User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Defense AI occasionally not followed
Page:
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Happened twice in my game yesterday and twice in my scrimmage today. I'll use the first one from the scrimmage as my example since I was testing a defense in that one and it's not my normal play call.

Single Back Formation, I have the following Input:

Single Back
Time Remaining blank
Ball Spot Between Any Spot and Any Spot
Down Between 1 and 4
Yards to First Down blank
Score Difference blank
Opponent's Formation Single Back
Number of WR's in Set 0 to 3

I had two 50% outputs, one is for a 3-3-5 Cover 2, the other is for a 4-3-4 cover 0.

The following play happened early in the 1st quarter:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=194805&pbp_id=7543645

That is my "bug" defense (last one on the list that only gets called if there has been an error) that is called. I intentionally made it a 3-1-7 so it would stand out when I see it on the field.

I inputted the following in the defensive tester:

Quarter - First
Time Remaining - 843 seconds
Ball Spot - Own 32
Down - First and 10
Score - I'm trailing by 0
Opponent Formation - Single Back
Number of Wide Receivers - 3

Results:

Matching Input
Input Named: Single Back

Possible Outputs
50% 3-3-5 (nickel 3-4 Cover 2 man)
50% 4-3-4 (4-3 Cover 0 man)
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Today, my SS stopped coming up to the line to cover the TE in a Cover 1 LB Blitz. First time I have ever noticed it doing that.
 
Link
 
This is a legit bug, does Bort or support need more evidence to start looking at it? Please let us know so when we notice the same problem again, we know what information needs to collect and what snapshot needs to take.
 
Link
 
bump
 
Link
 
The thread above you finally decided to disclose what his settings were and his "occasional" problem was immediately solved:


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1220022


Hazy's probably is likely similar, but he doesn't want to disclose.

Most of the "occasional" problems involve calling an offensive or defensive play that doesn't exist.

I gave the other guy 1 such play that doesn't exist: pass to TE (long). You guys need to find the other ones on your own. People who use basic settings that aren't all 100% are more likely to experience the occasional "bug" because you would be more likely to have a play that doesn't exist come up. If you set each play to something that is fixed, it is much easier to narrow down USER ERROR.

 
Link
 
SI, it is not related to this thread. If you want to continue to discuss this bug, answer the question you avoid last time:

Define "illegal blitzer", for example, do you mean MLB is an illegal blitzer in 3-4? Do you mean if anyone set blitz percentage at MLB in a 3-4, the output will be skipped?

and

What blitz package can make 3-4 cover 0 illegal?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
SI, it is not related to this thread. If you want to continue to discuss this bug, answer the question you avoid last time:

Define "illegal blitzer", for example, do you mean MLB is an illegal blitzer in 3-4? Do you mean if anyone set blitz percentage at MLB in a 3-4, the output will be skipped?

and

What blitz package can make 3-4 cover 0 illegal?



I am not telling you all of the advantages that I have gained through extensive trial and error.

Sorry, but you have to figure it out yourself.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

SI, it is not related to this thread. If you want to continue to discuss this bug, answer the question you avoid last time:

Define "illegal blitzer", for example, do you mean MLB is an illegal blitzer in 3-4? Do you mean if anyone set blitz percentage at MLB in a 3-4, the output will be skipped?

and

What blitz package can make 3-4 cover 0 illegal?



I am not telling you all of the advantages that I have gained through extensive trial and error.

Sorry, but you have to figure it out yourself.


Because you don't know. It is as simple as this. If you know, you'll have said it loudly and acted like you are superior to everyone.

Too bad, such a thing doesn't exist and you are too afraid to admit it.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 12:25:37
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

SI, it is not related to this thread. If you want to continue to discuss this bug, answer the question you avoid last time:

Define "illegal blitzer", for example, do you mean MLB is an illegal blitzer in 3-4? Do you mean if anyone set blitz percentage at MLB in a 3-4, the output will be skipped?

and

What blitz package can make 3-4 cover 0 illegal?



I am not telling you all of the advantages that I have gained through extensive trial and error.

Sorry, but you have to figure it out yourself.



Maybe ask Tim Harper?

With all the scrimmages and testing he has done, he probably knows more than anyone. Minihusk would also be a good person to ask. He should know as well.

Except that have spent a ton of timing finding these things out, I doubt they would just give them away.

Last edited Oct 15, 2008 12:25:54
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by buffalobills_tw


SI, it is not related to this thread. If you want to continue to discuss this bug, answer the question you avoid last time:

Define "illegal blitzer", for example, do you mean MLB is an illegal blitzer in 3-4? Do you mean if anyone set blitz percentage at MLB in a 3-4, the output will be skipped?

and

What blitz package can make 3-4 cover 0 illegal?



I am not telling you all of the advantages that I have gained through extensive trial and error.

Sorry, but you have to figure it out yourself.



Maybe ask Tim Harper?

With all the scrimmages and testing he has done, he probably knows more than anyone. Minihusk would also be a good person to ask. They should know as well.

Except that have spent a ton of timing finding these things out, I doubt they would just give them away.



My reply to you is the same:

Because you don't know. It is as simple as this. If you know, you'll have said it loudly and acted like you are superior to everyone.

Too bad, such a thing doesn't exist and you are too afraid to admit it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Originally posted by buffalobills_tw



SI, it is not related to this thread. If you want to continue to discuss this bug, answer the question you avoid last time:

Define "illegal blitzer", for example, do you mean MLB is an illegal blitzer in 3-4? Do you mean if anyone set blitz percentage at MLB in a 3-4, the output will be skipped?

and

What blitz package can make 3-4 cover 0 illegal?



I am not telling you all of the advantages that I have gained through extensive trial and error.

Sorry, but you have to figure it out yourself.



Maybe ask Tim Harper?

With all the scrimmages and testing he has done, he probably knows more than anyone. Minihusk would also be a good person to ask. They should know as well.

Except that have spent a ton of timing finding these things out, I doubt they would just give them away.



My reply to you is the same:

Because you don't know. It is as simple as this. If you know, you'll have said it loudly and acted like you are superior to everyone.

Too bad, such a thing doesn't exist and you are too afraid to admit it.



I don't care what you call me, I'm not giving away the stuff I know for free.

Do the work. Learn for yourself.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

My reply to you is the same:

Because you don't know. It is as simple as this. If you know, you'll have said it loudly and acted like you are superior to everyone.

Too bad, such a thing doesn't exist and you are too afraid to admit it.



I don't care what you call me, I'm not giving away the stuff I know for free.

Do the work. Learn for yourself.


It's ok, This just further confirms you don't know but you are too afraid to admit it. If you knew, you would have already said it loudly and acted like you are superior to everyone.

 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
Happened twice in my game yesterday and twice in my scrimmage today. I'll use the first one from the scrimmage as my example since I was testing a defense in that one and it's not my normal play call.

Single Back Formation, I have the following Input:

Single Back
Time Remaining blank
Ball Spot Between Any Spot and Any Spot
Down Between 1 and 4
Yards to First Down blank
Score Difference blank
Opponent's Formation Single Back
Number of WR's in Set 0 to 3

I had two 50% outputs, one is for a 3-3-5 Cover 2, the other is for a 4-3-4 cover 0.

The following play happened early in the 1st quarter:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=194805&pbp_id=7543645

That is my "bug" defense (last one on the list that only gets called if there has been an error) that is called. I intentionally made it a 3-1-7 so it would stand out when I see it on the field.

I inputted the following in the defensive tester:

Quarter - First
Time Remaining - 843 seconds
Ball Spot - Own 32
Down - First and 10
Score - I'm trailing by 0
Opponent Formation - Single Back
Number of Wide Receivers - 3

Results:

Matching Input
Input Named: Single Back

Possible Outputs
50% 3-3-5 (nickel 3-4 Cover 2 man)
50% 4-3-4 (4-3 Cover 0 man)


Having thought about this a bit, I am realizing that although I do watch every replay it is quite possible that I could miss something like this occurring. Unlike Hazy, I do not have a distinctive "catch all" defense at the bottom of my list. If my list errors out, it would use a standard defense. Since I have a variety of packages for almost every formation, it is quite possible that I would not notice a subtle change...I think I generally have at least one defense that would be similar too a default AI call for the more common formations at least. I would hazard a guess that mor folks have a set up similar to mine rather than Hazy's setup.

I think I will install a distinctive defense as a "last resort" option and see if I start seeing these errors pop up.



 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
...

Most of the "occasional" problems involve calling an offensive or defensive play that doesn't exist.

...


Sorry, but that's a BUG.

It is widespread known that there are limited offensive plays.

But Bort never announced that he just didn't code certain defensive plays - just like there's no pathing for a certain blitz combination vs. a certain offensive play - WHILE THE VERY SAME PLAY IS CODED VS. ALMOST ALL OTHER OFFENSIVE PLAYS.

So while I can understand somehow that you don't want to share your knowledge of the bug, you shouldn't deny that this is actually a bug.

Easiest fix: Bort should just tell people about it - or have a list announced of non-existing plays.


To point this out:

- knowing that a certain blitz has a different pathing vs. a certain play = secret to keep
- knowing that a certain blitz leads to a malfunction = bug = help to solve the issue

 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=146243&pbp_id=6071961

This is the single back big. We play one of our single back plays (3-3-5 and MLB + ROLB blitzing) - instead of the single back big plays (3-4 and 4-3 + no blitzers).

The single back big - input is above the single back inputs, so it should have triggered. But it has not!


I just realized that it must even go as far as some basic packages are not coded (base formations, coverage shell, zone/man underneath, play type focus, LB shift). The plays not called didn't involve ANY blitzing.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.