User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Sorting promoting teams by record this season?
Page:
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Bort, you just want these shitty teams to feel like they're doing something, so they continue to line your pockets.
 
Kirghiz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Anyway, I know some people won't like it, while others will think it's great. Many people say they want competition, even though their definition of competitive really is "I'm likely to win," while others think it means that everyone is likely to go 8-8. Some people feel as though it's a failure if you don't win 14 games, while others are glad just to sniff the playoffs. Different strokes for different folks I guess. Nobody likes to lose, but half the teams in the game have to lose every other day...just have to make that less painful somehow.


It is really too early to tell if it is good or not, but at first glance it seems like an improvement. At least with the teams I am affiliated with.
 
joemacleod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kirghiz
It is really too early to tell if it is good or not, but at first glance it seems like an improvement. At least with the teams I am affiliated with.


there appears to only be a few crazy leagues
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
IAnyway, I know some people won't like it, while others will think it's great. Many people say they want competition, even though their definition of competitive really is "I'm likely to win," while others think it means that everyone is likely to go 8-8. Some people feel as though it's a failure if you don't win 14 games, while others are glad just to sniff the playoffs. Different strokes for different folks I guess. Nobody likes to lose, but half the teams in the game have to lose every other day...just have to make that less painful somehow.

But the way this is set-up, you're forcing 16 teams that probably would have make the playoffs in other leagues not make the playoffs in these new concentrated leagues. It seems like a better way to promote competitiveness without penalizing teams for success is to contract leagues whenever possible (if you have 32+ CPUs in one tier), and then to spread guts or other under-leveled teams as evenly as possible between the remaining leagues.
 
Triple_A
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Champions not going up 3 caps is just lunacy. I like the way he sorted the teams but allowing champs a 2 cap jump with playoffs teams is beyond stupid.


+1000
I mentioned this too. This means that you will face the championship team every season.
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I'm going to attempt to sleep for a bit guys; feel free to discuss, add ideas, suggestions, etc. and I will check back later. And no, setting things up where top teams are playing lots of CPUs and gutted teams is not ideal...that's what we've had for a while now, and nobody really likes that either.

Anyway, I know some people won't like it, while others will think it's great. Many people say they want competition, even though their definition of competitive really is "I'm likely to win," while others think it means that everyone is likely to go 8-8. Some people feel as though it's a failure if you don't win 14 games, while others are glad just to sniff the playoffs. Different strokes for different folks I guess. Nobody likes to lose, but half the teams in the game have to lose every other day...just have to make that less painful somehow.


I don't like to lose, but I recognize it is part of the game. What I don't like is losing to a bunch of guys who are gaming the system.

Well, I also don't like it that a bunch of crappy teams are going to promote like they are good. There are enough quality teams to spread out across the cap, giving the cream a chance to rise to the top. Once we reach AAA or Pro, those of us with regular teams will catch up to the SSB's.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
So - for those folks upset / disappointed -


even if he nuked all SSB teams (wiped them from the face of the earth - team and players both) - you still wouldn't be happy; correct?


because still - teams that are the best of the crappiest will get promoted - and teams that would have been top 40% of a conference - will now miss the playoffs; lose fan support; lose playoff revenue; etc.


is that correct?

the old system sucked - I'm excited that bort tried something here - I just think it needs some tweaks....what would people offer as tweaks to fix this situation?
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Bort

IAnyway, I know some people won't like it, while others will think it's great. Many people say they want competition, even though their definition of competitive really is "I'm likely to win," while others think it means that everyone is likely to go 8-8. Some people feel as though it's a failure if you don't win 14 games, while others are glad just to sniff the playoffs. Different strokes for different folks I guess. Nobody likes to lose, but half the teams in the game have to lose every other day...just have to make that less painful somehow.

But the way this is set-up, you're forcing 16 teams that probably would have make the playoffs in other leagues not make the playoffs in these new concentrated leagues. It seems like a better way to promote competitiveness without penalizing teams for success is to contract leagues whenever possible (if you have 32+ CPUs in one tier), and then to spread guts or other under-leveled teams as evenly as possible between the remaining leagues.


That. Evenly distribute everyone - best team by record/lolbars goes in league 1, second in league 2, third in league 3, then snake it around like a fantasy football draft (so League 6 of 46 cap should have the 6th and 7th best teams, league 5 has 5th and 8th, and so on).
 
Link
 
I think we need to stop micro-focusing on the SSB aspect of it--there's more wrong with the restructure than simply the SSB teams. Its silly on its face to have "dog" leagues where BAD teams get promotions while GOOD teams of the SAME LEVEL are fighting for their very existence to achieve the same promotion. If the goal is to eventually get to the Pro or WL level, BAD teams shouldn't be rewarded by "winning" a promotion if they didn't have to play any good teams to do so. That to me is the larger over-riding issue.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
He wants the shitty teams to remain competitive, so that they continue to line his pockets.

This is the same logic he's been using since the beginning, he wants everything fair for the shit teams/owners.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Bort, you just want these shitty teams to feel like they're doing something, so they continue to line your pockets.


You'd rather play CPU's, gutjobs, and mediocre teams, with 1-2 real opponents per season?

You're basically saying you deserve to always go 14-2 or better, and we have to take the teams that can't get over the hump and throw them like lambs to the slaughter for the benefit of the currently better teams. It's not fun to be one of those teams. They can never win and pull themselves out of the gutter. Most of them quit before they can make it to AA and start at least getting media revenue. Maybe if we can give them a chance to build themselves up, there would be some more legit competition and we wouldn't have so few truly good teams.

Nah, other people who play GLB don't count. Only the current top teams matter. Those other teams simply exist to prop up other teams and deserve no consideration at all.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Bukowski

Bort, you just want these shitty teams to feel like they're doing something, so they continue to line your pockets.


You'd rather play CPU's, gutjobs, and mediocre teams, with 1-2 real opponents per season?

You're basically saying you deserve to always go 14-2 or better, and we have to take the teams that can't get over the hump and throw them like lambs to the slaughter for the benefit of the currently better teams. It's not fun to be one of those teams. They can never win and pull themselves out of the gutter. Most of them quit before they can make it to AA and start at least getting media revenue. Maybe if we can give them a chance to build themselves up, there would be some more legit competition and we wouldn't have so few truly good teams.

Nah, other people who play GLB don't count. Only the current top teams matter. Those other teams simply exist to prop up other teams and deserve no consideration at all.


No, I don't want my level 33 teams to play Season 7 SLOW BUILDS>

Why don't you get that?

Put all the SSB builds in their own fucking conference.
Edited by Bukowski on Jan 21, 2010 11:39:18
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
That. Evenly distribute everyone - best team by record/lolbars goes in league 1, second in league 2, third in league 3, then snake it around like a fantasy football draft (so League 6 of 46 cap should have the 6th and 7th best teams, league 5 has 5th and 8th, and so on).


I think this is the best answer. Snake draft the teams to fill the leagues. You still get competitive leages and you avoid the crap rising to the top...
 
DigitalDaggers
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
You'd rather play CPU's, gutjobs, and mediocre teams, with 1-2 real opponents per season?

You're basically saying you deserve to always go 14-2 or better, and we have to take the teams that can't get over the hump and throw them like lambs to the slaughter for the benefit of the currently better teams. It's not fun to be one of those teams. They can never win and pull themselves out of the gutter. Most of them quit before they can make it to AA and start at least getting media revenue. Maybe if we can give them a chance to build themselves up, there would be some more legit competition and we wouldn't have so few truly good teams.

Nah, other people who play GLB don't count. Only the current top teams matter. Those other teams simply exist to prop up other teams and deserve no consideration at all.


Dude, we are totally going to make SOOOOOO much money off of this change.
 
pcough
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dub J
I voted "no" because I am thinking beyond S14, tbh.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.