User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > How to improve Pass Blocking Assignments and still allow realistic levels of Pass Rush Pressure
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
I've thought about it and become convinced that if possible to implement, Mike's concept of better blocking schemes is the ideal basis for the solution here.

However, I do think we also want to address that (a) even accounting for the ease (which Mike's idea intends to fix) of getting a free route to the QB, Tunnel Vision is a little bit too good (a little bit), and (b) there shouldn't be very lot-Strength DE's that are successful.

So, in addition to Mike's suggested changes to the blocking schemes, I'd like to suggest that:

1) Pancakes affect morale more than they already do, by a fairly large margin when the victim is much weaker than the pancaker, and

2) Tunnel Vision, whose description does suggest it has a "roll" for triggering, should have that chance multiplied by sqrt(Morale / 100). If in-game Morale falls to 75, it would trigger about 14% less often. That's hardly enough to be called a nerf.

That combo, though, would hurt undersized DE's just enough that they'd have to bulk up, and cut down slightly on Tunnel Vision sacks without going ridiculously far.

But then, the question exists about what to do if Bort can't get the blocking schemes fixed in time for Season 6. He's indicated that getting it right is difficult.

If so, he'll likely need to temporarily nerf TV, because we absolutely cannot continue to have 10 sack a game players in Season 6. It would be temporary, and rolled back to my mild above suggestion once it's made hard enough to avoid engaging OT's. Otherwise it will only get worse, as everyone will know to go TV, TV, TV, and everyone will be getting ridiculous sack numbers.

But, while I'd rather see it not needed, one thing Bort cannot do is let next season be like this one in terms of sacks.

Again, I hope it isn't needed and that Bort can get the blocking scheme right; but if it is temporarily needed, it will need to be done.
 
aliuking
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Have you added that SPEED is not relative to size/weight? That one may not be terribly popular with some, but still applicable, IMO.


There are DEs in the NFL that are as fast as WRs that isn't the problem, the problem is that those DEs also have a lot of strength so that they aren't flattened by the DEs immediately. Right now, DEs are being rewarded for building CBs at DE spots and no matter how fast a DE is, it isn't realistic at all for a low strength DE to be able to do anything to a reasonably built OT, in fact that DE should be overpowered a large percentage of the time.

And we need to find a way to adjust blocking assignments as my team gets crushed by 3-4 blitzes where the line as is has no chance to block that blitz.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Here is what I would do, keep the line in their "zone" for a few "ticks" before releasing them to follow the current code. This will allow the RG to stay home and tack care of a speed DE on their side. This could be as short as a few ticks of game code just enough for the DE rushing to the inside becomes the biggest "threat".

That's it...that's all that needs to be done. The rest of the belly aching is by OT's that aren't built that well. Fix the RG bug, and I'd consider everything balanced.

This is coming from the owner of a L32 OT...I love seeing my guy battle a stud DE! It's a blast!


That was my initial suggestion after Bort commented
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aliuking
Originally posted by chief31

Have you added that SPEED is not relative to size/weight? That one may not be terribly popular with some, but still applicable, IMO.


There are DEs in the NFL that are as fast as WRs that isn't the problem, the problem is that those DEs also have a lot of strength so that they aren't flattened by the DEs immediately. Right now, DEs are being rewarded for building CBs at DE spots and no matter how fast a DE is, it isn't realistic at all for a low strength DE to be able to do anything to a reasonably built OT, in fact that DE should be overpowered a large percentage of the time.

And we need to find a way to adjust blocking assignments as my team gets crushed by 3-4 blitzes where the line as is has no chance to block that blitz.


+10
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Agree with that though I do, I defy you to find me a few defensive ends who run a sub-4.3 forty.
 
aliuking
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Agree with that though I do, I defy you to find me a few defensive ends who run a sub-4.3 forty.


There aren't many players period that run sub 4.3, I think only Deion Sanders did that in his combine and Figurs also did it once, but if you look at the combine numbers the speed of DEs aren't much different at all from WRs
 
Link
 
so they can possibly keep up for forty yards, thats an uncontested jump from a starting point, how often do d-lineman go uncontested off the snap from the line of scrimmage?
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
O Linemen make a blocking mistake and miss one?

Just liek Cbs make mistakes biting on pump fakes, how is it hard to imagine every other player might make mistakes?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by aliuking
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Agree with that though I do, I defy you to find me a few defensive ends who run a sub-4.3 forty.


There aren't many players period that run sub 4.3, I think only Deion Sanders did that in his combine and Figurs also did it once, but if you look at the combine numbers the speed of DEs aren't much different at all from WRs


randy moss ran a 4.2, adrain peterson ran a sub 4.3, darryl green did as well, andre rison, jerry rice, terrel owens had a 4.3 40 in the combine, chris johnson(titans rookie hb) reggie bush, roddy white, I can keep this list of hb, cb, and wr that tested sub 4.4 in the 40 whereas to my knowledge only jevon kearse has recorded a sub 4.5 40 at the combine
 
the_legenol
offline
Link
 
The two major causes of this problem are that a) the RG is always assigned to pick up blitzes (regardless of where they come from) and b) the OT pathing always causes him to step back, when, in some circumstances, it would be better for the player to fire off and engage the defender.

maybe better O-line tactics would help?

something along the lines of
PASS BLOCKING AGGRESSIVENESS:
-aggressive: fire off ball and engage defender
-passive: fall back and create pocket
-neutral: switch off between passive and aggressive

PASS BLOCKING ASSIGNMENT:
-man-to-man: always engage a specific target
-zone: stay home and pick up the defender who comes to you
-help: pick-up blitz or help with most dangerous target
Last edited Oct 21, 2008 10:56:55
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Did anyone saw a QB steps in the pocket ?

I been through all blitzing and DE rushes play loaded to this thread and some other thread. But never seen a QB taking a step forward making the fast running defense player just missing him (allowing the Ol to reposition for a block).
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by the_legenol
The two major causes of this problem are that a) the RG is always assigned to pick up blitzes (regardless of where they come from) and b) the OT pathing always causes him to step back, when, in some circumstances, it would be better for the player to fire off and engage the defender.

maybe better O-line tactics would help?

something along the lines of
PASS BLOCKING AGGRESSIVENESS:
-aggressive: fire off ball and engage defender
-passive: fall back and create pocket
-neutral: switch off between passive and aggressive

PASS BLOCKING ASSIGNMENT:
-man-to-man: always engage a specific target
-zone: stay home and pick up the defender who comes to you
-help: pick-up blitz or help with most dangerous target


That's a good addition, IMO. Everyone on the offensive DC, besides people listed only at QB or WR, could get choices.

For pass blocking aggressiveness, "neutral" could be, "Switch off between passive and aggressive, but avoid an option that has led to sacks." It would kind of be allowing auto-adjust.

"Passive" for a FB/HB would be to stay in the backfield slightly in front of the QB to pick up anyone who gets past the line, while "Aggressive" would be more their current behavior of running up to the line and trying to help at the line.

And since FB's and HB's should always be on "help," their second option would instead be how many sacks must be allowed before they always block rather than run a route, if they are not the primary receiver.

I know I'd personally want my FB on every play to stay near the QB and engage anyone-- blitzer or lineman who got through the line-- who was closing in on the QB.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
Did anyone saw a QB steps in the pocket ?

I been through all blitzing and DE rushes play loaded to this thread and some other thread. But never seen a QB taking a step forward making the fast running defense player just missing him (allowing the Ol to reposition for a block).


The problem with him stepping up, is that there often isn't a pocket.

Also the DE, instead of going 'around' the OT, basically just runs right at the QB, which nullifies the idea of a step up.

It would work, if the pocket held up, but in those cases there's no need for him to do it. Catch22.
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jared
Originally posted by aliuking

Originally posted by Azure Dreams


Agree with that though I do, I defy you to find me a few defensive ends who run a sub-4.3 forty.


There aren't many players period that run sub 4.3, I think only Deion Sanders did that in his combine and Figurs also did it once, but if you look at the combine numbers the speed of DEs aren't much different at all from WRs


randy moss ran a 4.2, adrain peterson ran a sub 4.3, darryl green did as well, andre rison, jerry rice, terrel owens had a 4.3 40 in the combine, chris johnson(titans rookie hb) reggie bush, roddy white, I can keep this list of hb, cb, and wr that tested sub 4.4 in the 40 whereas to my knowledge only jevon kearse has recorded a sub 4.5 40 at the combine


The fastest electronically timed 40 is Chris Johnson's 4.24.

Deion ran a 4.57 at the combine, but ran the last 10 yards backpedaling

Any other 40 times are pure urban legend, and hand timed 40s don't really mean a whole lot.

The 40 isn't even considered that important for D-linemen, it's the 3 cone and shuttle drills that coaches care about.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
O Linemen make a blocking mistake and miss one?

Just liek Cbs make mistakes biting on pump fakes, how is it hard to imagine every other player might make mistakes?


Pump Fake was nerfed
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.