User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > ***OFFICIAL CPL THUNDERDOME THREAD***
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by Gturtle


Originally posted by SteelersInsider



And if Zithers is on, then you have to let a ton of other people on like Boomer and BroncosBeTheBest to name 2.


currently banking on zither's ability to at least recognize good posting, tbh.


Also, given your track record (although it is improving) I'm inclined to say "try again later, after you win some in the Thunderdome" although I do have an idea now *goes to the discussion thread*



Frankly, given the obvious biases of the judges, I don't see why anyone not on the Trout, Halifax, Bastards, CCC, or Dryden would enter the Thunderdome. They have 0% chance to win vs anyone on those teams. Not because of the posting, but because of bias.

And though you guys are improving also (thank you), I'm inclined to say thanks but no thanks. Anyone on the Beans, Yetis, or outside CPL would be wise to do the same.

I ban my players from the team board all the time. I don't give a shit. I'm the only "fair" judge on the panel tbqh.

As I take dots too seriously, I would probably also take judging too seriously.


PEACE AND LOVE


I'm not really seeing the potential for bias. I'm pretty sure that this stems from the fact that I know that the other Hobo judges aren't going to give me anything solely because we're from the same team, and vice-versa. Maybe there's something I'm not considering, but we'll jump over that handle if/when we come to it



c'mon, when has 1 hobo taken the opposite side of another hobo?

bunch of sheep imo


same goes for Trout.

Only player on Trout I've seen stand up to VT is dkgojackets. He's the only rebel on that team.

 
DT35
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1207389

What happens now?
 
Michael Vick
offline
Link
 
Can I be a judge
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

c'mon, when has 1 hobo taken the opposite side of another hobo?


On the forums where hobos originated, obviously. Take Untouchable, for instance, who has been permabanned there twice, and Verus, who doesn't post that much here, but is one of four moderators on the other forum (who banned Untouchable.) Or how me and Bushidozin tend to square off on the other forum (he usually wins, fwiw)
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Idea:

Have judges. Also have open poles. Count each judge's vote as like 3 or 5 non-judicial votes, to temper the stupidity of the masses but still allow their input.

America, fuck yeah.


would need to trim down the judges list then imo.


Not every judge would necessarily need to serve on the judicial board for every match imo.
 
Link
 
If they aren't one of the first five judges to judge, then they are counted as regular voters and not judicial ones.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Rules:
*Only one Thunderdome at a time, first come first serve- a Thunderdome is not over until the loser has served his full punishment

*Two posters (the challenger, and the challengee) agree to the Thunderdome, and the resulting ban (but this ban is non-reversible, unlike other times when you can reverse a ban you ask for)

*Prior to the agreement of the Thunderdome, the Challenger determines the length of the ban that the loser will face (max of 3 days)

*The Challenger starts the Thunderdome Challenge thread

*The Challengee determines the format/length of the Thunderdome thread (Victor determined after 1 or 2 days, or Victor determined after XX posts by each contestant)

*The Five Judges that are willing to judge the challenge will chime in after the Challengee has posted the format.

*After the fifth judge has posted, the Challenger or the Chalengee begins the contest with the first post.

*Contestants then exchange posts (no editing previous posts for any reason) on an alternating basis.

*Winner is determined by majority judge rule (obviously)

*Obviously the CPL-accepted rules still apply to these threads, if you can't beat somebody without doing something worthy of a ban, you're not that good of a poster, are you?

*People who are challenged, and back down from the challenge are open to public ridicule.

*Judges can vote down a challenge similarly to how they self-appoint themselves as ruling over a given thread. If five judges say that they think this Thunderdome is too mismatched/dull/between two nobodies and won't be entertaining, with no judges saying otherwise, the challenge will be dismissed.


Pool of official judges:
Gart888
Gturtle
DrunkenOne
commander
dkgojackets
BobJoeJim
X
Asheme
jakobako
JeffGarcia
Untouchable
txag2k
Zithers
Armaro
Vando
Yeremiah
Azure_Dreams


hai! no underscore!
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
I might as well not ruin this thread with my crap posting so I will not post on this thread after this comment.

Edit: For wording
Last edited Oct 10, 2008 17:44:48
 
klaw19
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gart888
I for one am going to judge 100% based on poasting, not which team people are on.


rofl, you sound like all the scumbag politicians. It's easy to make a promise.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by klaw19
Originally posted by gart888

I for one am going to judge 100% based on poasting, not which team people are on.


rofl, you sound like all the scumbag politicians. It's easy to make a promise.


And it's easy to follow through on your promise if its something so simple.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by klaw19
rofl, you sound like all the scumbag politicians. It's easy to make a promise.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1207050
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by klaw19
Originally posted by gart888

I for one am going to judge 100% based on poasting, not which team people are on.


rofl, you sound like all the scumbag politicians. It's easy to make a promise.


It's easy to follow through too when it's such a dumb promise. Who the fuck cares which word their dots are associated with?
 
klaw19
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gart888
Originally posted by klaw19

Originally posted by gart888


I for one am going to judge 100% based on poasting, not which team people are on.


rofl, you sound like all the scumbag politicians. It's easy to make a promise.


And it's easy to follow through on your promise if its something so simple.


I didn't really figure you for a moron, but are you fucking stupid? Sure it's easy when there's no way to judge if you are following through on your promise or not.
 
DrunkenOne
offline
Link
 
no judges plz it makes 0 sense if you actually think about it
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by klaw19
Originally posted by gart888

Originally posted by klaw19


Originally posted by gart888



I for one am going to judge 100% based on poasting, not which team people are on.


rofl, you sound like all the scumbag politicians. It's easy to make a promise.


And it's easy to follow through on your promise if its something so simple.


I didn't really figure you for a moron, but are you fucking stupid? Sure it's easy when there's no way to judge if you are following through on your promise or not.


wat

there's no way to judge if i'm following through on my promise?

if the judges votes are public (as i think they should be), it will be ridiculously easy to track if i'm following through or not.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.