Well, if most of the options in the OP were added, the system would be in OK shape. It'd be a mess, with a HUUUGE pull-down, but at least there'd be some decent options.
I still don't understand why allowing players to pick their 2 training options is being disallowed. There are already some options with two 'strong' attributes together.. like Speed & Agility, Strength & Blocking, Throwing & Vision, so I don't buy reasons like trying to restrict slow building, or to keep players from pumping those 'good' attributes up. Instead, there's a serious lack of options, which greatly hinders venerans' ability to continue improving their players. And as far as training totally unrelated attribs goes, like Kicking and Throwing.. if someone really wants to, let them. Even a total football noob should quickly figure out that it's not worth working on them both.
How about this as a compromise: Players can pick which 2 attributes they train, but from mutually exclusive lists. The simplest way to set it up would be to pick 1 Physical Attribute and 1 Football Skill. Another way would be to put all of the very role-specific attribs on one side (Throwing, Kicking, Blocking, etc) and the more general stats on the other (eg. Speed, Agility, Tackling), possibly with some overlap (Vision & Confidence could easily go both ways, for example). But the Phys Attribs/Skills divide is already very close to this, so it's probably not worth going to all the trouble.
I still don't understand why allowing players to pick their 2 training options is being disallowed. There are already some options with two 'strong' attributes together.. like Speed & Agility, Strength & Blocking, Throwing & Vision, so I don't buy reasons like trying to restrict slow building, or to keep players from pumping those 'good' attributes up. Instead, there's a serious lack of options, which greatly hinders venerans' ability to continue improving their players. And as far as training totally unrelated attribs goes, like Kicking and Throwing.. if someone really wants to, let them. Even a total football noob should quickly figure out that it's not worth working on them both.
How about this as a compromise: Players can pick which 2 attributes they train, but from mutually exclusive lists. The simplest way to set it up would be to pick 1 Physical Attribute and 1 Football Skill. Another way would be to put all of the very role-specific attribs on one side (Throwing, Kicking, Blocking, etc) and the more general stats on the other (eg. Speed, Agility, Tackling), possibly with some overlap (Vision & Confidence could easily go both ways, for example). But the Phys Attribs/Skills divide is already very close to this, so it's probably not worth going to all the trouble.






























