User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
Page:
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Try looking at it from the team level. You can recruit players based on speed and have a great pass D, but they cannot stop the run for the life of them (the Colts, for the most part). They were smaller, but faster. Is this your defensive philosophy? Or do you want heavy hitters that can shut down the run - Monsters of the Midway or the Steel Curtain?

Now you have to recruit players that fit your DC's philosophy. If you do not work together as a team, you will now pay more of a price. I fail to see why this is a problem, but I am semi-retarded. I work at Burger King, I wear paper hats.


I did this exact thing once. I recruited a team with Super Fast Defensive Backs and Linebackers and even Defensive Ends to stop the pass. Crazy thing is they're also amazing against the run. (Ok, not a true story, players on my team are actually balance builds) But you see the point, right? I can recruit based off of attributes and have the same exact effect.
 
Dianwei32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity


Ok so the First Wide Receiver in your story is the Super Fast Light Dude. The Second Wide Receiver in your story is the Not as Fast Heavier Dude. The difference is that one guy is a bit stronger than the other.

Tell me, how is that different from a guy with 95/90/20 Spd/Agi/Str and a guy with 85/70/35 Spd/Agi/Str? I'll ruin it for you, its not different.


One difference is that you could get up to 35 STR without having to go down to 85/70 SPD/AGI, assuming the WR's were the same level, it would be more accurate to potray it as WR1 being 95/90/20 and WR2 as 94/89/35. Since by the time you are getting to 80-85 range (without equipment, I think it's logical to assume each WR could get 10 SPD/AGI from equipment) you've reached the 7:1, 8:1, or 9:1 soft caps, you could sacrifice 1 point in Speed and 1 point in Agility and get the 15 SP needed to raise Strength from 20 to 35.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Bah, darn maths..

But yeah, why go through all the trouble to do something we can already do. If you want to make the game more exciting for players at higher levels add in something that I can't already do and that really adds to the experience. All this will lead to is me finding the right weight for my player and moving on or exploiting it and making my player lose and gain weight as needed to win (though I highly doubt the latter will even be an option).


It just adds some DEPTH to players attributes. Speed would extend PAST just the build.

And I really don't see an "exploit". Each side has their respective benifits and weaknesses.


It adds to how high your stats can be. Either you're faster because of it or stronger because of it. If thats the result you want, spend a few SPs in Speed or Strength to make yourself faster or stronger, don't implement an entirely new system to change the game to get that effect.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dianwei32
Originally posted by TheInfinity



Ok so the First Wide Receiver in your story is the Super Fast Light Dude. The Second Wide Receiver in your story is the Not as Fast Heavier Dude. The difference is that one guy is a bit stronger than the other.

Tell me, how is that different from a guy with 95/90/20 Spd/Agi/Str and a guy with 85/70/35 Spd/Agi/Str? I'll ruin it for you, its not different.


One difference is that you could get up to 35 STR without having to go down to 85/70 SPD/AGI, assuming the WR's were the same level, it would be more accurate to potray it as WR1 being 95/90/20 and WR2 as 94/89/35. Since by the time you are getting to 80-85 range (without equipment, I think it's logical to assume each WR could get 10 SPD/AGI from equipment) you've reached the 7:1, 8:1, or 9:1 soft caps, you could sacrifice 1 point in Speed and 1 point in Agility and get the 15 SP needed to raise Strength from 20 to 35.


Wait, so I can sacrifice speed/agility for strength by changing how I spend my SPs? What do I need weight classes for then? I can do it right now.
Last edited Nov 23, 2008 20:56:58
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Also, lets keep in mind that this is in Bort's "thought of it randomly while driving in my car, driving in my car, driving in my car" list. It is way down the road, pun intended, and would not entirely ruin your build. It is just another thing to do for players in the future and is very much a part of football. Knickerbocker pointed out that it is a slight adjustment to tinker with your build. If you do not want to use it...you do not have to.

Think advanced equipment. You decide your own destiny.
Last edited Nov 23, 2008 20:58:10
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Also, lets keep in mind that this is in Bort's "thought of it randomly while driving in my car, driving in my car, driving in my car" list. It is way down the road, pun intended, and would not entirely ruin your build. It is just another thing to do for players in the future and is very much a part of football. Knickerbocker pointed out that it is a slight adjustment to tinker with your build. If you do not want to use it...you do nothave to.

Think advanced equipment. You decide your own destiny.


yep.

I'd love to play with all the classes and positions. See what works in what situation with who. But apparently its just doomed to get the "spend SP" argument.
 
Dianwei32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Originally posted by Dianwei32

Originally posted by TheInfinity
Ok so the First Wide Receiver in your story is the Super Fast Light Dude. The Second Wide Receiver in your story is the Not as Fast Heavier Dude. The difference is that one guy is a bit stronger than the other.

Tell me, how is that different from a guy with 95/90/20 Spd/Agi/Str and a guy with 85/70/35 Spd/Agi/Str? I'll ruin it for you, its not different.


One difference is that you could get up to 35 STR without having to go down to 85/70 SPD/AGI, assuming the WR's were the same level, it would be more accurate to potray it as WR1 being 95/90/20 and WR2 as 94/89/35. Since by the time you are getting to 80-85 range (without equipment, I think it's logical to assume each WR could get 10 SPD/AGI from equipment) you've reached the 7:1, 8:1, or 9:1 soft caps, you could sacrifice 1 point in Speed and 1 point in Agility and get the 15 SP needed to raise Strength from 20 to 35.


Wait, so I can sacrifice speed/agility for strength by changing how I spend my SPs? Why do I need weight classes for then? I can do it right now.

^Said by TheInfinity, but it won't go in the quote box for some reason^



I never said you couldn't do it right now, I was just pointing out that your logic was flawed in assuming that a WR would need to sacrifice 10 Speed and 20 agility in order to get 15 Strength.

The point of the weight classes would be doing things that go beyond what spending SPs in certain attributes can do, or augmenting the way you have chosen to spend your SP.
Last edited Nov 23, 2008 21:04:38
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by kretchfoop

Also, lets keep in mind that this is in Bort's "thought of it randomly while driving in my car, driving in my car, driving in my car" list. It is way down the road, pun intended, and would not entirely ruin your build. It is just another thing to do for players in the future and is very much a part of football. Knickerbocker pointed out that it is a slight adjustment to tinker with your build. If you do not want to use it...you do nothave to.

Think advanced equipment. You decide your own destiny.


yep.

I'd love to play with all the classes and positions. See what works in what situation with who. But apparently its just doomed to get the "spend SP" argument.


Just saying, there are other things that are more pressing in terms of in-game issues that I'd prefer Bort to spend his time with. Introducing this system would probably take a lot of work and since its not going to add much something else can be focused on. Maybe this can come back some time but I also just have the sneaking feeling that once all other attributes increase in value relative to speed/agility this won't even be on people's mind too much. Thats something time will tell, but for now this is where I stand and I appreciate that people disagree, it leads to a good dialogue that allows Bort to make a fully informed decision which is the most important outcome from all this.

 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
As long as adjusting our current weights to fit the new scale isn't too cumbersome (meaning, fuck it if it takes half a season to get my 182 lb CB return man down to lightweight status).
Last edited Nov 23, 2008 21:07:08
 
czman
offline
Link
 
People did not chose speed over strength because strength was more beneficial in GLB. They chose speed because it was the best way to min max* their player. The game engine leads people to the builds that are out there. If something is added that will allow them to increase their speed that does not cost SP it will be used. I really think this will just lead to many people making 155 LB REs.

Fixing what creates the inequality of speed in the game is the best fix and everything else just leads us back to the same conclusion. Speed>all


*Minimum points for maximum efficiency.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Originally posted by Knick

Originally posted by kretchfoop


Also, lets keep in mind that this is in Bort's "thought of it randomly while driving in my car, driving in my car, driving in my car" list. It is way down the road, pun intended, and would not entirely ruin your build. It is just another thing to do for players in the future and is very much a part of football. Knickerbocker pointed out that it is a slight adjustment to tinker with your build. If you do not want to use it...you do nothave to.

Think advanced equipment. You decide your own destiny.


yep.

I'd love to play with all the classes and positions. See what works in what situation with who. But apparently its just doomed to get the "spend SP" argument.


Just saying, there are other things that are more pressing in terms of in-game issues that I'd prefer Bort to spend his time with. Introducing this system would probably take a lot of work and since its not going to add much something else can be focused on. Maybe this can come back some time but I also just have the sneaking feeling that once all other attributes increase in value relative to speed/agility this won't even be on people's mind too much. Thats something time will tell, but for now this is where I stand and I appreciate that people disagree, it leads to a good dialogue that allows Bort to make a fully informed decision which is the most important outcome from all this.



You realize Bort said this is just an idea right? Not something he's going to code tomorrow.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Introducing this system would probably take a lot of work and since its not going to add much something else can be focused on.


It would actually probably only take a day or so. The code's already there. I'd just have to replace constants in the formulas with variables based on the player's weight class.
 
MonkeyMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Introducing this system would probably take a lot of work and since its not going to add much something else can be focused on.


It would actually probably only take a day or so. The code's already there. I'd just have to replace constants in the formulas with variables based on the player's weight class.


Maybe have a 2 or 3% chance of a Breakthrough class? Something that makes it Special and unique. Every gets to select a class and have a one time 2-3% chance of selecting some type of special add or or effect.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
I would just like to take a minute to post another way to make weight matter...and it has been suggested before.

Include the weight classes...even allow players to adjust their weight (the whole normal training + gain/lose weight option). However, it would be decent if weight class determined two things: Autopoints and training gains. For example, a heavier player would gain a greater amount of strength and tackling/blocking per level and in their training bar when training any of those. Similarly, the same would go for lighter players in terms of speed and agility.

Of course, this would be for the new players as soon as the change is made. This would further make building a player more interesting. You can slow build a light player to be fast and then bulk him up and make him a harder hitter, or vice versa. You can also have a balanced player and enjoy the extra SPs that come with advanced training without shifting weight.

Your thoughts?
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
For this to not piss people off tremendously the training for altering weight has to be completely independent of the attribute training. I'd leave it as a "Gain Weight/Lose Weight/Do Nothing" option that you set and it gets proccessed overnight. Maybe just have the weight change cost some money, how about the $ difference between 5x(daily salary) - 2x(cost to train on intense)?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.