Originally posted by beenlurken
Originally posted by Octowned
He hasn't DENIED x-factors, but all logic indicates there isn't some built in thing that ALWAYS makes a player better. Bort clearly likes randomness on a game-to-game factor, or even within-games. This is evident by... basically every quote from him on the matter? Having a single player defined as "great" before even playing a game goes completely against everything Bort has hinted/stated that he intends.
Clearly there are random factors we aren't clear about, and Bort would like there to be even more. The VAs simply added to this. And it sounds like he'll continue to do this. But I DON'T believe any of the above includes the so-called x-factor that people have tossed around.
I believe I said it yesterday - there is an explanation, but that doesn't mean it is the most obvious or even the best explanation. And guess how it turned out.. an explanation we didn't see coming.
We don't know everything about this game, not even Bort does. But I'm confident no player gets tagged with an advantage before you start building him. That goes COMPLETELY against the ENTIRE purpose of playing this game, which has been Bort's life for the last few years. You really think he'd have such a glaring contradiction to his philosophies and risk half his business over such a silly thing like an x-factor? I think not
Exactly... that is why we are "fixing a bug" and not removing "X-Factor". It was exposed that there was something hidden that allowed PT's wr to outperform. Bort could not longer ignore the issue since the X-Factor discussions reached an all time high this go around. His only options were to admit X-Factor and react from there (I think we established he could not do this) or claim there was a bug that needs fixing (eliminate X-Factor, not lose trust in consumer base because there was an X-Factor, everybody wins)
I completely disagree. Bort always has to option to tell the truth. Perhaps he is I don't know, But if there is/was an x-factor, he needs to just admit it, explain why it was there, explain why he is removing it and move on.
Domer
Originally posted by Octowned
He hasn't DENIED x-factors, but all logic indicates there isn't some built in thing that ALWAYS makes a player better. Bort clearly likes randomness on a game-to-game factor, or even within-games. This is evident by... basically every quote from him on the matter? Having a single player defined as "great" before even playing a game goes completely against everything Bort has hinted/stated that he intends.
Clearly there are random factors we aren't clear about, and Bort would like there to be even more. The VAs simply added to this. And it sounds like he'll continue to do this. But I DON'T believe any of the above includes the so-called x-factor that people have tossed around.
I believe I said it yesterday - there is an explanation, but that doesn't mean it is the most obvious or even the best explanation. And guess how it turned out.. an explanation we didn't see coming.
We don't know everything about this game, not even Bort does. But I'm confident no player gets tagged with an advantage before you start building him. That goes COMPLETELY against the ENTIRE purpose of playing this game, which has been Bort's life for the last few years. You really think he'd have such a glaring contradiction to his philosophies and risk half his business over such a silly thing like an x-factor? I think not
Exactly... that is why we are "fixing a bug" and not removing "X-Factor". It was exposed that there was something hidden that allowed PT's wr to outperform. Bort could not longer ignore the issue since the X-Factor discussions reached an all time high this go around. His only options were to admit X-Factor and react from there (I think we established he could not do this) or claim there was a bug that needs fixing (eliminate X-Factor, not lose trust in consumer base because there was an X-Factor, everybody wins)
I completely disagree. Bort always has to option to tell the truth. Perhaps he is I don't know, But if there is/was an x-factor, he needs to just admit it, explain why it was there, explain why he is removing it and move on.
Domer





























