User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
rmc007
offline
Link
 
I don't know how you work your formula Bort but a LB with at least 60+ strength and tackling should be able to bring down this ball carrier most of the time. Good vision and agility will help get him in better position to make the tackle and all that strength the running back has shouldn't result in a broken tackle. I'm not suggesting that this should work everytime. Take a real life example if you must: The Giants power running game ran all over the Ravens who have the 2nd best run defense in the NFL. Sometimes being a good tackler shouldn't be enough. Sometimes being a good tackler should completely shut down a run game. There needs to be some sort of random equation in this all.

It may be a case where the RB gains a couple of extra yards through contact or falls forward for a yard rather than get knocked back but generally you would expect a LB meeting a RB head on in good position to make the tackle nearly all of the time.

IMO a CB with less strength/tackling (less than 50) but good speed, agility, vision should get into a good position to make a tackle or force a push to the sideline and out of bounds when the run is to the far outside but more often than not the runner will break the tackle but be slowed down enough to allow a LB or safety to get across and have the chance at a tackle.

Power runners should be great for 3-5 yards but anything more than that should rely on great blocking or piss poor builds in terms of tackling.



 
TehKyou
offline
Link
 
Eh can we lock this soon, Bort seems satisfied with the results it has brought.
 
cmj33
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TehKyou
Eh can we lock this soon, Bort seems satisfied with the results it has brought.


+1
 
NWWarrior
offline
Link
 
read a ton of the pages but not all 82!

I am still very disappointed at how Bort nerfed the elusive back and the pitch play a few seasons ago and how terrible the pitch play still is as of our sim today. The Power back rules the game and has for quite a few seasons now and now he may be making it stronger....bummer
 
TehKyou
offline
Link
 
The pitch play seems alot better now IMO.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by NWWarrior
read a ton of the pages but not all 82!

I am still very disappointed at how Bort nerfed the elusive back and the pitch play a few seasons ago and how terrible the pitch play still is as of our sim today. The Power back rules the game and has for quite a few seasons now and now he may be making it stronger....bummer


+10
 
Link
 
Fix to pitch plays for RB's who are uber fast - they now are forced to move at a "safe" speed until they catch the pitch - added yesterday


on the 27th

Pitch plays improved - I noticed that pitches were incurring the same "slow down because your catching sucks" penalty as normal passes. This has been removed, so pitches develop much faster, without the HB having to stop or slow down nearly as much.

seems to me like he just changed his mind and then nerfed pitch again and used the word safe speed into of saying nerfed speed
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 18:01:28
 
NWWarrior
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lord Thomas Drake
Fix to pitch plays for RB's who are uber fast - they now are forced to move at a "safe" speed until they catch the pitch - added yesterday


on the 27th

Pitch plays improved - I noticed that pitches were incurring the same "slow down because your catching sucks" penalty as normal passes. This has been removed, so pitches develop much faster, without the HB having to stop or slow down nearly as much.

seems to me like he just changed his mind and then nerfed pitch again and used the word safe speed into of saying nerfed speed


amen again....we are forced to use our 2 elusive backs as between the tackle backs...a sizable disadvatage IMHO.

Teams havent had to really defend the pitch play for 3 seasons now and the game clearly favors all running to be done between the tackles!!!!!!!!!

Release the elusive back BORT and make the outside running game relevant again....
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 18:22:15
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by turnit643

Bort, after sleeping on it (I'm assuming you slept at some point), any conclusions about the original question you asked to start this thread?


I'm thinking where I have it currently is about right - looking around at most games today, YPC are ranging from 2-5 in general, with a few outliers. That seems about right to me.

The reduction of LB dropoff seems to have helped quite a bit to keep the rushing game in check, as well as the interior D line doing more.

As I've been looking around, I've seen an awful lot of 90% WR screen offenses too, with 90% completion pct but 2 yards per pass LOL.


Well, as I see it after 82 pages and 1220+ posts, nothing is going to change.. Expect the MISSED TACKLES value to go WAY up this season... and that's ok..
 
TehKyou
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NWWarrior
Originally posted by Lord Thomas Drake

Fix to pitch plays for RB's who are uber fast - they now are forced to move at a "safe" speed until they catch the pitch - added yesterday


on the 27th

Pitch plays improved - I noticed that pitches were incurring the same "slow down because your catching sucks" penalty as normal passes. This has been removed, so pitches develop much faster, without the HB having to stop or slow down nearly as much.

seems to me like he just changed his mind and then nerfed pitch again and used the word safe speed into of saying nerfed speed


amen again....we are forced to use our 2 elusive backs as between the tackle backs...a sizable disadvatage IMHO.

Teams havent had to really defend the pitch play for 3 seasons now and the game clearly favors all running to be done between the tackles!!!!!!!!!

Release the elusive back BORT and make the outside running game relevant again....


What the hell ....
Hows your reading comprehension?

This change actually HELPS pitch plays, before the HBs had to slow down as they made the "Catch" on the pitch ... that required .... you know ... the Catching attribute. Now they can run a little faster on it till the ball gets there then take off, DRASTICALLY reducing being tackled for a loss by that LB shooting through the gap of your pulling lineman .... I don't get what your complaining about.

Unless your saying that teams will just stack up on the outside on you because you have 2 elusive backs .... which they should have already been doing anyway...

All the pitch plays I've seen so far in scrimmage have been stopped by someone on the outside for at least a gain of a yard instead of being stopped by someone surging through the middle for a loss of 3.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 18:36:06
 
cmj33
offline
Link
 
I don't know, My elusive back had 104 on 24 carries against a team that out leveled us by 2-3 lvls ate each position. And I have seen a few pitch plays work great. Watch the Denton Spartans RB they love the pitch play.
 
cmj33
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=344506&pbp_id=526800 Like this play.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by the man of doom

well a corner could cut his legs

and he would fall forward


The corner could also get stiff armed trying to do that.


Also, watch some Earl Campbell footage about little guys going low on a big guy. Knee to the face and they would think of a different way the next time.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 18:42:57
 
DuhHerbavore
offline
Link
 
tackling should not have to be in the 70s cuz what are CBs going to do. CBs have to focus on speed/agility/vision/jumping/catching/ etc to ask them to pump up their strenght and tackling that high is unreasonable.
 
Thomas farve
offline
Link
 
Would say that the combination of the defender's strength, speed, tackling would have to be within 10 of the ball carrier's combination of speed, carrying and strength.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.