User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by iMan

Originally posted by TuNice


Originally posted by iMan



IRL, the most important thing you need to make a good tackle is CONFIDENCE


that is actually true lol


thank you.
you ever see those guys that always go for you feet?
and then those monsters that jsut drop their pads and nail you to the ground?
the first one is scared of being hurt and the second one is about to hurt you


No one can lower their pads if the guys dives at the feet, they may just get run over because he's moving to fast to trip up or wrap up by the legs but the best place to hit a very big, strong back is in the side of the knee or shin, you'll get them almost everytime.


I've seen Mike Sellers' 33 year old, 285 pound fulback ass jump over CB's who were going at his thighs multiple times. If you go at Marion Barber's shins, that's going to happen a lot unless you do it perfectly (right timing etc)... it isn't just about throwing yourself on the ground and waiting for him to trip over you, or touching his ankle so he falls down. These guys make a living running. They are good at running. They will run through or over you even if you grab their ankle, a lot of the time.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by Bort



How do you define "elusive" or "power" back for this, though? Just based on their running style?


Well, elusive broken tackles and power broken tackles are calculated differently ain't they? Maybe it should be "power moves" and "elusive moves" instead of "power/elusive back".


Elusive guys don't really break tackles except for spinning - they avoid contact entirely with fakes and such. Breaking tackles is a power back thing.

Maybe just

Power: more likely to get fooled by head fake/juke/spin
Wrap: more likely to get trucked


+1.

And one of the big problems is that the tackling system as a whol eneeds to be altered.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
This game is already ridiculously biased toward offense and now we're debating making EVERY defender get their tackling skill over 60 just to bring someone down? So, now in order to tackle someone, you have to make yourself dreadfully slow, inagile, or lacking vision.


The point is, every defender SHOULD NOT BE ABLE TO bring everyone down all the time. A CB missing tackles on a RB is okay. So if he wants to be able to do that, he should have to sacrifice some speed etc. and not be as good in coverage.
 
NWWarrior
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Deathblade


Originally posted by Bort




How do you define "elusive" or "power" back for this, though? Just based on their running style?


Well, elusive broken tackles and power broken tackles are calculated differently ain't they? Maybe it should be "power moves" and "elusive moves" instead of "power/elusive back".


Elusive guys don't really break tackles except for spinning - they avoid contact entirely with fakes and such. Breaking tackles is a power back thing.

Maybe just

Power: more likely to get fooled by head fake/juke/spin
Wrap: more likely to get trucked


+1.

And one of the big problems is that the tackling system as a whole needs to be altered.


With all the focus power back owners are justifying the over powered players, Azure points out that Bort clearly says that elusive backs in the GLB dont break tackles by DESIGN...well, there are plenty of elusive type backs in the NFL that do indeed break many tackles, IE Frank Gore, Bradshaw, Tomlinson, A Peterson, Lynch, Portis, Drew, Parker, Taylor, Jones...we could go on forever.

So instead of justifying the power backs with Brandon Jacobs and the 5+ broken tackles a power back gets on some plays right now in the GLB by using the NFL as proof. Remember that the elusive performs nothing like he should in the GLB.
Last edited Dec 31, 2008 12:33:52
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Most of those guys aren't elusive backs, you know....

Gore, Lynch, Jones-Drew, they're all actually POWER backs. Probably Taylor as well.

Portis and Peterson are hybrids.

I rarely see Parker or Bradshaw break tackles.

Jones? Julius? He hasn't broken a tackle in years.
 
NWWarrior
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Most of those guys aren't elusive backs, you know....

Gore, Lynch, Jones-Drew, they're all actually POWER backs. Probably Taylor as well.

Portis and Peterson are hybrids.

I rarely see Parker or Bradshaw break tackles.

Jones? Julius? He hasn't broken a tackle in years.


dont agree at all...Gore is not a power back nor is Portis and taylor makes people miss all the time and does not power thru people....and Jones (LOL) I meant Thomas
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NWWarrior


dont agree at all...Gore is not a power back nor is Portis and taylor makes people miss all the time and does not power thru people....and Jones (LOL) I meant Thomas


Gore is definately a Power back.

Portis is more of a combo back, although a high percentage of his runs are between the tackles.

Taylor is definately an elusive back.

Thomas Jones was an elusive back early in his career. He is more of a combo back now that he's older.



 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Power back doesn't mean where you run.
 
Rainey
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by iMan
Originally posted by Deathblade

Power Tackling
Pros:
Effective at stopping Powerbacks in their tracks.
Causes more fumbles.

Cons:
More likely to get faked out by elusive backs
More likely to miss tackles against elusive backs

Wrap-Up
Pros:
Effective against elusive backs
High tackle rate

Cons:
More likely to get plowed over by power backs, giving them an extra yard or two
More likely to miss tackles against power backs


By wraping up you will certainly bring a powerback down. you may be run over but you will bring him down.
trust me



Just because you are trying to wrap up, doesn't mean you will though. Trust me.
 
imaking
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hixtrix
I'm pretty sure this is what Bort had in mind when the changes were made: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=351369&pbp_id=599048


hahaha
 
NWWarrior
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Power back doesn't mean where you run.


correct...it is about style!

Gore makes people miss all the time, thats his style, elusive. Jacobs looks to punish you as he runs thats his style, power.
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by imaking
Originally posted by hixtrix

I'm pretty sure this is what Bort had in mind when the changes were made: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=351369&pbp_id=599048


hahaha


Yea, this should never happen. Even as a level 40 vs. level 20's with 20 STR/Tkl 20's

The game needs a huge hit to breaking tackles after you have just broken a tackle for x amount of ticks.
 
Steel ~Cult~ure
Y Not....
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?

I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."

I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.


For a straight up tackle:

I think it should boil down to point totals:
Power Running Back: 100 (strength) + 60 (agility) + 35 (0.5*Carrying) + corresponding multipliers from SA / VA / %
= 195 + corresponding multipliers from SA / VA / %
Defender making tackle needs to have a similar total in skills needed to tackle in order to have a 50/50 chance for tackling straight up

For a diving tackle:
Defenders total of skills that contribute to diving tackle should be 60% of the above total for a 50/50 chance for tackling.


For an immediate straight up tackle following a previous tackle attempt:
There should be a % reduction in the power back point total depending on how long after the 1st hit was made. A tackle attempt immediately after the 1st one should have a greater chance than a tackle made later after the power back has regained his momentum. There should be a susceptibility % to be tackled at this point that decreases with time after the prior tackle attempt.

For gang tackle:
The defenders should be able to add their points together if they are not engaged with another offensive player blocking them. The addition should be a multiplier instead of accumulative.


For a tackler that is engaged with a offensive player blocking
The tackler should have a reduction in point total in his ability to tackle. The amount or % of reduction should be impacted by how good of a blocker the engaged offensive player is.

Last edited Dec 31, 2008 16:39:37
 
Steel ~Cult~ure
Y Not....
offline
Link
 
Defensive players should not get a free pass if they are built to be fast, agile and neglect tackling and strength. A true power back is likely to be in the 90's for strength, 60+ for agility, SAs and multipliers.

So, that would be a minimum of 150 points and likely more ... should a defensive player with a combined 90 points from strength and tackling be able to easily tackle the power back???

Teams need to be able to plan their gameplan accordingly. If your team is unable to stop a power running game, well, then either get players that can stop it or invest in equipment that makes their strength / tackling higher so that they can stop the power back. If you see the powerback is a threat one week and the elusive back is the threat the next week, then flex your equipment.

In the NFL, no team defense is the best to stop all offenses. NFL defenses are likely to be stronger against one form of offense and weaker against its opposite. Tampa Bay has traditionally been a defense that relied on speed. Speed is not always the answer to stop power running. During the last few weeks of Tampa's season, they were decimated by the run ... coaching issues?? not set to stop power running consistently?? not sure .. Tampa fans will have more insight regarding this. Steelers / Ravens ... traditionally strong against the run ... generally have strong tackling machines ... Ray Lewis ... Suggs ... Farrior ... Levon Kirkland ... Ngata ... Hampton ... would you classify these players as ones high speed / agility and a lack of tackling and strength?


Just curious, for the defensive players that are getting run over ... are they primarily speed players that have invested SA / AEQ / vet abilities into speed type skills and neglected tackling and strength?????
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Here is my opinion and it is quite simple.




The same amount as it did last season, maybe just a tad bit more. You can't make a power back useless in season 6 and make him superman in season 7 when it would take a high level LB with 50 strength and tackling an entire season to get both up to the next cap.

If you want to make wholesale changes to something as important as tackling then you should make an announcement in advance like you did with agility back in season 4.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.