Just make it where day 480 is the cutoff for VA's and Training w/BT's. Problem solved. That way nobody is getting shafted.
Dpride59
offline
offline
Originally posted by BengalFish
Just make it where day 480 is the cutoff for VA's and Training w/BT's. Problem solved. That way nobody is getting shafted.
And everyone has more fun, balanced fun and nobody cries, win win win
Just make it where day 480 is the cutoff for VA's and Training w/BT's. Problem solved. That way nobody is getting shafted.
And everyone has more fun, balanced fun and nobody cries, win win win
jdros13
offline
offline
Originally posted by BengalFish
Just make it where day 480 is the cutoff for VA's and Training w/BT's. Problem solved. That way nobody is getting shafted.
Originally posted by Dpride59
And everyone has more fun, balanced fun and nobody cries, win win win
But the plateau gets shortened to 2 seasons rather than 3, which wasn't supposed to be the point. Make the cutoff at 440 days and you have 3 seasons worth of dots on equal footing (age range 440-520 to start a season) and the 400's are only behind by their last 3 boosts, one VA point and some training come playoff time.
I like balancing it out to start next season but cutting off at 440 for training/VA's, etc going forward.
Just make it where day 480 is the cutoff for VA's and Training w/BT's. Problem solved. That way nobody is getting shafted.
Originally posted by Dpride59
And everyone has more fun, balanced fun and nobody cries, win win win
But the plateau gets shortened to 2 seasons rather than 3, which wasn't supposed to be the point. Make the cutoff at 440 days and you have 3 seasons worth of dots on equal footing (age range 440-520 to start a season) and the 400's are only behind by their last 3 boosts, one VA point and some training come playoff time.
I like balancing it out to start next season but cutting off at 440 for training/VA's, etc going forward.
Edited by jdros13 on Jun 25, 2010 12:26:35
deez11010
offline
offline
Originally posted by CaptainUniverse
Your dot would have an extra 90 days of having receiving TPs, BTs, and VAs. It would be too difficult to take those all away to even out the field. Otherwise if they just removed decline from your dot, he'd have a HUGE advantage over those dots that are 441 days old.
Which is exactly how different from those who reach 530 days old over other guys at 441?
Your dot would have an extra 90 days of having receiving TPs, BTs, and VAs. It would be too difficult to take those all away to even out the field. Otherwise if they just removed decline from your dot, he'd have a HUGE advantage over those dots that are 441 days old.
Which is exactly how different from those who reach 530 days old over other guys at 441?
deez11010
offline
offline
I guess I'm missing something.
Whats the difference? If they were to take away my players decline at 530 days old, what more would I have at 530 days old, than another player who reaches 530 days old who "qualified" for the retroactive change? What would my dot at 530 have that their dot wont have at 530 if you make it retroactive for everybody?
Whats the difference? If they were to take away my players decline at 530 days old, what more would I have at 530 days old, than another player who reaches 530 days old who "qualified" for the retroactive change? What would my dot at 530 have that their dot wont have at 530 if you make it retroactive for everybody?
GuruMan88
offline
offline
How about if you are 480 days old at s17 you get 80 days of extended decline instead of the full 120 if you really want to make a change
BengalFish
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by BengalFish
Just make it where day 480 is the cutoff for VA's and Training w/BT's. Problem solved. That way nobody is getting shafted.
Originally posted by Dpride59
And everyone has more fun, balanced fun and nobody cries, win win win
But the plateau gets shortened to 2 seasons rather than 3, which wasn't supposed to be the point. Make the cutoff at 440 days and you have 3 seasons worth of dots on equal footing (age range 440-520 to start a season) and the 400's are only behind by their last 3 boosts, one VA point and some training come playoff time.
I like balancing it out to start next season but cutting off at 440 for training/VA's, etc going forward.
Either way....you're going to have a bunch of bitchin' going on.
The people who is going to be really pissed is those 441 day old dots.
Originally posted by BengalFish
Just make it where day 480 is the cutoff for VA's and Training w/BT's. Problem solved. That way nobody is getting shafted.
Originally posted by Dpride59
And everyone has more fun, balanced fun and nobody cries, win win win
But the plateau gets shortened to 2 seasons rather than 3, which wasn't supposed to be the point. Make the cutoff at 440 days and you have 3 seasons worth of dots on equal footing (age range 440-520 to start a season) and the 400's are only behind by their last 3 boosts, one VA point and some training come playoff time.
I like balancing it out to start next season but cutting off at 440 for training/VA's, etc going forward.
Either way....you're going to have a bunch of bitchin' going on.
The people who is going to be really pissed is those 441 day old dots.
deez11010
offline
offline
Originally posted by BengalFish
Either way....you're going to have a bunch of bitchin' going on.
The people who is going to be really pissed is those 441 day old dots.
I just dont get why some people can and some people cant. If they spent the same amount of $$ for the same thing, why cant they get the same benefits?
Either way....you're going to have a bunch of bitchin' going on.
The people who is going to be really pissed is those 441 day old dots.
I just dont get why some people can and some people cant. If they spent the same amount of $$ for the same thing, why cant they get the same benefits?
Phantom_Opera
offline
offline
Originally posted by BengalFish
Just make it where day 480 is the cutoff for VA's and Training w/BT's. Problem solved. That way nobody is getting shafted.
Originally posted by Dpride59
And everyone has more fun, balanced fun and nobody cries, win win win
Just make it where day 480 is the cutoff for VA's and Training w/BT's. Problem solved. That way nobody is getting shafted.
Originally posted by Dpride59
And everyone has more fun, balanced fun and nobody cries, win win win
jdros13
offline
offline
Originally posted by GuruMan88
How about if you are 480 days old at s17 you get 80 days of extended decline instead of the full 120 if you really want to make a change
that would already be the case I assume. They would still have a full season of VAs and training over any other dot going forward though if the cutoff becomes day 440, which is probably should be if the point of this whole thing is to actually increase the player pool by having a 3 season plateau.
There is every opportunity to do this right and there are some different ways to balance it that have been offered in the last 80 pages, some which penalize the 441-480 dots and some which will just be fun for the 440 and younger dots to make that balance happen. Either way, the original idea was a good one, it just needs to be balanced.
How about if you are 480 days old at s17 you get 80 days of extended decline instead of the full 120 if you really want to make a change
that would already be the case I assume. They would still have a full season of VAs and training over any other dot going forward though if the cutoff becomes day 440, which is probably should be if the point of this whole thing is to actually increase the player pool by having a 3 season plateau.
There is every opportunity to do this right and there are some different ways to balance it that have been offered in the last 80 pages, some which penalize the 441-480 dots and some which will just be fun for the 440 and younger dots to make that balance happen. Either way, the original idea was a good one, it just needs to be balanced.
jdros13
offline
offline
Originally posted by BengalFish
Either way....you're going to have a bunch of bitchin' going on.
The people who is going to be really pissed is those 441 day old dots.
only if the cutoff is a firm 440 days.
As originally proposed, the 481's are going to be disappointed. Personally I don't think there should be a cutoff, they should just balance the older dots and give us the biggest player pool possible for next season.
Either way....you're going to have a bunch of bitchin' going on.
The people who is going to be really pissed is those 441 day old dots.
only if the cutoff is a firm 440 days.
As originally proposed, the 481's are going to be disappointed. Personally I don't think there should be a cutoff, they should just balance the older dots and give us the biggest player pool possible for next season.
deez11010
offline
offline
Well, so far since I originally posted, I have yet to see a reason why theres a cut off at all. Seems to me theres no point to it. If you boosted, it should be retroactive. Done and done.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























