User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Domer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Originally posted by Octowned

He hasn't DENIED x-factors, but all logic indicates there isn't some built in thing that ALWAYS makes a player better. Bort clearly likes randomness on a game-to-game factor, or even within-games. This is evident by... basically every quote from him on the matter? Having a single player defined as "great" before even playing a game goes completely against everything Bort has hinted/stated that he intends.

Clearly there are random factors we aren't clear about, and Bort would like there to be even more. The VAs simply added to this. And it sounds like he'll continue to do this. But I DON'T believe any of the above includes the so-called x-factor that people have tossed around.

I believe I said it yesterday - there is an explanation, but that doesn't mean it is the most obvious or even the best explanation. And guess how it turned out.. an explanation we didn't see coming.

We don't know everything about this game, not even Bort does. But I'm confident no player gets tagged with an advantage before you start building him. That goes COMPLETELY against the ENTIRE purpose of playing this game, which has been Bort's life for the last few years. You really think he'd have such a glaring contradiction to his philosophies and risk half his business over such a silly thing like an x-factor? I think not


Exactly... that is why we are "fixing a bug" and not removing "X-Factor". It was exposed that there was something hidden that allowed PT's wr to outperform. Bort could not longer ignore the issue since the X-Factor discussions reached an all time high this go around. His only options were to admit X-Factor and react from there (I think we established he could not do this) or claim there was a bug that needs fixing (eliminate X-Factor, not lose trust in consumer base because there was an X-Factor, everybody wins)


I completely disagree. Bort always has to option to tell the truth. Perhaps he is I don't know, But if there is/was an x-factor, he needs to just admit it, explain why it was there, explain why he is removing it and move on.

Domer
 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Domer
I completely disagree. Bort always has to option to tell the truth. Perhaps he is I don't know, But if there is/was an x-factor, he needs to just admit it, explain why it was there, explain why he is removing it and move on.

Domer


Then he'd watch as tons of people quit in frustration and disgust and a riot broke out on the forums.
 
Kegergator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by geekor
Went back 15 pages and still no Bort, can someone point me in the direction of where Bort talks (besides changelog). Too much to go through, thanks is greatly appreciated!


Should start here

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3214072&page=53#27857134
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by geekor
Went back 15 pages and still no Bort, can someone point me in the direction of where Bort talks (besides changelog). Too much to go through, thanks is greatly appreciated!


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3214072&page=50#27856443
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

Regardless, I think it was Saris who made a pretty compelling argument as to why an X-factor would suit Bort's philosophies and be good for the game. If builds are the end-all / be-all, then ultimately this game degenerates into a mathematics exercise which everyone then copies and you end up with tons of identical players depending on the whim of the RNG. But if some players are mysteriously better than others, that encourages people to keep building to chase that elusive, inexplicable success.


I dunno, from a business sense, Bort gets his money from agents creating players. While the forums, team ownership aspects, etc, are all quite nice and make the game enjoyable, the game boils down to one thing: people building players.

The way to bring in new customers is to hook them on BUILDING PLAYERS, not making teams or these rofl-tastic forums.

Now, at what point in Bort's business model did he think "lets trivialize the entire point of building a player into a random number generator that takes place when you create the player, deeming him an all star or destined for failure"? Because I just don't ever see anybody with a brain in charge of this business making that decision.

Having an x-factor completely ruins Bort's BUSINESS. Sure maybe it sounds like it's in his philosophy, but there are many other ways he could accomplish similar random things without trivializing his entire product. And I'm sure he's been smart enough to think of other ways (chemistry, streaky, clutch, requiring supporting attributes to be high enough, the fact that the sim is based on rolls, etc).

You can put randomness in ever roll, in every sim, etc.. But the law of large numbers says the best builds will win (with equal tactics, ofc), and if Bort had half a brain he would NOT turn that statement into a false one.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Go to around page 53ish


damn im good
 
SAINT615
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ThaOutlaw
It took a HUGE debate between Deathblade and Jed to show Bort that it was in fact a bug.

Bort really believed there was not a bug, and offered up a variety of reasons as to why he believed they could be like that.

Finally, he was convinced, but don't act like it was just a magic reversal of belief.

Thank Deathblade and Jed.


Yeah - you may have missed the threads where Jed had to be beaten up and down before he would believe that there was something going on.

Deathblade's been on board for several months - Jed - about 8 hours now.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
I dunno, from a business sense, Bort gets his money from agents creating players. While the forums, team ownership aspects, etc, are all quite nice and make the game enjoyable, the game boils down to one thing: people building players.

The way to bring in new customers is to hook them on BUILDING PLAYERS, not making teams or these rofl-tastic forums.

Now, at what point in Bort's business model did he think "lets trivialize the entire point of building a player into a random number generator that takes place when you create the player, deeming him an all star or destined for failure"? Because I just don't ever see anybody with a brain in charge of this business making that decision.

Having an x-factor completely ruins Bort's BUSINESS. Sure maybe it sounds like it's in his philosophy, but there are many other ways he could accomplish similar random things without trivializing his entire product. And I'm sure he's been smart enough to think of other ways (chemistry, streaky, clutch, requiring supporting attributes to be high enough, the fact that the sim is based on rolls, etc).

You can put randomness in ever roll, in every sim, etc.. But the law of large numbers says the best builds will win (with equal tactics, ofc), and if Bort had half a brain he would NOT turn that statement into a false one.


You say that but even today Bort was trying to promote the idea of hidden attributes and how much he loves the idea of certain players showing up big in certain situations.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
I dunno, from a business sense, Bort gets his money from agents creating players. While the forums, team ownership aspects, etc, are all quite nice and make the game enjoyable, the game boils down to one thing: people building players.

The way to bring in new customers is to hook them on BUILDING PLAYERS, not making teams or these rofl-tastic forums.

Now, at what point in Bort's business model did he think "lets trivialize the entire point of building a player into a random number generator that takes place when you create the player, deeming him an all star or destined for failure"? Because I just don't ever see anybody with a brain in charge of this business making that decision.

Having an x-factor completely ruins Bort's BUSINESS. Sure maybe it sounds like it's in his philosophy, but there are many other ways he could accomplish similar random things without trivializing his entire product. And I'm sure he's been smart enough to think of other ways (chemistry, streaky, clutch, requiring supporting attributes to be high enough, the fact that the sim is based on rolls, etc).

You can put randomness in ever roll, in every sim, etc.. But the law of large numbers says the best builds will win (with equal tactics, ofc), and if Bort had half a brain he would NOT turn that statement into a false one.


At what point during the history of GLB did Bort make you think he even has half a brain. He has failed miserably every time he implements something new. Even making this correction mid-season is bullshit to those like PT who built their team around these builds. Bort has made one bad decision after another.
Edited by beenlurken on Sep 1, 2009 23:27:19
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Considering Jed locked this very thread with a canned answer about there being nothing to see here, no x-factor, everything is fine, I think I'll pass on thanking him tbh
 
geekor
offline
Link
 
Thanks guys
 
Bogleg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Domer
Bort always has to option to tell the truth. Perhaps he is I don't know, But if there is/was an x-factor, he needs to just admit it, explain why it was there, explain why he is removing it and move on.


He explained that there's a weird sim server / db server communication problem that happens sometimes, and it is apparent that he doesn't know the exact reason for it or the exact nature of it. Such is the beginning of the troubleshooting process.

He explained via Changelog that he has put a Band-Aid in place to prevent this problem from affecting gameplay to the extreme that it has been affecting it up to this point.

I think he's takng the technically correct actions.

But PT and others are absolutely right in that he is communicating poorly to the masses. I think that's just his personality, though.
 
Domer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnEnnui
Originally posted by Domer

I completely disagree. Bort always has to option to tell the truth. Perhaps he is I don't know, But if there is/was an x-factor, he needs to just admit it, explain why it was there, explain why he is removing it and move on.

Domer


Then he'd watch as tons of people quit in frustration and disgust and a riot broke out on the forums.


Maybe so. But many would stay and if he was indeed sincere and improved the game, people would come back.

Domer
 
Real LT
offline
Link
 
Bort is GLB's X-Factor.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
Now, at what point in Bort's business model did he think "lets trivialize the entire point of building a player into a random number generator that takes place when you create the player, deeming him an all star or destined for failure"? Because I just don't ever see anybody with a brain in charge of this business making that decision.

If 99.99% of players are differentiated on the basis of their builds, but 0.01% have something special randomly attached to them at creation, you don't think people would create endless amounts of players and boost them in hopes of finding out that they possess the mysterious X-factor? It's only because of DB's script that it became possible to identify anomalies, and to do so early enough to potentially avoid boosting non-X players.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.