User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World Pro Championship Tournament
Page:
 
NikeUnlimited
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ksychic
Originally posted by NikeUnlimited

Just make the World League real big. 64 teams, 4 divisions, top 4 in each go to playoffs.


Little bit too big..


Not big enough maybe.
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
I had no idea people hated the system so much the way it was now
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
+1. Think long term, people.


If you are thinking about long term, you need to realize there are a lot of the best teams in 2-3 regions and if you ration World Leagues slots to one team a season (or even two teams a season from each league) a lot of great teams are going to die because of the bottle neck in those leagues.

It's up to you whether you want the World League to be the best teams in GLB, with representation from every region even if some have more...or if you want the best 4 teams from each region regardless of how good that 3rd or 4th team might be.
 
SErebel11
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by rmiller517

WPL wouldn't have been balanced at all.


And likely would cause:

- Some owners to get promoted and quit after getting beat more than they are used to (can't handle losing syndrome - I've seen it over and over).
- Continued endless debate about how the wrong teams made it because we'd go with equal rep from each league
- Dilution of Pro league talent
- Extra teams to get promoted who aren't ready, with a ripple effect ALL THE WAY DOWN
- Extra teams to be demoted even if they didn't come in last place (due to dropdowns from WPL) which sucks for them, gives them less media revenue, etc


Point 1: sounds like you are catering to a certain group of owners

Point 2: Make some rules and stick to it. If people wanna make it to the World league then let them work at it.

Why cant something like this be done:

World League has 32 teams:

16 from the conference winners from each league

Then have a tournament in the offseason to determine the other 16

Have 16 pools

so it would be like 16 pools of the conference semi finalist (6 teams and 2 other teams with each league having an add on from each conference that has the highest seed from round 1 losers) and freeze the rosters and have 16 4 team tournaments in the first 2 days of the offseason for the remaining 16 spots left. You already freeze rosters 1 day anyhow and then everyone should be happy. I know a back to back game thing might be a conflict but it would be a small sacrifice to get the world league started. Then from there you promote accordingly. You could even choose to only promote 8 teams to world league per season and cut the bottom 4 from each conference which wouldnt be an issue imo considering the gutting rate as it is now anyway.

Point 3: It is already diluted. You have a ton of season 1 and 2 players in Minors Uncapped leagues. I have seen pro teams gut and fill up AA league teams before. I mean this is always gonna be an issue the way this game is set up. It will actually make the Pro leagues more competitive and enjoyable for owners there imo because it is the same few teams every season that is in the hunt for the league title anyway in many leagues. Then the top eschelon teams will be able to compete against a super team every week and will have the ability to recruit with them because of the world league title. The way it is set up now it is basically a big deal to play in certain Pro leagues and others are like redheaded step childs.

Point 4 and 5 are moot points: due to decline and people tired of losing and recruiting being a pain you will see teams getting sold back every season or teams asking for demotion to capped 13 to slow build and start over. I already see several teams from various leagues that have posted on the boards their intentions to do so.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by joemiken
Originally posted by Wrath Of Conor

Originally posted by Havoc




Do it like European soccer.

8 Pro champs auto promote and replace the bottom 8 WPL teams.

8 Pro runner ups play an additional playoff game against WPL teams #17-24. Winner plays in WPL the next season.


+1 Me likey,

I was all for the 16 team straight demotion and bring up the 16 conf champ participants, but this makes sense too because there will undoubtedly be teams that fall in the demotion category for WL but would still very likely be better than the conf champ loser.

Plus, it creates a wonderfully important set of games. I loved the World League play in day even though we weren't sure it was the case.

I think the 16 up, 16 down format works just fine. In future seasons, the conference champs from all 8 regions promote, regardless of what their teams already there do. Let's say Cincy/Monmouth/OTR/HHW all make the playoffs. They would stay and say, Washington/OFG promote after S11. To replace the void, an additional 2 teams get promoted from AAA. Within 2-3 seasons, you'd likely have the best teams in a World League.

Equal representation is NOT the way to go w/ a World League.


I don't think either my post nor Havoc's implies that equal representation is preserved.

In my thinking, the bottom 8 WL teams could have originated from any region and they are automatically replaced by the 8 Pro League champs. Likewise, teams 17-24 in WL get paired up with the 8 Pro League title game losers, again region not specified, winner gets in or stays in and the loser goes back to their Pro league to try again.
 
seorang
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joebarber
Originally posted by Havoc




Do it like European soccer.

8 Pro champs auto promote and replace the bottom 8 WPL teams.

8 Pro runner ups play an additional playoff game against WPL teams #17-24. Winner plays in WPL the next season.


I really like this plan tbh
 
presvedder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ksychic
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by ksychic


Originally posted by PackMan97



I'd love to see a World League, but I think just doing 4 conference final teams from each league is a horrible way to do the initial seeding.

Take the two two from each league (the league finals participants) and then take the top teams from the Pro World Tourney and Hazy's GLB Addicts tourney. If you have left over teams, take the top teams from the LARS computer rating.

This is a mix of the best of each league (ultimately deserving) and the best of the rest regardless of region.


If its called WORLD LEAGUE..

Then it should not have 10 USAPL teams, and 2 OPL teams


+1. Think long term, people.


YAY.. Bort agreed with me!


Probably not a good thing...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Dmac2008
Are you in favor of the World League, World Tournament, or neither?
World Champion League (promoted from Pro leagues)

149
World Champion Tournament (as posted today)

25
Neither. I like it the way it is now.

13

pretty much over now lol


The "neither" group is catching up still!!

It was almost as low as 1/20th of the top vote early I think, and then about 1/6 of the top vote just a few pages ago, now it is about 2/11.
 
refguru
offline
Link
 
The World League wouldn't be the best of the best--it would be the top four teams of this eyar's playoffs of each pro league. Most of the people who are in the know realize that USA Pro has many teams not in the world league who could possibly be the best in some of these other leagues. I think the tourney makes the most sense--esp. if we can put the leagues who have several "top" teams in different regions or brackets.

I tried to go in and vote and there is no option to vote--just shows the results.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
206
37
17
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Originally posted by Bort

BTW, where were you guys in season 2 when we announced the idea originally? We coulda had a world league for 8 seasons now.


There were several huge threads in the Suggestion forums in the early seasons that you were to good to make a presence in to really spark the discussions/ideas to take the World Pro League idea off the ground. It didnt help that you had douche bag moderators that jumped in and said "its never going to happen" every time it was proposed.


Bort... why did you not join in on this thread?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1164706&page=1
 
DigitalDaggers
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
206
37
17


i raise you eleventeen
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Here is another one and done WPL team.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=2953

Losing to Canadian and USA AAA teams.
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
1337 get
 
head1
offline
Link
 
After this season have a Pro League Tournament with all the top teams who think they can get to WPL and play it out. Top 2 finishers in that tournament that dont win their league + 8 league champs every season go up, bottom 5 in each WPL conference get sent back down.

This allows those Leagues like USA etc to get more in if they can. Seeding would be hard but i think enough people could come together to form a panel, maybe the WPL owners to decide seeding for the tournament.

Just a shot.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.