ummm, cliffs anybody?
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Xiong Yoshi
offline
offline
Originally posted by ken-in-rockwall
Well, as I see it after 82 pages and 1220+ posts, nothing is going to change.. Expect the MISSED TACKLES value to go WAY up this season... and that's ok..
You may want to go back and reread some of those posts... focus on just Bort's posts.
Well, as I see it after 82 pages and 1220+ posts, nothing is going to change.. Expect the MISSED TACKLES value to go WAY up this season... and that's ok..
You may want to go back and reread some of those posts... focus on just Bort's posts.
manureid
offline
offline
Scrimmage just player, one HB had 46 missed tackles on him. One of our LBs had 11 all last season, had 16 in this game. Nerf??
TehKyou
offline
offline
Originally posted by manureid
Scrimmage just player, one HB had 46 missed tackles on him. One of our LBs had 11 all last season, had 16 in this game. Nerf??
No. Theres a resurgance of Break Tackle abilities, as well as the Break Tackle SA effect on the formula has changed, getting to only 50 Str and Tackling is not adequate enough to take down 90 Strength 65 Carrying Power Backs on the first hit. Slow him down a little so the next guy might succeed? maybe.
Scrimmage just player, one HB had 46 missed tackles on him. One of our LBs had 11 all last season, had 16 in this game. Nerf??
No. Theres a resurgance of Break Tackle abilities, as well as the Break Tackle SA effect on the formula has changed, getting to only 50 Str and Tackling is not adequate enough to take down 90 Strength 65 Carrying Power Backs on the first hit. Slow him down a little so the next guy might succeed? maybe.
bhall43
offline
offline
Originally posted by gart888
ummm, cliffs anybody?
wouldnt even know where to start really...haha
ummm, cliffs anybody?
wouldnt even know where to start really...haha
keith_dude
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:
100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too
I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?
The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?
I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."
I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.
Maybe if there was such a thing as gang-tackling in this game it might be better. At least in real football 2 weak tacklers will combine to make a tackle...but since the LB's and DL all sit around patiently waiting until their turn to take a shot at him...
well...let's just say a guy shouldn't have 47 broken tackles in 35 runs like against my team today.
At some point I can see how advanced equipment and SAs are going to get out of hand.
Let's say I have a power back with:
100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too
I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?
The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?
I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."
I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.
Maybe if there was such a thing as gang-tackling in this game it might be better. At least in real football 2 weak tacklers will combine to make a tackle...but since the LB's and DL all sit around patiently waiting until their turn to take a shot at him...
well...let's just say a guy shouldn't have 47 broken tackles in 35 runs like against my team today.
At some point I can see how advanced equipment and SAs are going to get out of hand.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 19:06:38
TehKyou
offline
offline
Dec 29, 2007
- Fix to pitch plays for RB's who are uber fast - they now are forced to move at a "safe" speed until they catch the pitch
- Fix to bouncing ball intersection point finding routine, to make KR/PR catch ball properly more often
- Tacklers can now hang on and be dragged a short while if they barely miss their tackle roll, to allow for a gang tackle to possibly happen. Strength vs strength rolls helps determine how quickly the tackler will get shaken off.
- Fix to scrambing QB's scrambling too early in the play, rolling out into defenders - rollout now can't occur until several ticks into the play
- Made some adjustments to the location of pass blocking "zones" since the OTs and OGs got shifted back a yard on offensive formations
- Fumbles have a chance to be batted around instead of automatically getting picked up every time
- Possible fix uploaded for the omnipresent FB runaway bug
The more strength you have, the longer you hold on when barely missing a tackle.
- Fix to pitch plays for RB's who are uber fast - they now are forced to move at a "safe" speed until they catch the pitch
- Fix to bouncing ball intersection point finding routine, to make KR/PR catch ball properly more often
- Tacklers can now hang on and be dragged a short while if they barely miss their tackle roll, to allow for a gang tackle to possibly happen. Strength vs strength rolls helps determine how quickly the tackler will get shaken off.
- Fix to scrambing QB's scrambling too early in the play, rolling out into defenders - rollout now can't occur until several ticks into the play
- Made some adjustments to the location of pass blocking "zones" since the OTs and OGs got shifted back a yard on offensive formations
- Fumbles have a chance to be batted around instead of automatically getting picked up every time
- Possible fix uploaded for the omnipresent FB runaway bug
The more strength you have, the longer you hold on when barely missing a tackle.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 19:04:41
Kayoh
offline
offline
I wish I would've been here from the beginning of this thread.
I think that people should be able to choose which type of defensive scheme they want to use; penetrating or traditional. Traditional would have their defensive linemen try to hold up their blockers to let their LBers run free. This would be the defense where the defenders need to have a lot more tackling and strength as compared to speed and agility. The penetrating defense would have their defensive line trying to shoot gaps to make plays in the backfield. This type of D would require less strength, but much more agility and speed because if the DLine doesn't make a tackle in the backfield, then the OL gets to the second level and can block LBers and defensive backs, and that's when it's time for the D to play catch up.
I think that people should be able to choose which type of defensive scheme they want to use; penetrating or traditional. Traditional would have their defensive linemen try to hold up their blockers to let their LBers run free. This would be the defense where the defenders need to have a lot more tackling and strength as compared to speed and agility. The penetrating defense would have their defensive line trying to shoot gaps to make plays in the backfield. This type of D would require less strength, but much more agility and speed because if the DLine doesn't make a tackle in the backfield, then the OL gets to the second level and can block LBers and defensive backs, and that's when it's time for the D to play catch up.
keith_dude
offline
offline
Originally posted by TehKyou
Dec 29, 2007
- Fix to pitch plays for RB's who are uber fast - they now are forced to move at a "safe" speed until they catch the pitch
- Fix to bouncing ball intersection point finding routine, to make KR/PR catch ball properly more often
- Tacklers can now hang on and be dragged a short while if they barely miss their tackle roll, to allow for a gang tackle to possibly happen. Strength vs strength rolls helps determine how quickly the tackler will get shaken off.
- Fix to scrambing QB's scrambling too early in the play, rolling out into defenders - rollout now can't occur until several ticks into the play
- Made some adjustments to the location of pass blocking "zones" since the OTs and OGs got shifted back a yard on offensive formations
- Fumbles have a chance to be batted around instead of automatically getting picked up every time
- Possible fix uploaded for the omnipresent FB runaway bug
The more strength you have, the longer you hold on when barely missing a tackle.
But if a guy with 60 strength and 50 tackling gets "shaken" off immediately as if he's an 11 year old kid, there isn't a lot of dragging going on.
Dec 29, 2007
- Fix to pitch plays for RB's who are uber fast - they now are forced to move at a "safe" speed until they catch the pitch
- Fix to bouncing ball intersection point finding routine, to make KR/PR catch ball properly more often
- Tacklers can now hang on and be dragged a short while if they barely miss their tackle roll, to allow for a gang tackle to possibly happen. Strength vs strength rolls helps determine how quickly the tackler will get shaken off.
- Fix to scrambing QB's scrambling too early in the play, rolling out into defenders - rollout now can't occur until several ticks into the play
- Made some adjustments to the location of pass blocking "zones" since the OTs and OGs got shifted back a yard on offensive formations
- Fumbles have a chance to be batted around instead of automatically getting picked up every time
- Possible fix uploaded for the omnipresent FB runaway bug
The more strength you have, the longer you hold on when barely missing a tackle.
But if a guy with 60 strength and 50 tackling gets "shaken" off immediately as if he's an 11 year old kid, there isn't a lot of dragging going on.
TehKyou
offline
offline
with 60 strength (a few points over the average LB right now), you would hold on longer than someone with 30 strength (a little generous for the CBs right now).
Also as the LB theres more of a chance for someone to be nearby to finish them off.
A NT (with about 90+ Strength) can probably hold down that Power Back for a long time before someone cleans up the house.
Also as the LB theres more of a chance for someone to be nearby to finish them off.
A NT (with about 90+ Strength) can probably hold down that Power Back for a long time before someone cleans up the house.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 19:11:21
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by gart888
ummm, cliffs anybody?
wouldnt even know where to start really...haha
page 3? i read the first 2
Originally posted by gart888
ummm, cliffs anybody?
wouldnt even know where to start really...haha
page 3? i read the first 2
robjay08
offline
offline
You got to take all things into account..
You cant expect your LB with 50 strength, 50 tackling, 90 speed and 60 agility who was a fine player last year overnight turn into a 70 strength and 70 tackling guy, that will take lots of levels or lots of money shifting equipment and alot of linebackers iat that level, with those stats are probably an old player who would be retiring in 3-4 years...
I believe 55 strength and 55 tackling is a more reasonable ratio for taking down linebackers this year and boost both of those up to 60 next year so people can be more aware
You cant expect your LB with 50 strength, 50 tackling, 90 speed and 60 agility who was a fine player last year overnight turn into a 70 strength and 70 tackling guy, that will take lots of levels or lots of money shifting equipment and alot of linebackers iat that level, with those stats are probably an old player who would be retiring in 3-4 years...
I believe 55 strength and 55 tackling is a more reasonable ratio for taking down linebackers this year and boost both of those up to 60 next year so people can be more aware
aggiece98
offline
offline
Originally posted by hustl504
Well F = 1/2MV^2, so in order to stop a player you have to make his forward force = 0. So, stopping a player like that should take into account his weight, speed traveling, angle of the tackle, in addition to strength and tackling ability.
No, that is only if you want to stop him in his tracks (making forward force =0). I don't think any CB is going to do that to a power HB. He is going to cut his legs or get enough of a blow to knock him off balance.
However, i agree with teh rest of the things that should be taken into account.
Well F = 1/2MV^2, so in order to stop a player you have to make his forward force = 0. So, stopping a player like that should take into account his weight, speed traveling, angle of the tackle, in addition to strength and tackling ability.
No, that is only if you want to stop him in his tracks (making forward force =0). I don't think any CB is going to do that to a power HB. He is going to cut his legs or get enough of a blow to knock him off balance.
However, i agree with teh rest of the things that should be taken into account.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























