User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by smallbugger

well Bort should be getting this Shit storm

Why? For trying to make the game better?

Seriously, winning trophies/leagues/conferences means nothing right now. The game needs to be fixed, badly, and people getting angry over an "advantage" gained while the sim is broken is ridiculous, especially when the source of all this rage is an effort to improve the sim.


so the money I spent was into a meaningless hole. The time I spent on the game was worthless because we need guys cheating to make the game better.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
I agree, but tell that to the people that've funded the game up to this point and see where you get.

Well, I tell it to myself often, and it seems to go over pretty well.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by smallbugger


During the playoffs I basically mapped out the last three game of each opponent to figure out the best way to stop them, ect. That took a long time. Being a tester... you can test a build, SA or VA against a similar team to mine running our best plays to see how your team would do....

that would be cheating because they can see a sims results, while other would have to go with the knowledge and experience they got from previous games or scrimmages... both we paid real money for.

Bort should have Admins and paid people being testers, that would put those people under contract that they cannot cheat and use their given advantages over other players.... or maybe volunteers that will leave the actual game behind.

Bort can't just be choosing guys he likes to be given an advantage over paying customers....


Yeah that is possible, but there are reasons it isnt that simple.

1) The sim engine being used to run the games is totally different in many ways, the results would not translate directly to the live Site (I am not saying its entirely different and somethings wont translate, but those are the most basic things thats certainly not a secret to the n00biest of n00bs.

2) It pretty damn impossible to do that type of a test without justifying it in some way.

3) I would be very unlikely to be able to create a team 'similar' enough to your team (Or mine for that matter) in order to run that test.

4) It still fails to account for the other team changing their gameplan and you screwing yourself.

Basically I would learn more by running my own Pro team in a Friendly against any other team on the live site than from 100 tests on that server.

You obvioulsy have no way of knowing that for sure though, I understand that and its the biggest barrier to appeasing the masses imo.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers


2) It pretty damn impossible to do that type of a test without justifying it in some way.



Can you elaborate on this? How are things tracked or reviewed that get tested other than the tester?
 
r8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
[The game needs to be fixed, badly, and people getting angry over an "advantage" gained while the sim is broken is ridiculous, especially when the source of all this rage is an effort to improve the sim.


Probably the most true statement in this entire topic.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by smallbugger

well Bort should be getting this Shit storm

Why? For trying to make the game better?

Seriously, winning trophies/leagues/conferences means nothing right now. The game needs to be fixed, badly, and people getting angry over an "advantage" gained while the sim is broken is ridiculous, especially when the source of all this rage is an effort to improve the sim.


I don't think that is why people are mad, it's the fact that Bort tried to hide it instead of saying it outright and explaining who the testers were and why they had them originally. BTW oldskool was dead on.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by smallbugger
so the money I spent was into a meaningless hole.

The money you spent should have been an investment, into something you enjoyed and felt had potential to develop into something very worthwhile. If you thought you spent money on a finished, polished, working product, then that's an issue you'll have to take up with yourself.

Originally posted by smallbugger
The time I spent on the game was worthless because we need guys cheating to make the game better.

See, "cheating" would imply the game is finished, or in a state where someone is capable of being "cheated", but it isn't. These seasons are, unfortunately, rather meaningless. They're main purpose is to provide a measure of entertainment while we help the sim progress to a reliable state where inputs = outputs.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Asheme

Originally posted by smallbugger


well Bort should be getting this Shit storm

Why? For trying to make the game better?

Seriously, winning trophies/leagues/conferences means nothing right now. The game needs to be fixed, badly, and people getting angry over an "advantage" gained while the sim is broken is ridiculous, especially when the source of all this rage is an effort to improve the sim.


I don't think that is why people are mad, it's the fact that Bort tried to hide it instead of saying it outright and explaining who the testers were and why they had them originally. BTW oldskool was dead on.


and just to further clarify. I know people would still be mad but there would be less and it wouldn't be about being lied to, it would be about not getting picked.

Last edited Feb 15, 2009 15:11:21
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Can you elaborate on this? How are things tracked or reviewed that get tested other than the tester?

From my limited understanding, things are closely monitored by the admins to prevent abuse, no?
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by wombat killer

Can you elaborate on this? How are things tracked or reviewed that get tested other than the tester?

From my limited understanding, things are closely monitored by the admins to prevent abuse, no?


I was hoping someone that doesn't have a limited understanding would actually respond.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
I don't think that is why people are mad, it's the fact that Bort tried to hide it instead of saying it outright and explaining who the testers were and why they had them originally. BTW oldskool was dead on.

I'm not so sure he tried to hide it. I imagine he either thought it wasn't worth mentioning, or meant to and forgot. Bort has never been one to purposefully withhold information.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
I was hoping someone that doesn't have a limited understanding would actually respond.

By limited understanding I meant what I was told by a tester. But, carry on.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by jrry32

I don't think that is why people are mad, it's the fact that Bort tried to hide it instead of saying it outright and explaining who the testers were and why they had them originally. BTW oldskool was dead on.

I'm not so sure he tried to hide it. I imagine he either thought it wasn't worth mentioning, or meant to and forgot. Bort has never been one to purposefully withhold information.


Tpat made a comment in the beginning of all this saying "this wasn't supposed to public knowledge". Sounds like hiding to me.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by wombat killer

I was hoping someone that doesn't have a limited understanding would actually respond.

By limited understanding I meant what I was told by a tester. But, carry on.


I was looking for specifics from the person who made the post. But, carry on.
 
buck2008
offline
Link
 
ha you guys are crying why we are all testers since this game is still in beta god you are all babys



Bort when this goes live you should give back all flex that was bought during betta and clear all builds and start it all over from season one clear teams and reset the teams as well

just my thought
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.