User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Recent Upgrades(discussion)
Page:
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
First impression, I like it.
How many days can we expect the offseason to be?
 
Link
 
I just wanted to give my two cents about the playoffs/scrimmage debate.
Not sure how much code or how difficult this would be to implement but here it goes.

I think that there should be some benefit in the offseason to the players in both the playoffs and the scrimmages. There are several different ways to approach this and still keep player development within what was originally planned.

Admins what could be done is instead of earning XP's to level up why not award attribute points instead? It doesnt have to be alot. Maybe a point that gets distributed among the major skills for each game won. The losing team gets 1/2 a point.

Scrimmages could be done the same way only those teams do not earn but .25 points per game. Each player that wins a championship has 4 points distributed among their primary skills. A team that didnt go to the playoffs would get a maximum of 1 point distributed among their primary skills.

That's one way to do it.

Another way might actually be alot simpiler to code. Again it involves attribute points and not skill points. On another thread there were suggestions about items/equipment that could be added. We have 2 hands and 10 fingers. Why not award rings? Rings to the conference and league winners. Conference ring works like a lvl 8 equipment and league works like a level 16 (only it only enhances abilities not special abilities). Players on the team that win it all effectively get 5 attribute points.

Players that have playoff experience are highly coveted players. This game should reflect that as well.

Teams that have not made the playoffs and complaining about paying their players should just relax. You are getting a benefit that teams going to the championship don't get. What's that you say? The chance to experiment.

That's my 4 1/2 cents.
Last edited May 28, 2008 17:45:57
 
Dougster
offline
Link
 
I like the ring idea for conference and division champs. Maybe give them a morale boost similar to defense general or something along those lines. Would add value to the players.
 
big_n_rich
offline
Link
 
I also like the ring, maybe a +1 to confidence for each ring. That way it isn't too much of a penalty to those that didn't make it that for.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yard Dog
the new chemistry changes will be ridiculous. You will be able to make so many moves during the offseason and during the season and still be at 100% chemistry...

Should have left it... Teams that cut and sign 30 players per season can still get to 100%...


That's the point.
You're encouraged to make moves in the offseason instead of making them at the end of the season
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yard Dog
the new chemistry changes will be ridiculous. You will be able to make so many moves during the offseason and during the season and still be at 100% chemistry...

Should have left it... Teams that cut and sign 30 players per season can still get to 100%...


Tend to agree with this. Seems every team will be at 100...it will kind of make chemistry almost pointless. In my opinion.
 
kastagir
offline
Link
 
Those maximums in trade really limit the gutting of rosters as team owners sell back their team to Blitz and walk away. Very nice.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yard Dog
the new chemistry changes will be ridiculous. You will be able to make so many moves during the offseason and during the season and still be at 100% chemistry...

Should have left it... Teams that cut and sign 30 players per season can still get to 100%...


This should allow the new teams to get their team ready and compete a little quicker, while still discouraging last minute team stacking.

If the team makes the moves early, they can regain the chemistry before the end of the season, and the other teams in the league have time to adjust. If they make the moves late, they end the season with low chemistry when it matters (playoff time) and are hurt by it.

That's really what we're trying to target with chemistry: late season gutting and big last minute trades.

We'll see how it goes this season. If the effects are too great, we'll scale it back for season 4.
 
Tigerbait0307
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Yard Dog

the new chemistry changes will be ridiculous. You will be able to make so many moves during the offseason and during the season and still be at 100% chemistry...

Should have left it... Teams that cut and sign 30 players per season can still get to 100%...


This should allow the new teams to get their team ready and compete a little quicker, while still discouraging last minute team stacking.

If the team makes the moves early, they can regain the chemistry before the end of the season, and the other teams in the league have time to adjust. If they make the moves late, they end the season with low chemistry when it matters (playoff time) and are hurt by it.

That's really what we're trying to target with chemistry: late season gutting and big last minute trades.

We'll see how it goes this season. If the effects are too great, we'll scale it back for season 4.


Some people will complain no matter what. F them I like it. Great job.
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
What about for the teams that have actually prepared and planned around there chemistry? Kinda makes it pointless now that we keep a well maintained team and keep the same guys and avoided trades because of the chemistry, and now you can just get it right back up. No offense, but agree you should have left it how was or not made it so much of a gain back in chemistry. Maybe i'm just misunderstanding it, but hope it still keeps in mind those of us who prepared well.
Last edited May 28, 2008 19:00:16
 
G-Money
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HurricaneBear
What about for the teams that have actually prepared and planned around there chemistry? Kinda makes it pointless now that we keep a well maintained team and keep the same guys and avoided trades because of the chemistry, and now you can just get it right back up. No offense, but agree you should have left it how was or not made it so much of a gain back in chemistry.


I agree 100%. The point to "chemistry" (IMO) is to build a team with a core group of guys who stay together for many seasons......and teams should be awarded for pulling this off. I don't see how a team who's built from the ground up for 3 seasons should have an equal "chemistry" of a team who made 20-30 moves in one season......where is the "chemistry" there?? Just doesn't make sense.

 
modred
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

That's really what we're trying to target with chemistry: late season gutting and big last minute trades.


Then shouldn't the gain of chemistry during the playoffs be smaller? 136 (or 181 including the offseason) chemistry per season seems like an awful lot. It may just be due to the drastic change from what it is now. My first impression is that it does pretty much remove chemistry penalties. I guess the minimum roster requirements will also help the gutting issue.
 
islanders1986
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by G-Money
Originally posted by HurricaneBear

What about for the teams that have actually prepared and planned around there chemistry? Kinda makes it pointless now that we keep a well maintained team and keep the same guys and avoided trades because of the chemistry, and now you can just get it right back up. No offense, but agree you should have left it how was or not made it so much of a gain back in chemistry.


I agree 100%. The point to "chemistry" (IMO) is to build a team with a core group of guys who stay together for many seasons......and teams should be awarded for pulling this off. I don't see how a team who's built from the ground up for 3 seasons should have an equal "chemistry" of a team who made 20-30 moves in one season......where is the "chemistry" there?? Just doesn't make sense.





this game is still in Beta its going to be changing like this so when it goes final it will be good.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Chemistry was initially implemented to prevent dumping and collusion. It wasn't meant to prevent teams from making required moves.

I like the changes. Players want to leave teams for various reasons. Heck two of my best players want to leave my team this offseason to go play for their own teams and I have to replace them. This will allow me to do so without killing me chemistry wise.
 
Beefcake
offline
Link
 
Seems to me this will make Chemistry a pretty useless stat, pretty much all teams will be at or near 100% at all times, with the possible exception of BRAND new teams. There has to be a better way to balance (grace for new teams?)
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.