User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > World Championship Playoff vs. Champions' League
Page:
 
geturembedder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
I like the idea of each team playing each other twice in the regular season. Also, 16 teams is all I would want to have considered as the supreme elite of GLB. 32 teams is too many. Also, football is about adaptation, be interesting to see what happens in the championship when teams are playing for the third time.

Further, the league structure lends itself to 16 teams. You take 2 from each pro league and that won't cripple them for a while. And injecting 8 teams into the Pro Leagues when you relegate out of the World League is easier to manage.

Finally, changing regions is not the worst thing ever. I feel its safe to assume that teams don't plan on ever returning to their Regions if they make it into the World League.

---------------------------------------------

One thing to add: Ensuring competitive balance.

Come up with an emergency promotion method in case a team in the World League goes CPU and doesn't return after a season. Can include keeping some World League teams around by not relegating them or promoting conference champions from the Pro Leagues via some sort scheme where you try and determine who is best or make it an honest to goodness random choice. There should never ever be a CPU team in the World League.

If someone does something crazy like not selling their team but signing nothing but Level 20s to play their World League games that team can be deemed "unfit" and relegated. This has to be an extreme and utterly obvious case of tanking your team.

------------------------------------

Noting the competitive balance issues.. that's a good argument against a League and in favor of a tournament. Cause that would be a severe head ache.


Well each team would only face one team twice, and then play every other team once. That's why number one from the previous year should play number two. The new teams get a random draw. These games are played opening week.

As far as once your in the World league never expect to go back to your region that is correct.

As far as CPU teams go, I would like to say it would be unlikely that a team that got that far goes out midseason, but should they do it, it would be for the remainder of the season only as they would be ousted the following season. But that would be something that while I hope would be rare, would also be a reality.

Maybe teams can't go in unless the season is paid for and the team can't be sold until the season is over for World League.

If a team does not pay then you would start regular season playoff type tie breakers to see what conference champ gets to move up into the League.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
It would face the same gutting issues that every other league in this game does. If there's one trophy that we'd like to make immune to gutting, it would be this one. Once that problem is solved then a league could become a more attractive prospect. Of course, I'd love to see the gutting problem solved; not necessarily to stop it itself, but stem the negative downstream effects it creates.
 
Rondo4MVP
offline
Link
 
Nice Idea
+1
 
geturembedder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
It would face the same gutting issues that every other league in this game does. If there's one trophy that we'd like to make immune to gutting, it would be this one. Once that problem is solved then a league could become a more attractive prospect. Of course, I'd love to see the gutting problem solved; not necessarily to stop it itself, but stem the negative downstream effects it creates.


You are talking about 16 teams among 256. How hard is it to win a pro championship? To even get in this league you are gonna have to be some of the most commited SOBs on the planet.

Gutting will never go away. Ever. It's stupid to believe that it will. But it would be unlikely that a world league team would do so. Even then, there are several ideas in place to minimize the potential damage.
 
SAkram
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jprietman
the 3 round playoff sounds great

the champions league sounds horrible


 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Right; gutting won't ever stop, but one could prevent the negative effects of it, such as discounting all games in a season - past and future - against gutted teams.

I just don't want to change the league structure or pull teams out of their regional competitions. I'd also like to formalize inter-region rivalries in the first round of the playoffs - East vs. West Europe, Canada vs. USA, etc.
 
geturembedder
offline
Link
 
If it wasn't for the fact that you have to extend the offseason, I would be for the playoffs. Moving teams to different regions better than extending the off season.

Also, they don't have to move teams to other regions, I personally think it would be more fun, but others have suggested a few plausible ways of not doing that.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Well, the offseason usually goes to day 46 as it is; to play on days 42, 44, and 46 would not necessitate it to be extended. It would make offseason transactions difficult for the championship teams to deal with, but they're winning championships and likely have large front offices; I'm sure they could handle it.

I don't think a World League is a bad idea, but I think it would be too much of a shake-up at this point. The reason I supported the playoff first is because it would be easier to implement, and I really, really want a single World Champion.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Playoffs?! .. Playoffs?! Don't talk about Playoffs!

I'm 100% behind the idea but I couldn't resist. Make it happen.....-- damn it the guy that can make it happen doesn't read these. Fuck I wish he'd prove me wrong.
Last edited Jan 20, 2009 16:24:48
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Aw, Bort, you missed this one on your Epic pass.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Especially since it received mention (or something like this) in a restructuring poll...at the end of Season 5, I think?
 
geturembedder
offline
Link
 
Looks to not really be a priority of his.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
I'm pretty sure that Bort read it on his pass through, I think he browsed around through everything. Hopefully the idea is something he likes because I love it.

And yeah, my tone has changed some towards him. I still wish he would post more, but I can see how a person can get stuck on the boards for far longer than expected on a visit. One option is to get a Mod or Admin to be his mouthpiece though. Sort of they just drop him a line and post what he's thinking about stuff or directly tell him whats floating up here in epic and getting talked about heavily down in regular suggestions.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Oh well. Don't stop believin'.
 
bgharst
offline
Link
 
There are 10 day contracts already in the game. If you wanted to stick around for the World Championships before you moved on just get signed to one of those. Im not really sure why youd want to leave a Pro level team that just won it all though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.