User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Bort my FB last season started out being to slow to lead block. I took it UPON myself to correct these problems and got my speed and agl soft cap'd.

Here is my FB now...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=316465

65 speed, and 49 agl.

Now last season, I was able to effectively Lead block because OF MY SPEED. There was no delay in the HB waiting for me to set up.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=139253&pbp_id=9965306
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=137416&pbp_id=9061381
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=134375&pbp_id=8621921
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84608&pbp_id=7708215

Now here is this preseason and the "stutter" and "delay" we are seeing.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=186575&pbp_id=864025
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=186575&pbp_id=864735
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=191434&pbp_id=684937
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=191434&pbp_id=685519 (I really have no idea what is going on in this play)

I wish I could show my guy in action to better compare but I have not played yet this preseason. I still think this shows what we are talking about.

 
lawdawg95
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Possibly a player option in HB tactics would be good, a choice to hit the hole full speed as fast as possible or delay to follow the FB, or a balanced one, where he'd delay if he seems to need the FB or would go through a "good enough" hole without delay.

To some degree, a choice then about whether to behave more like last season and possibly get ahead of the FB, or to delay to make sure to follow the FB.


+1

We made sure and got our FBs more speed and agility and now it doesn't matter.
Last edited Sep 20, 2008 16:08:53
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
Originally posted by j4mzf0rm0d

While you're in here Bort, you might wanna have a look at pitches.

I've had to eliminate them from game plans all together. It's a guaranteed -2.5 yards against teams who know how to shift LBs and defend against the pitch.


Yep, especially the weakside pitch out of the weak I since that's the only play in that formation. You just stack up and blitz with no fear of being passed on. At least on the off tackle play out of the strong I there are passing plays you have to counter for.


Truth is (well my opinion) that even if you KNOW an offtackle play is coming, it's still not a dead ringer you can stop it because the pathing has some variance. Even if you have a LB in the right spot, one avoided tackle (doenst always mean a missed tackle) and it's into the secondary.

The weak I/pitch, there's one play, one assured path. One guy misses the tackle or it's avoided? Doesn't matter, another one or two more are right there.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
I formally request that the season does not officially start until this problem is resolved and tested. It is completely unfair to kick off a season with a broken running game and expect people to simply accept it and change their entire offensive philosophy to compensate for an obvious flaw.

.02

edit: I would also like to request an extra pre-season game or two to test them ourselves once a correction is made.
Last edited Sep 20, 2008 16:54:20
 
TCR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by kurieg

Originally posted by Bort


My main concern with the current state of the plays (since we don't have those other plays yet) is that people who have a huge discrepancy will complain about how bad the pathing for their HB is because he doesn't follow his blocker who is slower than dirt.


That's their fault. We had this problem 2 seasons ago, our HB was overrunning the FB, and we fixed it ourselves.

It's up to the players and team coaches/owners to assemble a team that makes sense. If they don't, tough.



Did you run into problems with the HB taking terrible approaches to the line when the FB was too slow, not following him, etc? If people can accept that as being their "problem" to fix, then I have no problem getting rid of the delay.
For 4 seasons our team the Hitmen have never had a FB issue.Our FB's have always been excellent lead blockers since we built them to be lead blockers.It seems to me we are catering to bad builds and aiding these people instead of rewarding the players who have been built right from the start.

Last edited Sep 20, 2008 17:00:10
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Sledge

Originally posted by Bort


Run pathing got an update this offseason (as mentioned in my announcement).

It's now a combination of the double-pass algo and new path calculation only every so many ticks instead of each tick, frequency depending on elusive/combo/power settings.

Only change I made to the off tackle play, though, is the short RB pause at the beginning to give the FB time to get moving and get to the hole.


Dont understand why you would need to make the change for the FB Bort. There is no problem with the sim related to the FB. The problem lies in peoples builds of the FB in relation to the speed of the HB.

If a team employees a power fullback then they need to understand the limitation they are under for the Hb rushing. Shrug same goes for a pass recieving TE. If a team starts one then there running game will suffer.

These 2 issues wont be resolved until we can assign players to specific plays.

A player that has a blocking Fb must always be aware of what the Hb is doing with his skill points..The FB an Hb on a team need to communicate. If a FB is late hitting the hole the HB shouldnt be increasing his speed with his points he should be working on other things while the Fb brings up his speed.

This fix kinda smacks of the cookie cutter type variety. Everyones Fb no matter how badly built will be able to perform.



Problem is that the HB is set to follow the FB as a lead blocker on many plays. If the FB is super slow in comparison, he will get ahead of him almost right away and the play will break down every time. If the FB gets 2-3 ticks to get going, the HB will actually have a lead blocker at least for a moment, no matter how quick he is.


That sounds like a problem with bad build FB. That's going to happen, the sim should not compensate for that. The agent will need to get the FB faster. I remember in season 2 our HBs were constantly running past the FB, so we made the FB faster and added more vision to the HB.
 
lawdawg95
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GO TEXANS
For 4 seasons our team the Hitmen have never had a FB issue.Our FB's have always been excellent lead blockers since we built them to be lead blockers.It seems to me we are catering to bad builds and aiding these people instead of rewarding the players who have been built right from the start.



Exactly. We saw that we needed to get our FBs more speed and agility so they could be better lead blockers. We did this and our running game thrived.

I'm also starting to feel like the bad builds are getting catered to through "fixes" or "nerfs" of talented players.

I mean Christ almighty. . . . going through the free agency pools is often comical because it's amazing some of the builds people come up with. Just because some can't build a player doesn't mean that those who did some research and busted their ass by working on their team's builds doesn't mean that it needs to be "fixed" to keep them pulled down with the bad builds.

I'm still curious as to what was "wrong" with off-tackle running last season. Our backs had no problems whatsoever.
 
lawdawg95
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HydrOshocK
I formally request that the season does not officially start until this problem is resolved and tested. It is completely unfair to kick off a season with a broken running game and expect people to simply accept it and change their entire offensive philosophy to compensate for an obvious flaw.

.02

edit: I would also like to request an extra pre-season game or two to test them ourselves once a correction is made.


+1
 
StoutOne
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Run pathing got an update this offseason (as mentioned in my announcement).

It's now a combination of the double-pass algo and new path calculation only every so many ticks instead of each tick, frequency depending on elusive/combo/power settings.

Only change I made to the off tackle play, though, is the short RB pause at the beginning to give the FB time to get moving and get to the hole.


On the off tackle play I've noticed the RG has changed blocking assignments, or this delay has affected the RG in some way as he now blocks my blitzing LB rather than last season he would have been TFL'ing the HB.
 
BuddyHorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lawdawg95
Originally posted by HydrOshocK

I formally request that the season does not officially start until this problem is resolved and tested. It is completely unfair to kick off a season with a broken running game and expect people to simply accept it and change their entire offensive philosophy to compensate for an obvious flaw.

.02

edit: I would also like to request an extra pre-season game or two to test them ourselves once a correction is made.


+1


seriously agree.
 
Link
 
Wow, I just went through the first few series of latest scrimmage, this is horrid. Both RBs (one speed, one power) doing that off-tackle stop, the speed RB (who is playing on balanced running last time I checked) is dancing around with a wide open hole until it's filled, one running play ends up with a RG in the backfield, going the opposite way of the RB. What happened? As cool as it is to have my guard actually go out and actively pick up the LB, the old way seemed a little more realistic and capable to running.
Last edited Sep 20, 2008 21:03:58
 
lawdawg95
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Van Windischgratz
What happened?


People were actually having success running the football last year and we can't tolerate success.

Success one season = Instant nerf the next.
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw

That sounds like a problem with bad build FB. That's going to happen, the sim should not compensate for that. The agent will need to get the FB faster. I remember in season 2 our HBs were constantly running past the FB, so we made the FB faster and added more vision to the HB.


I thought this was obvious in Season 1 And even so, it hasn't seemed like FB's need that much AGL/SPD to be somewhat effective...just enough to beat the HB to the hole and pick up the LB.


 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Hey Bort, it's pretty obvious that the changes are really a step backward, can we just revert to last season's off tackle and inside run code? Trying to fix it now on the fly will probably cause a lot of other issues which means that the first few games of this season will be guess work for everyone.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Hey Bort, it's pretty obvious that the changes are really a step backward, can we just revert to last season's off tackle and inside run code? Trying to fix it now on the fly will probably cause a lot of other issues which means that the first few games of this season will be guess work for everyone.


How about my idea of creating the advanced tactical option for HB's as I stated earlier in the thread of no delay, just hit the hole as fast as possible (essentially last season's code), delay to make sure you follow the FB (this season's code) or, in between, no delay if there's a good hole, but otherwise wait for the hole to develop and FB help?

Why that instead of a complete reversion? Because Bort might eventually get his changes fixed so it's better all around, and this season's system might actually be better even now if a team has a slow FB.

There's also the stutter-stepping fix, which may have helped things (if by itself) or may have hurt them. If there were still problems that didn't exist last season with the "no delay" option engaged, then another option of "be decisive and don't change course easily" (new system) or "change course whenever it seems to make sense" (last season's) with a middle option, could also be added.

Bort put in some new options for QB's pretty quickly last season, so I think it can be done and done quickly.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.