User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
FlatheadCat
offline
Link
 
Were you a tester, Darkus?
 
GP1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
I see your point but there are SO many variables in this game that I don't think people are realising the extent to which someone would have to go to to find everything that works for every player. Just trying to find out what works for one position would take hours and hours of work. Not withstanding the hours of work going into testing formations, tactics, etc. Also taking into account opposition builds and the correlation between those and the setup that you have. Then you have to get that information out into the general populace without it being know that you are doing it. This is the biggest problem with conspiracies, they are such huge operations.

Let's say Mike decides to exploit the test server and finds something. He keeps it to himself and leaves the exploit open. He then tells his team what to do. With the cross pollination of GLB it would be around the forums in hours.


Exactly right. These guys can figure out in a matter of hours what combinations work whereas it would take a regular GLBer, at 25 SP per season, months and months. THIS is the advantage that people complain about.

And if someone were to tell the team, surely they wouldnt go around telling others.

 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Darkus Black

With the cross pollination of GLB it would be around the forums in hours.

So it's all ok because some people might learn about it anyway? Wow.


That is not what I am saying. Stop taking my quote out of context. I am saying that IF it is exploited and shared then the information would come out quickly which would highlight that there is a leak and then it can be plugged. I wasn't saying it was acceptable to do it.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
and if two or three testers happened to be on the same team or GM one another's teams....the information shared could be much more efficient...
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black

That is not what I am saying. Stop taking my quote out of context. I am saying that IF it is exploited and shared then the information would come out quickly which would highlight that there is a leak and then it can be plugged. I wasn't saying it was acceptable to do it.


That is how you sound, sorry to say. You sound like you are making excuses and saying that it is fine...
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Originally posted by Darkus Black


I wouldn't say that just because a tester is on a team that they automatically give out information.


But if they ever talk to any non-tester about player builds or tactics (or set AIs), wouldn't it be nearly impossible to prevent information that they learned from getting out as it informs what they say about the game (they can't unknow it).


I see your point but there are SO many variables in this game that I don't think people are realising the extent to which someone would have to go to to find everything that works for every player. Just trying to find out what works for one position would take hours and hours of work. Not withstanding the hours of work going into testing formations, tactics, etc. Also taking into account opposition builds and the correlation between those and the setup that you have. Then you have to get that information out into the general populace without it being know that you are doing it. This is the biggest problem with conspiracies, they are such huge operations.

Let's say Mike decides to exploit the test server and finds something. He keeps it to himself and leaves the exploit open. He then tells his team what to do. With the cross pollination of GLB it would be around the forums in hours.


I think you're missing my point. My point wasn't a concern that people were going to intentionally exploit what they learned, but that it would necessarily inform and change what they know about builds and tactics, and so would inevitably inform how they built their own players, set their own AIs and how they advised other agents.

Unless you are saying that being a tester provides no useful information about the sim, then it has an effect and I don't think its possible to remove that effect despite the best intentions of Bort and the testers. In other words, under the best case scenario (100% intent among testers not to exploit anything) there is still a competitive advantage being given to testers and people that testers discuss the game with.

Last edited Feb 15, 2009 16:34:35
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GP1
Originally posted by Darkus Black

I see your point but there are SO many variables in this game that I don't think people are realising the extent to which someone would have to go to to find everything that works for every player. Just trying to find out what works for one position would take hours and hours of work. Not withstanding the hours of work going into testing formations, tactics, etc. Also taking into account opposition builds and the correlation between those and the setup that you have. Then you have to get that information out into the general populace without it being know that you are doing it. This is the biggest problem with conspiracies, they are such huge operations.

Let's say Mike decides to exploit the test server and finds something. He keeps it to himself and leaves the exploit open. He then tells his team what to do. With the cross pollination of GLB it would be around the forums in hours.


Exactly right. These guys can figure out in a matter of hours what combinations work whereas it would take a regular GLBer, at 25 SP per season, months and months. THIS is the advantage that people complain about.

And if someone were to tell the team, surely they wouldnt go around telling others.



You are still assuming all testers are telling their teams though. It is all ifs and buts. And how many people have players on their team that are on other teams in other conferences that would like to help them as well?
 
FlatheadCat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson
Were you a tester, Darkus?


 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black


You are still assuming all testers are telling their teams though. It is all ifs and buts. And how many people have players on their team that are on other teams in other conferences that would like to help them as well?



Even if "only" half told just their GM's, that is a lot of teams with an unfair advantage...What do you not get about this?
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black


I am saying that IF it is exploited and shared then the information would come out quickly which would highlight that there is a leak and then it can be plugged. I wasn't saying it was acceptable to do it.


So, like I said, because some people might learn about it because it was shared, you are saying that this automatically means that everyone will know about it within hours? And this somehow makes clandestine testing by users of the main game ok? Again, wow.
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by Darkus Black


That is not what I am saying. Stop taking my quote out of context. I am saying that IF it is exploited and shared then the information would come out quickly which would highlight that there is a leak and then it can be plugged. I wasn't saying it was acceptable to do it.


That is how you sound, sorry to say. You sound like you are making excuses and saying that it is fine...


No, I would certainly not be accepting of someone exploiting a test server and sharing the information with their team to win. A hollow victory is a hollow victory. I see no excitement in winning through cheating.
 
GP1
offline
Link
 
Even if they arent telling their teams, those testers personally, who play on teams we compete against, have inside information.

And, at least one of those testers is a team owner. You dont think he advises his team how to allocate SP? You think he'd continue to do so if he knew something didnt work? Even if his intentions arent to spread the information, it's an inevitable side effect.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by GP1

Originally posted by Darkus Black


I see your point but there are SO many variables in this game that I don't think people are realising the extent to which someone would have to go to to find everything that works for every player. Just trying to find out what works for one position would take hours and hours of work. Not withstanding the hours of work going into testing formations, tactics, etc. Also taking into account opposition builds and the correlation between those and the setup that you have. Then you have to get that information out into the general populace without it being know that you are doing it. This is the biggest problem with conspiracies, they are such huge operations.

Let's say Mike decides to exploit the test server and finds something. He keeps it to himself and leaves the exploit open. He then tells his team what to do. With the cross pollination of GLB it would be around the forums in hours.


Exactly right. These guys can figure out in a matter of hours what combinations work whereas it would take a regular GLBer, at 25 SP per season, months and months. THIS is the advantage that people complain about.

And if someone were to tell the team, surely they wouldnt go around telling others.



You are still assuming all testers are telling their teams though. It is all ifs and buts. And how many people have players on their team that are on other teams in other conferences that would like to help them as well?


And you are assuming that if they are telling their teams, that this information will somehow leak out to the entire population of GLB within hours. His inference was reasonable, your inference upon an inference is not.
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by Darkus Black



You are still assuming all testers are telling their teams though. It is all ifs and buts. And how many people have players on their team that are on other teams in other conferences that would like to help them as well?



Even if "only" half told just their GM's, that is a lot of teams with an unfair advantage...What do you not get about this?


Are you stupid? I am NOT saying that testers SHOULD be telling their teams. I am saying IF testers told their teams that WOULD be discovered very QUICKLY.

What are YOU not getting about that?
 
FlatheadCat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by mantis7

Originally posted by Darkus Black



That is not what I am saying. Stop taking my quote out of context. I am saying that IF it is exploited and shared then the information would come out quickly which would highlight that there is a leak and then it can be plugged. I wasn't saying it was acceptable to do it.


That is how you sound, sorry to say. You sound like you are making excuses and saying that it is fine...


No, I would certainly not be accepting of someone exploiting a test server and sharing the information with their team to win. A hollow victory is a hollow victory. I see no excitement in winning through cheating.


Did you or did you not have access to the test server when you won the League 6 peewee conference championship?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.