Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
i'm not saying i know much about the code at all, but here are possible reasons why these happened:
Originally posted by RAPB
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=168389&pbp_id=8627995 the FS is trying to tackle the carrier without being in the SS's way. the circle is caused by "i dont want to hit my SS causing both pursuers to go down" logic.Watch closer: the FS takes off at a right angle (towards the corner of the endzone), but then suddenly goes into the circle motion. As he does, the SS is still blocked by the SS.
Besides that: have you ever seen the "avoid teammate" motions in GLB? They look different. VERY different: one guy totally stops (usually the faster one), makes a sidestep and accelerates again.
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
Originally posted by RAPB
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=160572&pbp_id=8806150QB threw while FS had to make a vision check (do i go after the cross or the corner)Watch the play again. The FS already finished his vision check and keeps in the "perfect position" - at least what GLB understands as such. He's staying exactly in the middle between WR1 and WR3.
Hit pause and FF on the replay. You'll see him moving very little the 2 ticks before the ball is thrown; but he's moving sidewards to the inside. That doesn't make sense if he's playing the WR1 nor the WR3.
That's one of the issues I'd like to adress: the position the FS is ordered doesn't allow him to do anything:
- he's not there to deflect
- he's not in a position to intercept
- he lets a WR get deeper than him, so unless he's way faster, he's not able to tackle
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
Originally posted by RAPB
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=160572&pbp_id=8806159CB was playing tight as if for the INT; FS was playing over-the-top Tampa 2 to make the tackle if the CB failed.I wouldn't report it if the FS actually played over the top - but he doesn't! He's playing about 5 yards inside the WR - a position giving him a longer way towards the guy no matter what happens.
But - what a surprise! - the lateral position is pretty much exactly the middle between the lateral positions of WR1 and WR3 (only WR 1 is about 15 yards downfield).
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
Originally posted by RAPB
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=146248&pbp_id=8919504FS released to CB who shouldve made the deflection. again FS saw it was CB assignment and let off. had the QB not thrown that split second, the FS would be backpedaling to get a tackling angle in case the CB would fail.So how does that make sense?
A FS releasing the (only) deep going WR
to head towards the inside? And putting himself at the same yardline as the WR - but 4 yards away? How's that EVER a good idea? Shouldn't the FS - if releasing the WR - stay deeper than the WR and over his top?
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
again these are all just my opinions on how the code might have run that particular roll. nothing as to whether this is right, wrong or fair. just what the code might have said.You may be right, but for the reasons stated above I consider this an issue that needs serious work. Maybe it's too much to ask to have the "last line of defense" really playing "last line" (= always staying deeper / heading deep first) - but I will keep asking.