User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Suggestion to help with low down GM's trading away players
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
Longevity != intelligence. Ever meet a stupid old person?

Yeah, I've only been around since season 3, but that doesn't preclude me from being an individual with common sense.

Get over yourself and realize that just because you happen to have been logging into a site for longer than another person, that does not render your ideas infallible.


#1 A post was made in the suggestion forum (appropriate venue) that was based on events that occur (i.e a trusted GM turning on an owner for whatever reason and gutting a team)

#2 Instead of coming up with ways this might be implemented, posters criticize the suggestion. OP obviously takes offense as his post was not intended to become an argument.

#3 OP never said his idea was infallible, but a proper discussion did not occur to
determine if it was doable or not, just a bunch of 3 word sentences basically saying that there isn't a problem here move along.

Personally I think alot of you like to post to see your own words....probably the same people who don't speak up in RL

#####################################Rant Over#######################################

I think an option for an owner to check to say all trades must be approved by the owner would be a better option. It allows a GM or designated recruiter to do their job and get things accomplished but allows an owner the opportunity to review it before finalizing. This way the trade locks the players in, but a X hour window must elapse before consummated (sort of a clear medical/fitness exam thing in the NFL)

If the owner elects not to review trades then it can be consummated whenever accepted.

I think CBS sportsline has something similar for fantasy that when trades occur you can select whether it goes to the commish for review or the team votes or that it just happens...
Last edited Nov 15, 2008 17:34:57
 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by Shortstuffaaron2

Originally posted by prokop


or dont give GM trading privileges




OH NOES A TROLL


nope just another person with the same answer to a question that has been posed for a long time. Seems like the don't give GM's trade powers suggestion just does not work. How about a solution to the problem instead of the same old nonsense.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
NOBODY criticized the idea dude. The idea was fine. It needs no refinement. That's why there's no discussion. There's nothing to discuss other than the relative urgency of the suggestion. And since it was something the guy is clearly worried about, I pointed out that there are plenty of ways to prevent shady activities right now, today, this instant.
 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yankee Skipper
Originally posted by dmfa41

Longevity != intelligence. Ever meet a stupid old person?

Yeah, I've only been around since season 3, but that doesn't preclude me from being an individual with common sense.

Get over yourself and realize that just because you happen to have been logging into a site for longer than another person, that does not render your ideas infallible.


#1 A post was made in the suggestion forum (appropriate venue) that was based on events that occur (i.e a trusted GM turning on an owner for whatever reason and gutting a team)

#2 Instead of coming up with ways this might be implemented, posters criticize the suggestion. OP obviously takes offense as his post was not intended to become an argument.

#3 OP never said his idea was infallible, but a proper discussion did not occur to
determine if it was doable or not, just a bunch of 3 word sentences basically saying that there isn't a problem here move along.

Personally I think alot of you like to post to see your own words....probably the same people who don't speak up in RL

#####################################Rant Over#######################################

I think an option for an owner to check to say all trades must be approved by the owner would be a better option. It allows a GM or designated recruiter to do their job and get things accomplished but allows an owner the opportunity to review it before finalizing. This way the trade locks the players in, but a X hour window must elapse before consummated (sort of a clear medical/fitness exam thing in the NFL)

If the owner elects not to review trades then it can be consummated whenever accepted.

I think CBS sportsline has something similar for fantasy that when trades occur you can select whether it goes to the commish for review or the team votes or that it just happens...


See a constructive criticism. I am open arms to those.
 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
NOBODY criticized the idea dude. The idea was fine. It needs no refinement. That's why there's no discussion. There's nothing to discuss other than the relative urgency of the suggestion. And since it was something the guy is clearly worried about, I pointed out that there are plenty of ways to prevent shady activities right now, today, this instant.


The idea is not for me, it is for the 500-1000 first time owners we get every season.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
NOBODY criticized the idea dude. The idea was fine. It needs no refinement. That's why there's no discussion. There's nothing to discuss other than the relative urgency of the suggestion. And since it was something the guy is clearly worried about, I pointed out that there are plenty of ways to prevent shady activities right now, today, this instant.


Sorry I think telling someone their suggestion isn't worth looking into now is being critical, who are you all to judge what is important and what isn't. The fine folks that run this site are the ones to judge and they can't do that unless there are well thought out and discussed suggestions...
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yankee Skipper

#1 A post was made in the suggestion forum (appropriate venue) that was based on events that occur (i.e a trusted GM turning on an owner for whatever reason and gutting a team)

#2 Instead of coming up with ways this might be implemented, posters criticize the suggestion. OP obviously takes offense as his post was not intended to become an argument.

#3 OP never said his idea was infallible, but a proper discussion did not occur to
determine if it was doable or not, just a bunch of 3 word sentences basically saying that there isn't a problem here move along.

Personally I think alot of you like to post to see your own words....probably the same people who don't speak up in RL


1) Agreed. Proper Venue.

2) A suggestion was criticized and instead of acknowledging the easy way accomplish said goal, he calls everyone a troll and says this needs attention immediately.

3) Again you fail to grasp that there is a difference between "no problem here" and "there's a way to avoid this situation already"

I was going to ignore your post until I read the last line of your rant. You don't know me, I'd keep your head out of your ass until you put forth the effort to do such.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yankee Skipper
Originally posted by SwagOnLock

NOBODY criticized the idea dude. The idea was fine. It needs no refinement. That's why there's no discussion. There's nothing to discuss other than the relative urgency of the suggestion. And since it was something the guy is clearly worried about, I pointed out that there are plenty of ways to prevent shady activities right now, today, this instant.


Sorry I think telling someone their suggestion isn't worth looking into now is being critical, who are you all to judge what is important and what isn't. The fine folks that run this site are the ones to judge and they can't do that unless there are well thought out and discussed suggestions...


We can't change OT rules, add defensive blitzing schemes, or implement a Team PM option by being resourceful. We can manage trades by being resourceful.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Originally posted by Yankee Skipper

Originally posted by SwagOnLock


NOBODY criticized the idea dude. The idea was fine. It needs no refinement. That's why there's no discussion. There's nothing to discuss other than the relative urgency of the suggestion. And since it was something the guy is clearly worried about, I pointed out that there are plenty of ways to prevent shady activities right now, today, this instant.


Sorry I think telling someone their suggestion isn't worth looking into now is being critical, who are you all to judge what is important and what isn't. The fine folks that run this site are the ones to judge and they can't do that unless there are well thought out and discussed suggestions...


We can't change OT rules, add defensive blitzing schemes, or implement a Team PM option by being resourceful. We can manage trades by being resourceful.


have you made any suggestions for these?

And I agree we can, however, GLB moves fast, if A dude gets traded to another team because I wasn't online to make an offer that my GM brokered that sucks and eliminates the reason for me having GM's who are responsible for these things.

Again, it was a suggestion to help address a problem (if you want to debate whether it is a problem, start your own post)
 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by Yankee Skipper


#1 A post was made in the suggestion forum (appropriate venue) that was based on events that occur (i.e a trusted GM turning on an owner for whatever reason and gutting a team)

#2 Instead of coming up with ways this might be implemented, posters criticize the suggestion. OP obviously takes offense as his post was not intended to become an argument.

#3 OP never said his idea was infallible, but a proper discussion did not occur to
determine if it was doable or not, just a bunch of 3 word sentences basically saying that there isn't a problem here move along.

Personally I think alot of you like to post to see your own words....probably the same people who don't speak up in RL


1) Agreed. Proper Venue.

2) A suggestion was criticized and instead of acknowledging the easy way accomplish said goal, he calls everyone a troll and says this needs attention immediately.

3) Again you fail to grasp that there is a difference between "no problem here" and "there's a way to avoid this situation already"

I was going to ignore your post until I read the last line of your rant. You don't know me, I'd keep your head out of your ass until you put forth the effort to do such.


When did I see it needed immediate attention?
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yankee Skipper
Originally posted by SwagOnLock

Originally posted by Yankee Skipper


Originally posted by SwagOnLock



NOBODY criticized the idea dude. The idea was fine. It needs no refinement. That's why there's no discussion. There's nothing to discuss other than the relative urgency of the suggestion. And since it was something the guy is clearly worried about, I pointed out that there are plenty of ways to prevent shady activities right now, today, this instant.


Sorry I think telling someone their suggestion isn't worth looking into now is being critical, who are you all to judge what is important and what isn't. The fine folks that run this site are the ones to judge and they can't do that unless there are well thought out and discussed suggestions...


We can't change OT rules, add defensive blitzing schemes, or implement a Team PM option by being resourceful. We can manage trades by being resourceful.


have you made any suggestions for these?


Actually I have!

My OT thread
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1340273

Other two suggestions are already in the Epic Suggestions forum
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick


1) Agreed. Proper Venue.

2) A suggestion was criticized and instead of acknowledging the easy way accomplish said goal, he calls everyone a troll and says this needs attention immediately.
is it easy? Is their no risk associated to alternatives?

3) Again you fail to grasp that there is a difference between "no problem here" and "there's a way to avoid this situation already" I feel that the way to avoid it, creates a problem, I either am now only able to get anything accomplished via trades when I, as an owner am online or run the risk of losing a potential trade a GM has worked out because I wasn't online

I was going to ignore your post until I read the last line of your rant. You don't know me, I'd keep your head out of your ass until you put forth the effort to do such. Your 1st, post basically saying nothing at all told me all I needed


 
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Originally posted by Yankee Skipper

Originally posted by SwagOnLock


Originally posted by Yankee Skipper



Originally posted by SwagOnLock




NOBODY criticized the idea dude. The idea was fine. It needs no refinement. That's why there's no discussion. There's nothing to discuss other than the relative urgency of the suggestion. And since it was something the guy is clearly worried about, I pointed out that there are plenty of ways to prevent shady activities right now, today, this instant.


Sorry I think telling someone their suggestion isn't worth looking into now is being critical, who are you all to judge what is important and what isn't. The fine folks that run this site are the ones to judge and they can't do that unless there are well thought out and discussed suggestions...


We can't change OT rules, add defensive blitzing schemes, or implement a Team PM option by being resourceful. We can manage trades by being resourceful.


have you made any suggestions for these?


Actually I have!

My OT thread
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1340273

Other two suggestions are already in the Epic Suggestions forum


excellent, thanks for the link, I will take a read
 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Originally posted by Yankee Skipper

Originally posted by SwagOnLock


Originally posted by Yankee Skipper



Originally posted by SwagOnLock




NOBODY criticized the idea dude. The idea was fine. It needs no refinement. That's why there's no discussion. There's nothing to discuss other than the relative urgency of the suggestion. And since it was something the guy is clearly worried about, I pointed out that there are plenty of ways to prevent shady activities right now, today, this instant.


Sorry I think telling someone their suggestion isn't worth looking into now is being critical, who are you all to judge what is important and what isn't. The fine folks that run this site are the ones to judge and they can't do that unless there are well thought out and discussed suggestions...


We can't change OT rules, add defensive blitzing schemes, or implement a Team PM option by being resourceful. We can manage trades by being resourceful.


have you made any suggestions for these?


Actually I have!

My OT thread
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1340273

Other two suggestions are already in the Epic Suggestions forum


Where?

 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crazy454
Where?


Seriously?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1218134

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1311176
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.