I feel a poll coming on.
greengoose
offline
offline
Originally posted by NiteRider
Corrupt data packets
With only 1 field (the same field) in a database?
Corrupt data packets
With only 1 field (the same field) in a database?
PsychoMan
offline
offline
Originally posted by NiteRider
Corrupt data packets
you're not trying to answer my question, are you?
Corrupt data packets
you're not trying to answer my question, are you?
Bogleg
offline
offline
Originally posted by greengoose
Database
SQL Query to retrieve the data
Variables set up to store the data.
Functions which work on the data.
What on earth is there to not understand - and by not understand I mean that Bort can't fix it?. This isn't rocket science here.
There's hardware underneath all that, and there's data that needs to be consistent for it all to work, and there's software that Bort didn't write and doesn't maintain that manages that data and moves it between database and variables and functions.
It's not always that simple.
Bort has denied the existence of a hidden attribute and the like in the past. He has mentioned an affinity for randomness, but not in such a way as to cause playerA who is equal in all aspects to playerB consistently outperform playerB. He talks about game-to-game, quarter-to-quarter, and the like, but not any kind of consistent "this guy is destined for the HoF'" type crap.
Database
SQL Query to retrieve the data
Variables set up to store the data.
Functions which work on the data.
What on earth is there to not understand - and by not understand I mean that Bort can't fix it?. This isn't rocket science here.
There's hardware underneath all that, and there's data that needs to be consistent for it all to work, and there's software that Bort didn't write and doesn't maintain that manages that data and moves it between database and variables and functions.
It's not always that simple.
Bort has denied the existence of a hidden attribute and the like in the past. He has mentioned an affinity for randomness, but not in such a way as to cause playerA who is equal in all aspects to playerB consistently outperform playerB. He talks about game-to-game, quarter-to-quarter, and the like, but not any kind of consistent "this guy is destined for the HoF'" type crap.
steellithium
offline
offline
Originally posted by greengoose
Database
SQL Query to retrieve the data
Variables set up to store the data.
Functions which work on the data.
What on earth is there to not understand - and by not understand I mean that Bort can't fix it?. This isn't rocket science here.
Well, I agree in small cases. When you start dealing with huge databases, SQL has issues that have to be resolved. There are different ways to sync up data, and different file systems perform differently. I have written custom kernel schedulers for specific databases I've used. Once you start reaching a million records the game changes entirely. You have to start using some more complex linux/unix servers with custom built kernels at some point.
Database
SQL Query to retrieve the data
Variables set up to store the data.
Functions which work on the data.
What on earth is there to not understand - and by not understand I mean that Bort can't fix it?. This isn't rocket science here.
Well, I agree in small cases. When you start dealing with huge databases, SQL has issues that have to be resolved. There are different ways to sync up data, and different file systems perform differently. I have written custom kernel schedulers for specific databases I've used. Once you start reaching a million records the game changes entirely. You have to start using some more complex linux/unix servers with custom built kernels at some point.
steellithium
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bogleg
There's hardware underneath all that
This is important too. Matching hardware and software is a feat in itself.
There's hardware underneath all that
This is important too. Matching hardware and software is a feat in itself.
well - i guess I can say I'm glad a bug was discovered - and hopefully this work around is effective.
too bad it took 5 seasons of discussion; locked threads; arguments and denials to get here...
too bad it took 5 seasons of discussion; locked threads; arguments and denials to get here...
SteelersInsider
offline
offline
Originally posted by monsterkill
Originally posted by trancegression
I realize that 'this' particular weight issue was not on purpose, and I do appreciate that Bort has applied a fix, what I am concerned about is Bort's postings in this thread where he states that he is not denying or confirming that there is an unknown random factor that makes a player better and he has also stated that even if one does not exist he thinks it might be a good idea to put one in a some point. Maybe I am misinterpreting what Bort said but that is what I took away from his posts.
thats what i got from it too and it worries me that he doesnt think it would be a bad idea
If he doesn't have something like that in there, it would be possible for someone's script to get EXACT numbers on what attributes cause what to happen. He might as well give all the formulas away. Deathblade gets closer and closer every day.
This game is becoming more about who has the best programmer rather than being a fun football game imo.
Originally posted by trancegression
I realize that 'this' particular weight issue was not on purpose, and I do appreciate that Bort has applied a fix, what I am concerned about is Bort's postings in this thread where he states that he is not denying or confirming that there is an unknown random factor that makes a player better and he has also stated that even if one does not exist he thinks it might be a good idea to put one in a some point. Maybe I am misinterpreting what Bort said but that is what I took away from his posts.
thats what i got from it too and it worries me that he doesnt think it would be a bad idea
If he doesn't have something like that in there, it would be possible for someone's script to get EXACT numbers on what attributes cause what to happen. He might as well give all the formulas away. Deathblade gets closer and closer every day.
This game is becoming more about who has the best programmer rather than being a fun football game imo.
steellithium
offline
offline
Originally posted by Tony Dungy
If he doesn't have something like that in there, it would be possible for someone's script to get EXACT numbers on what attributes cause what to happen. He might as well give all the formulas away. Deathblade gets closer and closer every day.
This game is becoming more about who has the best programmer rather than being a fun football game imo.
That is why the BETA tag is attached.
If he doesn't have something like that in there, it would be possible for someone's script to get EXACT numbers on what attributes cause what to happen. He might as well give all the formulas away. Deathblade gets closer and closer every day.
This game is becoming more about who has the best programmer rather than being a fun football game imo.
That is why the BETA tag is attached.
Joe Buck
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bogleg
Originally posted by greengoose
Database
SQL Query to retrieve the data
Variables set up to store the data.
Functions which work on the data.
What on earth is there to not understand - and by not understand I mean that Bort can't fix it?. This isn't rocket science here.
There's hardware underneath all that, and there's data that needs to be consistent for it all to work, and there's software that Bort didn't write and doesn't maintain that manages that data and moves it between database and variables and functions.
It's not always that simple.
Bort has denied the existence of a hidden attribute and the like in the past. He has mentioned an affinity for randomness, but not in such a way as to cause playerA who is equal in all aspects to playerB consistently outperform playerB. He talks about game-to-game, quarter-to-quarter, and the like, but not any kind of consistent "this guy is destined for the HoF'" type crap.
But we have example after example of Borts intent for various items in the game not being realized in actual results. As coded does not equal as expected. VA's anyone?
It's only with great transparency that things like VA wonkiness, Sure Tackler, Hard Count, buggy plays like Singleback Flanker Drag never passing to WR1 or HB for 7 seasons (due to a missing comma), etc were debugged in large part due to the userbase's efforts at analyzing it, providing links, etc. The dirty work.
With a hidden attribute system or whatever, that only Bort knows about, that means it is up to him to debug it / figure out if its working as intended or not.
Originally posted by greengoose
Database
SQL Query to retrieve the data
Variables set up to store the data.
Functions which work on the data.
What on earth is there to not understand - and by not understand I mean that Bort can't fix it?. This isn't rocket science here.
There's hardware underneath all that, and there's data that needs to be consistent for it all to work, and there's software that Bort didn't write and doesn't maintain that manages that data and moves it between database and variables and functions.
It's not always that simple.
Bort has denied the existence of a hidden attribute and the like in the past. He has mentioned an affinity for randomness, but not in such a way as to cause playerA who is equal in all aspects to playerB consistently outperform playerB. He talks about game-to-game, quarter-to-quarter, and the like, but not any kind of consistent "this guy is destined for the HoF'" type crap.
But we have example after example of Borts intent for various items in the game not being realized in actual results. As coded does not equal as expected. VA's anyone?
It's only with great transparency that things like VA wonkiness, Sure Tackler, Hard Count, buggy plays like Singleback Flanker Drag never passing to WR1 or HB for 7 seasons (due to a missing comma), etc were debugged in large part due to the userbase's efforts at analyzing it, providing links, etc. The dirty work.
With a hidden attribute system or whatever, that only Bort knows about, that means it is up to him to debug it / figure out if its working as intended or not.
Joe Buck
offline
offline
So I missed about the last 50 pages of this thread - what is the error that was discovered?
taurran
offline
offline
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by Tony Dungy
If he doesn't have something like that in there, it would be possible for someone's script to get EXACT numbers on what attributes cause what to happen. He might as well give all the formulas away. Deathblade gets closer and closer every day.
This game is becoming more about who has the best programmer rather than being a fun football game imo.
That is why the BETA tag is attached.
Cop out.
REAL retail games can't go through their entire life cycle with beta tags attached. The Beta tag is just an out for potential issues in coding. This game needs more developers.
Originally posted by Tony Dungy
If he doesn't have something like that in there, it would be possible for someone's script to get EXACT numbers on what attributes cause what to happen. He might as well give all the formulas away. Deathblade gets closer and closer every day.
This game is becoming more about who has the best programmer rather than being a fun football game imo.
That is why the BETA tag is attached.
Cop out.
REAL retail games can't go through their entire life cycle with beta tags attached. The Beta tag is just an out for potential issues in coding. This game needs more developers.
britdevine316
offline
offline
After like 6 seasons of people obviously seeing an x-factor, glad to see this got fixed in an appropriate time frame...../sarcasm
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























