User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Steel_Destroyer
Defensive players should not get a free pass if they are built to be fast, agile and neglect tackling and strength. A true power back is likely to be in the 90's for strength, 60+ for agility, SAs and multipliers.

So, that would be a minimum of 150 points and likely more ... should a defensive player with a combined 90 points from strength and tackling be able to easily tackle the power back???

Teams need to be able to plan their gameplan accordingly. If your team is unable to stop a power running game, well, then either get players that can stop it or invest in equipment that makes their strength / tackling higher so that they can stop the power back. If you see the powerback is a threat one week and the elusive back is the threat the next week, then flex your equipment.

In the NFL, no team defense is the best to stop all offenses. NFL defenses are likely to be stronger against one form of offense and weaker against its opposite. Tampa Bay has traditionally been a defense that relied on speed. Speed is not always the answer to stop power running. During the last few weeks of Tampa's season, they were decimated by the run ... coaching issues?? not set to stop power running consistently?? not sure .. Tampa fans will have more insight regarding this. Steelers / Ravens ... traditionally strong against the run ... generally have strong tackling machines ... Ray Lewis ... Suggs ... Farrior ... Levon Kirkland ... Ngata ... Hampton ... would you classify these players as ones high speed / agility and a lack of tackling and strength?


Just curious, for the defensive players that are getting run over ... are they primarily speed players that have invested SA / AEQ / vet abilities into speed type skills and neglected tackling and strength?????


Very simple here. Would you pump your LBs confidence to 100 if 30 works fine? Lbs have been going speed because 50 tackling and 50 strength was enough to make almost every tackle. It isn't that people don't want to pump strength or tackling it just hadn't been needed up until this point.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by Steel_Destroyer

Defensive players should not get a free pass if they are built to be fast, agile and neglect tackling and strength. A true power back is likely to be in the 90's for strength, 60+ for agility, SAs and multipliers.

So, that would be a minimum of 150 points and likely more ... should a defensive player with a combined 90 points from strength and tackling be able to easily tackle the power back???

Teams need to be able to plan their gameplan accordingly. If your team is unable to stop a power running game, well, then either get players that can stop it or invest in equipment that makes their strength / tackling higher so that they can stop the power back. If you see the powerback is a threat one week and the elusive back is the threat the next week, then flex your equipment.

In the NFL, no team defense is the best to stop all offenses. NFL defenses are likely to be stronger against one form of offense and weaker against its opposite. Tampa Bay has traditionally been a defense that relied on speed. Speed is not always the answer to stop power running. During the last few weeks of Tampa's season, they were decimated by the run ... coaching issues?? not set to stop power running consistently?? not sure .. Tampa fans will have more insight regarding this. Steelers / Ravens ... traditionally strong against the run ... generally have strong tackling machines ... Ray Lewis ... Suggs ... Farrior ... Levon Kirkland ... Ngata ... Hampton ... would you classify these players as ones high speed / agility and a lack of tackling and strength?


Just curious, for the defensive players that are getting run over ... are they primarily speed players that have invested SA / AEQ / vet abilities into speed type skills and neglected tackling and strength?????


Very simple here. Would you pump your LBs confidence to 100 if 30 works fine? Lbs have been going speed because 50 tackling and 50 strength was enough to make almost every tackle. It isn't that people don't want to pump strength or tackling it just hadn't been needed up until this point.


Fine. But don't cry when it's no longer enough and you have to pump Strength and Tackling, though. People could have chosen to wait until after preseason to boost, if they wanted.
 
cbrown
offline
Link
 
stopping the guy should be broke down some. In the nfl a good LB will wrap him up and pull him down with the RB on gain a extra yard or 2 during the tackle, ocassionaly the LB get a really good hit and stops him in his tracks. A CB would tackle a RB but the RB would gain a extra 3 to 4 yards
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbrown
stopping the guy should be broke down some. In the nfl a good LB will wrap him up and pull him down with the RB on gain a extra yard or 2 during the tackle, ocassionaly the LB get a really good hit and stops him in his tracks. A CB would tackle a RB but the RB would gain a extra 3 to 4 yards


No...you actually need to be a very good tackler to tackle someone who's very hard to tackle at all. If he has Strength, plus good Carrying, plus very high power SA's, that means he knows how to get out of being tackled.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Originally posted by Steel_Destroyer


Defensive players should not get a free pass if they are built to be fast, agile and neglect tackling and strength. A true power back is likely to be in the 90's for strength, 60+ for agility, SAs and multipliers.

So, that would be a minimum of 150 points and likely more ... should a defensive player with a combined 90 points from strength and tackling be able to easily tackle the power back???

Teams need to be able to plan their gameplan accordingly. If your team is unable to stop a power running game, well, then either get players that can stop it or invest in equipment that makes their strength / tackling higher so that they can stop the power back. If you see the powerback is a threat one week and the elusive back is the threat the next week, then flex your equipment.

In the NFL, no team defense is the best to stop all offenses. NFL defenses are likely to be stronger against one form of offense and weaker against its opposite. Tampa Bay has traditionally been a defense that relied on speed. Speed is not always the answer to stop power running. During the last few weeks of Tampa's season, they were decimated by the run ... coaching issues?? not set to stop power running consistently?? not sure .. Tampa fans will have more insight regarding this. Steelers / Ravens ... traditionally strong against the run ... generally have strong tackling machines ... Ray Lewis ... Suggs ... Farrior ... Levon Kirkland ... Ngata ... Hampton ... would you classify these players as ones high speed / agility and a lack of tackling and strength?


Just curious, for the defensive players that are getting run over ... are they primarily speed players that have invested SA / AEQ / vet abilities into speed type skills and neglected tackling and strength?????


Very simple here. Would you pump your LBs confidence to 100 if 30 works fine? Lbs have been going speed because 50 tackling and 50 strength was enough to make almost every tackle. It isn't that people don't want to pump strength or tackling it just hadn't been needed up until this point.


Fine. But don't cry when it's no longer enough and you have to pump Strength and Tackling, though. People could have chosen to wait until after preseason to boost, if they wanted.


Oh wait, you want DEs nerfed because it is unrealistic but you want powerbacks that break 25 tackles a game?
 
Steel ~Cult~ure
Y Not....
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by Steel_Destroyer

Defensive players should not get a free pass if they are built to be fast, agile and neglect tackling and strength. A true power back is likely to be in the 90's for strength, 60+ for agility, SAs and multipliers.

So, that would be a minimum of 150 points and likely more ... should a defensive player with a combined 90 points from strength and tackling be able to easily tackle the power back???

Teams need to be able to plan their gameplan accordingly. If your team is unable to stop a power running game, well, then either get players that can stop it or invest in equipment that makes their strength / tackling higher so that they can stop the power back. If you see the powerback is a threat one week and the elusive back is the threat the next week, then flex your equipment.

In the NFL, no team defense is the best to stop all offenses. NFL defenses are likely to be stronger against one form of offense and weaker against its opposite. Tampa Bay has traditionally been a defense that relied on speed. Speed is not always the answer to stop power running. During the last few weeks of Tampa's season, they were decimated by the run ... coaching issues?? not set to stop power running consistently?? not sure .. Tampa fans will have more insight regarding this. Steelers / Ravens ... traditionally strong against the run ... generally have strong tackling machines ... Ray Lewis ... Suggs ... Farrior ... Levon Kirkland ... Ngata ... Hampton ... would you classify these players as ones high speed / agility and a lack of tackling and strength?


Just curious, for the defensive players that are getting run over ... are they primarily speed players that have invested SA / AEQ / vet abilities into speed type skills and neglected tackling and strength?????


Very simple here. Would you pump your LBs confidence to 100 if 30 works fine? Lbs have been going speed because 50 tackling and 50 strength was enough to make almost every tackle. It isn't that people don't want to pump strength or tackling it just hadn't been needed up until this point.


They can adjust by flexing their equipment from speed to strength / tackling when going against a power running back and back against speed elusive backs ... if going against a dual threat, then either pick your poison or balance between the 2 skills
 
Spirer
offline
Link
 
Just wanted to note that there is no way to match defense players to offensive ones or to field the "right" LB or Safety to stop the power back when he is on. With this in mind, defense players are more balanced than offense players and usually need more attributes, while offense ones tend to be more focused. Defense also tires faster.

So I'm hopping people will be reasonable, since expecting the defense guys to have the same levels on skills or special abilities will lead to offense having a big advantage.
 
ruleslawyer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Steel_Destroyer
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Originally posted by Steel_Destroyer


Defensive players should not get a free pass if they are built to be fast, agile and neglect tackling and strength. A true power back is likely to be in the 90's for strength, 60+ for agility, SAs and multipliers.

So, that would be a minimum of 150 points and likely more ... should a defensive player with a combined 90 points from strength and tackling be able to easily tackle the power back???

Teams need to be able to plan their gameplan accordingly. If your team is unable to stop a power running game, well, then either get players that can stop it or invest in equipment that makes their strength / tackling higher so that they can stop the power back. If you see the powerback is a threat one week and the elusive back is the threat the next week, then flex your equipment.

In the NFL, no team defense is the best to stop all offenses. NFL defenses are likely to be stronger against one form of offense and weaker against its opposite. Tampa Bay has traditionally been a defense that relied on speed. Speed is not always the answer to stop power running. During the last few weeks of Tampa's season, they were decimated by the run ... coaching issues?? not set to stop power running consistently?? not sure .. Tampa fans will have more insight regarding this. Steelers / Ravens ... traditionally strong against the run ... generally have strong tackling machines ... Ray Lewis ... Suggs ... Farrior ... Levon Kirkland ... Ngata ... Hampton ... would you classify these players as ones high speed / agility and a lack of tackling and strength?


Just curious, for the defensive players that are getting run over ... are they primarily speed players that have invested SA / AEQ / vet abilities into speed type skills and neglected tackling and strength?????


Very simple here. Would you pump your LBs confidence to 100 if 30 works fine? Lbs have been going speed because 50 tackling and 50 strength was enough to make almost every tackle. It isn't that people don't want to pump strength or tackling it just hadn't been needed up until this point.


They can adjust by flexing their equipment from speed to strength / tackling when going against a power running back and back against speed elusive backs ... if going against a dual threat, then either pick your poison or balance between the 2 skills


agreed

Because the depth charts/tactics and AI are locked in, all the elements of mismatches and surprise are 100% in favor of the offense.
 
WINTYWINTY
offline
Link
 
IRL, the DL has great strength and less tackiling, just because there is always someome behind them to still make the tackle, so maybe 50 tackling and anywhere from 70-90 strength.

For LB's, they need good tackling, but they still have good strength, so maybe 55-60 tackling with 60-70 strength.

CB's rarely need to tackle power backs, because they run up the middle, and they really don't use strength as much as DL or LB, so maybe 40-50 strength and probably 70 tackling
 
Chevy
offline
Link
 
Lots of variables.

To me ... Technique is key. How a tackle is made is just as important as the overall strength of the tackler. A 300lb DT will bury you with weight and pure power. A linebacker will use speed and strength to drive through and wrap-up. A corner will most likely use speed and agility to cut your legs out from under you.
 
Bill Jack
offline
Link
 
Watch AD truck Al Harris and decide what Al needed.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MozIVCW9Vo0

 
ruleslawyer
offline
Link
 
He did indeed get trucked.... Play ended 2 yards later though.
 
Gott
offline
Link
 
Let me summarize the 1.5k + posts.

I have a power back.

"I think you need an exorbitant amount of tackling, strength, agility, vision, confidence and speed to take down this back."


I have defensive players that have high speed and have ignored strength and tackling, as they've been completely worthless, since wrap-up tackling is too good.

"I think speed should be half of the equation, and only soft capped (48) tackling and strength are required to tackle this back."
Last edited Jan 1, 2009 02:16:00
 
Katarn2000x
offline
Link
 
The problem is to have a good, solid system of tackling, you'd have to allow every player to be critically rebuilt.

For example, for the back in question a really sensical amount to surely tackle this back would be about:

100 strength
80 tackling

to guarantee a tackle every time. But have it linear, so if he has

70 strength, 55 tackling

he'll tackle about 70% of the time, and so on.

But the problem is, after having 6 seasons of tackling and strength being effectively useless in any decent amount for the majority of players, you'd HAVE to allow them to rebuild their players, otherwise the ones lucky enough to have a decent build with the new functionality of the game will gain a massive advantage until the unlucky agents start from the beginning.
 
Hukton Vioxx
offline
Link
 
It should be a viable gameplan option to run right at a DE who is built purely to rush the QB and have the ROT push him backwards all the time.

On the flip side, it is hard to keep defenders from even grabbing at a RB without holding. A really strong tackler is not going to let a guy go right buy him all the time, and if the ball carrier is significantly weaker, the defender should have a decent chance of stopping him with just an arm tackle. This would also make things like chop blocks more important, since they essentially take the defender out of the play for a couple seconds, and can spring a RB.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.