User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Have "Superstars" and "All-Pros"
Page:
 
satandole666
offline
Link
 
This is just one of a few band-aid fixes that are currently active topics. This won't change anything if some of the underlying mechanics aren't changed.

Attributes need to be balanced better. I've seen it mentioned in other threads and I think it is a great idea.

Special Abilities need to be improved. Change the effectiveness or come up with new ones. There needs to be actual tough decisions to make when it comes to spending skill points. Currently this isn't the case because 1/2 of every positions abilities are useless (or one/two are significantly better than the rest) and Speed/Agil seems to be the way to go with every position that isn't an interior lineman.

We don't need flex or random skill points to differentiate players. That is the purpose of skill points in the first place. The problem is game balance pure and simple. If there was more than one or two ways to build a dominant player you would see it. No amount of cash or skill points can change that.
 
R.Williams 34
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
It has to be random flames, Bort is never going to and should never raise the price of anything.

Getting a "superstar" or 'Allpro" player neds to be totally random if this is ever going to come into affect.

I also would support another attribute or a new SA Tree unlocking at Lvl 29. Anything to give the boosting player something more to do after 3 seasons. Right now we have 3 seasons of growth, then 7 seasons of not much to do.


bad idea, if some one is smart they can just keep makin the guy and retiring him until he gets a superstar.
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by R.Williams34
Originally posted by britdevine316

It has to be random flames, Bort is never going to and should never raise the price of anything.

Getting a "superstar" or 'Allpro" player neds to be totally random if this is ever going to come into affect.

I also would support another attribute or a new SA Tree unlocking at Lvl 29. Anything to give the boosting player something more to do after 3 seasons. Right now we have 3 seasons of growth, then 7 seasons of not much to do.


bad idea, if some one is smart they can just keep makin the guy and retiring him until he gets a superstar.


They wont know till LVL 29, which they have already spent 2-3 seasons worth of boosts or like 5-6 seasons of non boosting. If you want to burn $ as a booster, I guess you could just retire till you get a "superstar", but then again they should be limited to 2 superstars per agent at a time.
 
kjara
offline
Link
 
It needs more limiting on the number per team.

I think 2 superstars and 5 All-Pros is more than sufficient.
 
R.Williams 34
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
Originally posted by R.Williams34

Originally posted by britdevine316


It has to be random flames, Bort is never going to and should never raise the price of anything.

Getting a "superstar" or 'Allpro" player neds to be totally random if this is ever going to come into affect.

I also would support another attribute or a new SA Tree unlocking at Lvl 29. Anything to give the boosting player something more to do after 3 seasons. Right now we have 3 seasons of growth, then 7 seasons of not much to do.


bad idea, if some one is smart they can just keep makin the guy and retiring him until he gets a superstar.


They wont know till LVL 29, which they have already spent 2-3 seasons worth of boosts or like 5-6 seasons of non boosting. If you want to burn $ as a booster, I guess you could just retire till you get a "superstar", but then again they should be limited to 2 superstars per agent at a time.


Originally posted by kjara
It needs more limiting on the number per team.

I think 2 superstars and 5 All-Pros is more than sufficient.


so you would have to wait till lvl 29 to relize if your a spuer star or not? ok not a bad idea except one problem, IE i jus made a QB hoping to god he turns out to be my superstar, but the team im on needed an OT so i make on too. lvl 29 comes around and my OT is the superstar. well not many teams are going to want sign a superstar OT as 1 of their 2 superstars they are aloud to have. maybe an allpro lineman would be signed, if all 5 of your allpros were your lineman then you have your 2 superstar as defensive players, 1 MLB and 1 DE. thats how i would do it. but you cant tell which player will become the superstar.

what could be done is for the superstar player, each agent is aloud ,o IDK 3 superstar and5 allpro players. the superstar player would 2x as much FP to creat and boost, and the all pro players would cost 1.5x as much flex to creat and boost. now for a superstar they receive a 50% training boost and once they reach a certain lvl then they would begin to get more exp or more SP. because if you think about it not every superstar was the superstar when he was a rookie, most of them took a yr or 2 to bloom, so by starting out with just an increase in training then once they hit lvl 20? they would begin to get more SP. IE if lvl 20 is what is decided the lvls 20-25 would get 6 SP, 26-30 would get 7 SPs, and 31-retirement would get 8 SPs, and 8 would be the max they could receive. i think that the more SPs should start at lvl 20 mainly because your player is still in his prime, once you get to i think its lvl 29 thats when you get 25 exp/night and 100exp/game. so by starting earlier than the exp cap makes it more fun for the GLB player. same thing goes for all-pros except they only get a 20% training increase and their max SP should be 7 not 8.
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Id take a Superstar OT. Why are LOT's sometimes the highest picks in the draft, they are very important.

Also limiting it to 2 superstars and 4 all pro's by agent along with 2 superstars and 4 all pro's per team would be a good idea.
Last edited Dec 1, 2008 12:45:05
 
R.Williams 34
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
Id take a Superstar OT. Why are LOT's sometimes the highest picks in the draft, they are very important.

Also limiting it to 2 superstars and 4 all pro's by agent along with 2 superstars and 4 all pro's per team would be a good idea.


i mean i agree an amzing line is so important, look at the bengals, we have great skill players but no line to protect our QB to give him time to get the ball out to the skill players. a line is incredibly important. i just personaly would make it my allpro players be line and my 2 superstars be LB and DE.
 
R.Williams 34
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by R.Williams34
Originally posted by britdevine316

Originally posted by R.Williams34


Originally posted by britdevine316



It has to be random flames, Bort is never going to and should never raise the price of anything.

Getting a "superstar" or 'Allpro" player neds to be totally random if this is ever going to come into affect.

I also would support another attribute or a new SA Tree unlocking at Lvl 29. Anything to give the boosting player something more to do after 3 seasons. Right now we have 3 seasons of growth, then 7 seasons of not much to do.


bad idea, if some one is smart they can just keep makin the guy and retiring him until he gets a superstar.


They wont know till LVL 29, which they have already spent 2-3 seasons worth of boosts or like 5-6 seasons of non boosting. If you want to burn $ as a booster, I guess you could just retire till you get a "superstar", but then again they should be limited to 2 superstars per agent at a time.


Originally posted by kjara

It needs more limiting on the number per team.

I think 2 superstars and 5 All-Pros is more than sufficient.


so you would have to wait till lvl 29 to relize if your a spuer star or not? ok not a bad idea except one problem, IE i jus made a QB hoping to god he turns out to be my superstar, but the team im on needed an OT so i make on too. lvl 29 comes around and my OT is the superstar. well not many teams are going to want sign a superstar OT as 1 of their 2 superstars they are aloud to have. maybe an allpro lineman would be signed, if all 5 of your allpros were your lineman then you have your 2 superstar as defensive players, 1 MLB and 1 DE. thats how i would do it. but you cant tell which player will become the superstar.

what could be done is for the superstar player, each agent is aloud ,o IDK 3 superstar and5 allpro players. the superstar player would 2x as much FP to creat and boost, and the all pro players would cost 1.5x as much flex to creat and boost. now for a superstar they receive a 50% training boost and once they reach a certain lvl then they would begin to get more exp or more SP. because if you think about it not every superstar was the superstar when he was a rookie, most of them took a yr or 2 to bloom, so by starting out with just an increase in training then once they hit lvl 20? they would begin to get more SP. IE if lvl 20 is what is decided the lvls 20-25 would get 6 SP, 26-30 would get 7 SPs, and 31-retirement would get 8 SPs, and 8 would be the max they could receive. i think that the more SPs should start at lvl 20 mainly because your player is still in his prime, once you get to i think its lvl 29 thats when you get 25 exp/night and 100exp/game. so by starting earlier than the exp cap makes it more fun for the GLB player. same thing goes for all-pros except they only get a 20% training increase and their max SP should be 7 not 8.


+1?
 
tycoon34
offline
Link
 
I like it, but I think there should be a limit on All-pros. And you should consider re-naming it; there aren't 22 All-pros on a roster

But yeah, this would be pretty awesome. Dunno how you could implement it though: the pro-league teams won't have any yet and the lower leveled teams will.
 
R.Williams 34
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tycoon34
I like it, but I think there should be a limit on All-pros. And you should consider re-naming it; there aren't 22 All-pros on a roster

But yeah, this would be pretty awesome. Dunno how you could implement it though: the pro-league teams won't have any yet and the lower leveled teams will.


yeah we have a limit. only 2 super star players and 4 allpro players per team.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Regardless of other problems with the game right now, I like this idea...other than the extra FP part.

I say limit it even further (1 Superstar per account and 2 All-Pros) and have the costs be normal. Why? To give something back to the players who only have a couple of players on their account at all and aren't the huge spenders.

The biggest spenders in the game generally have some of the best players (practice makes perfect), some of the best teams (if you're really good and can populate your team with a bunch of your own really good players, running the team is easier), and a good chunk of the notoriety.

So by limiting it further, sure, the big spenders get the same benefit as everyone else, just not an even bigger one and, at the same time, the smaller spenders have basically all their players as either Superstars or All-Pros so they get to have fun, too.

The only downside I see is this system could further encourage multi-abuse by people who want to make a bunch of Superstars and nothing else.
 
R.Williams 34
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Regardless of other problems with the game right now, I like this idea...other than the extra FP part.

I say limit it even further (1 Superstar per account and 2 All-Pros) and have the costs be normal. Why? To give something back to the players who only have a couple of players on their account at all and aren't the huge spenders.

The biggest spenders in the game generally have some of the best players (practice makes perfect), some of the best teams (if you're really good and can populate your team with a bunch of your own really good players, running the team is easier), and a good chunk of the notoriety.

So by limiting it further, sure, the big spenders get the same benefit as everyone else, just not an even bigger one and, at the same time, the smaller spenders have basically all their players as either Superstars or All-Pros so they get to have fun, too.

The only downside I see is this system could further encourage multi-abuse by people who want to make a bunch of Superstars and nothing else.


actualy i like this a lot better. its gives plenty back to the players that arent able to actually have a great player. i agree the vets usually have better characters due to playing longeer, and yeah when i get my team ill be one of those coaches with a lot of the players being my own.

so definatly +1 to this idea.
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54
teams can only have a max of 5.


I have one problem with this. No matter how much you think people understand that games are won in the trenches and positions like Safety and FB and TE are also very important, people are ALWAYS going to take the star QB/HB/WR and a few other key positions like DE and CB instead of your O-lineman/DT/FS. That kind of makes the game even less fun for us non-glamour guys. Even if you were to say ok 1 d-lineman, 1 secondary ect...people would just always take the DE and CB. I think you HAVE to find a way to make it unlimited for every team. I'm not certain how to do that and make it perfectly fair, but if you can think of something then + 1 billion
Last edited Dec 1, 2008 16:33:24
 
R.Williams 34
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kira
I have one problem with this. No matter how much you think people understand that games are won in the trenches and positions like Safety and FB and TE are also very important, people are ALWAYS going to take the star QB/HB/WR and a few other key positions like DE and CB instead of your O-lineman/DT/FS. That kind of makes the game even less fun for us non-glamour guys. Even if you were to say ok 1 d-lineman, 1 secondary ect...people would just always take the DE and CB. I think you HAVE to find a way to make it unlimited for every team. I'm not certain how to do that and make it perfectly fair, but if you can think of something then + 1 billion


ok how about this, each team gets 2 superstars on defence and offense, but limit it to only 1 star player and one non-glamour position. and for defense one DB and one LB/D-line.??? hows that sound?
 
R.Williams 34
offline
Link
 
2 supestars for defense,
2 superstars for offense,
3 pros for D,
and 3 pros for O.

supers for offense, 1 must be non-glamour player, if they sign 2 non-glamour players good for them.
supers for defense can be 1 DB, and 1 LB/D-line
pros go the same way, must have 1 non-glamour pro on offense, and then for d 1 DB, 1 LB/D-line then the 3rd can be split to what you want.?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.