User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > The new promotion system
Page:
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Bort


5. Avg playoff game points differential
6. Avg postseason scrimmage points differential
7. Avg playoff points scored
8. Avg postseason scrimmage points scored
9. Avg playoff points allowed (lower is better)
10. Avg postseason scrimmages points allowed (lower is better)


I may just be overgeeking here (OK I know I am), but what it the point of #9/10 after running #5-8? Looks to me like #9/10 will never decide anything - so now it just bugs me that I may be missing something.


I don't know, but I hate that everything is biased towards good offenses.

Points Against is more important than Points For. Defense wins championships.
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
Originally posted by Painmaker

Originally posted by Bort



5. Avg playoff game points differential
6. Avg postseason scrimmage points differential
7. Avg playoff points scored
8. Avg postseason scrimmage points scored
9. Avg playoff points allowed (lower is better)
10. Avg postseason scrimmages points allowed (lower is better)


I may just be overgeeking here (OK I know I am), but what it the point of #9/10 after running #5-8? Looks to me like #9/10 will never decide anything - so now it just bugs me that I may be missing something.


I don't know, but I hate that everything is biased towards good offenses.

Points Against is more important than Points For. Defense wins championships.


I don't think its possible for 9 or 10 to use.

Let X be the points for, Y be the points against.

5 is a tie if X1-Y1 = X2 - Y2.
7 is a tie if X1 = X2
so that means Y1 = Y2.

Therefore #9 isn't used.

6 8 and 10 apply the same rules.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Bort


5. Avg playoff game points differential
6. Avg postseason scrimmage points differential
7. Avg playoff points scored
8. Avg postseason scrimmage points scored
9. Avg playoff points allowed (lower is better)
10. Avg postseason scrimmages points allowed (lower is better)


I may just be overgeeking here (OK I know I am), but what it the point of #9/10 after running #5-8? Looks to me like #9/10 will never decide anything - so now it just bugs me that I may be missing something.


I agree if you have a tie in points scored and a tie in points differential, you'll have a tie in points allowed. It's a mathematical certainty.

 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McMichael
The promotion/Relegation system happens each season. If a "Lucky" team gets promoted over a "Better" team this season, then ends up being unable to compete next season they will be relegated back down while the "Better" team will likely get promoted the next season.


That was the previous system, which still partially exists. It was a system based on reward, and your scenario is a lot dif than my one and done situation. Let's argue the facts people.

Part of the problem with the last system is that the best team may not get promoted, causing leagues to be lopsided. A lopsided league can discourage other teams in the league because they continue to get pounded on by a team that outclasses them, and it can discourage the team doing the pounding because they get bored. The newly implemented system should strive to promote the best teams.

Originally posted by Painmaker

Think of the scrimmages as the consolation bracket. Playoff Round 2 losers play other Round 2 losers, etc. It's still the postseason if you're vying for promotion and the opportunity is there (which it may or may not be depending on the specific situation that season).


I'm not saying that there still isn't competition in this "consolation" bracket, but I have an issue with the fact that it takes precedent over the regular season, the importance of these scrimmages further lessens the importance and excitement of the regular season.

A lot of people argue that college sports (basketball, football) are more exciting because of the importance of every last game. To me it seems like GLB is taking a route that would be like the NIT (virtually a consolation bracket) meaning more than the regular season in college basketball.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Theory: the team in the scrimmages is the one getting promoted, not the one that played during the season, so if it comes down to that tiebreaker it's important to get the better team and it's better to determine who's better by recent performance (i.e. scrimmage W/L) as opposed to the previous season.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
So now top teams can't use postseason scrimmages to work on new strategies and gameplans. Instead we have to gameplan and work them like regular season games even though half of our players don't think they matter for anything? What if the team I'm playing in a scrimmage doesn't think they have any shot at moving up so they mail the scrimmage in or do something dumb like start all their backups, but the other team hoping to be promoted has a team that plays them straight up? You're making games that by definition (scrimmage) don't matter matter. The only fair way to do this is to base it on regular season results of some sort.

I really don't like this the more I think about it.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 22:03:10
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
So now top teams can't use postseason scrimmages to work on new strategies and gameplans. Instead we have to gameplan and work them like regular season games even though half of our players don't think they matter for anything? What if the team I'm playing in a scrimmage doesn't think they have any shot at moving up so they mail the scrimmage in or do something dumb like start all their backups, but the other team hoping to be promoted has a team that plays them straight up? You're making games that by definition (scrimmage) don't matter matter.

I really don't like this the more I think about it.


Also, you know there will be those juggernaut teams that will lose in the playoffs, and then attempt to stay in the lower league by throwing scrimmage games, either so they can stick around and try to get a trophy, or play against lesser competition.
 
Link
 
So I understand there is no "make the playoffs bonus", but if you win the round do you still get the bonus?
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Theory: the team in the scrimmages is the one getting promoted, not the one that played during the season, so if it comes down to that tiebreaker it's important to get the better team and it's better to determine who's better by recent performance (i.e. scrimmage W/L) as opposed to the previous season.


Originally posted by nfratami

I'm not saying that there still isn't competition in this "consolation" bracket, but I have an issue with the fact that it takes precedent over the regular season, the importance of these scrimmages further lessens the importance and excitement of the regular season.

A lot of people argue that college sports (basketball, football) are more exciting because of the importance of every last game. To me it seems like GLB is taking a route that would be like the NIT (virtually a consolation bracket) meaning more than the regular season in college basketball.
 
scottyxWINx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami

Also, you know there will be those juggernaut teams that will lose in the playoffs, and then attempt to stay in the lower league by throwing scrimmage games, either so they can stick around and try to get a trophy, or play against lesser competition.


Exactly, it will happen all the time.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 22:34:13
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
How will the scrimmages be determined is my question... Who plays who, and on what basis?
 
itsme420
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
How will the scrimmages be determined is my question... Who plays who, and on what basis?


Bort and a dartboard
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by itsme4
Originally posted by tigerbait22

How will the scrimmages be determined is my question... Who plays who, and on what basis?


Bort and a dartboard


Can't be luck of the draw..... Where you play a scrub team from the other division.. makes no sense..
 
Baustin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
How will the scrimmages be determined is my question... Who plays who, and on what basis?


I would think that wouldn't change. Teams knocked out of the playoffs play their like number from the other conference.
 
itsme420
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
Originally posted by itsme4

Originally posted by tigerbait22


How will the scrimmages be determined is my question... Who plays who, and on what basis?


Bort and a dartboard


Can't be luck of the draw..... Where you play a scrub team from the other division.. makes no sense..


yeah I'm hoping there is some method to the madness o_o
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.