User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Sorting promoting teams by record this season?
Page:
 
Triple_A
offline
Link
 
Hello Bort, Honestly, Championship teams should have moved up 3 caps. This would allow more competition and put most of the so called SSB teams 3 caps higher. The current method means you will face these championship teams every season SSB or not.
This would of been the easiest solution and the fairest
 
czman
offline
Link
 
This looks like it has turned into a rage fest, surprise.....surprise.

Anyway I have a somewhat useful idea that should help solve the basic problem with this new structure.

Bort's solutions "works" for one season.

Next season teams that were not very good but got put in really bad leagues will be put in leagues that have teams that went 18-2 in great leagues. Moreover, good teams that miss the playoffs will get placed with terrible teams that missed the playoffs in terrible leagues.

This is one of those systems that was not thought through and will get worse and worse as times wears on.

A believe that it makes sense to change the system to something like this.

Example:

League 22 cap #1 and league 22 cap #2 Take all of the playoff teams that promote from both of those leagues and stick them together in league 30 cap #1. This keeps leagues balanced and keeps rivalries in place.

or

take everyone from league 22 cap #1 who makes the playoffs and everyone from league cap 26 #1 and move them to 30 cap #1.

you are obviously going to have some filling to do because of gutted teams and teams that promote 3 caps but that can be worked out depending on how many teams select those options.

Inherently the system in place is going to destroy teams that are not that good but get stuck win because of their leagues and promote to leagues filled with great teams.

It is also going to be an awful solution when teams in great leagues that miss the playoffs get struck with a bunch of people that fail in bad leagues. Those leagues are going to be the worst leagues ever created.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman


Bort, you know I'm normally in favor of your moves. Bukowski is often against them, so he gets flagged as a bit of a malcontent and an over reactor. But he's right on this one. Teams don't deserve to go 14-2 or better, they deserve to win as many games as their roster dictates. In your new structure, if I'm understanding it, you're giving crap teams artificial wins by putting them with other crap teams. 38 capped leagues should all contain the same level of competition, because they're all equal at 38 capped teams. By sorting this way, the last 38 capped league really isn't 38 capped, it's probably more like a 32 cap with a few higher levels strewn about. Teams that don't try don't deserve to have winning seasons, but if you bundle 32 teams who don't try together, 16 of them have to make the playoffs.
The 9th best team in League 1 is getting screwed out of the playoffs, while the 33rd best team in a given level cap is being given an easy trophy.
 
DigitalDaggers
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
You aren't affected by this AT ALL.


his opinion is as valid as yours, fwiw
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
FYP


If you were snake drafting the leagues before, it was a constipated snake. Cap 30#4 last season was a very well balanced league, with 8 teams who legitimately had a chance to make the title game.

Very few, if any, of the other Cap 30's could make that claim. But there were no purely crap teams winning Cap 30 or 31 titles last season. There will be at least 4-5 of them winning Cap 38 titles...
 
Eamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski


If they constantly lose and suck, they're much more likely to quit the game for good.


So why is this a horrible idea if it's trying to get new players to stay longer? Do you want all these new players to quit before they get to their 40s?

I don't personally like it either, but ffs stop complaining about every change ever made. Have there been awful decisions made? Sure. Have there been excellent decisions made? Sure. How would you like to go back to the Season 1-2 sim?

Damn, man. Realize that Bort and DD are "The Man" and if you want to continue playing this game they created you are gonna have to go along with some changes even if they aren't the greatest ideas in our mind.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by pottsman

You did that? They seemed pretty random.


Yep, CPU teams were attempted to be as evenly distributed as possible, etc. The problems we always run into that people sell after the fact or have empty rosters after winning, or cut everyone and start over without demoting. Things like that screw the pooch no matter what we do. The more we spread out the lesser teams the more likely everyone is going to run into it.


See, you missed half my point. Evenly distribute the GOOD teams, too, is what I was saying.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Yep, CPU teams were attempted to be as evenly distributed as possible, etc.

Pottsman's idea wasn't just dealing with CPUs, however. He suggested a snake draft of all teams in that tier. So instead of taking the 32 best records and putting them in the same league, you'd assign them consecutively to league #1, #2, #3, etc on down the line. So that way you are distributing talent in a way that promotes competition without keeping all the top teams together.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DigitalDaggers
Originally posted by Bukowski

You aren't affected by this AT ALL.


his opinion is as valid as yours, fwiw


Except that my team is directly affected, but yeah, whatever.
 
Judan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
You aren't affected by this AT ALL.


I was just moved to a 38 cap as DDL demoted from Pro.

Although, according to you, we suck because we're in #6.

 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Yep, CPU teams were attempted to be as evenly distributed as possible, etc. The problems we always run into that people sell after the fact or have empty rosters after winning, or cut everyone and start over without demoting. Things like that screw the pooch no matter what we do. The more we spread out the lesser teams the more likely everyone is going to run into it.


You start at the top, not the bottom. CPU's will always be with us. So will bad teams. As long as the leagues are equalized across a cap, the best teams will eventually find each other in Pro.
 
DarthVisor
offline
Link
 
This is just bad.... HATE IT HATE IT HATE IT!

 
calamnet
offline
Link
 
Just an opinion, but the champ teams probably should of moved up 3 caps.

Now that the structure is done, my team will not only be facing the same team from last season in the same conference, a 3-year SSB team, but I'm guessing there are others. Kind of a big waste of my time at the moment.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shield.bearer
Originally posted by Bort

Yep, CPU teams were attempted to be as evenly distributed as possible, etc. The problems we always run into that people sell after the fact or have empty rosters after winning, or cut everyone and start over without demoting. Things like that screw the pooch no matter what we do. The more we spread out the lesser teams the more likely everyone is going to run into it.


You start at the top, not the bottom. CPU's will always be with us. So will bad teams. As long as the leagues are equalized across a cap, the best teams will eventually find each other in Pro.


Right.

And I don't know about everyone else, but I really don't have time to sit and game-plan every single fucking game. Which, honestly, will probably leave me to not game-planning for any of them.

This makes the good teams less likely to enjoy the game, but increases the fun for the shit teams/owners.

Bravo Bort, you've done it again. Reward the weak, punish the strong.
 
Ryiotgear
offline
Link
 
Why not just promote more teams upward from the left side of the pyramid (i.e. the good leagues) and promote teams to the left horizontally from the right side (i.e. the bad leagues). That eliminates the best of the worst being promoted upwards.

You could classify leagues horiztonally among gold, silver, bronze or something so only those on the left side (i.e. gold leagues) are eligible to promote upward.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.