User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Sorting promoting teams by record this season?
Page:
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Bukowski

Bort, you just want these shitty teams to feel like they're doing something, so they continue to line your pockets.


You'd rather play CPU's, gutjobs, and mediocre teams, with 1-2 real opponents per season?

You're basically saying you deserve to always go 14-2 or better, and we have to take the teams that can't get over the hump and throw them like lambs to the slaughter for the benefit of the currently better teams. It's not fun to be one of those teams. They can never win and pull themselves out of the gutter. Most of them quit before they can make it to AA and start at least getting media revenue. Maybe if we can give them a chance to build themselves up, there would be some more legit competition and we wouldn't have so few truly good teams.

Nah, other people who play GLB don't count. Only the current top teams matter. Those other teams simply exist to prop up other teams and deserve no consideration at all.


Bort, you know I'm normally in favor of your moves. Bukowski is often against them, so he gets flagged as a bit of a malcontent and an over reactor. But he's right on this one. Teams don't deserve to go 14-2 or better, they deserve to win as many games as their roster dictates. In your new structure, if I'm understanding it, you're giving crap teams artificial wins by putting them with other crap teams. 38 capped leagues should all contain the same level of competition, because they're all equal at 38 capped teams. By sorting this way, the last 38 capped league really isn't 38 capped, it's probably more like a 32 cap with a few higher levels strewn about. Teams that don't try don't deserve to have winning seasons, but if you bundle 32 teams who don't try together, 16 of them have to make the playoffs.
The 9th best team in League 1 is getting screwed out of the playoffs, while the 33rd best team in a given level cap is being given an easy trophy.
 
DigitalDaggers
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
as a side note - with all of this discussion going on - I have to revisit a thread I made a few weeks ago - what is MONEY (in game money) really adding to GLB?


seems like a lot of the unhappy folks here are unhappy about the lost revenue; ticket sales; playoff revenue and fan support.

i've yet to see a compelling reason why in game money should be in the game - as i think it brings a lot more negatives than positives (not to mention the rich get incredibly richer aspect)


we will be working on things for players to buy, and fleshing out the in-game economy
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by jdbolick

Originally posted by shield.bearer


I think this is the best answer. Snake draft the teams to fill the leagues just like you used to do because it created a ton of parity.






FYP
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Bukowski


Bort, you just want these shitty teams to feel like they're doing something, so they continue to line your pockets.


You'd rather play CPU's, gutjobs, and mediocre teams, with 1-2 real opponents per season?

You're basically saying you deserve to always go 14-2 or better, and we have to take the teams that can't get over the hump and throw them like lambs to the slaughter for the benefit of the currently better teams. It's not fun to be one of those teams. They can never win and pull themselves out of the gutter. Most of them quit before they can make it to AA and start at least getting media revenue. Maybe if we can give them a chance to build themselves up, there would be some more legit competition and we wouldn't have so few truly good teams.

Nah, other people who play GLB don't count. Only the current top teams matter. Those other teams simply exist to prop up other teams and deserve no consideration at all.


Bort, you know I'm normally in favor of your moves. Bukowski is often against them, so he gets flagged as a bit of a malcontent and an over reactor. But he's right on this one. Teams don't deserve to go 14-2 or better, they deserve to win as many games as their roster dictates. In your new structure, if I'm understanding it, you're giving crap teams artificial wins by putting them with other crap teams. 38 capped leagues should all contain the same level of competition, because they're all equal at 38 capped teams. By sorting this way, the last 38 capped league really isn't 38 capped, it's probably more like a 32 cap with a few higher levels strewn about. Teams that don't try don't deserve to have winning seasons, but if you bundle 32 teams who don't try together, 16 of them have to make the playoffs.
The 9th best team in League 1 is getting screwed out of the playoffs, while the 33rd best team in a given level cap is being given an easy trophy.


Thank you.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by jdbolick


Originally posted by shield.bearer



I think this is the best answer. Snake draft the teams to fill the leagues just like you used to do because it created a ton of parity.






FYP


You need to read what pottsman has to say.
 
joesox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by haleykrl DTD
locked leagues imo


 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by jdbolick


Originally posted by shield.bearer



I think this is the best answer. Snake draft the teams to fill the leagues just like you used to do because it created a ton of parity.






FYP


You did that? They seemed pretty random.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shield.bearer
bukowski's team and mine were in a great, competitive league last season. The teams who were built well and gameplanned best all had legit shots at the title. My team, 13-3 in the regular season, won the title. But any of the teams we beat (other than the first round) in the playoffs had a real shot at winning it.

That should be the goal of every league. Well built teams have a chance, poorly built ones don't.


i see your point (and Buk's) - but at the same time - if you were in a great; competitive league last season - then you were some of the few....

 
Link
 
this created parody?
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
FYP

Is that what you used to do? If so, I wasn't aware of it. I thought teams were placed in their tier and then assigned to leagues randomly. If you already used a snake format and it didn't work, then obviously that's a legitimate argument in favor of trying something new.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
Originally posted by shield.bearer

bukowski's team and mine were in a great, competitive league last season. The teams who were built well and gameplanned best all had legit shots at the title. My team, 13-3 in the regular season, won the title. But any of the teams we beat (other than the first round) in the playoffs had a real shot at winning it.

That should be the goal of every league. Well built teams have a chance, poorly built ones don't.


i see your point (and Buk's) - but at the same time - if you were in a great; competitive league last season - then you were some of the few....



Some of the few? Not in these low level capped leagues, it really wasn't a problem.
 
Judan
offline
Link
 
I agree the SSB problem is there. What I do not agree with is that people are brazenly saying other teams 'suck' or they're 'bad' and they're not 'elite'. People feel their league/conf is more competitive and trash the other leagues which are competitive in their own right.

Give me a break. If they win their conference, they're good enough to win. If you don't, you don't. Also, the conspiracy theories about Bort nerfing good dots/teams so 'bad' people can compete is ridiculous. He's nerfed extreme builds which were game breakers, not game changers.

Also, there is no spoon.

Edited by Doc on Jan 21, 2010 11:47:56
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
You did that? They seemed pretty random.


Yep, CPU teams were attempted to be as evenly distributed as possible, etc. The problems we always run into that people sell after the fact or have empty rosters after winning, or cut everyone and start over without demoting. Things like that screw the pooch no matter what we do. The more we spread out the lesser teams the more likely everyone is going to run into it.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Doc
I agree the SSB problem is there. What I do not agree with is that people are brazenly saying other teams 'suck' or they're 'bad' and they're not 'elite'. People feel their league/conf is more competitive and trash the other leagues which are competitive in their own right.

Give me a break. If they win their conference, they're good enough to win. If you don't, you don't. Also, the conspiracy theories about Bort nerfing good dots/teams so 'bad' people can compete is ridiculous. He's nerfed extreme builds which will game breakers, not game changers.

Also, there is no spoon.



You aren't affected by this AT ALL.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by pottsman

You did that? They seemed pretty random.


Yep, CPU teams were attempted to be as evenly distributed as possible, etc. The problems we always run into that people sell after the fact or have empty rosters after winning, or cut everyone and start over without demoting. Things like that screw the pooch no matter what we do. The more we spread out the lesser teams the more likely everyone is going to run into it.


Why don't you comment on pottsman's other post?

That is what you need to read.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.