User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
PsychoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
After like 6 seasons of people obviously seeing an x-factor, glad to see this got fixed in an appropriate time frame...../sarcasm


this fix doesn't fix an x-factor tbh
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PsychoMan
Originally posted by britdevine316

After like 6 seasons of people obviously seeing an x-factor, glad to see this got fixed in an appropriate time frame...../sarcasm


this fix doesn't fix an x-factor tbh


This seems to affect only the speed based "x-factor" claims. But there are many others out there. Tackle-breaking on combo backs, guys with average catching who are mini-Cris Carters, etc.
 
PsychoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joe Buck
This seems to affect only the speed based "x-factor" claims. But there are many others out there. Tackle-breaking on combo backs, guys with average catching who are mini-Cris Carters, etc.


weight affects more than just speed.

besides, my point was it's not an x-factor 'fix' because the x-factor we are talking about is consistently shown on the same players. the fix he talks about doesn't make sense that the bug would always show up on the same player.
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
It would affect the same player if it was a corrupt database entry for their weight.
 
PsychoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joe Buck
It would affect the same player if it was a corrupt database entry for their weight.


:wall:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Tony Dungy

If he doesn't have something like that in there, it would be possible for someone's script to get EXACT numbers on what attributes cause what to happen. He might as well give all the formulas away. Deathblade gets closer and closer every day.

This game is becoming more about who has the best programmer rather than being a fun football game imo.


There is nothing wrong with randomness from play to play, on each play there should be various 'rolls' affected by player attributes/SA/VAs, etc, these rolls all involve randomness which is a good thing as there needs to be some randomness. What is not a good idea is to have two players, each with the exact same build, and one consistently outperforms the other. Again these are just my opinions, maybe some people including Bort think that there would good to incorporate a random hidden attribute on player creation that dictates if he will be a superstar or not.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Only thing that bothers me about the whole thing is the word "unfixable". Never heard of the word. Everything is fixable, it's just sometimes the fix isn't exactly what we envision.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
I'm gonna move this one to Bugs since this is where testing was already going on for what's been realized to be a bug. If the fix which was put in place did not resolve the issue, please feel free to use this thread for continued testing and/or adding to proof of the bug.
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PsychoMan
Originally posted by Joe Buck

It would affect the same player if it was a corrupt database entry for their weight.


:wall:


:break thru: it's plausible. the dirt on the CD analogy.
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

If 99.99% of players are differentiated on the basis of their builds, but 0.01% have something special randomly attached to them at creation, you don't think people would create endless amounts of players and boost them in hopes of finding out that they possess the mysterious X-factor? It's only because of DB's script that it became possible to identify anomalies, and to do so early enough to potentially avoid boosting non-X players.


create, test, and retire maybe. that's not extra revenue for Bort.
and at what risk, people finding out and getting fed up and Bort LOSING revenue.
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
You say that but even today Bort was trying to promote the idea of hidden attributes and how much he loves the idea of certain players showing up big in certain situations.


in certain situations. My entire point is that Bort loves randomness in certain situations, but having pre-defined great players is the exact opposite. That is EVERY situation.

If you can PREDICT who is going to have that great "moment" it isn't random anymore.
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
Originally posted by PierreThomas

You say that but even today Bort was trying to promote the idea of hidden attributes and how much he loves the idea of certain players showing up big in certain situations.


in certain situations. My entire point is that Bort loves randomness in certain situations, but having pre-defined great players is the exact opposite. That is EVERY situation.

If you can PREDICT who is going to have that great "moment" it isn't random anymore.


and like i mentioned earlier, it is certainly not outside the realm of possibility that Bort's coded in random greatness actually acts in a way that is more like constant greatness. There's about two dozen examples of that elsewhere in the sim, that eventually got fixed due to transparency (which this obviously cannot have).
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Also this would seem to explain (if the error were consistently to a player) why certain OL just seem to be pancake monsters despite having nothing in Pancake SA, not very strong, and not particularly heavy. Weight transfer error reading too high.

Then others that are heavy, tons in Pancake, etc, barely getting any.

Hmmmm.
Edited by Joe Buck on Sep 2, 2009 08:13:30
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned

Originally posted by jdbolick
If 99.99% of players are differentiated on the basis of their builds, but 0.01% have something special randomly attached to them at creation, you don't think people would create endless amounts of players and boost them in hopes of finding out that they possess the mysterious X-factor? It's only because of DB's script that it became possible to identify anomalies, and to do so early enough to potentially avoid boosting non-X players.

create, test, and retire maybe. that's not extra revenue for Bort.
and at what risk, people finding out and getting fed up and Bort LOSING revenue.

Create, boost, and retire. Remember, for 10 seasons people couldn't tell if their players had an X-factor until late in their career, even then it was largely supposition, and despite many threats I don't know of anyone who actually did quit because of the evidence supporting the existence of an X-factor. Moreover, when it only affects one player out of every 1,000 or 10,000, then there isn't as much sense of injustice that your player didn't get "it." Instead people will be inclined to create and boost more players to chase that "it." In fact, would it really be that different from being the lucky person who hit a +3 strength, +1 Power Through piece?
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
Maybe you are seeing users behaving differently than I do. I don't think the public starting to notice random players performing great for no logical reason would cause an increase in revenue, I think it would cause a decrease in revenue. Oh wait, this already happened? And I've heard multiple "I'm sick of this, not spending more money" and not a peep of "I'm going to spend a bazillion flex to get an x-factor!!11!" and this whole thing turned out to be a bust anyway.

And finding a great piece shopping is an option for everybody, and while luck is involved, at least you know when you got it, pay for the thrill of finding it, and the advantage of such a piece really isn't THAT huge when you compare it to the baseline of that most other players got something at least similar to that piece.

Bort loves random, but on the micro-level.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.