User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Interesting topic of the Week: Evolutionism versus Creationism
Page:
 
DedJVE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by DecadentDefiance

no rly wut


See you in a few days, stop posting those tags.


Can I say "Snypah" here for effect?
 
DedJVE
offline
Link
 
(Talk about luckyimo)
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Originally posted by Asheme

Originally posted by Originally posted by X


First off, atheists aren't claiming to know something that in unknowable. Well, not all atheists.

They are. If anyone uses the term "atheist" to describe themselves, then, by definition, they are making a knowledge claim. I understand what you mean, but it's a misuse of the word.


Agnostic fits what you describe much better.


Again, not really. The only qualification of "atheism" is lack of theistic believes.


Ugh...I tried but all of this additional shit is fucking me up.
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Yeremiah

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by X



Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder




Originally posted by X





Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder






So we don't base our beliefs on what we can prove now?


See this is why I hate the word "belief" and the phrase "belief system" in a conversation like this. I don't have a "belief system" per se because belief happens in the void of substantiating knowledge. I don't "believe" in a god because I have never seen or am not aware of any substantiating logic. No, I've never been to Beijing either, so don't try that one.

Point is that my philosophical world view is that there is nothing beyond the natural world. No supernatural forces at work. If some magical sky wizard comes down tomorrow and shoots lazers and the moon and spells out "I AM HERE" then my philosophical world might change. Until then...


That's all well and good, but you're either certain there is/isn't a god, or you don't know. If you're certain there isn't a god, then you're just as foolish as the people that insist there is a god.


I am certain that I have never seen evidence nor heard of evidence of the existence of god.


And I agree, but again, that's such a small sample size, saying "there is absolutely no god" is beyond silly.


I am pretty sure there is no god. But anything is possible.


QFT


I never said there was no god.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I posted that before refreshing the thread, but still, the point stands.

It's not a lack of theistic belief, it's the opposite of, which is unbelief.

If you look up the definition of atheist in any dictionary, it will say something along the lines of a person who claims there are no supreme being/being.

Central to the definition of the word is a denial, or a negative knowledge claim.
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Yeah, I posted that before refreshing the thread, but still, the point stands.

It's not a lack of theistic belief, it's the opposite of, which is unbelief.

If you look up the definition of atheist in any dictionary, it will say something along the lines of a person who claims there are no supreme being/being.

Central to the definition of the word is a denial, or a negative knowledge claim.


Strong atheism, yes. Weak atheism, not so much. Which is why I made the distinction is atheistic philosophy.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Originally posted by Asheme

Yeah, I posted that before refreshing the thread, but still, the point stands.

It's not a lack of theistic belief, it's the opposite of, which is unbelief.

If you look up the definition of atheist in any dictionary, it will say something along the lines of a person who claims there are no supreme being/being.

Central to the definition of the word is a denial, or a negative knowledge claim.


Strong atheism, yes. Weak atheism, not so much. Which is why I made the distinction is atheistic philosophy.


X, help me out and check a box here:

[ ]There is a god
[ ]There may or may not be a god
[ ]There is no god
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by X

Originally posted by Asheme


Yeah, I posted that before refreshing the thread, but still, the point stands.

It's not a lack of theistic belief, it's the opposite of, which is unbelief.

If you look up the definition of atheist in any dictionary, it will say something along the lines of a person who claims there are no supreme being/being.

Central to the definition of the word is a denial, or a negative knowledge claim.


Strong atheism, yes. Weak atheism, not so much. Which is why I made the distinction is atheistic philosophy.


X, help me out and check a box here:

[ ]There is a god
[ ]There may or may not be a god
[ ]There is no god
[x]I lack a belief system that accounts for the existence of a god


Last edited Oct 12, 2008 19:39:03
 
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by X


Originally posted by Asheme



Yeah, I posted that before refreshing the thread, but still, the point stands.

It's not a lack of theistic belief, it's the opposite of, which is unbelief.

If you look up the definition of atheist in any dictionary, it will say something along the lines of a person who claims there are no supreme being/being.

Central to the definition of the word is a denial, or a negative knowledge claim.


Strong atheism, yes. Weak atheism, not so much. Which is why I made the distinction is atheistic philosophy.


X, help me out and check a box here:

[ ]There is a god
[ ]There may or may not be a god
[ ]There is no god
[x]I lack a belief system that accounts for the existence of a god




Ok, my fault, let me rephrase the choices:

[ ]There is a god
[ ]There may or may not be a god
[ ]There is no god

 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by X

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by X



Originally posted by Asheme




Yeah, I posted that before refreshing the thread, but still, the point stands.

It's not a lack of theistic belief, it's the opposite of, which is unbelief.

If you look up the definition of atheist in any dictionary, it will say something along the lines of a person who claims there are no supreme being/being.

Central to the definition of the word is a denial, or a negative knowledge claim.


Strong atheism, yes. Weak atheism, not so much. Which is why I made the distinction is atheistic philosophy.


X, help me out and check a box here:

[ ]There is a god
[ ]There may or may not be a god
[ ]There is no god
[x]I lack a belief system that accounts for the existence of a god




Ok, my fault, let me rephrase the choices:

[ ]There is a god
[ ]There may or may not be a god
[ ]There is no god
[x]None of the above?


 
Link
 
I'm having trouble understanding how any thoughts/beliefs you have could fall outside of those three choices.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
I'm having trouble understanding how any thoughts/beliefs you have could fall outside of those three choices.


Me too.
 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

I'm having trouble understanding how any thoughts/beliefs you have could fall outside of those three choices.


Me too.


scientology
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
<Gturtle> Someone ask VT if I need to believe in the invisible lion that might be in my room right now. I've got no way of telling one way or the other, but I'm pretty sure that might've been why that pencil fell off my desk.
 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
<Gturtle> I mean, sure, gravity and the fact that the pencil was on a slightly slanted surface might have explained it
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.