User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > New Plays/Playbooks
Page:
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

OOP penalty is fairly high for HB -> QB tho. QB is really the only position that can play QB without at least a 30-40% OOP penalty.


Um...wow?

I thought OOP topped out at like 15-20%, and most positions were like 5-10%.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
I mean right now, I could transfer all my EQT into one of my RBs throwing, and with their high vision and throwing up to about 30 now, that would do them well enough to throw when needed (short/med passes) and just run the ball all game from QB rush plays. That kind of thing is too cheesey but will be done by some GMs out there.


I would love to play a team that decided to do that, Do you know how easy that could be shut down? The idea here is making it viable for a RUNNING QB with QB SA's to be called in to execute a running play from the QB position.

Go ahead and put a HB with throwing in at QB and run it 100% or Better yet have him pass some with out Passing SA's You have to be a little realistic, the running play designs for the QB are not that devastating, especially if ran 90 % of the time.

However, If ran 6-8 times a game at strategic Down and distances could be a back breaker for the defense and extend drives. That is what I am looking for a QB1 (restricted to only a QB) so that Teams can actually use the running plays as an addition not the majority of play calling.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ron2288
I just logged on and looked at the new stuff....it looks awesome

I have a question. I have not read thru this whole thread so if it has been discussed forgive me.

If I want my back HB to run a sweep I would set it to run the sweep then set it for HB2?
I have only 2 HB's on the roster. Again I just saw the title of this thread and posted this so if this has been discussed sorry to bring it back up


Check your Depth Chart page and it should make sense.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Bort


OOP penalty is fairly high for HB -> QB tho. QB is really the only position that can play QB without at least a 30-40% OOP penalty.


Um...wow?

I thought OOP topped out at like 15-20%, and most positions were like 5-10%.


Oh no. You really think a DT playing K would only get a 20% penalty? 5% penalties are for the easy position movements like CB -> FS or LB -> DE or something like that.
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 02:57:45
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by GG


I know what you mean. One team I GM we have a pure pocket QB and a pure scrambling QB (built for running) and I envisioned using the QB and QB1 slots that way....but now that I think about it, it still opens it up for cheese. Unless someone can devise a clever method to prevent that??


As Bort said on the previous page...pure running QB's will not have as many SA's as HB's. Granted, it is still kind of cheesy, because you can get away with a QB having ZERO throwing ability running the ball. I hate using real life to argue a point, but in real life, if a QB subs in only to throw, or only to run, the defense will be all over you like flies on shit.

The only real way I can think to not have cheesy situations is to forgo the QB1.


Exactly. In the end I agree to forego the QB1 slot idea.

EDIT- Pending some other ingenious idea someone might have???
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 03:01:01
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ron2288
I just logged on and looked at the new stuff....it looks awesome

I have a question. I have not read thru this whole thread so if it has been discussed forgive me.

If I want my back HB to run a sweep I would set it to run the sweep then set it for HB2?
I have only 2 HB's on the roster. Again I just saw the title of this thread and posted this so if this has been discussed sorry to bring it back up


If you only have two, keep your normal RB position as normal starter/backup.

Add the RB's to the RB1 and RB2 positions, one deep. So your starter could be RB1, and backup could be RB2, or vice versa, it doesn't matter.

If you want to use a specific one, you would select RB1 or RB2, depending on which one you want. If you want them to just swap out based on energy, use the generic RB.
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 02:57:25
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG

EDIT- Pending some other ingenious idea someone might have???


I'm trying...not having much success though...it basically comes down to somehow tying throwing in with QB running ability. It wouldn't make much sense though...
 
Link
 
You guys are really putting TOO much thought into this. QB's only have a certain amount of SA's for running. And a Running QB should still be able to throw the ball. I have one that is much more for run, however he does have throwing of 45 at lvl 13 and soft cap speed and agility is work in progress.

So on your line of thinking, the running guy comes in and everyone plays QB spy or DE contain, and what happens he throws a slant or an option right sprint right and hit the WR running the 7 route, Easy TD.

Let's just keep it simple, a restricted QB1 slot will actually make a fair option.
Plus if you look at the plays the Majority will get shut down by a run blitz, only the Draw's have the potential to really burn an over aggressive Defense.
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 03:05:46
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by GG


EDIT- Pending some other ingenious idea someone might have???


I'm trying...not having much success though...it basically comes down to somehow tying throwing in with QB running ability. It wouldn't make much sense though...


Yeah, I cant think of anything right now either. Maybe it'll come to someone out there like 2 days from now.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Football Genius
You guys are really putting TOO much thought into this. QB's only have a certain amount of SA's for running. And a Running QB should still be able to throw the ball. I have one that is much more for run, however he does have throwing of 45 at lvl 13 and soft cap speed and agility is work in progress.

So on your line of thinking, the running guy comes in and everyone plays QB spy or DE contain, and what happens he throws a slant or an option right sprint right and hit the WR running the 7 route, Easy TD.


You are not thinking enough about it.

Why would the running QB need ANY throwing ability? He comes in only for running plays. He might be somewhat made to pass as well, which is great, and is what we are trying to make happen. However, there is nothing preventing someone from making a 100% pure run QB with no passing ability at all, and swapping in for every single run play.

Your situation about the DE Contain and such, that is all fine and dandy, but they will not be running that because defense can't change plays based on personnel. They will still be running their base defense regardless of which QB is in, the 100% passer, or the 100% runner. There's no reason for the offense to "trick" the defense and have the running QB throw the ball, or have the passing QB run it.

Letting the defense change plays based on personnel could be very interesting however...
 
Link
 
Well ok since you went there, What about Super vision? and Vision on LB's?? Bort has said before that When a Guy that was not suppose to blitz, blitz's on a play for an easy sack it was because the LB was able to read the play pre-snap.

Why would you think that a CB or SS in the box with super vision would not do the same and read the play and stop it for a negative run play?

 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Football Genius

Let's just keep it simple, a restricted QB1 slot will actually make a fair option.
Plus if you look at the plays the Majority will got shut down by a run blitz, only the Draw's have the potential to really burn an over aggressive Defense.


I guess it boils down to whether Bort thinks that people building specialized rushing QBs that are used for specified QB rush plays only from the QB1 slot is an "exploit" or not. I mean, you wouldnt just run the QB run plays all game, but it would mean agents building specialized carrying QBs(leaving their throwing at 14 and pumping all the carrying abilities up). So is that something that's ok or too cheesy? Even without the SAs of head fake etc, you could still build a beastly rushing QB if you just totally didnt care about his throwing abilities.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
I think being able to have defensive tactics based on opponents personnel in the game would possibly help the situation, and even give people some "trick" plays.

For example, if a team has one of these pure running QBs, the defense could go into a more anti-run defense when they are in the game. The offense could in return, try to throw a dump pass or something. The same could be said with the passing QB, teams could have their defense set to more anti-pass, and it would make a QB sneak up the middle possibly more effective.
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 03:20:07
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GG



I guess it boils down to whether Bort thinks that people building specialized rushing QBs that are used for specified QB rush plays only from the QB1 slot is an "exploit" or not. I mean, you wouldnt just run the QB run plays all game, but it would mean agents building specialized carrying QBs(leaving their throwing at 14 and pumping all the carrying abilities up). So is that something that's ok or too cheesy? Even without the SAs of head fake etc, you could still build a beastly rushing QB if you just totally didnt care about his throwing abilities.


Well I am looking at it with a pure heart here. You can check my Baby QB out and see that I am not doing that and he is still a season out from be effective at either.

However, lets say there are and will be people who do just what you say. Put nothing to throwing and all running (Str,Vis,Speed,Agi,Carrying).

If a GM try's to run that play more than dozen times they will get shut down by a run defense. So if a guy builds a QB like that for run only, How much PT do you think he is going to get? 20 plays tops, and thats if he is in on ST's, which will kill his energy and make him less effective in the run play's.

To avoid that, an agent would have to make him be able to throw some and not sell out completely. I doubt there is many owners that would pay the salary for a lvl 25-32 Running only QB for less than 10 plays of production.

Plus adding the QB1 slot will make it able to use the run play's with at least some success. If it gets out of hand Bort can always Pull out the Nerf Bat ! It's not like he hasn't pulled that thing out of the closet a few times already.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
I think being able to have defensive tactics based on opponents personnel in the game would possibly help the situation, and even give people some "trick" plays.

For example, if a team has one of these pure running QBs, the defense could go into a more anti-run defense when they are in the game. The offense could in return, try to throw a dump pass or something. The same could be said with the passing QB, teams could have their defense set to more anti-pass, and it would make a QB sneak up the middle possibly more effective.


This would be a good idea. I guess if/when Bort expands the defensive options to allow for personnel settings then the QB-QB1 thing could be brought in then??
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.