User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Menyu
offline
Link
 
To me, I have no issues with more broken tackles but I do have a problem with how they are broken. I've seen HBs plow through 3-4 defenders at times and barely look like they are having a problem. I feel like players who break tackles easily should be able to do that but breaking tackles should tire you, slow you down while you move on. What I see here is a steam train running through everyone. That's simply nowhere near realistic.
 
pattybrhg
offline
Link
 
I totally agree with Menyu. Backs breaking tackles should at least slow the guy down. I have no problem with backs breaking tackles, but it's totally unrealistic compared to a real game to have a back never even slow down after breaking a tackle.
 
Zsirvone28
offline
Link
 
In all reality, I see this game as an 'Online Madden Player Creation Sim' League. Basically, you create your player and you put him up against other agents with other players. Both games are based off of numbers and percentages. The big differences I see are the Special Abilities and Veteran Abilities that are being implemented. Both of these were implemented in an attempt to make players more 'unique'. I must say, Bort has done a great job with that as well as all of GLB. I'm a very big fan and I've been around since Season 1. Ever since I've been here, strength and tackling have been the two major attributes that the game undervalues. Speed is overvalued. While agility is undervalued a bit. Just because someone built a SPEED HEAVY DEMON DEFENSIVE PLAYER doesn't mean they should get rewarded by having 10 tackling, playing on wrap up, and never missing a tackle. That's just ridiculous. I've been following this thread for a while, seeing everyone's suggestions, and coming up with something of my own. The true power backs of the NFL in MADDEN don't have 100 strength. They don't have 90 Strength. AT MOST they have mid 80s strength. All successful backs are in the 60-80 range. They all have 90+ agility, speed, and acceleration. What makes them so good at breaking tackles? The BTK attribute. The BTK attribute in GLB should be equivalent to our SAs in GLB. Power Backs should have a decent bit more strength than Elusive backs, but Elusive Backs should only have a decent bit more speed and agility then Power Backs to be successful.

Now to the other side of the ball. Defensive players don't need a TON of strength to bring down ball carriers. In Madden they have the TAK attribute. Cornerbacks are in the 60s, Linebackers and Defensive Lineman are in the 80s and 90s. Cornerbacks shouldn't have a ridiculous amount of strength OR tackling to take down power HBs. GLB is a good bit watered down then Madden, so I'm proposing this:

Cornerbacks should be in the general area of 30 strength and 45 tackling by level 45 to be good at tackling power backs
Linebackers should be in the general idea of 65 strength and 65 tackling by level 45
Defensive End should be in the general idea of 85 strength and 60 tackling by level 45
Defensive Tackles should be in the general idea of 90 strength and 60 tackling by level 45

The balance between speed and strength is what makes each defensive position important on the football field. GLB is turning into this 11 speed demons vs 11 speed demons type of game where people want a speed advantage over people. Strength is VITAL to being in the trenches and shedding blocks. You can't have a Cornerback fighting off a FB in pursuit to a HB. Why not though? Because they don't have the strength to do it. NOT A SINGLE PLAYER should be able to run a circle around offensive blocker to make a tackle. Strength is important to all players, but it gets more important as you get closer and closer to the trenches. That's what GLB is lacking. The necessity of strength in the trenches due to DEs having ridiculous amounts of speed to beat OTs. Speed is NOT NECESSARY for DEs. But somehow, it's every DEs best stat. Why? Because GLB is speed-based. Which is just ridiculous. I'm not complaining, I've just continued to adapt. I'm trying to point this game in the right direction. DEs with tons of speed should get nowhere because they shouldn't have the acceleration/agility to come off the snap and beat an OT out of his stance. Power Backs SHOULD be breaking 2 tackles a play, but they should be brought down right as they do so. Gang tackles is what Madden was missing for a while, and when implemented, it made Madden much better. I think gang tackles would make GLB much better as well.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 22:52:06
 
ruleslawyer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?


I think that may be the problem to begin with. Strength/Carry are utterly useless to a RB when their legs are knocked out from under them. That's football from bobbleheads to pros. That's not to say my answer is "diving tackle" either. There are a lot of factors, this question is hard to answer without knowing confidence and vision. The problem is that for the most part defenders are shed like beads of water on broken tackles, the rb merrily goes about his business, totally fresh and seemingly unaffected by the effort.

As for Str/Tkl/Sas vs Str/Car/Sa's?

I don't think that is really how tackles and broken tackles work.

Energy at the moment of impact is #1 (speed, agil, vis getting both players to that precise point of impact)

Then it's tackle/str/stam vs carry/str/stam to see if it's an immediate drop, wrestling match for the football, back dragging defender, back diving for yardage. Also, there are plenty of "win" 'plays for a back where they end up down but dive and stretch for an extra 1-3 yards.

Also, are backs turned at all on a missed tackle? Do they ever get knocked backwards, turned around or to either side? They don't seem to be suffering much of a movement penalty.

 
BDIrish79
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ruleslawyer
Originally posted by Bort


Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?


I think that may be the problem to begin with. Strength/Carry are utterly useless to a RB when their legs are knocked out from under them. That's football from bobbleheads to pros. That's not to say my answer is "diving tackle" either. There are a lot of factors, this question is hard to answer without knowing confidence and vision. The problem is that for the most part defenders are shed like beads of water on broken tackles, the rb merrily goes about his business, totally fresh and seemingly unaffected by the effort.

As for Str/Tkl/Sas vs Str/Car/Sa's?

I don't think that is really how tackles and broken tackles work.

Energy at the moment of impact is #1 (speed, agil, vis getting both players to that precise point of impact)

Then it's tackle/str/stam vs carry/str/stam to see if it's an immediate drop, wrestling match for the football, back dragging defender, back diving for yardage. Also, there are plenty of "win" 'plays for a back where they end up down but dive and stretch for an extra 1-3 yards.

Also, are backs turned at all on a missed tackle? Do they ever get knocked backwards, turned around or to either side? They don't seem to be suffering much of a movement penalty.



This is a "dead on" analysis. Strength and Tackling are not the only attributes which should determine how you stop a power back. Anyone who as ever played, coached or seen a game knows that smaller, less powerful players regularly drop a power back with a solid tackle. Power backs are normally stopped in two ways: get them before they get started("beating them to the punch") and gang tackling.

To accomplish either of these two, you need Speed, Agility, Vision and Confidence. I have read a few individuals post in this thread that say defenses shouldn't have 11 "Speed Demons" and that is ridiculous. Can anyone tell me one great defense that wasn't fast, agile and had great vision? You have to shed blocks and get to the ball carrier as quickly as possible or you can't make the tackle!

I am not saying that Tackling and Strength shouldn't have more emphasis, but ball carriers shouldn't get a free ride. Let's see the back suffer a movement penalty on broken tackles and a "gang tackling" bonus for the defense to go with this new Tackling "nerf".
 
jlusch21
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

That's what I'm getting at - people generally aren't upset when the make the tackle and the guy gains an additional couple of yards at the end. They are upset when they see "I missed 5 tackles!!! WTF"


It's America Bort.... We LOVE LOVE LOVE stats

I get upset at my defense when they give up the extra yard or two though, so i'm with ya
 
satandole666
offline
Link
 
I'll keep my answer simple.

A player should be a consistent tackler (esp on wrap up) if they have a minimum of first cap in strength and tackling. I'll define consistent to 60-75% tackles made.

To be an excellent tackler (say 90%) a 2nd cap in strength and tackling should be required.

If you want to be gods gift to tackling 3rd caps in both should be the max.

A few reasons for this. Expecting everyone on the defense to have more than 48 tackling (think secondary, especially in lower players) will gimp so many people. Think of the wasted SPs when you tackle that 15 strength 100 speed receiver you couldn't chase down.

Another great reason, tackling and carrying are two of the most boring attributes to train/spend on. The effects are rarely visibly tangible and if everything goes right you can't really tell.
Last edited Dec 31, 2008 01:42:34
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zsirvone28
In all reality, I see this game as an 'Online Madden Player Creation Sim' League. Basically, you create your player and you put him up against other agents with other players. Both games are based off of numbers and percentages. The big differences I see are the Special Abilities and Veteran Abilities that are being implemented. Both of these were implemented in an attempt to make players more 'unique'. I must say, Bort has done a great job with that as well as all of GLB. I'm a very big fan and I've been around since Season 1. Ever since I've been here, strength and tackling have been the two major attributes that the game undervalues. Speed is overvalued. While agility is undervalued a bit. Just because someone built a SPEED HEAVY DEMON DEFENSIVE PLAYER doesn't mean they should get rewarded by having 10 tackling, playing on wrap up, and never missing a tackle. That's just ridiculous. I've been following this thread for a while, seeing everyone's suggestions, and coming up with something of my own. The true power backs of the NFL in MADDEN don't have 100 strength. They don't have 90 Strength. AT MOST they have mid 80s strength. All successful backs are in the 60-80 range. They all have 90+ agility, speed, and acceleration. What makes them so good at breaking tackles? The BTK attribute. The BTK attribute in GLB should be equivalent to our SAs in GLB. Power Backs should have a decent bit more strength than Elusive backs, but Elusive Backs should only have a decent bit more speed and agility then Power Backs to be successful.

Now to the other side of the ball. Defensive players don't need a TON of strength to bring down ball carriers. In Madden they have the TAK attribute. Cornerbacks are in the 60s, Linebackers and Defensive Lineman are in the 80s and 90s. Cornerbacks shouldn't have a ridiculous amount of strength OR tackling to take down power HBs. GLB is a good bit watered down then Madden, so I'm proposing this:

Cornerbacks should be in the general area of 30 strength and 45 tackling by level 45 to be good at tackling power backs
Linebackers should be in the general idea of 65 strength and 65 tackling by level 45
Defensive End should be in the general idea of 85 strength and 60 tackling by level 45
Defensive Tackles should be in the general idea of 90 strength and 60 tackling by level 45

The balance between speed and strength is what makes each defensive position important on the football field. GLB is turning into this 11 speed demons vs 11 speed demons type of game where people want a speed advantage over people. Strength is VITAL to being in the trenches and shedding blocks. You can't have a Cornerback fighting off a FB in pursuit to a HB. Why not though? Because they don't have the strength to do it. NOT A SINGLE PLAYER should be able to run a circle around offensive blocker to make a tackle. Strength is important to all players, but it gets more important as you get closer and closer to the trenches. That's what GLB is lacking. The necessity of strength in the trenches due to DEs having ridiculous amounts of speed to beat OTs. Speed is NOT NECESSARY for DEs. But somehow, it's every DEs best stat. Why? Because GLB is speed-based. Which is just ridiculous. I'm not complaining, I've just continued to adapt. I'm trying to point this game in the right direction. DEs with tons of speed should get nowhere because they shouldn't have the acceleration/agility to come off the snap and beat an OT out of his stance. Power Backs SHOULD be breaking 2 tackles a play, but they should be brought down right as they do so. Gang tackles is what Madden was missing for a while, and when implemented, it made Madden much better. I think gang tackles would make GLB much better as well.


Wonderful post. One of the better posts I've ever seen here.

 
navytexas1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?

I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."

I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.


Leag Leaders will be the level 27 players. Leag Champs will be made of pure level 27's.. all level 27's are kings and rest is needs to retire. Does mater the make and model. If its 1927 Model. That Car is going to be HOT.
 
navytexas1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by Zsirvone28

In all reality, I see this game as an 'Online Madden Player Creation Sim' League. Basically, you create your player and you put him up against other agents with other players. Both games are based off of numbers and percentages. The big differences I see are the Special Abilities and Veteran Abilities that are being implemented. Both of these were implemented in an attempt to make players more 'unique'. I must say, Bort has done a great job with that as well as all of GLB. I'm a very big fan and I've been around since Season 1. Ever since I've been here, strength and tackling have been the two major attributes that the game undervalues. Speed is overvalued. While agility is undervalued a bit. Just because someone built a SPEED HEAVY DEMON DEFENSIVE PLAYER doesn't mean they should get rewarded by having 10 tackling, playing on wrap up, and never missing a tackle. That's just ridiculous. I've been following this thread for a while, seeing everyone's suggestions, and coming up with something of my own. The true power backs of the NFL in MADDEN don't have 100 strength. They don't have 90 Strength. AT MOST they have mid 80s strength. All successful backs are in the 60-80 range. They all have 90+ agility, speed, and acceleration. What makes them so good at breaking tackles? The BTK attribute. The BTK attribute in GLB should be equivalent to our SAs in GLB. Power Backs should have a decent bit more strength than Elusive backs, but Elusive Backs should only have a decent bit more speed and agility then Power Backs to be successful.

Now to the other side of the ball. Defensive players don't need a TON of strength to bring down ball carriers. In Madden they have the TAK attribute. Cornerbacks are in the 60s, Linebackers and Defensive Lineman are in the 80s and 90s. Cornerbacks shouldn't have a ridiculous amount of strength OR tackling to take down power HBs. GLB is a good bit watered down then Madden, so I'm proposing this:

Cornerbacks should be in the general area of 30 strength and 45 tackling by level 45 to be good at tackling power backs
Linebackers should be in the general idea of 65 strength and 65 tackling by level 45
Defensive End should be in the general idea of 85 strength and 60 tackling by level 45
Defensive Tackles should be in the general idea of 90 strength and 60 tackling by level 45

The balance between speed and strength is what makes each defensive position important on the football field. GLB is turning into this 11 speed demons vs 11 speed demons type of game where people want a speed advantage over people. Strength is VITAL to being in the trenches and shedding blocks. You can't have a Cornerback fighting off a FB in pursuit to a HB. Why not though? Because they don't have the strength to do it. NOT A SINGLE PLAYER should be able to run a circle around offensive blocker to make a tackle. Strength is important to all players, but it gets more important as you get closer and closer to the trenches. That's what GLB is lacking. The necessity of strength in the trenches due to DEs having ridiculous amounts of speed to beat OTs. Speed is NOT NECESSARY for DEs. But somehow, it's every DEs best stat. Why? Because GLB is speed-based. Which is just ridiculous. I'm not complaining, I've just continued to adapt. I'm trying to point this game in the right direction. DEs with tons of speed should get nowhere because they shouldn't have the acceleration/agility to come off the snap and beat an OT out of his stance. Power Backs SHOULD be breaking 2 tackles a play, but they should be brought down right as they do so. Gang tackles is what Madden was missing for a while, and when implemented, it made Madden much better. I think gang tackles would make GLB much better as well.


Wonderful post. One of the better posts I've ever seen here.



NFL has some fast DE's some with 4.3 in 40yd dash with pads
 
Major9999
offline
Link
 
Bort,

I think for a Power Back as you describe to be stopped, you may want to think about implementing a new type of tackling mechanism. One that slows down players but doesn't outright stop them without help.

Say for instance the HB you describe is heading for a CB with reasonable tackling and strength (say 40 and 30 respectively, for a CB) right at the line of scrimmage. In real life what would happen? Probably the CB would slow the HB down but it would really take a 2nd or 3rd tackler to help bring him down. If the CBs tackling technique does brings him down he probably would still be able to get 3-4 yards out of it easily.

Thus, for the future you may want to work on a mechanism whereby a weaker tackler could slow a power backs progression but not entirely stop him until a 2nd or 3rd tackler gets in on the play.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Major9999
Bort,

I think for a Power Back as you describe to be stopped, you may want to think about implementing a new type of tackling mechanism. One that slows down players but doesn't outright stop them without help.

Say for instance the HB you describe is heading for a CB with reasonable tackling and strength (say 40 and 30 respectively, for a CB) right at the line of scrimmage. In real life what would happen? Probably the CB would slow the HB down but it would really take a 2nd or 3rd tackler to help bring him down. If the CBs tackling technique does brings him down he probably would still be able to get 3-4 yards out of it easily.

Thus, for the future you may want to work on a mechanism whereby a weaker tackler could slow a power backs progression but not entirely stop him until a 2nd or 3rd tackler gets in on the play.


IRL - the CB would dive and try to take out his legs. With enough agility/vision (68/61 min) he should have about a 50-60% chance of making the tackle. Without good agility/vision he should have about a 25 - 30% chance of making the tackle.

 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by navytexas1


NFL has some fast DE's some with 4.3 in 40yd dash with pads


Name 3

 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BDIrish79

To accomplish either of these two, you need Speed, Agility, Vision and Confidence. I have read a few individuals post in this thread that say defenses shouldn't have 11 "Speed Demons" and that is ridiculous. Can anyone tell me one great defense that wasn't fast, agile and had great vision? You have to shed blocks and get to the ball carrier as quickly as possible or you can't make the tackle!


Tennessee Titans this year doesn't have 11 speed demons
70's Steelers weren't a bunch of speed freaks on D
In fact I would say Steelers LBs today aren't as fast as many other LBs in NFL

Speed isn't everything in the NFL
Frank Gore is one of the slowest HBs in the NFL
Anquan Boldin is one of the slowest WRs in the NFL
Super Mario Williams is by no means the fastest DE in the NFL

 
odt
offline
Link
 
on a regular basis I'd say:

60+ strength
70+ tackling
and maybe speed and agility could compensate slightly for lower strength or tackling

Then like 12 of big hit, monster hit, wrap up tackle and diving tackle
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.