announcement about a week ago. If you start at the top of the tree, you can't screw up.
3)You can't promote a 1st year team to an uncapped league.
4)No freezes are necessary. Someone could sell their team on day 1. So where do you draw the line? You will always have a CPU team in high level leagues, people's priorities change, you can't stop it.
5)This kind of discussion needs to start more than 3 days before the season ends if you want actual help, like you asked for.
6)You posted a the promotion order, is there a demotion list that you follow? Maybe you should post that as well.
 
boilerup
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by supgreg
1) Stop trying to save "everybody". You miss your expiration deadline, tough titties. And, no, it won't happen to me.
2) Promotion/demotion should start at the top (Pro League), not at the bottom. The 1st thing you need to do is send all CPU teams to the bottom. 2nd, send all gutted/slow build teams to level appropriate league. 3rd, fill the empty spots with the promoted teams from below using the criteria you set up in your announcement about a week ago. If you start at the top of the tree, you can't screw up.
3)You can't promote a 1st year team to an uncapped league.
4)No freezes are necessary. Someone could sell their team on day 1. So where do you draw the line? You will always have a CPU team in high level leagues, people's priorities change, you can't stop it.
5)This kind of discussion needs to start more than 3 days before the season ends if you want actual help, like you asked for.
6)You posted a the promotion order, is there a demotion list that you follow? Maybe you should post that as well.


Not much here I'd disagree with, especially point No. 5.

Glad to see some logically thinking people made it to the thread finally. Hope Bort makes it to Pages 8-9.

Last edited Dec 20, 2008 13:42:20
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
It'd also be nice to be told that if you aren't selling your team back, but most agents on the team want to rebuild their players, from lvl 1 up, you can no matter what level of competition you've made it to so far. For example, that's exactly what we want to do on my team, but we're in Africa AAA, which means we cannot sign the lvl 1's, because AAA has a minimum lvl signing number of 20.

I contacted Support, and was told by an admin who will remain anonymous in here, to basically piss off, and there wasn't shit anyone would do for me, because I didn't finish second to last, or last in my conference during season 6.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but wouldn't you want to help out a team owner who's owned his team since the halfway mark of season 2, kept the team, boosted his players, and not had any complaints drawn against him as an owner as of yet, rather than basically helping out the new guy who'll get a gutted team down at BBB level?

A self-gut, non-resale team should be able to move down if they so choose to. I agree with some of the other things said recently in this thread, but this is the pressing matter on my mind.
 
Snaza
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero

A self-gut, non-resale team should be able to move down if they so choose to. I agree with some of the other things said recently in this thread, but this is the pressing matter on my mind.


^ This.. and this v...

2) Promotion/demotion should start at the top (Pro League), not at the bottom. The 1st thing you need to do is send all CPU teams to the bottom. 2nd, send all gutted/slow build teams to level appropriate league. 3rd, fill the empty spots with the promoted teams from below using the criteria you set up in your announcement about a week ago. If you start at the top of the tree, you can't screw up.

Which supgreg posted.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Interestingly enough, in Bort's latest Admin Announcement, he says this:

"We are NOT doing league swaps this season since it has caused such a big headache every time we have done it in the past. However, you can still request to be flagged for demotion to the bottom level, or down one level, if your team is a slow build team or can't hack it at their level."

Which begs the question...why the hell can't my team, which is self-gutting and slow-building for season 7 with lvl 1's, or wanting to, be demoted?

Can someone tell me?
 
Colin Mochrie
offline
Link
 
wrong thread.
Last edited Dec 20, 2008 17:12:53
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
Interestingly enough, in Bort's latest Admin Announcement, he says this:

"We are NOT doing league swaps this season since it has caused such a big headache every time we have done it in the past. However, you can still request to be flagged for demotion to the bottom level, or down one level, if your team is a slow build team or can't hack it at their level."

Which begs the question...why the hell can't my team, which is self-gutting and slow-building for season 7 with lvl 1's, or wanting to, be demoted?

Can someone tell me?


i'm confused - because within your OWN quote of Bort - you quoted this:

"However, you can still request to be flagged for demotion to the bottom level, or down one level, if your team is a slow build team or can't hack it at their level."

send a ticket to support requesting to be 'flagged for demotion to the bottom level'
 
boilerup
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by boilerup
Glad to see some logically thinking people made it to the thread finally. Hope Bort makes it to Pages 8-9.


Guess that didn't happen.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
Originally posted by turnerhero

Interestingly enough, in Bort's latest Admin Announcement, he says this:

"We are NOT doing league swaps this season since it has caused such a big headache every time we have done it in the past. However, you can still request to be flagged for demotion to the bottom level, or down one level, if your team is a slow build team or can't hack it at their level."

Which begs the question...why the hell can't my team, which is self-gutting and slow-building for season 7 with lvl 1's, or wanting to, be demoted?

Can someone tell me?


i'm confused - because within your OWN quote of Bort - you quoted this:

"However, you can still request to be flagged for demotion to the bottom level, or down one level, if your team is a slow build team or can't hack it at their level."

send a ticket to support requesting to be 'flagged for demotion to the bottom level'


He did send the ticket and got denied, that's his problem and why he quoted Bort as saying that.
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
I'm not sure what happened with this. Going to epic it as a reminder. Just move it back out or whatever if it's already been done.
 
MessorLord
offline
Link
 
Bort i was on a team that was doing really well. Playoffs ever since their creation but by the time this moving up was implemented we were moved up to AAA and got slaughtered. We disbanded right after the season
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Usama


I agree with these sentiments. An average lv.20 team should be able to beat a lv.30 team, with better gameplanning, with builds being the controlled variable.


The bolded statement is something I disagree with. Around Level 20, many of your skills are still in the 1:1 range. Most players have put 1-2 skills over the first soft cap, and nothing more. The builds are still lacking, still relatively unbalanced, still young. Around Level 30, the builds are more rounded, VAs have also kicked in to aid in abilities, and many players have more skills over the soft cap.

The higher your level, the closer teams should be. I'd agree with you if you were to say a Level 50 team should beat a Level 60 team with greater game planning, because by then many players have MULTIPLE skills into the 2:1, 3:1 even 4:1 range. That makes those 50 SP from the 10 levels much less 'effective' since 50 SP may only add 12 points to the skills.

However, at Level 20-30, those 50 SP can often times add 35-50 points into the overall build, depending on which skill you're increasing.

The reason higher level players can "shorten the gap" is because of the cost to increase some capped attributes. The lower your player, the cheaper it is to improve his build, and this results in a larger "gap" between players.
 
MessorLord
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staz
Originally posted by Usama



I agree with these sentiments. An average lv.20 team should be able to beat a lv.30 team, with better gameplanning, with builds being the controlled variable.


The bolded statement is something I disagree with. Around Level 20, many of your skills are still in the 1:1 range. Most players have put 1-2 skills over the first soft cap, and nothing more. The builds are still lacking, still relatively unbalanced, still young. Around Level 30, the builds are more rounded, VAs have also kicked in to aid in abilities, and many players have more skills over the soft cap.

The higher your level, the closer teams should be. I'd agree with you if you were to say a Level 50 team should beat a Level 60 team with greater game planning, because by then many players have MULTIPLE skills into the 2:1, 3:1 even 4:1 range. That makes those 50 SP from the 10 levels much less 'effective' since 50 SP may only add 12 points to the skills.

However, at Level 20-30, those 50 SP can often times add 35-50 points into the overall build, depending on which skill you're increasing.

The reason higher level players can "shorten the gap" is because of the cost to increase some capped attributes. The lower your player, the cheaper it is to improve his build, and this results in a larger "gap" between players.


I agree totally because i ahve been on the end of it because they add higher teams to my league and well its not easy when everyone wants to go to another team. But eh pains of being an owner i call it
 
gijosh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
Originally posted by turnerhero

Interestingly enough, in Bort's latest Admin Announcement, he says this:

"We are NOT doing league swaps this season since it has caused such a big headache every time we have done it in the past. However, you can still request to be flagged for demotion to the bottom level, or down one level, if your team is a slow build team or can't hack it at their level."

Which begs the question...why the hell can't my team, which is self-gutting and slow-building for season 7 with lvl 1's, or wanting to, be demoted?

Can someone tell me?


i'm confused - because within your OWN quote of Bort - you quoted this:

"However, you can still request to be flagged for demotion to the bottom level, or down one level, if your team is a slow build team or can't hack it at their level."

send a ticket to support requesting to be 'flagged for demotion to the bottom level'

/support ticket for demotion doesnt work. ive been doing it for four seasons now.

The problem is mid-season, someone guts and takes my team's place at the bottom two. I have made good economic decisions for my team. our stadium is complete. I still cant recruit anyone good. Players dont go to teams that can pay them big salaries. they want winning teams. I have no idea how my team has an advantage over anyone.

they need to drop all CPUs to the bottom. then level appropraite drops to take care of sell-offs and gut-jobs. then promote accordingly. the fact that i finish int hebottom three every year ahead of a gut job and sell off team is frustrating and becoming un-fun. at some poitn Id like to play teams that are real competition. Id also liek for those games not be scrimmages I have to pay for.

 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
The OP is how it works now. Implemented, moved out of epic, added to past epic suggestions. Locking up.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.