User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Gott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hukton Vioxx
It should be a viable gameplan option to run right at a DE who is built purely to rush the QB and have the ROT push him backwards all the time.

On the flip side, it is hard to keep defenders from even grabbing at a RB without holding. A really strong tackler is not going to let a guy go right buy him all the time, and if the ball carrier is significantly weaker, the defender should have a decent chance of stopping him with just an arm tackle. This would also make things like chop blocks more important, since they essentially take the defender out of the play for a couple seconds, and can spring a RB.


Agreed. All of these speed and agility DEs should get run over repeatedly. It's also annoying to see backs constantly running right through defenders without so much as a broken tackle.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kavadas
Originally posted by GMathiasf

This game is already ridiculously biased toward offense and now we're debating making EVERY defender get their tackling skill over 60 just to bring someone down? So, now in order to tackle someone, you have to make yourself dreadfully slow, inagile, or lacking vision.


Don't see what the big deal is if carrying and catching are needed in those same quantities and strength becomes, like, not shit for receivers. And vision starts to work for power runners rather than against.

Stuff that makes sense...


Surprised that my post incited a plethora of responses, but I chose this one to reply to. The point is that carrying and catching are NOT needed in those quantities. Same with vision. WRs don't appear to need to have any blocking ability or strength to successfully block anyone on the outside on top of that. Basically, what you create is a dynamic where defenders have no choice but to sacrifice speed/agility to be stronger/better tacklers, while the offensive players don't have to make that sacrifice. Too many 52-47 games between good teams happened last season. It got so bad that we started playing our punter on KRS because he wasn't getting any punts. 22 punts in 16 games is just silly. No team forced us to punt more than 4 times all season including playoffs. Pre-season, now in AAA, things look just as ridiculous. 4 punts in two games against GREAT competition. The problem is that defenses can't make stops normally, they can basically only hope for turnovers or sacks to make stops. I'm all for tackling being an important skill, but it can only work if carrying/catching/blocking/strength become equally important on the other side of the ball.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
So whats the conclusion in this behemoth 89 page thread?
 
Taha19
offline
Link
 
70 STR and 50 tackling should be enough


but it sould depend on the positions making the tackle.. the LB should have a better chance of tackling a Power HB then say a CB
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
Originally posted by Kavadas

Originally posted by GMathiasf


This game is already ridiculously biased toward offense and now we're debating making EVERY defender get their tackling skill over 60 just to bring someone down? So, now in order to tackle someone, you have to make yourself dreadfully slow, inagile, or lacking vision.


Don't see what the big deal is if carrying and catching are needed in those same quantities and strength becomes, like, not shit for receivers. And vision starts to work for power runners rather than against.

Stuff that makes sense...


Surprised that my post incited a plethora of responses, but I chose this one to reply to. The point is that carrying and catching are NOT needed in those quantities. Same with vision. WRs don't appear to need to have any blocking ability or strength to successfully block anyone on the outside on top of that. Basically, what you create is a dynamic where defenders have no choice but to sacrifice speed/agility to be stronger/better tacklers, while the offensive players don't have to make that sacrifice. Too many 52-47 games between good teams happened last season. It got so bad that we started playing our punter on KRS because he wasn't getting any punts. 22 punts in 16 games is just silly. No team forced us to punt more than 4 times all season including playoffs. Pre-season, now in AAA, things look just as ridiculous. 4 punts in two games against GREAT competition. The problem is that defenses can't make stops normally, they can basically only hope for turnovers or sacks to make stops. I'm all for tackling being an important skill, but it can only work if carrying/catching/blocking/strength become equally important on the other side of the ball.


While I definitely agree about last season, I've seen considerably more realistic offensive production in just this preseason. I'll use my Tonga squad as an example. My punter has punted 13 times in this preseason along: 6 and 7 in each game, respectively. The first we won 41-7, the second we won 37-20, not exactly the closest of contests. In the first game, we had 326 yards of total offense, in our second we had 339. In both games our defense has forced 2 turnovers while we've given up none in either game.

And I agree with your overall point as well: if a secondary attribute such as tackling has increased significance, than all the secondary attributes across the board should.
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
So whats the conclusion in this behemoth 89 page thread?


60/60 is enough, more is obviously better.
 
Bill Jack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ruleslawyer
He did indeed get trucked.... Play ended 2 yards later though.


Al Harris had sidelines, if not, AD keeps on going....

Not a Vikes fan, but I read Al Harris cheap shotted AD in 07 so I think Peterson was looking for that opportunity to embarrass Harris and even sweeter right in front of Packer bench.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by GG

So whats the conclusion in this behemoth 89 page thread?


60/60 is enough, more is obviously better.


Does Bort agree with that line of thinking? What about all the AEQT, SA, and VA bonuses thrown in for break tackle and power thru etc?

Last edited Jan 1, 2009 07:48:34
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by Maddoc

Originally posted by GG


So whats the conclusion in this behemoth 89 page thread?


60/60 is enough, more is obviously better.


Does Bort agree with that line of thinking? What about all the AEQT, SA, and VA bonuses thrown in for break tackle and power thru etc?

Should defenders not have some kind of SA/VA that counters all those break tackle bonuses?


This is the line of reasoning Bort stated some forty odd pages back, and stated that in testing those numbers produced reasonably good results. Not perfect, never-miss-a-tackle, but good. People continued arguing long after he finished tweaking things.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Should defenders not have some kind of SA/VA that counters all those break tackle bonuses? Think DBs here too. In GLB you get a lot of LBs held up in blocks and the HBs basically traipsing free with just DBs in front of them.

Is that 60/60 for all defenders? Wouldnt CBs tackle/strength be applied a lot differently to DTs and DTs differently to LBs? Seeing as they all have so many different attribute requirements that CBs and LBs cant be so one-dimensionally built.
Last edited Jan 1, 2009 07:49:06
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Should defenders not have some kind of SA/VA that counters all those break tackle bonuses? Think DBs here too. In GLB you get a lot of LBs held up in blocks and the HBs basically traipsing free with just DBs in fron of them.

Is that 60/60 for all defenders? Wouldnt CBs tackle/strength be applied a lot differently to DTs and DTs differently to LBs? Seeing as they all have so many different attribute requirements that CBs and LBs cant be so one-dimensionally built.


60/60 will give you a good chance to pull down some of the best power backs running around in pro. I don't really know any more than that, and I personally don't believe stats should work differently for different positions (different softcaps maybe, but that's an entirely different discussion). Basically I'm just giving you the answer that Bort came to way, way back in this thread because the rest of it has just been arguing back and forth with no real resolution to be had.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
well i appreciate you giving me the lowdown.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
For the sake of argument, saying something 'controversial', i would add....

imo, all those rpg elements (VA/SA/EQT) is where theres always trouble in GLB. SAs should be nothing but football skills you acquire rather than bonuses. VAs shouldnt even exist. And EQT doesnt add anything to the game. This is just my opinion and people can totally disagree with it. They probably know better than I. But imo, I see all these things as things that hold the game back, that tie it down, and that end up complicating the raw attributes which ends up meaning so much nerfing and tweaking of attributes.
 
ruleslawyer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
For the sake of argument, saying something 'controversial', i would add....

imo, all those rpg elements (VA/SA/EQT) is where theres always trouble in GLB. SAs should be nothing but football skills you acquire rather than bonuses. VAs shouldnt even exist. And EQT doesnt add anything to the game. This is just my opinion and people can totally disagree with it. They probably know better than I. But imo, I see all these things as things that hold the game back, that tie it down, and that end up complicating the raw attributes which ends up meaning so much nerfing and tweaking of attributes.


I agree

piling more stuff on top of base player attributes that are in constant flux makes the balancing act tougher. Wooing the paying to beta crowd with trinkets, shinies and advanced features when the core needs to be made stable (and tested through a generation or two of player careers) first.
Last edited Jan 1, 2009 08:10:45
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ruleslawyer

I agree

piling more stuff on top of base player attributes that are in constant flux makes the balancing act tougher. Wooing the paying to beta crowd with trinkets, shinies and advanced features when the core needs to be made stable (and tested through a generation or two of player careers) first.


Yep, totally agree.

Like, Bort put a lot of work into creating VAs, AEQT, etc, but why that instead of investing all that time instead to overhauling the attribute system, adding more attributes, making it a more stable and deeper system, allowing people to use the +/- feature to redistribute their spent SPs into the new attribute system that would've solved more core problems in the game than piling all these bonuses etc on top of a shaky and shallow attribute system.

I mean, that time and effort was invested in creating all these new things, so I dont see how investing that time instead to re-doing what already existed was something "not feasible" or "not desirable".

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.