User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by williamcohms
How long has this been going on? So it's possible my teams lost games because other people had better knowledge of how the game works?


That is without a doubt the case.

However, is completely irrelevant.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by williamcohms
So I've been dumping SP into SA hoping they'll improve my elusive back adn someone else has the ability to go on a test server, max out juke, headfake, spin, and see instantly what the effect is

Actually you have been dumping SP into SA hoping they'll improve your elusive back and a tester has the ability to go on a test server, max out juke, and if having juke at 10 with accompanying physical abilities doesn't seem to do much then he can tell bort and bort can balance out this aspect of HBs so the SP you spent in juke won't have been wasted.


i'm confident that's actually being reported... although it's worth noting that the userbase would never know for sure.

additionally, bort balancing things out takes a while... so when a teammate asks a tester whether they should plunk SP into juke, how does the tester answer? i'll bet dollars to dimes that the tester will tell the teammate to hold off for now ← unethical
 
Cactus71
offline
Link
 
this fucker exploded
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Animalmother
Solutions?
1) List or identify everyone with access
2) Give everyone access
3) Forbid anyone with access from also playing GLB
4) Allow everyone to "re-roll" and test builds
5) 100% Flex return for retiring anyone created before this point
6) Deny and downplay this whole thing and pray it goes away
7) ?



1 - Possible, but you'll probably find testers withdrawing rather than be "outed" and nobody ever willing to do it again.

2 - Not likely, that would require a server of equal capacity (if not more) to the current one if you're considering allowing everyone to build players/teams etc and sim games.

3 - Again you're likely just to get the Testers giving up the Testing capability. Why get punished for doing something for free?

4 - Not really much point. GLB has already established a build hierarchy. Presumably the testing is to identify the current issues and negotiate a way around them. Allowing everyone to re-roll and "test" (when test isn't anything definitive) doesn't achieve anything.

5 - I've always supported 100% Flex Back anyway. But then again I also supported reduced player costs and FP costs and was called MAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAD for suggesting it.

6 - This is nothing really, the vast majority wont care - a determined few (amongst whom are flamers and trolls undermining any efforts) may stick it out but eventually they have to decide whether the game is worth it to keep playing, or if they should jack it in.

7 - Everyone chils and considers that you don't send a train driver to test a plane, so why would you get an outside to test GLB? The "advantage" is the fact they're spending how much time of their existence on a test server, for free, presumably testing items for Borts benefit so that he can improve the server - not build designs so that they can improve their own players (which would require building and boosting identical players to your current lot, then editing them all and testing them in a game 5 or 6 times to get an idea of what may or may not be a good choice of development - whereas you could just put 15pts in speed and know that it definitely works anyway)..
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by jrry32

Now it can go wrong tpat if he sees that 10 in juke is WAY overpowered and decided to keep it to himself.


This assumes that the testers are selfish individuals and not interested in the development of the game though.


Pretty fair assumption if you know anything about people.
 
Mithra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by williamcohms

So I've been dumping SP into SA hoping they'll improve my elusive back adn someone else has the ability to go on a test server, max out juke, headfake, spin, and see instantly what the effect is?


Actually you have been dumping SP into SA hoping they'll improve your elusive back and a tester has the ability to go on a test server, max out juke, and if having juke at 10 with accompanying physical abilities doesn't seem to do much then he can tell bort and bort can balance out this aspect of HBs so the SP you spent in juke won't have been wasted.


I thought you couldn't tell anything from the limited testing you all did? I thought you couldn't tell what was up because of how difficult it is to simulate opposing teams? I thought only extreme builds could be tested? Is 10 juke and accompanying physical abilities extreme?
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Now it can go wrong tpat if he sees that 10 in juke is WAY overpowered and decided to keep it to himself.


I have a feeling that with the assumed small number of people in there, and that the games are probably watched by multiple people, with the builds definitely open, it'd get caught.
 
Drago
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by williamcohms

So I've been dumping SP into SA hoping they'll improve my elusive back adn someone else has the ability to go on a test server, max out juke, headfake, spin, and see instantly what the effect is?


Actually you have been dumping SP into SA hoping they'll improve your elusive back and a tester has the ability to go on a test server, max out juke, and if having juke at 10 with accompanying physical abilities doesn't seem to do much then he can tell bort and bort can balance out this aspect of HBs so the SP you spent in juke won't have been wasted.


...but until Bort gets around to doing that - the tester has a distinct advantage over you in player creation...

...of a HB in this "hypothetical" situation.
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by williamcohms
How long has this been going on? So it's possible my teams lost games because other people had better knowledge of how the game works?


Not only possible but most likely.
 
Banned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by williamcohms

How long has this been going on? So it's possible my teams lost games because other people had better knowledge of how the game works?


That is without a doubt the case.

However, is completely irrelevant.


WHAT? I FUCKIN PAY TO LOSE TO SOME GUY WHO GETS MONEY MAKING ME LOSE, NOW IM PISSED
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by jrry32

Now it can go wrong tpat if he sees that 10 in juke is WAY overpowered and decided to keep it to himself.


This assumes that the testers are selfish individuals and not interested in the development of the game though.


I base that assumption on basic human nature, Bort's not always such great choices of mods or admins and how much people want to win.
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Boltz
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by williamcohms


How long has this been going on? So it's possible my teams lost games because other people had better knowledge of how the game works?


That is without a doubt the case.

However, is completely irrelevant.


WHAT? I FUCKIN PAY TO LOSE TO SOME GUY WHO GETS MONEY MAKING ME LOSE, NOW IM PISSED


 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by jrry32

Now it can go wrong tpat if he sees that 10 in juke is WAY overpowered and decided to keep it to himself.


This assumes that the testers are selfish individuals and not interested in the development of the game though.


This assumes they are human. Its not like GLB has never seen mods push the envelope.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by jrry32

Now it can go wrong tpat if he sees that 10 in juke is WAY overpowered and decided to keep it to himself.


I have a feeling that with the assumed small number of people in there, and that the games are probably watched by multiple people, with the builds definitely open, it'd get caught.


Again, we don't know this though. We are both making assumptions.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by williamcohms
So I've been dumping SP into SA hoping they'll improve my elusive back adn someone else has the ability to go on a test server, max out juke, headfake, spin, and see instantly what the effect is?

Actually you have been dumping SP into SA hoping they'll improve your elusive back and a tester has the ability to go on a test server, max out juke, and if having juke at 10 with accompanying physical abilities doesn't seem to do much then he can tell bort and bort can balance out this aspect of HBs so the SP you spent in juke won't have been wasted.

...but until Bort gets around to doing that - the tester has a distinct advantage over you in player creation...
...of a HB in this "hypothetical" situation.


exactly.

crap, i just agreed with drago.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.