User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by joeflex73
I didnt mind the old way, adding the new training way was fine, but the bars didn't have to be added at all. I liked seeing improvement in players every night.

I don't think anything has to be done...but for the sake of those with OCD or whatever, round everything UP to the nearest integer, no one gets worse and the decimals disappear.


Horrible Idea.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
wow... step away from GLB for a bit and this thread goes to nine pages. i scanned through it and there seemed to be some discussion about how the new training is okay because it effects everyone equally. untrue. here's why:

while no one is exempt from the new delays and inefficiencies of training, it disproportionately affects higher level players. lower level players get approximately +50%/day on normal training, so they can realize the effects of their training roughly every other day.

but higher level players are more in the neighborhood of +5%/day... which means they have to train for half a season before they finally get the benefit of having trained. and yes, even fully softcapped L32 could probably find a better return somewhere, but that's still missing the point.

cliff notes: the new training system is needlessly complex and arbitrarily punishes higher-level players.
 
dkgojackets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
Originally posted by joeflex73

I didnt mind the old way, adding the new training way was fine, but the bars didn't have to be added at all. I liked seeing improvement in players every night.

I don't think anything has to be done...but for the sake of those with OCD or whatever, round everything UP to the nearest integer, no one gets worse and the decimals disappear.


Horrible Idea.


 
dkgojackets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
wow... step away from GLB for a bit and this thread goes to nine pages. i scanned through it and there seemed to be some discussion about how the new training is okay because it effects everyone equally. untrue. here's why:

while no one is exempt from the new delays and inefficiencies of training, it disproportionately affects higher level players. lower level players get approximately +50%/day on normal training, so they can realize the effects of their training roughly every other day.

but higher level players are more in the neighborhood of +5%/day... which means they have to train for half a season before they finally get the benefit of having trained. and yes, even fully softcapped L32 could probably find a better return somewhere, but that's still missing the point.

cliff notes: the new training system is needlessly complex and arbitrarily punishes higher-level players.


+5% a day? Are you at 65 base in everything?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dkgojackets
+5% a day? Are you at 65 base in everything?


well, i wasn't just talking about my players... but yeah, 74.07 base on this one:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=777081

disclaimers:
- yes, i'll obviously be bringing up his str/vis first... but when it comes time to work punting and get 7-8x returns, i'll probably have to wait a season to see that effect.
- yes, the difference between 98pnt and 99pnt is negligible... but that's not the point.
 
tordman
offline
Link
 
Don't take away my .99 points.

It would make me angry. And you wouldn't like me when I'm angry.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tordman
Don't take away my .99 points.
It would make me angry. And you wouldn't like me when I'm angry.


how about you keep those .99 points but then also get your 99% included in sim calculations?
 
emdude
offline
Link
 
I think either one of two things should happen:

1. Add any numbers after the decimal point to the training bar progress percentage of that particular skill. (e.g. If you have 48.60 in a skill and 20% on your training progress, you now would have 48 in the skill and 80% on training progress.) Automatic skill points would now be added to the training bar percentage of the skill in order to keep the skill values at whole numbers only.

OR...

2. Add any training bar percentage values to the actual skill point values and do away with the training bars. (e.g.- if you have 48.60 in a skill and 20% of that skill's training progress filled, you now would have 48.80 in that skill and no training bar)

Either way would solve all complaints.
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
wow... step away from GLB for a bit and this thread goes to nine pages. i scanned through it and there seemed to be some discussion about how the new training is okay because it effects everyone equally. untrue. here's why:

while no one is exempt from the new delays and inefficiencies of training, it disproportionately affects higher level players. lower level players get approximately +50%/day on normal training, so they can realize the effects of their training roughly every other day.

but higher level players are more in the neighborhood of +5%/day... which means they have to train for half a season before they finally get the benefit of having trained. and yes, even fully softcapped L32 could probably find a better return somewhere, but that's still missing the point.

cliff notes: the new training system is needlessly complex and arbitrarily punishes higher-level players.


The training has always worked so that stronger attributes are harder to increase. That's the way it should be.
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by emdude
I think either one of two things should happen:

1. Add any numbers after the decimal point to the training bar progress percentage of that particular skill. (e.g. If you have 48.60 in a skill and 20% on your training progress, you now would have 48 in the skill and 80% on training progress.) Automatic skill points would now be added to the training bar percentage of the skill in order to keep the skill values at whole numbers only.

OR...

2. Add any training bar percentage values to the actual skill point values and do away with the training bars. (e.g.- if you have 48.60 in a skill and 20% of that skill's training progress filled, you now would have 48.80 in that skill and no training bar)

Either way would solve all complaints.


+1 on option 1 w/ the % used in the sim if the fractions were before. This is what I've been saying.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
Originally posted by Catullus 16

wow... step away from GLB for a bit and this thread goes to nine pages. i scanned through it and there seemed to be some discussion about how the new training is okay because it effects everyone equally. untrue. here's why:

while no one is exempt from the new delays and inefficiencies of training, it disproportionately affects higher level players. lower level players get approximately +50%/day on normal training, so they can realize the effects of their training roughly every other day.

but higher level players are more in the neighborhood of +5%/day... which means they have to train for half a season before they finally get the benefit of having trained. and yes, even fully softcapped L32 could probably find a better return somewhere, but that's still missing the point.

cliff notes: the new training system is needlessly complex and arbitrarily punishes higher-level players.


The training has always worked so that stronger attributes are harder to increase. That's the way it should be.


?????? wow, you completely missed the point. not only am i quite obviously aware of that (who isn't?), but that's not at all what i'm talking about.
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
nothing in that post makes a valid point

Besides, what have you bought? One piece of custom equipment and one team? You spend very little money so you should have very little say in the matter.
Last edited Sep 26, 2008 09:54:04
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
nothing in that post makes a valid point
Besides, what have you bought? One piece of custom equipment and one team? You spend very little money so you should have very little say in the matter.


are you talking to me?
 
essteeay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
nothing in that post makes a valid point

Besides, what have you bought? One piece of custom equipment and one team? You spend very little money so you should have very little say in the matter.


Please leave this thread. You obviously have nothing constructive to add.

Catullus, I understand your suggestion, but as I've said before if we use your system we might as well get rid of the training bar altogether. It doesn't serve a useful purpose.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by essteeay
Catullus, I understand your suggestion, but as I've said before if we use your system we might as well get rid of the training bar altogether. It doesn't serve a useful purpose.


true, it would be reduced to mere window-dressing... and although it's a slight cosmetic upgrade, the decimals were far easier to see than having to mouse-over the training bars.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.