User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by im4ut999
Originally posted by DigitalDaggers

Training Points aren't nothing.

But yeah, if folks don't like the option they can decline as normal.


So you're saying 80 TPs are equal to 5% of ALL attributes? No way DD.....

40 training days gets a player:
1) 120 BTs for 10 SP....on A single attribute of interest, maybe 5%...
2) light training would be maybe 2 additional points....on a single attr....
3) 120 BTs COULD be 5 AEQ upgrades......but most of the players in this range were not expecting to be "useful" for another season, so most likley have not been accumulating BTs towards another AEQ, so doubtful many players would be

So a 5% decline penalty is offsetting 5-10% on a SINGLE attribute OR 5 AEQ upgrades....

Why don't you just stop giving TP RIGHT NOW on players over 440 days old....

Drop the penalty to 1-2% range, tops....

How many SP have been applied to a 440 day old player? 74 levels * 5 plus 60 for ALG plus starting points....maybe 500 points? 5% is 25 SP loss, and much harder on the top attributes, that most likely are not the ones that have benefited from these end of career SP points generated.....

WAY TOO HARSH of a penalty, imo.....


In adding up my WR's three highest attributes, he loses:
56 SPs on his highest attribute
29 SPs on his second highest attribute
7 SPs on his third highest attribute
So on his top 3 attributes, he loses 92 SPs. Can someone tell me how that adds up to 12 SPs from the TPs?
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
1% decline offsets training (and doesn't punish S5 dots for no reason) and everyone is happy.

Not sure why that isn't the option.


That's exactly what I said yesterday.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
In adding up my WR's three highest attributes, he loses:
56 SPs on his highest attribute
29 SPs on his second highest attribute
7 SPs on his third highest attribute
So on his top 3 attributes, he loses 92 SPs. Can someone tell me how that adds up to 12 SPs from the TPs?


Instead of proving the math shit, lets just all work to balance it so there is no advantage, and GLB doesn't burn down their entire empire by making an announcement that injected as much life into the game as anything(s5d0 were good to go) only to screw every agent with a s5 or s6 dot in the game...
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reddogrw
horrible announcement - easy decision to retire my season 5 guy now


+1

New changes are awful. My 478 day old dot (at the end of the season) will have 4% decline and the same number of VAs as a 440 day old dot with 0% decline, and it will remain that way throughout the extended plateau? FFFFFFUUUUUUUUU
 
Mstr_October
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme

1% decline offsets training and bonus tokens. Shit, make the opt-in effective now for the next few days and stop TPs at that point for all dots that opt in.

Literally anything else is better than this decision. Even just cutting S5 dots out all together would be preferable.


THIS!!! It is pretty simply math. Please apply it before making rash changes to something that actually looked pretty well thought out to make, what I believe, very very few people happy. Almost everyone I know was happy with the original announcement minus the extra VAs, but a 1% decline for the 440-480 dots is the best, and most fair option.
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
In adding up my WR's three highest attributes, he loses:
56 SPs on his highest attribute
29 SPs on his second highest attribute
7 SPs on his third highest attribute
So on his top 3 attributes, he loses 92 SPs. Can someone tell me how that adds up to 12 SPs from the TPs?


WOW....I think you're being way TOO hard on a 5% loss.....even if his top attr is at 100 natural, you only lose 5 points off the attr value.....

Now if you had actually spent SP on those 5 points, you would not have had SP to build anything else up.....

Be realistic...don't over-compensate....
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Originally posted by reddogrw

horrible announcement - easy decision to retire my season 5 guy now


+1

New changes are awful. My 478 day old dot (at the end of the season) will have 4% decline and the same number of VAs as a 440 day old dot with 0% decline, and it will remain that way throughout the extended plateau? FFFFFFUUUUUUUUU


It's so stupid.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by im4ut999
Originally posted by jrry32

In adding up my WR's three highest attributes, he loses:
56 SPs on his highest attribute
29 SPs on his second highest attribute
7 SPs on his third highest attribute
So on his top 3 attributes, he loses 92 SPs. Can someone tell me how that adds up to 12 SPs from the TPs?


WOW....I think you're being way TOO hard on a 5% loss.....even if his top attr is at 100 natural, you only lose 5 points off the attr value.....

Now if you had actually spent SP on those 5 points, you would not have had SP to build anything else up.....

Be realistic...don't over-compensate....


5 points of attribute value from 100 to 95 is like 90 skill points. I am being realistic, I am using this thing called math. I don't see how 12 SPs = 92 SPs.
Edited by jrry32 on Jun 25, 2010 16:02:18
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DigitalDaggers
i believe so, yes.

as long they have boosted enough to earn the full 3 seasons.




Ok, I disagree that players that have been lvl 74 with a mild decline should be allowed to have 3 more seasons of extended plateau...but sounds like a bunch of people are unhappy with the 5% to physical attributes....so all in all, I'd say it's a plan that makes both sides equally uphappy and therefore probably a good thing.

I'm ok with it since neither sides are being dissatisfied equally
 
ijg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DigitalDaggers


it's your choice to extend or not. feel free to not extend if you don't think the trade-off is fair.


DD, nobody is going to choose to extend at that cost. Was that the point of this? If so, would have been better to not have an opt-in and just have d440 cutoff. All this has done is piss people off more by creating a "solution" that makes people feel like they weren't listened to.
 
Mstr_October
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dpride59
Instead of proving the math shit, lets just all work to balance it so there is no advantage, and GLB doesn't burn down their entire empire by making an announcement that injected as much life into the game as anything(s5d0 were good to go) only to screw every agent with a s5 or s6 dot in the game...


This shouldn't really be that difficult to do.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP


Ok, I disagree that players that have been lvl 74 with a mild decline should be allowed to have 3 more seasons of extended plateau...but sounds like a bunch of people are unhappy with the 5% to physical attributes....so all in all, I'd say it's a plan that makes both sides equally uphappy and therefore probably a good thing.

I'm ok with it since neither sides are being dissatisfied equally


Right? At least they took the approach that pisses off everyone rather than pleasing anyone. Its almost as if they said what is the most rational balanced way to inject life into the game? Alright do the opposite lets play some fucking baseball
Edited by Dpride59 on Jun 25, 2010 16:04:19
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by im4ut999
WOW....I think you're being way TOO hard on a 5% loss.....even if his top attr is at 100 natural, you only lose 5 points off the attr value.....

Now if you had actually spent SP on those 5 points, you would not have had SP to build anything else up.....

Be realistic...don't over-compensate....

It's about SP value. You don't spend SP on the things you increase through training either, but it still adds to the overall SP value of the build.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
season 5 dots have the option of delaying the decline that happened this season that many days longer than season 1,2,3 or 4 dots did, and won't have any advantage over future dots. this is a perfect change. if you don't like it, retire. that simple.
 
Mstr_October
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by im4ut999
WOW....I think you're being way TOO hard on a 5% loss.....even if his top attr is at 100 natural, you only lose 5 points off the attr value.....

Now if you had actually spent SP on those 5 points, you would not have had SP to build anything else up.....

Be realistic...don't over-compensate....


Do you think it is possible to raise Speed from 95-100 in one season of training?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.