User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Interpreting the Polls
Page:
 
GP1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by phthalatemagic
PP laying the knowledge down!

I do think it's possible that tpat just isn't as informed as he thinks he is. (not a dig, it's just a possibility) If that really is the case, I think he should stop speaking so authoritatively.


Word. Exactly what I was trying to say.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
If you want people to play this game straight, then why the f**k did you employ cheats as moderators and alpha testers?? And if you didn't know they were cheats BEFORE you hired them, why did you continue to let them hang around once they'd been found out??


This is what I read. The mod who supposedly broke all these rules is no longer a mod, hence Bort DOES NOT turn a blind eye to the breaking of the rules. Current mods are who you are criticizing now so I am asking what specific things current mods did. Former mods are former mods for a reason, and I do not see what the actions of one former mod whose position was stripped has anything to do with the current ones.

I am not trying to be annoying, but I hear so much about mods cheating, but when I put it to anyone to tell me specifically when, how, where, with which team a current mod has cheated no one can do it, or at least they have not yet.

If they do and the point is a legitimate case of cheating, collusion, gutting, etc. then I will concede on that point. I just want specifics, that is all. I am tired of the "Mods always cheat" stereotype without real facts about current mods to back it up, and if everything you are saying pertains to Tim Harper and to him only, then he was stripped of his position for those very reasons (I have nothing against Tim as a person), and then we can say that was one person, but again what does that have to do with me or any of the other current mods? We are not all like Tim in our personalities or in our methods of running our teams. He was quite unique in both regards. I don't think Tim was as bad as people made him out to be, but even if he was, he was one person, he lost his position, and now he is just a regular user.

The list of mods I simply copied and pasted from the forum rules post. There was nothing strategic about who I included on the list. They are simply the current mods. I am not speaking authoritatively about anything except in telling you what mods do. Other than that I just asked a lot of questions. I am telling you what I know and think and if I don't know something I will tell you that I don't know, and if I disagree with Bort or the other admins or if I am disappointed in them I will tell you that as well if asked. Just as you might expect when dealing with other people disappointment and frustration happen all the time.

Originally posted by PP
Sorry, I missed this one. Do I need to remind you what Canadian Pro team was the one that caused all the fuss about this and who owned it at the time? Hint, it was the team that had almost all of it's players playing Special teams, O & D in their PO game because all the rest had been moved to their USA pro team for their PO game. I'll give him this, that former mod is responsible for more rules being created in this game than any other player (changes to stamina, trade deadline and roster mins, to name a few). Shame it was to stop him from pimping the system, instead of based on his suggestions. Remind me pls, what was done again to punish him for all of these acts? I'm pretty sure that the answer to that ? was nothing. Yeah, VB is WAY off base.


I honestly do not know about this one way or another. I have never had a Canadian team or a player on a Canadian team. I do not really read the Canadian forums although I was up on all the Dongate stuff because it was a wider GLB issue.

Originally posted by PP
I thought Bort has said already that it only took him a couple of days to do the training thing, that it was relatively quick and easy. As a matter of fact, he's said that at least twice that I've seen, and both times he was saying that to discredit the posters complaining that he spent too much time on it.


If that is true (and I don't doubt that it is), then I don't know why he is only now fixing these things. We had an "Oddities in the Sim on Offense" thread in the mod forum that is 90 posts long and an "Oddities in the Sim on Defense" post that is 70 posts long and I can tell you that no one was more frustrated by Bort not addressing these last season than myself and several of the other mods. That is not to knock Bort because he is a reasonable person, and I don't know why he didn't address them - there could have been a very good reason we just don't know about, but I was definitely frustrated by it as were many other mods and many other users as well. I don't know what else to say about it than that.


 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by 1VBChaos

If you want people to play this game straight, then why the f**k did you employ cheats as moderators and alpha testers?? And if you didn't know they were cheats BEFORE you hired them, why did you continue to let them hang around once they'd been found out??


This is what I read. The mod who supposedly broke all these rules is no longer a mod, hence Bort DOES NOT turn a blind eye to the breaking of the rules. Current mods are who you are criticizing now so I am asking what specific things current mods did. Former mods are former mods for a reason, and I do not see what the actions of one former mod whose position was stripped has anything to do with the current ones.

I am not trying to be annoying, but I hear so much about mods cheating, but when I put it to anyone to tell me specifically when, how, where, with which team a current mod has cheated no one can do it, or at least they have not yet.

If they do and the point is a legitimate case of cheating, collusion, gutting, etc. then I will concede on that point. I just want specifics, that is all. I am tired of the "Mods always cheat" stereotype without real facts about current mods to back it up, and if everything you are saying pertains to Tim Harper and to him only, then he was stripped of his position for those very reasons (I have nothing against Tim as a person), and then we can say that was one person, but again what does that have to do with me or any of the other current mods?


I'm honest to God not trying to be a pain in the ass or paint all mods as cheaters. I think being a mod is an extremely thankless job with the only real payoffs possibly being a few flex points (don't know that, just an assumption that could be wrong) and a little extra knowledge due to being tied closer to Bort...or, for those on an ego trip (NOT all, just those with huge egos, and there are a couple), power and an ego stroke. The good ones get shit on all the time.

HOWEVER, the nameless mod did NOT get stripped for those stunts. He got stripped for going on a power trip and banning innocent players, 3 full seasons later. The closest thing to a mass player revolt that GLB has ever seen is what got him stripped, not his season 1 stunts. They were very neatly swept under the carpet. Without the revolve, I personally doubt he would have been stripped for that either (but I could be wrong). Add all of that together and that's why I believe so many players from that era believe that mods are cheaters and Bort helps you. Personally, I do not believe that. However, it's extremely easy to understand why so many do.

If you truly do hate how mods are labeled by some (and I don't blame you if you do) and are going to get angry at anyone, I'd suggest that your anger should be pointed at the nameless former mod and Bort. After all, together, they created this perception, regardless of it's fair or not (and I honestly do think it's rather unfair, but also completely understandable why the ones that feel that way do).


Edit: Oh, and I'll take you for your word that you didn't know and appologize for assuming that you did. The threads about those "stunts" were all over this main forum. I'm sure they were on the Canadian forums as well, but I don't know anything about that (I don't have a team in Canada and have never visited their forums either). I assumed because you have always been so active that you couldn't have missed it.

Last edited Sep 25, 2008 12:44:06
 
BullFrogOnNet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti


Former mods are former mods for a reason, and I do not see what the actions of one former mod whose position was stripped has anything to do with the current ones.



I am not trying to be annoying, but I hear so much about mods cheating, but when I put it to anyone to tell me specifically when, how, where, with which team a current mod has cheated no one can do it, or at least they have not yet.

I just want specifics, that is all.






it is about the decision making process in who they made Mods then that reflect on Mods now, irregardless if any currently have done wrong now or not.
The track record is clearly there.

This isn't gonna go over well and people are gonna be upset but what I am about to go into is truth so fuck it.

What about Satch's account that is knowingly being babysat by a GM of his? Hud says here at the bottom of the page http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1027423&page=15

Both accounts should be banned by GLB rules. There is a constant double standard for Mods, Alpha testers, and now obviosly former Mods or thoe close to the inner circle if you will.

Clearly a Mod knows about this as he posted such. Why is this allowed inspite of the rule when they know of a case that this is happening?
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 12:48:54
 
The Suthrner
offline
Link
 
This thread is supposed to be about the recent polls but has gone way off course maybe it should be locked.
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Suthrner
This thread is supposed to be about the recent polls but has gone way off course maybe it should be locked.


Don't on my account....I'm done

 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti

This is what I read. The mod who supposedly broke all these rules is no longer a mod, hence Bort DOES NOT turn a blind eye to the breaking of the rules. Current mods are who you are criticizing now so I am asking what specific things current mods did. Former mods are former mods for a reason, and I do not see what the actions of one former mod whose position was stripped has anything to do with the current ones.






I'm not going to lie. That is all the farther I read on your post. I don't want in this argument you are having with the other poster. I'm just curious about this statement. If I remember correctly, it was said that certain mod stepped down for the better of the game. Then it was a mutual that that person was no longer a mod. Now it was he was stripped. I'm kind of confused what actually happened now.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by panther17
If I remember correctly, it was said that certain mod stepped down for the better of the game. Then it was a mutual that that person was no longer a mod. Now it was he was stripped. I'm kind of confused what actually happened now.


Me too.

 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BullFrogOnNet
it is about the decision making process in who they made Mods then that reflect on Mods now, irregardless if any currently have done wrong now or not.The track record is clearly there.


The track record is what I am disputing. So far Tim Harper is the only specifics we can come up with. Satchmo is now either in a coma or has passed on due to a terminal illness and so an exception was made. He was really only a mod for about 2 weeks anyway before his condition deteriorated to the point that he is no longer here. I don't know what the timetable is for the situation to be resolved but I am guessing that at some point the guy sitting his account will have to give it up, and also if anyone else had a terminal illness who had contributed to the game the way Satchmo did then probably Bort would make the same exception even if he were not a mod.


Last edited Sep 25, 2008 13:13:05
 
karma99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by panther17

If I remember correctly, it was said that certain mod stepped down for the better of the game. Then it was a mutual that that person was no longer a mod. Now it was he was stripped. I'm kind of confused what actually happened now.


Me too.



No confusion, it was stated at the time as a mutual decision. Whether that was to save TH's embarrasment I don't know, but the impression was given that had TH stood his ground and said "I don't care how they reacted" then he'd still be a mod now.
That didn't show that Bort was interested in policing his "staff" and that they have free reign, the same way Serenity kept mod status after being caught dual accounting.
I must admit it's been quiet recently, the new mods are doing a lot to improve relationships, but I don't think many people will ever understand quite how much damage that the multiple mod sagas in seasons 1-3 did to the perception of this games running as a professional business, especially to the more casual readers of the forums.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1110980

Back on the topic of interpreting the results
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I can tell you on Tim that he received warnings and several chances from Bort to act differently towards the people on the forum. What was in those conversations none of the other mods were privy to so we don't know what was said, but it is not at all the fact that it was totally under the radar until he was finally no longer a mod. His 2nd team was taken away season 1, he received warnings or conversations from Bort, and finally he was removed from being a mod. Stripped, stepped down, whcih was it? To be honest probably the whole stepped down part was a saving face deal or a euphemism. Bort is very long-suffering and he does not fly off the handle and make rash decisions or snap judgements, so he did not hasten to crucify Tim the first time something came up. He gave him chances and eventually they had to part ways. I think everyone knows why Tim is no longer a mod so fired or resigned is just an argument of semantics. I don't mind admitting that.

For the other 12 or however many mods, we are not so much changing to improve relations as being the same people we have always been, which is helpful, reasonable people who try to make yours and our own experiences better. One thing we have started working on is more consistency by doling out more specific forum assignments and picking more mods. What happens is I log in, open my inbox, and someone has PMed me saying "please go look in Antactica AA #1, it's out of hand," and I go look and there are several threads with cursing, attacks, and indeed it looks like no mod has ever even read the forum and it is just out of control, so we go in and start to enforce the rules and make it civil and readable again. Of course at that point it appears we are on a "power trip". What is needed is a more consistenct presence in all areas by mods (it is not acceptible for there to be threads and forums never read by mods), and we have recently taken the tangible steps I mentioned above to effect this, so hopefully real or perceived power trips will come up seldom if ever from now on.

That is an organizational improvement, but the people who are mods are still generally good people. The new assignments helps us appear the way we really are, whereas I think the perception of mods has in the past been quite far from the reality.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 13:31:07
 
BullFrogOnNet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti




The track record is what I am disputing. So far Tim Harper is the only specifics we can come up with. Satchmo is now either in a coma or has passed on due to a terminal illness and so an exception was made. He was really only a mod for about 2 weeks anyway before his condition deteriorated to the point that he is no longer here. I don't know what the timetable is for the situation to be resolved but I am guessing that at some point the guy sitting his account will have to give it up, and also if anyone else had a terminal illness who had contributed to the game the way Satchmo did then probably Bort would make the same exception even if he were not a mod.







So now we are only valued for our "contributions" to the game? Well everyone contributes to the game in their own way no matter how big or small and everyone should have the same importance level. Some people only contribute money, some like Satchmo information and helpfulness, some pointing out the flaws and bugs. Even the guy that makes an account and puts a player in the D league and then can't get a team because his build sucks and quits the game is just as important as Satch because he contributed to letting the Admins know the game wasn't for him and had something been different even though we would never know is still a valid contribution. Sorry for that run on sentence. So making an exception for that reason doesn't hold water. Special cases are BS, everyone has a special case. Everyone should be treated equal period but that is clearly not the case.
 
karma99
offline
Link
 
That's interesting to know tpat, it's only a shame this wasn't known at the time as it really didn't seem like TH was given any punishment and that it was his choice after discussing it all with Bort (it came across like 2 mates having a friendly chat and TH taking the higher ground to save Bort some grief).
This incident has played a large part in costing Bort anymore money from me for the past 2 seasons, that it appeared he couldn't care less what his mods did was a serious issue for me supporting this game.
It's nice to know that's not the case.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BullFrogOnNet
So now we are only valued for our "contributions" to the game? Well everyone contributes to the game in their own way no matter how big or small and everyone should have the same importance level. Some people only contribute money, some like Satchmo information and helpfulness, some pointing out the flaws and bugs. Even the guy that makes an account and puts a player in the D league and then can't get a team because his build sucks and quits the game is just as important as Satch because he contributed to letting the Admins know the game wasn't for him and had something been different even though we would never know is still a valid contribution. Sorry for that run on sentence. So making an exception for that reason doesn't hold water. Special cases are BS, everyone has a special case. Everyone should be treated equal period but that is clearly not the case.


Mostly it was his terminal illness, which we verified. If anyone else had a terminal illness, and we were able to verify it, we would probably make an allowance to them. The fact that he helped a lot of people was just because he was a great guy in spite of his own physical struggles.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.