User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by wombat killer

When were those reference to testers made?

Two I found with a quick search: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1935499
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2057498

Originally posted by wombat killer

You may think not supposed to be public is not hiding, but don't project your flawed logic on the rest of us.

It doesn't. If one wants to assert that not telling something = deliberately withholding, then the burden of proof is on them.

Also, and more to the point, tpat != Bort. Moderators are not admins (and other admins aren't Bort, tbh), nor do they speak for Bort.


Seriously? That is what you are going with? Just the mention of testers and tests?
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
I wouldn't say that just because a tester is on a team that they automatically give out information.


Why not? They spend money too. It's more unreasonable to believe they would rather purposefully disadvantage themselves by not using the information that they learned on the test server than to give themselves an advantage. I doubt the testers like throwing money away.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Either way, while I can't even begin to fathom the stupidity in this original decision, and how it wasn't predicted that it would leak almost immediately and people would invariably start a shit storm, that can't be changed.

However, things that are discovered by the testers need to somehow be made public now. It should not be up to the testers to decide who gets the privileged info that they obtain. I'm all for making the game better but it can't be done in this kind of secretive manner. It should continue but me much more transparent. Maybe even the builds of testers' players should be mandated to be open. But it can't be left so that all the things testers learn are just candy for them to dole out as they please.
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1

But if they ever talk to any non-tester about player builds or tactics (or set AIs), wouldn't it be nearly impossible to prevent information that they learned from getting out as it informs what they say about the game (they can't unknow it).


And what if a tester is an Offensive Coordinator for a team? Are we to believe that he will deliberately choose an inferior gameplan to avoid using the knowledge he gained from testing? Is it even reasonable to think that people can make that distinction?
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Either way, while I can't even begin to fathom the stupidity in this original decision, and how it wasn't predicted that it would leak almost immediately and people would invariably start a shit storm, that can't be changed.

However, things that are discovered by the testers need to somehow be made public now. It should not be up to the testers to decide who gets the privileged info that they obtain. I'm all for making the game better but it can't be done in this kind of secretive manner. It should continue but me much more transparent. Maybe even the builds of testers' players should be mandated to be open. But it can't be left so that all the things testers learn are just candy for them to dole out as they please.


Exactly.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TerrellOwns
Originally posted by Gyuri1


But if they ever talk to any non-tester about player builds or tactics (or set AIs), wouldn't it be nearly impossible to prevent information that they learned from getting out as it informs what they say about the game (they can't unknow it).


And what if a tester is an Offensive Coordinator for a team? Are we to believe that he will deliberately choose an inferior gameplan to avoid using the knowledge he gained from testing? Is it even reasonable to think that people can make that distinction?


No one wants to even focus on this. All they want to talk about is bugs and exploits that are found. It would be hard to imagine that in the course of testing for bugs and exploits that other useful information is not learned.

Is that information available to the public? Perhaps. Over a long time frame. Or many players. And much flex points.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Your middle point is incorrect. People ARE being cheated. Some of them may not feel cheated, and that's good, imo, but they ARE being cheated. They're having others be given a secretive advantage by the administration, thus undermining their own efforts to improve/win.

Analogy time: say you take a shit, and someone comes by and makes off with your doogie howser for stool research. Now, you could techincally get upset and say that he stole something from you, but, if you looked at it rationally, you would realize that he stole a pile of shit from you, and he might figure out why your large intestine is bleeding, and you might not be so pissed off.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 16:25:45
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
I just want to jump in and say that it's ridiculous to expect people to turn in their sources.

Hypothetically, if i were to turn in my source of inside information what does that solve? I no longer have access to the info, but others do. Unless we can ensure that all leakers are going to be removed from the test server, expecting anybody to turn in their own source (while plenty of others still exist, helping their competition) is absurd.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TerrellOwns

And what if a tester is an Offensive Coordinator for a team? Are we to believe that he will deliberately choose an inferior gameplan to avoid using the knowledge he gained from testing? Is it even reasonable to think that people can make that distinction?


This -- TO makes an excellent point here... THIS is the reason people are pissed off.

Edit: and OC is just ONE example of countless...

DC, Build suggesting...etc..
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 16:27:56
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Seriously? That is what you are going with? Just the mention of testers and tests?

Um, yeah? I said he'd made mention of it, then linked threads where he made mention of it.

Not sure where the breakdown is there.
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by Darkus Black

I wouldn't say that just because a tester is on a team that they automatically give out information.


But if they ever talk to any non-tester about player builds or tactics (or set AIs), wouldn't it be nearly impossible to prevent information that they learned from getting out as it informs what they say about the game (they can't unknow it).


I see your point but there are SO many variables in this game that I don't think people are realising the extent to which someone would have to go to to find everything that works for every player. Just trying to find out what works for one position would take hours and hours of work. Not withstanding the hours of work going into testing formations, tactics, etc. Also taking into account opposition builds and the correlation between those and the setup that you have. Then you have to get that information out into the general populace without it being know that you are doing it. This is the biggest problem with conspiracies, they are such huge operations.

Let's say Mike decides to exploit the test server and finds something. He keeps it to himself and leaves the exploit open. He then tells his team what to do. With the cross pollination of GLB it would be around the forums in hours.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
With the cross pollination of GLB it would be around the forums in hours.

So it's all ok because some people might learn about it anyway? Wow.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black

Let's say Mike decides to exploit the test server and finds something. He keeps it to himself and leaves the exploit open. He then tells his team what to do. With the cross pollination of GLB it would be around the forums in hours.



I think you are full of it, personally.....I snipped a lot out of your quote...but with mods locking every thread mentioning testing, this wouldn't happen..

And trying to say that people wouldnt use the information gained from test servers...come on...are you serious?

edit: it sounds like you are just blindly justifying this, without any thought to what harm it is doing
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 16:30:36
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Darkus Black

I wouldn't say that just because a tester is on a team that they automatically give out information.


Why not? They spend money too. It's more unreasonable to believe they would rather purposefully disadvantage themselves by not using the information that they learned on the test server than to give themselves an advantage. I doubt the testers like throwing money away.


People judge people by their own standards.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by awesome

Originally posted by Darkus Black


I wouldn't say that just because a tester is on a team that they automatically give out information.


Why not? They spend money too. It's more unreasonable to believe they would rather purposefully disadvantage themselves by not using the information that they learned on the test server than to give themselves an advantage. I doubt the testers like throwing money away.


People judge people by their own standards.


Avoiding the question doesn't negate it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.