This game is already ridiculously biased toward offense and now we're debating making EVERY defender get their tackling skill over 60 just to bring someone down? So, now in order to tackle someone, you have to make yourself dreadfully slow, inagile, or lacking vision.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
cmj33
offline
offline
Originally posted by GMathiasf
This game is already ridiculously biased toward offense and now we're debating making EVERY defender get their tackling skill over 60 just to bring someone down? So, now in order to tackle someone, you have to make yourself dreadfully slow, inagile, or lacking vision.
It really isn't a debate it's already been done.
This game is already ridiculously biased toward offense and now we're debating making EVERY defender get their tackling skill over 60 just to bring someone down? So, now in order to tackle someone, you have to make yourself dreadfully slow, inagile, or lacking vision.
It really isn't a debate it's already been done.
maitey
offline
offline
Originally posted by GMathiasf
This game is already ridiculously biased toward offense and now we're debating making EVERY defender get their tackling skill over 60 just to bring someone down? So, now in order to tackle someone, you have to make yourself dreadfully slow, inagile, or lacking vision.
ya think days are numbered of this sim. I know I am getting extremely tired of this BS EVERY season. Recruiting is just getting worse and worse, there is not a pool of good talent 35+. These wide swings in build changes are game breaking for me.
This game is already ridiculously biased toward offense and now we're debating making EVERY defender get their tackling skill over 60 just to bring someone down? So, now in order to tackle someone, you have to make yourself dreadfully slow, inagile, or lacking vision.
ya think days are numbered of this sim. I know I am getting extremely tired of this BS EVERY season. Recruiting is just getting worse and worse, there is not a pool of good talent 35+. These wide swings in build changes are game breaking for me.
Kavadas
offline
offline
Originally posted by GMathiasf
This game is already ridiculously biased toward offense and now we're debating making EVERY defender get their tackling skill over 60 just to bring someone down? So, now in order to tackle someone, you have to make yourself dreadfully slow, inagile, or lacking vision.
Don't see what the big deal is if carrying and catching are needed in those same quantities and strength becomes, like, not shit for receivers. And vision starts to work for power runners rather than against.
Stuff that makes sense...
Originally posted by maitey
ya think days are numbered of this sim. I know I am getting extremely tired of this BS EVERY season. Recruiting is just getting worse and worse, there is not a pool of good talent 35+. These wide swings in build changes are game breaking for me.
No offense, but GLB is in beta. It says so right on the front page: http://www.goallineblitz.com
Don't cry because you still don't understand what "beta" means IMO.
This game is already ridiculously biased toward offense and now we're debating making EVERY defender get their tackling skill over 60 just to bring someone down? So, now in order to tackle someone, you have to make yourself dreadfully slow, inagile, or lacking vision.
Don't see what the big deal is if carrying and catching are needed in those same quantities and strength becomes, like, not shit for receivers. And vision starts to work for power runners rather than against.
Stuff that makes sense...
Originally posted by maitey
ya think days are numbered of this sim. I know I am getting extremely tired of this BS EVERY season. Recruiting is just getting worse and worse, there is not a pool of good talent 35+. These wide swings in build changes are game breaking for me.
No offense, but GLB is in beta. It says so right on the front page: http://www.goallineblitz.com
Don't cry because you still don't understand what "beta" means IMO.
Last edited Dec 31, 2008 08:46:57
Painmaker
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:
100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too
I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?
The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?
I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."
I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.
Dang, missed this question while I was on vacation. Going provide an answer untainted from reading any of the other responses first.
Several factors come into this. Here are a few examples:
- First and foremost is balance. The second guy to hit the ballcarrier has a tremendous advantage because the ballcarrier is no longer in sole control of his momentum and center of gravity relative to his foot position. There should be a significant tackling bonus for attempting a tackle shortly after another player has delivered a hit, even if the previous tackling attempt was "missed" because it slowed the runner and made him shift his balance to some extent.
- Second is tackling opportunity. Independent of the RB's strength, if a tackler gets a clean shot at the ballcarrier he's usually going to bring the ballcarrier down. Agility factors into this but so does room... in other words, it's hard for an agile back to evade a tackle when he's shooting through a two-foot gap between offensive linemen. In the open field it becomes easier for him to make the tackler miss. If the tackler is coming off of a block, then it's much harder for him to just take the runner down and he's going to need both strength and tackling ability to make that one-armed tackle or whatever.
- Third is speed going into the tackle. Solid DBs (not "tackle artists," just everyday solid DBs) are able to make tackles because they use the energy they bring into the play with their speed to make up for strength they give up to bigger and stronger RBs. Some factor needs to be in place to account for the speed advantage a defender might bring into the tackle.
- There are almost certainly more factors to consider. Energy, awareness (is the tackle coming from the side or behind?), willingness to "sell out" on the play (perhaps captured by some combination of confidence and morale), whether the tackling attempts are coming in short succession from opposing sides so the runner has little time to shift the ball, etc, all might be other factors.
In other words it shouldn't be nearly as simple as just comparing the ballcarrier's strength, carrying and agility to the tackler's strength and tackling. In some situations (say, third guy to hit the HB in the space of two seconds) I'd say a 30 strength and tackling CB should bring a 100 strength and carrying HB down 95% of the time. In some situations (say, running past a NT who is still engaged by a dominating C) I'd say a 50 strength and carrying HB should be able to break a 100 strength and tackling DT's tackling attempt around 50% of the time.
The actual game situation should have much more weight than just comparing the players' skills.
Let's say I have a power back with:
100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too
I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?
The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?
I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."
I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.
Dang, missed this question while I was on vacation. Going provide an answer untainted from reading any of the other responses first.
Several factors come into this. Here are a few examples:
- First and foremost is balance. The second guy to hit the ballcarrier has a tremendous advantage because the ballcarrier is no longer in sole control of his momentum and center of gravity relative to his foot position. There should be a significant tackling bonus for attempting a tackle shortly after another player has delivered a hit, even if the previous tackling attempt was "missed" because it slowed the runner and made him shift his balance to some extent.
- Second is tackling opportunity. Independent of the RB's strength, if a tackler gets a clean shot at the ballcarrier he's usually going to bring the ballcarrier down. Agility factors into this but so does room... in other words, it's hard for an agile back to evade a tackle when he's shooting through a two-foot gap between offensive linemen. In the open field it becomes easier for him to make the tackler miss. If the tackler is coming off of a block, then it's much harder for him to just take the runner down and he's going to need both strength and tackling ability to make that one-armed tackle or whatever.
- Third is speed going into the tackle. Solid DBs (not "tackle artists," just everyday solid DBs) are able to make tackles because they use the energy they bring into the play with their speed to make up for strength they give up to bigger and stronger RBs. Some factor needs to be in place to account for the speed advantage a defender might bring into the tackle.
- There are almost certainly more factors to consider. Energy, awareness (is the tackle coming from the side or behind?), willingness to "sell out" on the play (perhaps captured by some combination of confidence and morale), whether the tackling attempts are coming in short succession from opposing sides so the runner has little time to shift the ball, etc, all might be other factors.
In other words it shouldn't be nearly as simple as just comparing the ballcarrier's strength, carrying and agility to the tackler's strength and tackling. In some situations (say, third guy to hit the HB in the space of two seconds) I'd say a 30 strength and tackling CB should bring a 100 strength and carrying HB down 95% of the time. In some situations (say, running past a NT who is still engaged by a dominating C) I'd say a 50 strength and carrying HB should be able to break a 100 strength and tackling DT's tackling attempt around 50% of the time.
The actual game situation should have much more weight than just comparing the players' skills.
Defeugo
offline
offline
Other than the need for some sort of Gang Tackling concept (both as something that just happens and as a team concept) I think there needs to be more factors in tackling. Even Deon Sanders could tackle Bam Morris every once and a while (whether it be by chance or just a cunning move). Different players tackle in different ways (ex. corners commonly go for the legs which would reduce the RB's use of strength in breaking the tackle, increase the effect of agility on breaking the tackle). A vision check (possibly modified by a players tactics) should be make by the tackler to determine what type of tackle to go for and use the appropriate attributes to try and make the tackle. The RB should make a vision check to recognize the type of tackle and then try to avoid the tackle using the appropriate attributes. A Strength Break Tackle of a power back could still beat an Agility Tackle of a corner (depending on how good of a Str Break Tackle rolled vs how good of a Agil make Tackle rolled) but not necessarily as well as a Strength Break Tackle of a Power Back vs a Strength Make Tackle of a Corner Back. The Tackling Attribute would always be a part of every Tackle attempt of course and Agility Break Tackles shouldn't be as effective as strength break tackles since agility also helps you avoid tackle attempts in general (via Juke or whatever).
I know that this would make the programming more complicated and folks would be pissed that their old "sure fire builds" didn't work 100% of the time, but nothing works 100% of the time in real football and this game should be the same.
I know that this would make the programming more complicated and folks would be pissed that their old "sure fire builds" didn't work 100% of the time, but nothing works 100% of the time in real football and this game should be the same.
Last edited Dec 31, 2008 09:38:14
mogs01gt
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:
100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too
I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?
The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?
I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."
I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.
If we only are talking about strength vs str/tack, then I would say 50str and 50tak +wrap up SA. However other stats play a part in the formula. I would hope a ball carrier with 100str+SA's could rip through a tackler with 50/50+SA's split in strength and tackling. Though in my opinion, tackling should be at the first softcap while strength should hit the second softcap. I would assume a 60str/48tack or 65-70str/48tack setup should be able to handle any 100str power back. Including SA's and VA's.
Let's say I have a power back with:
100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too
I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?
The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?
I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."
I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.
If we only are talking about strength vs str/tack, then I would say 50str and 50tak +wrap up SA. However other stats play a part in the formula. I would hope a ball carrier with 100str+SA's could rip through a tackler with 50/50+SA's split in strength and tackling. Though in my opinion, tackling should be at the first softcap while strength should hit the second softcap. I would assume a 60str/48tack or 65-70str/48tack setup should be able to handle any 100str power back. Including SA's and VA's.
Vincent Neal
offline
offline
Originally posted by GMathiasf
This game is already ridiculously biased toward offense and now we're debating making EVERY defender get their tackling skill over 60 just to bring someone down? So, now in order to tackle someone, you have to make yourself dreadfully slow, inagile, or lacking vision.
No, in order to tackle someone, you need to know how to tackle. Makes sense, right? In order to be fast, you need speed. In order to throw a good pass, you need throwing. Want to kick a football? You need kicking. Let's say you want to be a good and reliable tackler. Guess what stat you need. TACKLING.
This game is already ridiculously biased toward offense and now we're debating making EVERY defender get their tackling skill over 60 just to bring someone down? So, now in order to tackle someone, you have to make yourself dreadfully slow, inagile, or lacking vision.
No, in order to tackle someone, you need to know how to tackle. Makes sense, right? In order to be fast, you need speed. In order to throw a good pass, you need throwing. Want to kick a football? You need kicking. Let's say you want to be a good and reliable tackler. Guess what stat you need. TACKLING.
hazyblue
offline
offline
Originally posted by maitey
Originally posted by GMathiasf
This game is already ridiculously biased toward offense and now we're debating making EVERY defender get their tackling skill over 60 just to bring someone down? So, now in order to tackle someone, you have to make yourself dreadfully slow, inagile, or lacking vision.
ya think days are numbered of this sim. I know I am getting extremely tired of this BS EVERY season. Recruiting is just getting worse and worse, there is not a pool of good talent 35+. These wide swings in build changes are game breaking for me.
It can be frustrating, but it is still Beta and people should maybe make balanced players rather than every season focusing on a certain type of player to make use of an exploit.
Originally posted by GMathiasf
This game is already ridiculously biased toward offense and now we're debating making EVERY defender get their tackling skill over 60 just to bring someone down? So, now in order to tackle someone, you have to make yourself dreadfully slow, inagile, or lacking vision.
ya think days are numbered of this sim. I know I am getting extremely tired of this BS EVERY season. Recruiting is just getting worse and worse, there is not a pool of good talent 35+. These wide swings in build changes are game breaking for me.
It can be frustrating, but it is still Beta and people should maybe make balanced players rather than every season focusing on a certain type of player to make use of an exploit.
NWWarrior
offline
offline
Originally posted by hazyblue
It can be frustrating, but it is still Beta and people should maybe make balanced players rather than every season focusing on a certain type of player to make use of an exploit.
You mean every GLB position player should look exactly the same right?
Thats what you would have if everyone made balanced players and the game would be boring. mho
It can be frustrating, but it is still Beta and people should maybe make balanced players rather than every season focusing on a certain type of player to make use of an exploit.
You mean every GLB position player should look exactly the same right?
Thats what you would have if everyone made balanced players and the game would be boring. mho
Vincent Neal
offline
offline
Originally posted by NWWarrior
Originally posted by hazyblue
It can be frustrating, but it is still Beta and people should maybe make balanced players rather than every season focusing on a certain type of player to make use of an exploit.
You mean every GLB position player should look exactly the same right?
Thats what you would have if everyone made balanced players and the game would be boring. mho
Just like how every player spammed speed when speed was the "it" stat? Everyone was the same. Jacked up speed, nothing else. Thankfully, the game realized that you can't be an idiot savant of football and succeed.
Originally posted by hazyblue
It can be frustrating, but it is still Beta and people should maybe make balanced players rather than every season focusing on a certain type of player to make use of an exploit.
You mean every GLB position player should look exactly the same right?
Thats what you would have if everyone made balanced players and the game would be boring. mho
Just like how every player spammed speed when speed was the "it" stat? Everyone was the same. Jacked up speed, nothing else. Thankfully, the game realized that you can't be an idiot savant of football and succeed.
Last edited Dec 31, 2008 10:45:17
NWWarrior
offline
offline
disagree...there where those that spammed speed and will always be the ones who try and find the latest advantage, but at least that left us with many different builds. Not everyone did that, please
If we all go balanced then we will ALL look the same...period
If we all go balanced then we will ALL look the same...period
ruleslawyer
offline
offline
So having high speed and 1 or 2 lowish abilities makes you an idiot savant of football but having high str with 1 or 2 lowish abilities doesn't?
Nothing has been realized.
Nothing has been realized.
Last edited Dec 31, 2008 11:36:38
hixtrix
offline
offline
I'm pretty sure this is what Bort had in mind when the changes were made: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=351369&pbp_id=599048
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























