User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AA Leagues > South America AA #1 > SEC is the Best Conference and Big East is the worst
Page:
 
oldarmyc
offline
Link
 
Other than keeping this alive...if anything has been proven in college football is rankings don't mean shit, and the only way to prove who is better is to play each other. Since there is no playoff system the media and everyone else for that matter is left to argue who is better and who isn't, and the only real way to solve is to play the game against each other. The worst thing that college football did is to allow for all wins including those against II A schools count to bowl eligibility. I applaud Clemson and Alabama for playing each other in the first game, and Ohio State and USC playing each other, as this makes for better games and better football. Nothing worse than having to watch crap games for four weeks before conference play starts. As much as I like App State beating Michigan how many times is that going to happen in the next seasons.

Been drinking so this may be more of a ramble than making a point.
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Who needs ESPN.com when you have this thread. I think Marauder and Ron created the biggest internet archive of stats in this thread.
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kobby
Originally posted by marauder22

Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell


How is UCLA ranked in 1 but not the other

LMAO the guys an obvious idiot.


it's the rankings when the teams played. i just wanted to emphasize that when tennessee played ucla they weren't playing what ucla turned out to be but at the time the 23rd ranked team in the nation. seems so long ago with how they've turned out but yes tennessee lost in OT on what i call a fluke all the way across the country to then the 23rd best team in the nation. it was only after that, that ucla turned out to be terrible. i also sort of wanted to help u guys out by giving usc credit for a win against a top 5 team but i can change it so they play no top 10 teams if you'd like. of course after cal gets beat by somebody terrible the pac 10 won't have a second ranked team so that would look pretty bad, whereas the sec will go 7-1 in bowl games like they always do against equal level teams from other conferences and end up with 5-6 "overrated" ranked teams like they do every year.

here's sec vs. pac 10 bowl records, teams ranked in the final AP poll to end the year, and teams ranked in the top 5 or 10 in the nation to end the year. as you'll notice for the last 10 years!, the pac 10 has never once had more bowl wins or as many top 25 teams to finish the year as the sec:

2007: sec 7-2, 5 ranked teams, 2 top 2 teams, won national title
pac 10 4-2, 4 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team

2006: sec 6-3, 6 ranked teams, 2 top 5 teams, 3 top 10 teams, won national title
pac 10 3-3, 3 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team

2005: sec 3-3, 5 ranked teams, 3 top 10 teams
pac 10 3-2, 4 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team

2004: sec 3-3, 4 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams
pac 10 3-2, 3 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams, won national title

2003: sec 5-2, 5 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams, won 1/2 national title
pac 10 4-2, 2 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams, won 1/2 national title

2002: sec 3-4, 3 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team
pac 10 2-5, 2 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams

2001: sec 5-3, 5 ranked teams, 2 top 5 teams, 3 top 10 teams
pac 10 2-2, 4 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams

2000: sec 4-5, 6 ranked teams, 1 top 10 team
pac 10 3-1, 3 ranked teams, 2 top 5 teams, 3 top 10 teams

1999: sec 4-4, 6 ranked teams, 2 top 10 teams
pac 10 1-4, 1 ranked team #19

1998: sec 4-4 4 ranked teams, 2 top 5 teams, won national title
pac 10 1-4 2 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams


and this brings me to my next point, u guys were arguing that the sec always has up teams and down teams and that's why it's not as good, well the only up team in the pac 10 is usc. the only team to finish in the top 5 in the country since 2001 is usc. since that time, the sec has had 5 teams finish in the top 5 (tennessee, georgia, florida, lsu, and auburn).

also the pac 10 hasn't had a team win at least a share of the national title other than usc since 1991 when washington won a share. in that time usc won 1 1/2, while the sec won 5 1/2 with 4 different teams all of which they won outright except for the one lsu split (lsu twice, florida twice, tennessee, and alabama). the last national title the pac 10 won outright was way back in 1972 by...u guessed it usc, then 1967 by again usc. but then it's...well no my list only goes back to 1936. aww shucks, so that's 1 split national title for the pac 10 not including usc for the past 72 years. the sec has 11 outright and 16 including splits from 6 different teams (lsu, florida, tennessee, bama, georgia, and auburn).

zing. sec>pac 10 /discussion.


Who had UCLA ranked preseason? Here are the rankings before Tennessee played UCLA.


1. Georgia (22) 0-0 1,528
2. Ohio State (21) 0-0 1,506
3. USC (12) 0-0 1,490
4. Oklahoma (4) 0-0 1,444
5. Florida (6) 0-0 1,415
6. Missouri 0-0 1,266
7. LSU 0-0 1,135
8. West Virginia 0-0 1,116
9. Clemson 0-0 1,105
10. Auburn 0-0 968
11. Texas 0-0 966
12. Texas Tech 0-0 786
13. Wisconsin 0-0 771
14. Kansas 0-0 707
15. Arizona State 0-0 631
16. Brigham Young 0-0 590
17. Virginia Tech 0-0 578
18. Tennessee 0-0 509
19. South Florida 0-0 496
20. Illinois 0-0 483
21. Oregon 0-0 366
22. Penn State 0-0 293
23. Wake Forest 0-0 227
24. Alabama 0-0 89
25. Pittsburgh


Here's the rankings after UCLA beat Tennessee.


1. USC (21) 1-0 1,539
2. Georgia (20) 1-0 1,506
3. Ohio State (15) 1-0 1,497
4. Oklahoma (2) 1-0 1,432
5. Florida (5) 1-0 1,415
6. Missouri (1) 1-0 1,301
7. LSU (1) 1-0 1,207
8. West Virginia 1-0 1,108
9. Auburn 1-0 1,033
10. Texas 1-0 1,028
11. Wisconsin 1-0 849
12. Texas Tech 1-0 842
13. Alabama 1-0 834
14. Kansas 1-0 748
15. Arizona State 1-0 672
15. Brigham Young 1-0 672
17. South Florida 1-0 588
18. Oregon 1-0 508
19. Penn State 1-0 467
20. Wake Forest 1-0 414
21. Fresno State 1-0 242
22. Utah 1-0 214
23. UCLA 1-0 151
24. Illinois 0-1 147
24. South Carolina 1-0 147


What do you know. UCLA is ranked 23rd. So when they played Tennessee. They were unranked, but after the game they were 23rd. So you putting up their 23rd ranking on Tennessee's schedule is wrong.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 22:26:00
 
mcallero
offline
Link
 
yeah, ucla moved in to top 25 after beating tenn

nevertheless, you kind of ignored everything else in the post...
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mcallero
yeah, ucla moved in to top 25 after beating tenn

nevertheless, you kind of ignored everything else in the post...


His posts furthers what I said. 2 or 3 good teams in the SEC every year. The rest are programs that get their rankings on their program names. See Auburn, Tennessee this season. See Bama last season. See Auburn 03 etc.....Every year the top team changes, but theirs always only 2 or 3 top teams. This season you have 4 teams. LSU, Florida, Bama, UGA. Then after that, theirs a severe drop. Auburn(See Tennesee), Vandy, South Carolina, Arkansas, Mississippi State, Tennessee(Great Program down season. Exactly what I've been saying.) etc.....


One more thing. He should have said since 02. Their has only been one team in the Pac 10 to finish in the top 5. Oregon finished 2nd in 01. Then again its very hard to finish in the top 5 when you have a loss on your record. Every team in the Pac 10 plays each other. UGA and LSU didn't play each other last season. If they did only 1 of them would of ended up in the top 5. UGA wasn't a top 5 team in the country last season IMO. Beating Hawaii in the sugar bowl and getting all that unwarranted hype. I Would have loved it had they played USC in the Rose Bowl last season.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 22:39:03
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
USC won't play the SEC... the whole Big Ten hand shake agreement.. That's sad... takes away from very fun games against USC or an SEC opponent.. I don't like it.
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
UGA's schedule last season. This got them the number 2 ranking. People just recall the ass whoopen they put on Hawaii. How many top teams do you really think would have done that to Hawaii?

September 1 Oklahoma State W 35-14 1-0 (0-0)(Joke)
September 8 South Carolina L 16-12 1-1 (0-1)(Average)
September 15 Western Carolina W 45-16 2-1 (0-1)(Joke)
September 22 at No. 16 Alabama W 26-23 3-1 (1-1)(6-6)
September 29 Mississippi W 45-17 4-1 (2-1)(Joke)
October 6 at Tennessee L 35-14 4-2 (2-2)(Did anybody forget the ass whoopen Cal put on them?)
October 13 at Vanderbilt W 20-17 5-2 (3-2)(Joke)
October 27 at No. 11 Florida W 42-30 6-2 (4-2)(No defense. They got scored on at will by Michigan.)
November 3 Troy W 44-34 7-2 (4-2)(Joke)
November 10 No. 18 Auburn W 45-20 8-2 (5-2)(Solid team that got beat by South Florida. Who got taken to the shed by Oregon)
November 17 No. 23 Kentucky W 24-13 9-2 (6-2)(Managed to beat a FSU team that had their entire team almost out because of suspension)
November 24 at Georgia Tech W 31-17 10-2 (6-2)(Average at best)
January 1 vs. No. 10 Hawaii W 41-10(Joke)
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
USC won't play the SEC... the whole Big Ten hand shake agreement.. That's sad... takes away from very fun games against USC or an SEC opponent.. I don't like it.


How do you figure that? They played SEC teams 4 of the last 6 years. Auburn in 02-03. Tubberville got out of the 04 game, and USC played Va Tech in the K.O. classic to open that season in Maryland. In 05 and 06 they beat the snot out of Arkansas. Their trying to schedule a game with LSU now. Hell back in 02. USC wanted to set up a game with Miami for the 03 season. Coker didn't want the game. USC wants competition, but most teams don't wanna play USC in an OOC game.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 22:50:46
 
mcallero
offline
Link
 
same could be said for USC if i ran through their schedule. How high was nebraska ranked when they played? And others... illinois= hawaii last year imo
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mcallero
same could be said for USC if i ran through their schedule. How high was nebraska ranked when they played? And others... illinois= hawaii last year imo


Illinois would beat Hawaii. Doesn't change the fact that Illinois shouldn't have been in the Rose bowl. I won't pump that team up. They were solid, but not BCS material.
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mcallero
same could be said for USC if i ran through their schedule. How high was nebraska ranked when they played? And others... illinois= hawaii last year imo


When SC played Oregon. Oregon was a legit top team in the country. Then Dixon went down and so did that offense for a couple of weeks. ASU was solid. Cal was a solid team, but had a collapse. They still took Tennessee(SEC championship game rep. to the shed).
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Oregon schedule with dixon

September 1 Houston W 48-27 1-0 (0-0)
September 8 at Michigan W 39-7 2-0 (0-0)(Beat Florida)
September 15 Fresno State W 52-21 3-0 (0-0)
September 22 at Stanford W 55-31 4-0 (1-0)
September 29 No. 6 California L 31-24 4-1 (1-1)(Fumbled at the Cal 1)
October 13 Washington State W 53-7 5-1 (2-1)
October 20 at Washington W 55-34 6-1 (3-1)
October 27 No. 12 USC W 24-17 7-1 (4-1)
November 3 No. 4 Arizona State W 35-23 8-1 (5-1)


Oregon after Dixon

November 15 at Arizona L 34-24 8-2 (5-2)(Played one series and Oregon scored. Before his injury)
November 24 at UCLA L 16-0 8-3 (5-3)(Didn't even score.)
December 1 Oregon State L 38-31 8-4 (5-4)(Rivalry game, Oregon had 8 starers out.)
December 31 vs. No. 21 South Florida W 56-21 9-4 (5-4)
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 23:02:36
 
mcallero
offline
Link
 
fluke... and oregon would have lost 4 games with dixon in the sec
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mcallero
fluke... and oregon would have lost 4 games with dixon in the sec


What was a fluke, and who would Oregon have lost to besides LSU?
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 23:04:05
 
mcallero
offline
Link
 
UGA, UF, AU, LSU
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.