User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
I think Mike will be honest enough to admit that he could have created any build that he wanted to and tested it multiple times IF desired. I know Mike would not do that to gain an edge but he won't deny that It could have been done.


I could build anyway I want, but not in secrecy, it would be fully tackable, and I would have to explain why I did so.

Testing multiple times is fundamental to any testing (Obviously), but again it needs to be focussed and justified.

To gain that edge everyone is worried about, I would need to convince others that there is a legit reason for the test, and all results would be screened by more than just myself, so IF I found anything that was useful it would enter the 'Bug/Exploit' domain and be addressed immediately.

Testing multiple plays against one Play in preperation for a specific game for example, needs to be strongly justified. (I guess this is the biggest concern after builds?)

As for making players too closely related to my own/my team, its doable, but heavily monitored for obvious reasons.

 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 

Last edited Feb 15, 2009 16:02:51
 
bram
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by smallbugger



During the playoffs I basically mapped out the last three game of each opponent to figure out the best way to stop them, ect. That took a long time. Being a tester... you can test a build, SA or VA against a similar team to mine running our best plays to see how your team would do....

that would be cheating because they can see a sims results, while other would have to go with the knowledge and experience they got from previous games or scrimmages... both we paid real money for.

Bort should have Admins and paid people being testers, that would put those people under contract that they cannot cheat and use their given advantages over other players.... or maybe volunteers that will leave the actual game behind.

Bort can't just be choosing guys he likes to be given an advantage over paying customers....


Yeah that is possible, but there are reasons it isnt that simple.

1) The sim engine being used to run the games is totally different in many ways, the results would not translate directly to the live Site (I am not saying its entirely different and somethings wont translate, but those are the most basic things thats certainly not a secret to the n00biest of n00bs.

2) It pretty damn impossible to do that type of a test without justifying it in some way.

3) I would be very unlikely to be able to create a team 'similar' enough to your team (Or mine for that matter) in order to run that test.

4) It still fails to account for the other team changing their gameplan and you screwing yourself.

Basically I would learn more by running my own Pro team in a Friendly against any other team on the live site than from 100 tests on that server.

You obvioulsy have no way of knowing that for sure though, I understand that and its the biggest barrier to appeasing the masses imo.


While i have no axe to grind with mike, the statements above have a little to much double speak in them for me to be comfortable with. " is totally different in many ways" " very unlikely " are all thing we hear every day from our political masters when their cought with their fingers in the pie. Just a opinion.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by tigerbait22

I think Mike will be honest enough to admit that he could have created any build that he wanted to and tested it multiple times IF desired. I know Mike would not do that to gain an edge but he won't deny that It could have been done.


I could build anyway I want, but not in secrecy, it would be fully tackable, and I would have to explain why I did so.

Testing multiple times is fundamental to any testing (Obviously), but again it needs to be focussed and justified.

To gain that edge everyone is worried about, I would need to convince others that there is a legit reason for the test, and all results would be screened by more than just myself, so IF I found anything that was useful it would enter the 'Bug/Exploit' domain and be addressed immediately.




But, it would only be addressed if you brought attention to it. Surely there were many things that you didn't bring attention to because you felt it wasn't that big of a deal or because you only subconsciously noticed it. Either way, you have more information on how the game works than the rest of us. You are using this information to play against other paying customers.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

I hate been evasive at a time like this, hope everyone understands.


Mike, many of us at least understand your difficult position and appreciate your effort to address people's immediate concerns. As far as I'm concerned you're handling the situation with judgment and integrity.


I agree with this.

I'd say my general concern level about the whole subject has only been moderate, as I think the testing was absolutely necessary and in the best interests of the game, but I worry about the quick flow of inside information to teams that testers play on and other agents they are affiliated with as I think it's nearly unavoidable despite the best intentions of Bort and the testers.

The difference between figuring things out on day 1 and day 10 (to pick an arbitrary later date) is pretty substantial, as it allows early boosting without a cost to player development and increases the already large (though inevitable) disadvantage for those agents that don't have a good network of other agents to help them figure things out.

While I very much appreciate Mike's efforts to get some useful information out, and think it should do a lot to quell many of the conspiracy theories, they doesn't really address the inherent tension between getting the sim working properly and consistently (season-to-season) and the inequality of access to potentially useful information between testers (and the agents they are affiliated with) and non-testers.

That being said, I'm not sure what the perfect fix to the situation is, and, if the testers do a good enough job getting the sim into solid working shape, hopefully the scope and impact of the season-to-season changes will slow down, giving the inside information much less impact. In other words, if Bort isn't constantly ramping up or damping down the effects of different attributes/SAs, or altering the basic playing dynamic, then there will be less new information that can be used to gain a competitive advantage.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Asheme

Originally posted by tigerbait22


As for carte blanche' I heard from a trusted guy that you can indeed test any build that you want on the test server and run that sim as many times as you want.


Originally posted by Mike Rogers


Testing is not 'at the Testers Discretion', you need to justify what your looking into, and checks are in place that make 'secret testing' impossible.


Originally posted by tpaterniti

Originally posted by AgentTBC



2) Can testers create players with whatever stats they want and test them in games?


2. Yes wouldn't be much of a test site otherwise



Both true, we can test what needs to be tested, but not at our sole discretion, which is the vital part.
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by tigerbait22

I think Mike will be honest enough to admit that he could have created any build that he wanted to and tested it multiple times IF desired. I know Mike would not do that to gain an edge but he won't deny that It could have been done.


I could build anyway I want, but not in secrecy, it would be fully tackable, and I would have to explain why I did so.

Testing multiple times is fundamental to any testing (Obviously), but again it needs to be focussed and justified.

To gain that edge everyone is worried about, I would need to convince others that there is a legit reason for the test, and all results would be screened by more than just myself, so IF I found anything that was useful it would enter the 'Bug/Exploit' domain and be addressed immediately.

Testing multiple plays against one Play in preperation for a specific game for example, needs to be strongly justified. (I guess this is the biggest concern after builds?)

As for making players too closely related to my own/my team, its doable, but heavily monitored for obvious reasons.



Two things:

1. Doesn't this imply that unless Bort immediately fixes every problem that you discover, that there will definitely be periods of time where a given tester will be aware of problems/exploits that exist in the game that the general public is not aware of or is less aware of the specifics?

2. From what you've said, wouldn't the testing process be more efficient if Bort didn't have to worry about testers using information to their advantage - if the testers were not also players?
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
Then as stands GLB is a joke?

As an accurate sim? Yes. Inputs != outputs at the moment. Joke is a harsher word than I would use, but it's definitely broken, and needs fixing. I believe it will be taken care of, hence why I'm still around.

Originally posted by tigerbait22
Nothing to do with making the game better.. you put a good spin job on my point and twisted it into things that are not true.. A tester could put whatever they wanted build wise into the sim.

Not really. Apologies if that's how it came off, but my point is that words like "expose", "hide", "cheat" would only be applicable if the sim, and by extension, the game, was in a working state.

Originally posted by awesome
In summation: You don't care about the game, you don't care about the users, you don't care about fairness.

Since you don't care, why are you here defending actions that were clearly in the wrong?

Speaking of twisting words. I do care about the game, but I can recognize that it's broken. I wouldn't be here if I didn't care. And, no, I don't care about fairness in terms of competitive balance right now, because that competition is more or less meaningless. So what's the point?
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by weather999

Could you provide any screenshots of this testing, Mike?


Pretty sure that for now the answer is no, I think if anyone does that its got to be an Admin.

(Besides theres not much to see, it looks alot like this site )


Just for the skeptics to confirm you are a tester
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
It's pointless. All of it. Can't undo what was done and Bort is gone from this issue. I am out of this thread, but I will leave saying one last thing.

My personal belief in the game has taken a big hit here. People whisper and talk. GLB is a small community. I know that some info gained through the testing process was used for personal gain.

Whether Asheme is right or not that we should be concerned about the future of the game and not the present is for each to decide. I pay for the game right now as is, and try to compete now. I may very well be burned out of GLB by the time the game is ever a finished product. My guess is that it will never make it to a finished product. When a business needs to pull from its player base to begin to test doesn't say too much for the coders and designers of the game IMO.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
When a business needs to pull from its player base to begin to test doesn't say too much for the coders and designers of the game IMO.

Means it's in beta, no?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22


I know that some info gained through the testing process was used for personal gain.



And you reported the individual while providing supporting facts to back up the allegation?
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
It's pointless. All of it. Can't undo what was done and Bort is gone from this issue. I am out of this thread, but I will leave saying one last thing.

My personal belief in the game has taken a big hit here. People whisper and talk. GLB is a small community. I know that some info gained through the testing process was used for personal gain.

Whether Asheme is right or not that we should be concerned about the future of the game and not the present is for each to decide. I pay for the game right now as is, and try to compete now. I may very well be burned out of GLB by the time the game is ever a finished product. My guess is that it will never make it to a finished product. When a business needs to pull from its player base to begin to test doesn't say too much for the coders and designers of the game IMO.


Surely pulling from the players is the BEST way to test the game. What should be addressed is where the leak came from, name names for who had information and then they should be questioned as to where that information came from. I wouldn't say that just because a tester is on a team that they automatically give out information.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
I wouldn't say that just because a tester is on a team that they automatically give out information.


But if they ever talk to any non-tester about player builds or tactics (or set AIs), wouldn't it be nearly impossible to prevent information that they learned from getting out as it informs what they say about the game (they can't unknow it).
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 16:19:20
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by tigerbait22

Then as stands GLB is a joke?

As an accurate sim? Yes. Inputs != outputs at the moment. Joke is a harsher word than I would use, but it's definitely broken, and needs fixing. I believe it will be taken care of, hence why I'm still around.

Originally posted by tigerbait22

Nothing to do with making the game better.. you put a good spin job on my point and twisted it into things that are not true.. A tester could put whatever they wanted build wise into the sim.

Not really. Apologies if that's how it came off, but my point is that words like "expose", "hide", "cheat" would only be applicable if the sim, and by extension, the game, was in a working state.

Originally posted by awesome

In summation: You don't care about the game, you don't care about the users, you don't care about fairness.

Since you don't care, why are you here defending actions that were clearly in the wrong?

Speaking of twisting words. I do care about the game, but I can recognize that it's broken. I wouldn't be here if I didn't care. And, no, I don't care about fairness in terms of competitive balance right now, because that competition is more or less meaningless. So what's the point?


Your middle point is incorrect. People ARE being cheated. Some of them may not feel cheated, and that's good, imo, but they ARE being cheated. They're having others be given a secretive advantage by the administration, thus undermining their own efforts to improve/win.

It would be like the makers of some MMO randomly choosing a few players they like and giving them weapons with 20 damage more than any weapon in the game can currently boast as well as a bunch of new effects. They get to learn whether this weapon functions well and people like it, so it can improve the game in the long run. And some people would say "hey, its just one piece of equip and it would lead to us getting a whole new batch of cool stuff, so whatever"... but it doesn't change the fact that some people WERE given an unfair advantage.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.