User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Sorting promoting teams by record this season?
Page:
 
Link
 
If I requested to be demoted but have 1 guy over the cap at 35 ( we are requesting to be demoted to a 34), is there a chance I still get it? Even If I did say I would cut the One guy .
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Boise_Saints23
If I requested to be demoted but have 1 guy over the cap at 35 ( we are requesting to be demoted to a 34), is there a chance I still get it? Even If I did say I would cut the One guy .


need to cut him first
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
I have 2 players that I did not boost for a couple seasons but boost now. The two players that did not boost are doing pretty good now but I bet they will suck when other players pass them by because I missed out on some early boosts that I can't get back.

I pretty much try everything once to see what works and what does not. I do not have the benefit of a test server so my tests are on my own dime. I wish I could take the moral high ground on this new topic but I cannot. Curiosity is in my nature and experimenting is the fun part of this game.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by reddogrw
Originally posted by Boise_Saints23

If I requested to be demoted but have 1 guy over the cap at 35 ( we are requesting to be demoted to a 34), is there a chance I still get it? Even If I did say I would cut the One guy .


need to cut him first


I accidently sent him a contract a few days ago and cant release , thats why Im asking
 
sunshineduck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blln4lyf
What the fuck.

Cliffs?


DD: stabbity stab

GLB: no u
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Bort

Yeah, it doesn't really affect much about promotions and whatnot other than potentially making for a more competitive league.

Well, it could actually penalize teams for being successful by putting them in a more difficult league than someone who ended up with a worse record. In theory that could mean inferior teams promoting the following season.


That would be the case for only one season though. After the first season when the team underperforms against top talent they would be resorted into a more mediocre league the next season where they would in all likelyhood cut through the chaff.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Managed to finish off the demotion requests...wow there were a lot of stragglers. I had a chance to think about the "SSB dilemma" a little though while clicking through.

How 'bout something sorta in the middle as a stop-gap for season 14, since we can't figure out all the issues with this proposed system right now:

Take and sort the teams like I was thinking, but then split them into top and bottom half. Then randomly spread the teams around amongst their half. Then you get better teams vs better teams for the most part, but the leagues will be more of a range of competition. Or you could take thirds, depending on how many leagues are needed for the tier.

Then we can keep talking about it, get the system ironed out 100%, but at least we get somewhat better competition for next season as well.
 
boondocksaint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Managed to finish off the demotion requests...wow there were a lot of stragglers. I had a chance to think about the "SSB dilemma" a little though while clicking through.

How 'bout something sorta in the middle as a stop-gap for season 14, since we can't figure out all the issues with this proposed system right now:

Take and sort the teams like I was thinking, but then split them into top and bottom half. Then randomly spread the teams around amongst their half. Then you get better teams vs better teams for the most part, but the leagues will be more of a range of competition. Or you could take thirds, depending on how many leagues are needed for the tier.

Then we can keep talking about it, get the system ironed out 100%, but at least we get somewhat better competition for next season as well.


+1

Get it done, big man
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Managed to finish off the demotion requests...wow there were a lot of stragglers. I had a chance to think about the "SSB dilemma" a little though while clicking through.

How 'bout something sorta in the middle as a stop-gap for season 14, since we can't figure out all the issues with this proposed system right now:

Take and sort the teams like I was thinking, but then split them into top and bottom half. Then randomly spread the teams around amongst their half. Then you get better teams vs better teams for the most part, but the leagues will be more of a range of competition. Or you could take thirds, depending on how many leagues are needed for the tier.

Then we can keep talking about it, get the system ironed out 100%, but at least we get somewhat better competition for next season as well.


Either of those sound fair from a cap promotion point of view.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Managed to finish off the demotion requests...wow there were a lot of stragglers. I had a chance to think about the "SSB dilemma" a little though while clicking through.

How 'bout something sorta in the middle as a stop-gap for season 14, since we can't figure out all the issues with this proposed system right now:

Take and sort the teams like I was thinking, but then split them into top and bottom half. Then randomly spread the teams around amongst their half. Then you get better teams vs better teams for the most part, but the leagues will be more of a range of competition. Or you could take thirds, depending on how many leagues are needed for the tier.

Then we can keep talking about it, get the system ironed out 100%, but at least we get somewhat better competition for next season as well.


I kind of like the thirds idea but mix the top with the bottom since the bottom was not going to win anyways or they were slow building and might compete. The middle can duke it out and enjoy their season.

Either way it sounds like something needs to be done. What that is I am sure I do not know. lol
 
sdt74
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Managed to finish off the demotion requests...wow there were a lot of stragglers. I had a chance to think about the "SSB dilemma" a little though while clicking through.

How 'bout something sorta in the middle as a stop-gap for season 14, since we can't figure out all the issues with this proposed system right now:

Take and sort the teams like I was thinking, but then split them into top and bottom half. Then randomly spread the teams around amongst their half. Then you get better teams vs better teams for the most part, but the leagues will be more of a range of competition. Or you could take thirds, depending on how many leagues are needed for the tier.

Then we can keep talking about it, get the system ironed out 100%, but at least we get somewhat better competition for next season as well.


Originally posted by boondocksaint
+1

Get it done, big man


 
foshizzel17
my drizzt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Managed to finish off the demotion requests...wow there were a lot of stragglers. I had a chance to think about the "SSB dilemma" a little though while clicking through.

How 'bout something sorta in the middle as a stop-gap for season 14, since we can't figure out all the issues with this proposed system right now:

Take and sort the teams like I was thinking, but then split them into top and bottom half. Then randomly spread the teams around amongst their half. Then you get better teams vs better teams for the most part, but the leagues will be more of a range of competition. Or you could take thirds, depending on how many leagues are needed for the tier.

Then we can keep talking about it, get the system ironed out 100%, but at least we get somewhat better competition for next season as well.


yes.
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
And how do you define a SSB team? How much "better" do they have to be? It's an amorphous concept, not a hard percentage value.
Did anyone ever answer this question? The answer was that if a player had X consecutive training XP without game XP between any of them (say X*2 = 16 so 16 days without a game) then that player is SSB, and the team is SSB if Y players are SSB (let Y = 10 since that is sizeable enough and on a 55 man roster everyone will get at least 1 play and thus 1 game of XP in 16 days).
 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vinman
No thanks


 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Maybe I did not understand what you were proposing at the last minute Bort, but looking at this league:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=37

There are 16 teams that would have all made the playoffs the old way that will not make the playoffs now. Thus, unless you change the promotion rules, they will not be able to make the jump to AA that they could have the old way.

Please let us know how you are planning to handle promotion with this new system. If you have not thought about it, allow me to suggest that you remove all performance based cap movement and just move the new balanced leagues as a whole. The point in performance based cap movements seemed to be to promote competition by holding back the worse teams until they got competitive. This new system handles the competition side of it, so just move us all forward at once.
Edited by Plankton on Jan 21, 2010 10:34:21
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.