User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by Mike Rogers



2) It pretty damn impossible to do that type of a test without justifying it in some way.



Can you elaborate on this? How are things tracked or reviewed that get tested other than the tester?


I'll try.

Testing is not 'at the Testers Discretion', you need to justify what your looking into, and checks are in place that make 'secret testing' impossible.

I believe the specifics are being address by Bort, and I dont want to comment on it too much. I know what, but why etc isnt fully disclosed so me debating it is not going to be useful for anything except ambush fodder.

I hate been evasive at a time like this, hope everyone understands.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by Mike Rogers




2) It pretty damn impossible to do that type of a test without justifying it in some way.



Can you elaborate on this? How are things tracked or reviewed that get tested other than the tester?


I'll try.

Testing is not 'at the Testers Discretion', you need to justify what your looking into, and checks are in place that make 'secret testing' impossible.

I believe the specifics are being address by Bort, and I dont want to comment on it too much. I know what, but why etc isnt fully disclosed so me debating it is not going to be useful for anything except ambush fodder.

I hate been evasive at a time like this, hope everyone understands.


Thanks for responding. I understand if Bort asked the testers not to elaborate on certain things then you aren't going to.
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Could you provide any screenshots of this testing, Mike?
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by jrry32

I don't think that is why people are mad, it's the fact that Bort tried to hide it instead of saying it outright and explaining who the testers were and why they had them originally. BTW oldskool was dead on.

I'm not so sure he tried to hide it. I imagine he either thought it wasn't worth mentioning, or meant to and forgot. Bort has never been one to purposefully withhold information.


Actually I think he mentioned it was going to happen once or twice around Bug/Suggestions, then he said a few times that Testers were looking at something and it was pretty much ignored, I missed why this is a big deal now.

I wasnt surprised when I got the invite (Well surprised the I got one, not surprised there was Testing happening by players.)

I dont think he said the testers were Owners/GMs/Users, but I just assumed they would be, who else would do it really except a third party.

Even after someone said 'Told you so' no one really seemed to care that much initially from what I saw (few exceptions of course), mostly 'about time stuff got fixed' comments, but as soon as threads went AWOL, EVERYONE cared
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by weather999
Could you provide any screenshots of this testing, Mike?


Pretty sure that for now the answer is no, I think if anyone does that its got to be an Admin.

(Besides theres not much to see, it looks alot like this site )
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
I was looking for specifics from the person who made the post. But, carry on.

Yup, and I was merely trying to be helpful, with the anticipation Mike Rogers would either confirm or refute, hence the question mark at the end. But you decided to douche it up a bit. Different strokes, I suppose.

Originally posted by wombat killer
Tpat made a comment in the beginning of all this saying "this wasn't supposed to public knowledge". Sounds like hiding to me.

Bort has made several references to testers, as MR already pointed out. "Not supposed to be public" != "hiding". I'd hope logic would see you through to that conclusion.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by wombat killer

I was looking for specifics from the person who made the post. But, carry on.

Yup, and I was merely trying to be helpful, with the anticipation Mike Rogers would either confirm or refute, hence the question mark at the end. But you decided to douche it up a bit. Different strokes, I suppose.

Originally posted by wombat killer

Tpat made a comment in the beginning of all this saying "this wasn't supposed to public knowledge". Sounds like hiding to me.

Bort has made several references to testers, as MR already pointed out. "Not supposed to be public" != "hiding". I'd hope logic would see you through to that conclusion.


When were those reference to testers made?

You may think not supposed to be public is not hiding, but don't project your flawed logic on the rest of us.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by wombat killer

I was looking for specifics from the person who made the post. But, carry on.

Yup, and I was merely trying to be helpful,


No, you were merely trying to troll, as usual.

Originally posted by Asheme

Bort has made several references to testers, as MR already pointed out. "Not supposed to be public" != "hiding". I'd hope logic would see you through to that conclusion.


Right, and the moving/deletion of every single thread that had to do with test servers wasn't an attempt to suppress the truth... The only reason that we are able to talk about this now is that everyone saw straight through this bullshit for what it really is: fraud.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by jrry32

I don't think that is why people are mad, it's the fact that Bort tried to hide it instead of saying it outright and explaining who the testers were and why they had them originally. BTW oldskool was dead on.

I'm not so sure he tried to hide it. I imagine he either thought it wasn't worth mentioning, or meant to and forgot. Bort has never been one to purposefully withhold information.


Has anyone ever mentioned in the past that Bort ought to focus more attention on strategic communication with his customers?

At this point I'm thinking he might want to consider taking a course or doing side research on the subject... he's got enough material of his own to write a paper or two. Considering the speed of communication this community uses, he can hardly afford to ignore this highly sensitive aspect of a business's relationship with its customers. In fact I thought he hired an expert on customer relations -- where was this staff member in the decision process for how to implement testing? Off to the side, unaware... or sitting at the table, unproductive?

FWIW I've heard enough now from the testing community to believe that test server access doesn't include carte blanche opportunity to run whatever scenario you care to run -- but that still relies on my trust of those folks whereas process transparency from the beginning obviously would have made things clear much earlier.

The order in which people receive information makes a huge difference as to how they register that information and what additional conclusions they draw. If the last decade and a half have taught us anything about American culture, it's that we're not big fans of organizational secrecy. Secrecy leads to mistrust, mistrust leads to lost confidence -- which leads to failure. Damage control is often more expensive than using the right mix of talent to support making good decisions from the outset.

Customer relations isn't just talking to the customer, it's also making sure that you're doing business in a way that the customer will approve or tolerate. That customer relations person should attend every planning discussion... and be held accountable (i.e., replaced/upgraded) if he or she isn't performing.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 15:42:08
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
If Bort was so stand up about everything where is he now? That's my question, and how can a guy as smart as Bort think that this logic of letting players test out the sim engine is okay is beyond me.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
If Bort was so stand up about everything where is he now? That's my question, and how can a guy as smart as Bort think that this logic of letting players test out the sim engine is okay is beyond me.


Here is the scary part. We were heading to this result the second Bort came up with this idea. How did he not see that?
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Asheme

Originally posted by jrry32


I don't think that is why people are mad, it's the fact that Bort tried to hide it instead of saying it outright and explaining who the testers were and why they had them originally. BTW oldskool was dead on.

I'm not so sure he tried to hide it. I imagine he either thought it wasn't worth mentioning, or meant to and forgot. Bort has never been one to purposefully withhold information.


Has anyone ever mentioned in the past that Bort ought to focus more attention on strategic communication with his customers?

At this point I'm thinking he might want to consider taking a course or doing side research on the subject... he's got enough material of his own to write a paper or two. Considering the speed of communication this community uses, he can hardly afford to ignore this highly sensitive aspect of a business's relationship with its customers. In fact I thought he hired an expert on customer relations -- where was this staff member in the decision process for how to implement testing? Off to the side, unaware... or sitting at the table, unproductive?

FWIW I've heard enough now from the testing community to believe that test server access doesn't include carte blanche opportunity to run whatever scenario you care to run -- but that still relies on my trust of those folks whereas process transparency from the beginning obviously would have made things clear much earlier.

The order in which people receive information makes a huge difference as to how they register that information and what additional conclusions they draw. If the last decade and a half have taught us anything about American culture, it's that we're not big fans of organizational secrecy. Secrecy leads to mistrust, mistrust leads to lost confidence -- which leads to failure. Damage control is often more expensive than using the right mix of talent to support making good decisions from the outset.

Customer relations isn't just talking to the customer, it's also making sure that you're doing business in a way that the customer will approve or tolerate. That customer relations person should attend every planning discussion... and be held accountable (i.e., replaced/upgraded) if he or she isn't performing.


I agree 100% about the lack of communication. Cited this as my biggest complaint about the game.

As for carte blanche' I heard from a trusted guy that you can indeed test any build that you want on the test server and run that sim as many times as you want.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
When were those reference to testers made?

Two I found with a quick search: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1935499
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2057498

Originally posted by wombat killer
You may think not supposed to be public is not hiding, but don't project your flawed logic on the rest of us.

It doesn't. If one wants to assert that not telling something = deliberately withholding, then the burden of proof is on them.

Also, and more to the point, tpat != Bort. Moderators are not admins (and other admins aren't Bort, tbh), nor do they speak for Bort.
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
I think Mike will be honest enough to admit that he could have created any build that he wanted to and tested it multiple times IF desired. I know Mike would not do that to gain an edge but he won't deny that It could have been done.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
I hate been evasive at a time like this, hope everyone understands.


Mike, many of us at least understand your difficult position and appreciate your effort to address people's immediate concerns. As far as I'm concerned you're handling the situation with judgment and integrity.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.