User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Playoff Profit sharing...
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tmoon
One of the "fun" dilemas of the game is deciding to boost your team early which means a possible early exit from the playoffs or boost your team late which means advancement in the playoffs but no home field games. Its a choice that is being again taken away... who needs to win home field for the revenue if there is not a reward. If I can set in a league and make no effort with my team and make the playoffs (not hard to do) and get massive revenue why do I even need to try during the regular season. The people who always complain about revenue sharing are the people that can't win, will never win, don't know how to win... Your all like a bunch of government check collectors... GIVE ME MONEY FOR DOING NOTHING!!!


+1000
 
Link
 
Originally posted by purehatred
Originally posted by geturembedder

I think the fair way would be to leave the home revenue untouched, and just up the playoff bonuses. I think 100000 is fair, but if you up it to 200000 and double up each one than that is plenty, and if you can't work with that then you get what you deserve.


Exactly. No one is saying it's right for a playoff team to get only get 100 k...that's chump change.

But it's not fair to have to give away a chunk of money that was earned by a team that fought very hard to be one of the top 4 seeds in their league. Especially since playoff tickets are such a big part of what a team earns each year.

Until there are other forms of revenue outside of tickets/concessions, revenue sharing shouldn't be put in place.


+1
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chief Bootnaka
Originally posted by Crushr

Originally posted by geturembedder


Originally posted by Crushr



Originally posted by Toric




Rev sharing just makes Zero sense to me..

i bust my ass finding the best staff and the best players. We spend seasons fixing builds and getting the team ready to win..

Hrs and hrs of work... Damm right we get to the home playoff games. but it was EARNED..

With the new promotion system the playoffs have little enough to offer. Come now the pretty cup was always cool but earning the promote, that was the real prize! I do understand why that needs to change.. However taking the money away for home playoff games is yet another shot at the teams that take the game for real, work hard and put the real time in that this game takes...

with the new system of teams dropping there is simply not going to be a huge need for this anyway. your killing the stadiums re starting them as capped teams.. whats the point of giving them a shitload of playoff money before they drop?


I am not saying that it's easy for a team that is gutted to get up and running.. but with luck your system fixes that. I do not think it's fair that you pull the funds (the reward) from teams that bust ass to get home games in the playoffs.

We (after this change) Will all have stared this game at the same lev.. I know the gutted team owners got screwed. but again I said after this change... We are all starting with the same chances..

When i got my yeam 4 GMs and I sat on MSN recruiting it.. Damm right we built a great team IMO. then we spent the time to get those players building into a team plan. If we Earn a playoff game for all that work... why should we get Taxed because some basement team has no idea how to recruit, build or play.. I

I hear the "rich get richer crap" truth is good teams get better! We are far from rich were fighting to get our guys lev 32 gear same as everyone else at our lev.. How d we do that? we win playoff games. Now you guys want to water that down..

Teams that play well, build well and plan well should not be punished.... they should be applauded for hanging in there together.. We have not asked for hand outs. we earned every $ we got from hard work....

and an FYI the NFL has TV rev sharing _GLB does not have tv contracts. we all have the same fan base. (win and it grows, lose and it falls) with the gutted teams gone all new owners will start even. .. there is no need for this IMO




I still don't understand the outrage over this idea after reading your post. You act as if only the top 4 teams are busting their asses to make the playoffs and get a home playoff game.. Thats simply not the case. What about the 5-8 seeds who busted their ass just to get into the playoffs? You think 100k is fair?? Cmon get real. You can't take in 2.5 mil for a home playoff game while your opponent gets 100k and tell me thats fair! Especially for a 4 seed hosting a 5 seed. The ideas I've seen are trying to NOT take cash away from the home seeds. They are trying to add new revenue in to share so you will likely in fact either make the same cash or more. Even if they don't do that, the 1-4 seeds will still get the lionshare of the revenue. You see it all day long GLB forums, people bitching about competition and gutted teams ruining their leagues. This helps out those teams who are struggling to keep pace with the top 4 teams. Now they at least get something more than 100k or 200k if they make the second round of the playoffs. I say DO IT! Its a great idea and brings a lot of needed equity to the whole playoff revenue issue!


I think the fair way would be to leave the home revenue untouched, and just up the playoff bonuses. I think 100000 is fair, but if you up it to 200000 and double up each one than that is plenty, and if you can't work with that then you get what you deserve.


I'd be fine with that as well. I just don't understand how some are bitching about this just because someone else is getting money finally.. Its like they WANT the rest of their league to go broke and be less competetive...


They are less competitive because they failed! All of us had to recruit, cover salary, and get quality owner's to work with us on our goal. You failed, and probably went after higher levels to be competitive and in turn shot yourself in the foot, so kudos to you! EVERYONE STARTS OFF THE SAME! Except those who inherit a gutted team, which is a douchebag move to do in the first place. If the team gets sold, delete it, give the player's F/A, and give owner's a fair shot at winning!



Failed?? WTF are you talking about? Did the Cleveland Browns fail? They didn't make the playoffs last year? Yet I see they are still playing games this season. Get real dude. If you can't understand how this is fair for all then you just will never get it. Do you honestly believe that team #5 getting 100k and team 4 getting 2.5 mill is REALLY fair?? Many times they have the exact same record and goes down to a tiebreaker. Should that really cost 2.4 million dollars to the #5 team? Are you opposed to leveling the playing field for the good of the league?? Sounds like it to me. All I am saying is that the current playoff payouts are WAY too good for the 1-4 teams and way too harsh on 5-8.

OH and FYI, I DID get a gutted team and yes I am building it to be competetive. I am not one to be complacent with losing. My team will be just fine and we really dont care what your opinion about it is!
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 10:24:57
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Groucho
How about this idea:

If the visiting team wants to get ticket sales for the playoff game, no problem. They can build expansions to the home team's stadium. Ticket prices in those expansions are set by the visiting team, and they get all proceeds from the sales as well. Home team gets all concessions, and (of course) gets to keep the expansions.

Win/Win.


Moronic/Moronic
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by Chief Bootnaka

Originally posted by Crushr


Originally posted by geturembedder



Originally posted by Crushr




Originally posted by Toric





Rev sharing just makes Zero sense to me..

i bust my ass finding the best staff and the best players. We spend seasons fixing builds and getting the team ready to win..

Hrs and hrs of work... Damm right we get to the home playoff games. but it was EARNED..

With the new promotion system the playoffs have little enough to offer. Come now the pretty cup was always cool but earning the promote, that was the real prize! I do understand why that needs to change.. However taking the money away for home playoff games is yet another shot at the teams that take the game for real, work hard and put the real time in that this game takes...

with the new system of teams dropping there is simply not going to be a huge need for this anyway. your killing the stadiums re starting them as capped teams.. whats the point of giving them a shitload of playoff money before they drop?


I am not saying that it's easy for a team that is gutted to get up and running.. but with luck your system fixes that. I do not think it's fair that you pull the funds (the reward) from teams that bust ass to get home games in the playoffs.

We (after this change) Will all have stared this game at the same lev.. I know the gutted team owners got screwed. but again I said after this change... We are all starting with the same chances..

When i got my yeam 4 GMs and I sat on MSN recruiting it.. Damm right we built a great team IMO. then we spent the time to get those players building into a team plan. If we Earn a playoff game for all that work... why should we get Taxed because some basement team has no idea how to recruit, build or play.. I

I hear the "rich get richer crap" truth is good teams get better! We are far from rich were fighting to get our guys lev 32 gear same as everyone else at our lev.. How d we do that? we win playoff games. Now you guys want to water that down..

Teams that play well, build well and plan well should not be punished.... they should be applauded for hanging in there together.. We have not asked for hand outs. we earned every $ we got from hard work....

and an FYI the NFL has TV rev sharing _GLB does not have tv contracts. we all have the same fan base. (win and it grows, lose and it falls) with the gutted teams gone all new owners will start even. .. there is no need for this IMO




I still don't understand the outrage over this idea after reading your post. You act as if only the top 4 teams are busting their asses to make the playoffs and get a home playoff game.. Thats simply not the case. What about the 5-8 seeds who busted their ass just to get into the playoffs? You think 100k is fair?? Cmon get real. You can't take in 2.5 mil for a home playoff game while your opponent gets 100k and tell me thats fair! Especially for a 4 seed hosting a 5 seed. The ideas I've seen are trying to NOT take cash away from the home seeds. They are trying to add new revenue in to share so you will likely in fact either make the same cash or more. Even if they don't do that, the 1-4 seeds will still get the lionshare of the revenue. You see it all day long GLB forums, people bitching about competition and gutted teams ruining their leagues. This helps out those teams who are struggling to keep pace with the top 4 teams. Now they at least get something more than 100k or 200k if they make the second round of the playoffs. I say DO IT! Its a great idea and brings a lot of needed equity to the whole playoff revenue issue!


I think the fair way would be to leave the home revenue untouched, and just up the playoff bonuses. I think 100000 is fair, but if you up it to 200000 and double up each one than that is plenty, and if you can't work with that then you get what you deserve.


I'd be fine with that as well. I just don't understand how some are bitching about this just because someone else is getting money finally.. Its like they WANT the rest of their league to go broke and be less competetive...


They are less competitive because they failed! All of us had to recruit, cover salary, and get quality owner's to work with us on our goal. You failed, and probably went after higher levels to be competitive and in turn shot yourself in the foot, so kudos to you! EVERYONE STARTS OFF THE SAME! Except those who inherit a gutted team, which is a douchebag move to do in the first place. If the team gets sold, delete it, give the player's F/A, and give owner's a fair shot at winning!



Failed?? WTF are you talking about? Did the Cleveland Browns fail? They didn't make the playoffs last year? Yet I see they are still playing games this season. Get real dude. If you can't understand how this is fair for all then you just will never get it. Do you honestly believe that team #5 getting 100k and team 4 getting 2.5 mill is REALLY fair?? Many times they have the exact same record and goes down to a tiebreaker. Should that really cost 2.4 million dollars to the #5 team? Are you opposed to leveling the playing field for the good of the league?? Sounds like it to me. All I am saying is that the current playoff payouts are WAY tooood for the 1-4 teams and way to0harsh on 5-8.

OH and FYI, I DID get a gutted team and yes I am building it to be competetive. I am not one to be complacent with losing. My team will be just fine and we really dont care what your opinion about it is!


What is fair is that everyone knows what's at stake between 4th and 5th, and the 4th place team earned it by making the 4th seed, the 5th place team, well they failed in making the top four. Just like the 9th team failed to make the top 8 and be in the playoffs, the 5th team failed to make the top 4 and have the opportunity for a big payday.
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 10:29:29
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by Chief Bootnaka

Originally posted by Crushr


Originally posted by geturembedder



Originally posted by Crushr




Originally posted by Toric





Rev sharing just makes Zero sense to me..

i bust my ass finding the best staff and the best players. We spend seasons fixing builds and getting the team ready to win..

Hrs and hrs of work... Damm right we get to the home playoff games. but it was EARNED..

With the new promotion system the playoffs have little enough to offer. Come now the pretty cup was always cool but earning the promote, that was the real prize! I do understand why that needs to change.. However taking the money away for home playoff games is yet another shot at the teams that take the game for real, work hard and put the real time in that this game takes...

with the new system of teams dropping there is simply not going to be a huge need for this anyway. your killing the stadiums re starting them as capped teams.. whats the point of giving them a shitload of playoff money before they drop?


I am not saying that it's easy for a team that is gutted to get up and running.. but with luck your system fixes that. I do not think it's fair that you pull the funds (the reward) from teams that bust ass to get home games in the playoffs.

We (after this change) Will all have stared this game at the same lev.. I know the gutted team owners got screwed. but again I said after this change... We are all starting with the same chances..

When i got my yeam 4 GMs and I sat on MSN recruiting it.. Damm right we built a great team IMO. then we spent the time to get those players building into a team plan. If we Earn a playoff game for all that work... why should we get Taxed because some basement team has no idea how to recruit, build or play.. I

I hear the "rich get richer crap" truth is good teams get better! We are far from rich were fighting to get our guys lev 32 gear same as everyone else at our lev.. How d we do that? we win playoff games. Now you guys want to water that down..

Teams that play well, build well and plan well should not be punished.... they should be applauded for hanging in there together.. We have not asked for hand outs. we earned every $ we got from hard work....

and an FYI the NFL has TV rev sharing _GLB does not have tv contracts. we all have the same fan base. (win and it grows, lose and it falls) with the gutted teams gone all new owners will start even. .. there is no need for this IMO




I still don't understand the outrage over this idea after reading your post. You act as if only the top 4 teams are busting their asses to make the playoffs and get a home playoff game.. Thats simply not the case. What about the 5-8 seeds who busted their ass just to get into the playoffs? You think 100k is fair?? Cmon get real. You can't take in 2.5 mil for a home playoff game while your opponent gets 100k and tell me thats fair! Especially for a 4 seed hosting a 5 seed. The ideas I've seen are trying to NOT take cash away from the home seeds. They are trying to add new revenue in to share so you will likely in fact either make the same cash or more. Even if they don't do that, the 1-4 seeds will still get the lionshare of the revenue. You see it all day long GLB forums, people bitching about competition and gutted teams ruining their leagues. This helps out those teams who are struggling to keep pace with the top 4 teams. Now they at least get something more than 100k or 200k if they make the second round of the playoffs. I say DO IT! Its a great idea and brings a lot of needed equity to the whole playoff revenue issue!


I think the fair way would be to leave the home revenue untouched, and just up the playoff bonuses. I think 100000 is fair, but if you up it to 200000 and double up each one than that is plenty, and if you can't work with that then you get what you deserve.


I'd be fine with that as well. I just don't understand how some are bitching about this just because someone else is getting money finally.. Its like they WANT the rest of their league to go broke and be less competetive...


They are less competitive because they failed! All of us had to recruit, cover salary, and get quality owner's to work with us on our goal. You failed, and probably went after higher levels to be competitive and in turn shot yourself in the foot, so kudos to you! EVERYONE STARTS OFF THE SAME! Except those who inherit a gutted team, which is a douchebag move to do in the first place. If the team gets sold, delete it, give the player's F/A, and give owner's a fair shot at winning!



Failed?? WTF are you talking about? Did the Cleveland Browns fail? They didn't make the playoffs last year? Yet I see they are still playing games this season. Get real dude. If you can't understand how this is fair for all then you just will never get it. Do you honestly believe that team #5 getting 100k and team 4 getting 2.5 mill is REALLY fair?? Many times they have the exact same record and goes down to a tiebreaker. Should that really cost 2.4 million dollars to the #5 team? Are you opposed to leveling the playing field for the good of the league?? Sounds like it to me. All I am saying is that the current playoff payouts are WAY too good for the 1-4 teams and way too harsh on 5-8.

OH and FYI, I DID get a gutted team and yes I am building it to be competetive. I am not one to be complacent with losing. My team will be just fine and we really dont care what your opinion about it is!


What I am saying is that first it sucks that you got a gutted team, that I feel is one of the injustices of the game.

Second, we were a #6 seed last year, and we had to work harder to get to the next round, and we did beat the #3 seed, but we weren't upset that the better teams got more money, we just set our goals towards being in that top 4 at the end of the season.

Third, I am against free handouts, whether in this game or in life, hard work generates character, and success.

SUCCESS ONLY COMES BEFORE WORK IN THE DICTIONARY!
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Seems like a lot of us are getting tripped up on what we DO agree on and what we DON'T agree on.

I think there's general consensus that 5-8 really should get MUCH better compensation for making the playoffs. The question we disagree on is HOW to get that money to them.

One group argues for revenue sharing, i.e. taking away money that in the past went to the 1-4 seeds in order to make things "fairer." This brings the playoff teams closer together in terms of revenue collected from the playoffs, but leaves the higher seeds with much less than they expected. The previous poster who cited a 10% share to the lower seeds is (IMO) a little naive. If $100k-$200k isn't a drop in the bucket, $500k (10% of $5M) isn't really a whole lot better in game terms when equipment upgrades are on the order of $800k/player. OTOH, a 25% drop in revenue is easily over $1M and quite possibly robs the higher seed of a stadium upgrade.

The flaw in this argument is the assumption that there is a finite pool of playoff money that has to be divvied up. That's not true. Bort has shown openness to the idea by having suggested the Jumbotron option himself (http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1141616&page=7).

I think a far fairer way to address the needs of the 5-8 teams is to give them an alternate revenue source to close the gap with the 1-4's, such as the Jumbotron. This way teams that are in the 1-4 seed that have been planning ahead (and yes, teams do plan 2-3 seasons ahead--I do it and I don't consider my team anywhere NEAR the upper echelon of GLB so I'm sure MANY others do it as well) don't get penalized--they get roughly the playoff revenue they estimated. The 5-8's don't get shafter because they can pick up quite a bit MORE money than a paltry 10-15% cut of $5M by concessions sales w/ or w/o reduced price ticket sales, depending on what Bort sees fit to allow tickets to be sold for. Now the best teams get the rewards they expected, the 5-8 have much more money than they would have with revenue sharing, and teams that are 9-16 have a MAJOR incentive to get that last playoff spot.

I just don't see what the objection is to this last proposal except that there are those who feel a need to PUNISH those evil higher seeds. We need to figure out if our priority is to hurt the teams at the top or get some help to the 5-8 teams. I'd vote for the latter.
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 10:35:12
 
Link
 
I have over 100 mil in total team assets right now. I could give that entire amount (were it possible) to another team and they wouldn't be closer to me competitively.

Until Bort rolls out the new stuff to use GLBucks for, this is all fluff.

Of course, it's useful fluff as it dips our collective toes in the "profit sharing" kiddie pool, so when 50-50 hits, a group can say "Well, we've already got 75-50, what's a little more".
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chief Bootnaka
Originally posted by tmoon

One of the "fun" dilemas of the game is deciding to boost your team early which means a possible early exit from the playoffs or boost your team late which means advancement in the playoffs but no home field games. Its a choice that is being again taken away... who needs to win home field for the revenue if there is not a reward. If I can set in a league and make no effort with my team and make the playoffs (not hard to do) and get massive revenue why do I even need to try during the regular season. The people who always complain about revenue sharing are the people that can't win, will never win, don't know how to win... Your all like a bunch of government check collectors... GIVE ME MONEY FOR DOING NOTHING!!!


+1000


100% WRONG!!! First, you think that every owner who makes the playoffs as a 5-8 seed didn't bust their asses to build their team?? Thats not only ridiculous its down right Offensive! That attitude shows no respect for what it takes to build a team. I have over the last 2 1/2 seasons put in more hours on GLB forums etc than I have at work!! Yet we are just now seeing the benefits. So tell me, how is that not busting your ass? Get over the superiority complex and realize that this is the right thing to do. You seem like the type who simply wants to nix this so that you keep the rest of your league down because thats the only logical explanation for opposing this. And the idea is to ADD ADDITIONAL revenues outside of ticket sales so that no one takes your 'precious'home game revenue.
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 10:35:57
 
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by Crushr

Originally posted by Chief Bootnaka


Originally posted by Crushr



Originally posted by geturembedder




Originally posted by Crushr





Originally posted by Toric






Rev sharing just makes Zero sense to me..

i bust my ass finding the best staff and the best players. We spend seasons fixing builds and getting the team ready to win..

Hrs and hrs of work... Damm right we get to the home playoff games. but it was EARNED..

With the new promotion system the playoffs have little enough to offer. Come now the pretty cup was always cool but earning the promote, that was the real prize! I do understand why that needs to change.. However taking the money away for home playoff games is yet another shot at the teams that take the game for real, work hard and put the real time in that this game takes...

with the new system of teams dropping there is simply not going to be a huge need for this anyway. your killing the stadiums re starting them as capped teams.. whats the point of giving them a shitload of playoff money before they drop?


I am not saying that it's easy for a team that is gutted to get up and running.. but with luck your system fixes that. I do not think it's fair that you pull the funds (the reward) from teams that bust ass to get home games in the playoffs.

We (after this change) Will all have stared this game at the same lev.. I know the gutted team owners got screwed. but again I said after this change... We are all starting with the same chances..

When i got my yeam 4 GMs and I sat on MSN recruiting it.. Damm right we built a great team IMO. then we spent the time to get those players building into a team plan. If we Earn a playoff game for all that work... why should we get Taxed because some basement team has no idea how to recruit, build or play.. I

I hear the "rich get richer crap" truth is good teams get better! We are far from rich were fighting to get our guys lev 32 gear same as everyone else at our lev.. How d we do that? we win playoff games. Now you guys want to water that down..

Teams that play well, build well and plan well should not be punished.... they should be applauded for hanging in there together.. We have not asked for hand outs. we earned every $ we got from hard work....

and an FYI the NFL has TV rev sharing _GLB does not have tv contracts. we all have the same fan base. (win and it grows, lose and it falls) with the gutted teams gone all new owners will start even. .. there is no need for this IMO




I still don't understand the outrage over this idea after reading your post. You act as if only the top 4 teams are busting their asses to make the playoffs and get a home playoff game.. Thats simply not the case. What about the 5-8 seeds who busted their ass just to get into the playoffs? You think 100k is fair?? Cmon get real. You can't take in 2.5 mil for a home playoff game while your opponent gets 100k and tell me thats fair! Especially for a 4 seed hosting a 5 seed. The ideas I've seen are trying to NOT take cash away from the home seeds. They are trying to add new revenue in to share so you will likely in fact either make the same cash or more. Even if they don't do that, the 1-4 seeds will still get the lionshare of the revenue. You see it all day long GLB forums, people bitching about competition and gutted teams ruining their leagues. This helps out those teams who are struggling to keep pace with the top 4 teams. Now they at least get something more than 100k or 200k if they make the second round of the playoffs. I say DO IT! Its a great idea and brings a lot of needed equity to the whole playoff revenue issue!


I think the fair way would be to leave the home revenue untouched, and just up the playoff bonuses. I think 100000 is fair, but if you up it to 200000 and double up each one than that is plenty, and if you can't work with that then you get what you deserve.


I'd be fine with that as well. I just don't understand how some are bitching about this just because someone else is getting money finally.. Its like they WANT the rest of their league to go broke and be less competetive...


They are less competitive because they failed! All of us had to recruit, cover salary, and get quality owner's to work with us on our goal. You failed, and probably went after higher levels to be competitive and in turn shot yourself in the foot, so kudos to you! EVERYONE STARTS OFF THE SAME! Except those who inherit a gutted team, which is a douchebag move to do in the first place. If the team gets sold, delete it, give the player's F/A, and give owner's a fair shot at winning!



Failed?? WTF are you talking about? Did the Cleveland Browns fail? They didn't make the playoffs last year? Yet I see they are still playing games this season. Get real dude. If you can't understand how this is fair for all then you just will never get it. Do you honestly believe that team #5 getting 100k and team 4 getting 2.5 mill is REALLY fair?? Many times they have the exact same record and goes down to a tiebreaker. Should that really cost 2.4 million dollars to the #5 team? Are you opposed to leveling the playing field for the good of the league?? Sounds like it to me. All I am saying is that the current playoff payouts are WAY tooood for the 1-4 teams and way to0harsh on 5-8.

OH and FYI, I DID get a gutted team and yes I am building it to be competetive. I am not one to be complacent with losing. My team will be just fine and we really dont care what your opinion about it is!


What is fair is that everyone knows what's at stake between 4th and 5th, and the 4th place team earned it by making the 4th seed, the 5th place team, well they failed in making the top four. Just like the 9th team failed to make the top 8 and be in the playoffs, the 5th team failed to make the top 4 and have the opportunity for a big payday.


I think that you should have won more games so that you don't have to get yourself on the fringe, and if my team gets the #5 seed this year, guess what, WE WILL TRY HARDER, not cry and complain about it's unfair that we don't get it. How about this, get good owner's, try to get good builds, and the coordinators thing works too, and maybe trying to implement some AI so that you win, and you will be in the Top 4 if you aren't, then try harder, it is a game not real life, and in other top games I don't think they have level up or kill total sharing!
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chief Bootnaka
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by Crushr


Originally posted by Chief Bootnaka



Originally posted by Crushr




Originally posted by geturembedder





Originally posted by Crushr






Originally posted by Toric







Rev sharing just makes Zero sense to me..

i bust my ass finding the best staff and the best players. We spend seasons fixing builds and getting the team ready to win..

Hrs and hrs of work... Damm right we get to the home playoff games. but it was EARNED..

With the new promotion system the playoffs have little enough to offer. Come now the pretty cup was always cool but earning the promote, that was the real prize! I do understand why that needs to change.. However taking the money away for home playoff games is yet another shot at the teams that take the game for real, work hard and put the real time in that this game takes...

with the new system of teams dropping there is simply not going to be a huge need for this anyway. your killing the stadiums re starting them as capped teams.. whats the point of giving them a shitload of playoff money before they drop?


I am not saying that it's easy for a team that is gutted to get up and running.. but with luck your system fixes that. I do not think it's fair that you pull the funds (the reward) from teams that bust ass to get home games in the playoffs.

We (after this change) Will all have stared this game at the same lev.. I know the gutted team owners got screwed. but again I said after this change... We are all starting with the same chances..

When i got my yeam 4 GMs and I sat on MSN recruiting it.. Damm right we built a great team IMO. then we spent the time to get those players building into a team plan. If we Earn a playoff game for all that work... why should we get Taxed because some basement team has no idea how to recruit, build or play.. I

I hear the "rich get richer crap" truth is good teams get better! We are far from rich were fighting to get our guys lev 32 gear same as everyone else at our lev.. How d we do that? we win playoff games. Now you guys want to water that down..

Teams that play well, build well and plan well should not be punished.... they should be applauded for hanging in there together.. We have not asked for hand outs. we earned every $ we got from hard work....

and an FYI the NFL has TV rev sharing _GLB does not have tv contracts. we all have the same fan base. (win and it grows, lose and it falls) with the gutted teams gone all new owners will start even. .. there is no need for this IMO




I still don't understand the outrage over this idea after reading your post. You act as if only the top 4 teams are busting their asses to make the playoffs and get a home playoff game.. Thats simply not the case. What about the 5-8 seeds who busted their ass just to get into the playoffs? You think 100k is fair?? Cmon get real. You can't take in 2.5 mil for a home playoff game while your opponent gets 100k and tell me thats fair! Especially for a 4 seed hosting a 5 seed. The ideas I've seen are trying to NOT take cash away from the home seeds. They are trying to add new revenue in to share so you will likely in fact either make the same cash or more. Even if they don't do that, the 1-4 seeds will still get the lionshare of the revenue. You see it all day long GLB forums, people bitching about competition and gutted teams ruining their leagues. This helps out those teams who are struggling to keep pace with the top 4 teams. Now they at least get something more than 100k or 200k if they make the second round of the playoffs. I say DO IT! Its a great idea and brings a lot of needed equity to the whole playoff revenue issue!


I think the fair way would be to leave the home revenue untouched, and just up the playoff bonuses. I think 100000 is fair, but if you up it to 200000 and double up each one than that is plenty, and if you can't work with that then you get what you deserve.


I'd be fine with that as well. I just don't understand how some are bitching about this just because someone else is getting money finally.. Its like they WANT the rest of their league to go broke and be less competetive...


They are less competitive because they failed! All of us had to recruit, cover salary, and get quality owner's to work with us on our goal. You failed, and probably went after higher levels to be competitive and in turn shot yourself in the foot, so kudos to you! EVERYONE STARTS OFF THE SAME! Except those who inherit a gutted team, which is a douchebag move to do in the first place. If the team gets sold, delete it, give the player's F/A, and give owner's a fair shot at winning!



Failed?? WTF are you talking about? Did the Cleveland Browns fail? They didn't make the playoffs last year? Yet I see they are still playing games this season. Get real dude. If you can't understand how this is fair for all then you just will never get it. Do you honestly believe that team #5 getting 100k and team 4 getting 2.5 mill is REALLY fair?? Many times they have the exact same record and goes down to a tiebreaker. Should that really cost 2.4 million dollars to the #5 team? Are you opposed to leveling the playing field for the good of the league?? Sounds like it to me. All I am saying is that the current playoff payouts are WAY tooood for the 1-4 teams and way to0harsh on 5-8.

OH and FYI, I DID get a gutted team and yes I am building it to be competetive. I am not one to be complacent with losing. My team will be just fine and we really dont care what your opinion about it is!


What is fair is that everyone knows what's at stake between 4th and 5th, and the 4th place team earned it by making the 4th seed, the 5th place team, well they failed in making the top four. Just like the 9th team failed to make the top 8 and be in the playoffs, the 5th team failed to make the top 4 and have the opportunity for a big payday.


I think that you should have won more games so that you don't have to get yourself on the fringe, and if my team gets the #5 seed this year, guess what, WE WILL TRY HARDER, not cry and complain about it's unfair that we don't get it. How about this, get good owner's, try to get good builds, and the coordinators thing works too, and maybe trying to implement some AI so that you win, and you will be in the Top 4 if you aren't, then try harder, it is a game not real life, and in other top games I don't think they have level up or kill total sharing!


The problem here is that you are only looking at this under the premise that you lose revenue. Are you opposed to this even if you DON'T lose revenue? How about if the revenue came from TV rights or team gear sales?? Is that acceptable? I mean this way 1-4 lose NO money and 5-8 get a FAIR reward for making the playoffs right?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by Chief Bootnaka

Originally posted by tmoon


One of the "fun" dilemas of the game is deciding to boost your team early which means a possible early exit from the playoffs or boost your team late which means advancement in the playoffs but no home field games. Its a choice that is being again taken away... who needs to win home field for the revenue if there is not a reward. If I can set in a league and make no effort with my team and make the playoffs (not hard to do) and get massive revenue why do I even need to try during the regular season. The people who always complain about revenue sharing are the people that can't win, will never win, don't know how to win... Your all like a bunch of government check collectors... GIVE ME MONEY FOR DOING NOTHING!!!


+1000


100% WRONG!!! First, you think that every owner who makes the playoffs as a 5-8 seed didn't bust their asses to build their team?? Thats not only ridiculous its down right Offensive! That attitude shows no respect for what it takes to build a team. I have over the last 2 1/2 put in more hours on GLB forums etc than I have at work!! Yet we are just now seeing the benefits. So tell me, how is that not busting your ass? Get over the superiority complex and realize that this is the right thing to do. You seem like the type who simply wants to nix this so that you keep the rest of your league down because thats the only logical explanation for opposing this. And the idea is to ADD ADDITIONAL revenues outside of ticket sales so that no one takes your 'precious'home game revenue.


I think you are thinking that we are against this so that we can keep other teams down, but the big thing is, you got slighted by getting a gutted team, BUT EVERYONE in my League got new teams, and we all had to recruit, sign, build and so on, so YES I am against giving the slacker's money that the teams have earned that make the TOP 4, you are in a totally different situation, and maybe they should address that for previously gutted teams, but I am against having to give money to teams in our division that DIDN'T put in the days and days, and sleepless nights to have a productive team.

I didn't start with a roster, and every person that I have on the roster was recruited when there was noone to recruit, and because the other teams didn't want to put in the hard work and time, they should receive some sort of favor, bullshiza!
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
*sighs*

This is starting to bore me.

I'll admit that 1-4 make too much money and should be willing to give some of it up (even if its me, I HOPE) but some of the other owners with their hands out waiting for MY money need to admit that they have made poor economic decisions, that their cash shortages result from a failed "win now" orientation, and that they overpaid for FAs that didn't produce to expectations.

GLB is the such a level playing field.

What do I mean? I mean that all that separates any team from any team is a few seasons of winning. Not enough money? Win more, build stadium. Can't recruit? Win more, and FAs will beg you for a spot on your team (I have personally received 2 random PMs asking for WR spots on my team this season).

I would be in favor of a 50-50 split if I could get 2 guarantees:

#1 Recipients would be forced to use the money ONLY on stadium upgrades.
#2 Recipients would be required to stop bitching and moaning about economic inequality in GLB.

Thanks!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Knightman
Seems like a lot of us are getting tripped up on what we DO agree on and what we DON'T agree on.

I think there's general consensus that 5-8 really should get MUCH better compensation for making the playoffs. The question we disagree on is HOW to get that money to them.

One group argues for revenue sharing, i.e. taking away money that in the past went to the 1-4 seeds in order to make things "fairer." This brings the playoff teams closer together in terms of revenue collected from the playoffs, but leaves the higher seeds with much less than they expected. The previous poster who cited a 10% share to the lower seeds is (IMO) a little naive. If $100k-$200k isn't a drop in the bucket, $500k (10% of $5M) isn't really a whole lot better in game terms when equipment upgrades are on the order of $800k/player. OTOH, a 25% drop in revenue is easily over $1M and quite possibly robs the higher seed of a stadium upgrade.

The flaw in this argument is the assumption that there is a finite pool of playoff money that has to be divvied up. That's not true. Bort has shown openness to the idea by having suggested the Jumbotron option himself (http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1141616&page=7).

I think a far fairer way to address the needs of the 5-8 teams is to give them an alternate revenue source to close the gap with the 1-4's, such as the Jumbotron. This way teams that are in the 1-4 seed that have been planning ahead (and yes, teams do plan 2-3 seasons ahead--I do it and I don't consider my team anywhere NEAR the upper echelon of GLB so I'm sure MANY others do it as well) don't get penalized--they get roughly the playoff revenue they estimated. The 5-8's don't get shafter because they can pick up quite a bit MORE money than a paltry 10-15% cut of $5M by concessions sales w/ or w/o reduced price ticket sales, depending on what Bort sees fit to allow tickets to be sold for. Now the best teams get the rewards they expected, the 5-8 have much more money than they would have with revenue sharing, and teams that are 9-16 have a MAJOR incentive to get that last playoff spot.

I just don't see what the objection is to this last proposal except that there are those who feel a need to PUNISH those evil higher seeds. We need to figure out if our priority is to hurt the teams at the top or get some help to the 5-8 teams. I'd vote for the latter.


I think you are right, and maybe the person/person's that suggested it, give revenue to the teams that are in the 5-8 out of general funds not out of the dedicated owner's pocket's who have striven to be more successful, but how and why are always going to come into question.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
*sighs*

This is starting to bore me.

I'll admit that 1-4 make too much money and should be willing to give some of it up (even if its me, I HOPE) but some of the other owners with their hands out waiting for MY money need to admit that they have made poor economic decisions, that their cash shortages result from a failed "win now" orientation, and that they overpaid for FAs that didn't produce to expectations.

GLB is the such a level playing field.

What do I mean? I mean that all that separates any team from any team is a few seasons of winning. Not enough money? Win more, build stadium. Can't recruit? Win more, and FAs will beg you for a spot on your team (I have personally received 2 random PMs asking for WR spots on my team this season).

I would be in favor of a 50-50 split if I could get 2 guarantees:

#1 Recipients would be forced to use the money ONLY on stadium upgrades.
#2 Recipients would be required to stop bitching and moaning about economic inequality in GLB.

Thanks!


I like this. I'd actually be in favor of only 1 condition: A public act of contrition when people realize that money doesn't make them any more competitive.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.